Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Meno

Meno (77)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0059.tlg024.perseus-eng2:77
Refs {'start': {'reference': '77', 'human_reference': 'Section 77'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
77
77a
Men.

But I should stay, Socrates, if you would give me many such answers.

Soc.

Well then, I will spare no endeavor, both for your sake and for my own, to continue in that style; but I fear I may not succeed in keeping for long on that level. But come now, you in your turn must try and fulfil your promise by telling me what virtue is in a general way; and you must stop producing a plural from the singular, as the wags say whenever one breaks something, but leave virtue

77b
whole and sound, and tell me what it is. The pattern you have now got from me.

Men.

Well, in my view, Socrates, virtue is, in the poets words,

to rejoice in things honorable and be able for them
[*]; and that, I say, is virtueto desire what is honorable and be able to procure it.

Soc.

Do you say that he who desires the honorable is desirous of the good?

Men.

Certainly.

Soc.

Implying that there are some who desire the evil, and others the good? Do not all men,

77c
in your opinion, my dear sir, desire the good?

Men.

I think not.

Soc.

There are some who desire the evil?

Men.

Yes.

Soc.

Thinking the evil to be good, do you mean, or actually recognizing it to be evil, and desiring it nevertheless?

Men.

Both, I believe.

Soc.

Do you really believe, Meno, that a man knows the evil to be evil, and still desires it?

Men.

Certainly.

Soc.

What do you mean by desires? Desires the possession of it?

77d
Men.

Yes; what else could it be?

Soc.

And does he think the evil benefits him who gets it, or does he know that it harms him who has it?

Men.

There are some who think the evil is a benefit, and others who know that it does harm.

Soc.

And, in your opinion, do those who think the evil a benefit know that it is evil?

Men.

I do not think that at all.

Soc.

Obviously those who are ignorant of the evil do not desire it, but only what they supposed

77e
to be good, though it is really evil; so that those who are ignorant of it and think it good are really desiring the good. Is not that so?

Men.

It would seem to be so in their case.

Soc.

Well now, I presume those who, as you say, desire the evil, and consider that the evil harms him who gets it, know that they will be harmed by it?

