Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Meno

Meno (76)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0059.tlg024.perseus-eng2:76
Refs {'start': {'reference': '76', 'human_reference': 'Section 76'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
76
76a
Soc.

Well then, you speak of a surface, and also of a solidthe terms employed in geometrical problems?

Men.

I do.

Soc.

So now you are able to comprehend from all this what I mean by figure. In every instance of figure I call that figure in which the solid ends; and I may put that more succinctly by saying that figure is limit of solid.

Men.

And what do you say of color, Socrates?

Soc.

How overbearing of you, Meno, to press an old man with demands for answers, when you will not trouble yourself

76b
to recollect and tell me what account Gorgias gives of virtue!

Men.

When you have answered my question, Socrates, I will answer yours.

Soc.

One might tell even blindfolded, Meno, by the way you discuss, that you are handsome and still have lovers.

Men.

Why so?

Soc.

Because you invariably speak in a peremptory tone, after the fashion of spoilt beauties, holding as they do a despotic power so long as their bloom is on them. You have also, I daresay,

76c
made a note of my weakness for handsome people. So I will indulge you, and answer.

Men.

You must certainly indulge me.

Soc.

Then would you like me to answer you in the manner of Gorgias,[*] which you would find easiest to follow?

Men.

I should like that, of course.

Soc.

Do not both of you say there are certain effluences[*] of existent things, as Empedocles held?

Men.

Certainly.

Soc.

And passages into which and through which the effluences pass?

Men.