Tokens

Men 1 w 3
But 1 w 7
I 1 w 8
should 1 w 14
stay 1 w 18
Socrates 1 w 27
if 1 w 30
you 1 w 33
would 1 w 38
give 1 w 42
me 1 w 44
many 1 w 48
such 1 w 52
answers 1 w 59
Soc 2 w 63
Well 1 w 68
then 1 w 72
I 2 w 74
will 1 w 78
spare 1 w 83
no 1 w 85
endeavor 1 w 93
both 1 w 98
for 1 w 101
your 1 w 105
sake 1 w 109
and 1 w 112
for 2 w 115
my 1 w 117
own 1 w 120
to 1 w 123
continue 1 w 131
in 2 w 133
that 1 w 137
style 1 w 142
but 1 w 146
I 3 w 147
fear 1 w 151
I 4 w 152
may 1 w 155
not 1 w 158
succeed 1 w 165
in 3 w 167
keeping 1 w 174
for 3 w 177
long 1 w 181
on 3 w 183
that 2 w 187
level 1 w 192
But 2 w 196
come 1 w 200
now 1 w 203
you 3 w 207
in 5 w 209
your 2 w 213
turn 1 w 217
must 1 w 221
try 1 w 224
and 2 w 227
fulfil 1 w 233
your 3 w 237
promise 1 w 244
by 1 w 246
telling 1 w 253
me 3 w 255
what 1 w 259
virtue 1 w 265
is 2 w 267
in 7 w 269
a 15 w 270
general 1 w 277
way 1 w 280
and 3 w 284
you 6 w 287
must 2 w 291
stop 1 w 295
producing 1 w 304
a 19 w 305
plural 1 w 311
from 1 w 315
the 2 w 318
singular 1 w 326
as 1 w 329
the 3 w 332
wags 1 w 336
say 1 w 339
whenever 1 w 347
one 1 w 350
breaks 1 w 356
something 1 w 365
but 2 w 369
leave 1 w 374
virtue 2 w 380
whole 1 w 385
and 4 w 388
sound 1 w 393
and 5 w 397
tell 2 w 401
me 5 w 403
what 2 w 407
it 1 w 409
is 3 w 411
The 1 w 415
pattern 1 w 422
you 7 w 425
have 1 w 429
now 2 w 432
got 1 w 435
from 2 w 439
me 6 w 441
Men 2 w 445
Well 2 w 450
in 11 w 453
my 2 w 455
view 1 w 459
Socrates 2 w 468
virtue 3 w 475
is 4 w 477
in 12 w 480
the 4 w 483
poet 1 w 487
s 26 w 489
words 1 w 494
to 3 w 497
rejoice 1 w 504
in 13 w 506
things 1 w 512
honorable 1 w 521
and 6 w 524
be 1 w 526
able 2 w 530
for 4 w 533
them 1 w 537
Perhaps 1 w 544
from 3 w 548
Simonides 1 w 557
and 7 w 562
that 3 w 566
I 5 w 568
say 2 w 571
is 5 w 574
virtue 4 w 580
to 4 w 583
desire 1 w 589
what 3 w 593
is 6 w 595
honorable 2 w 604
and 8 w 607
be 2 w 609
able 4 w 613
to 5 w 615
procure 1 w 622
it 2 w 624
Soc 4 w 628
Do 1 w 631
you 8 w 634
say 3 w 637
that 4 w 641
he 8 w 643
who 2 w 646
desires 1 w 653
the 6 w 656
honorable 3 w 665
is 7 w 667
desirous 1 w 675
of 1 w 677
the 7 w 680
good 1 w 684
Men 3 w 688
Certainly 1 w 698
Soc 5 w 702
Implying 1 w 711
that 5 w 715
there 1 w 720
are 2 w 723
some 2 w 727
who 3 w 730
desire 3 w 736
the 9 w 739
evil 1 w 743
and 9 w 747
others 1 w 753
the 11 w 756
good 2 w 760
Do 2 w 763
not 2 w 766
all 1 w 769
men 1 w 772
in 17 w 775
your 4 w 779
opinion 1 w 786
my 3 w 789
dear 1 w 793
sir 5 w 796
desire 4 w 803
the 12 w 806
good 3 w 810
Men 4 w 814
I 7 w 816
think 1 w 821
not 3 w 824
Soc 6 w 828
There 1 w 834
are 3 w 837
some 3 w 841
who 4 w 844
desire 5 w 850
the 13 w 853
evil 2 w 857
Men 5 w 861
Yes 1 w 865
Soc 7 w 869
Thinking 1 w 878
the 14 w 881
evil 3 w 885
to 6 w 887
be 3 w 889
good 4 w 893
do 1 w 896
you 10 w 899
mean 1 w 903
or 10 w 906
actually 1 w 914
recognizing 1 w 925
it 3 w 927
to 7 w 929
be 4 w 931
evil 4 w 935
and 10 w 939
desiring 1 w 947
it 4 w 949
nevertheless 1 w 961
Men 6 w 965
Both 1 w 970
I 8 w 972
believe 1 w 979
Soc 8 w 983
Do 3 w 986
you 11 w 989
really 1 w 995
believe 2 w 1002
Meno 1 w 1007
that 6 w 1012
a 60 w 1013
man 2 w 1016
knows 1 w 1021
the 16 w 1024
evil 5 w 1028
to 8 w 1030
be 7 w 1032
evil 6 w 1036
and 11 w 1040
still 1 w 1045
desires 2 w 1052
it 5 w 1054
Men 8 w 1058
Certainly 2 w 1068
Soc 9 w 1072
What 1 w 1077
do 2 w 1079
you 12 w 1082
mean 2 w 1086
by 2 w 1088
desires 3 w 1095
Desires 1 w 1103
the 17 w 1106
possession 1 w 1116
of 2 w 1118
it 6 w 1120
Men 9 w 1124
Yes 2 w 1128
what 4 w 1133
else 1 w 1137
could 1 w 1142
it 7 w 1144
be 8 w 1146
Soc 10 w 1150
And 1 w 1154
does 1 w 1158
he 22 w 1160
think 2 w 1165
the 18 w 1168
evil 7 w 1172
benefits 1 w 1180
him 1 w 1183
who 5 w 1186
gets 1 w 1190
it 9 w 1192
or 11 w 1195
does 2 w 1199
he 24 w 1201
know 2 w 1205
that 7 w 1209
it 10 w 1211
harms 1 w 1216
him 2 w 1219
who 6 w 1222
has 1 w 1225
it 11 w 1227
Men 10 w 1231
There 2 w 1237
are 4 w 1240
some 4 w 1244
who 7 w 1247
think 3 w 1252
the 19 w 1255
evil 8 w 1259
is 8 w 1261
a 71 w 1262
benefit 2 w 1269
and 12 w 1273
others 2 w 1279
who 8 w 1282
know 3 w 1286
that 8 w 1290
it 13 w 1292
does 3 w 1296
harm 2 w 1300
Soc 11 w 1304
And 2 w 1308
in 27 w 1311
your 5 w 1315
opinion 2 w 1322
do 6 w 1325
those 1 w 1330
who 9 w 1333
think 4 w 1338
the 21 w 1341
evil 9 w 1345
a 75 w 1346
benefit 3 w 1353
know 4 w 1357
that 9 w 1361
it 15 w 1363
is 9 w 1365
evil 10 w 1369
Men 11 w 1373
I 9 w 1375
do 7 w 1377
not 4 w 1380
think 5 w 1385
that 10 w 1389
at 19 w 1391
all 4 w 1394
Soc 12 w 1398
Obviously 1 w 1408
those 2 w 1413
who 10 w 1416
are 5 w 1419
ignorant 1 w 1427
of 3 w 1429
the 22 w 1432
evil 11 w 1436
do 8 w 1438
not 5 w 1441
desire 8 w 1447
it 16 w 1449
but 3 w 1453
only 1 w 1457
what 5 w 1461
they 1 w 1465
supposed 1 w 1473
to 9 w 1475
be 12 w 1477
good 5 w 1481
though 1 w 1488
it 17 w 1490
is 10 w 1492
really 2 w 1498
evil 12 w 1502
so 6 w 1505
that 11 w 1509
those 3 w 1514
who 11 w 1517
are 6 w 1520
ignorant 2 w 1528
of 4 w 1530
it 18 w 1532
and 13 w 1535
think 6 w 1540
it 19 w 1542
good 6 w 1546
are 7 w 1549
really 3 w 1555
desiring 2 w 1563
the 24 w 1566
good 7 w 1570
Is 1 w 1573
not 6 w 1576
that 12 w 1580
so 7 w 1582
Men 12 w 1586
It 1 w 1589
would 2 w 1594
seem 1 w 1598
to 10 w 1600
be 13 w 1602
so 8 w 1604
in 33 w 1606
their 1 w 1611
case 1 w 1615
Soc 13 w 1619
Well 3 w 1624
now 7 w 1627
I 12 w 1629
presume 1 w 1636
those 4 w 1641
who 12 w 1644
as 4 w 1647
you 14 w 1650
say 4 w 1653
desire 9 w 1660
the 26 w 1663
evil 13 w 1667
and 14 w 1671
consider 1 w 1679
that 13 w 1683
the 27 w 1686
evil 14 w 1690
harms 2 w 1695
him 3 w 1698
who 13 w 1701
gets 2 w 1705
it 20 w 1707
know 5 w 1712
that 14 w 1716
they 2 w 1720
will 2 w 1724
be 14 w 1726
harmed 1 w 1732
by 3 w 1734
it 21 w 1736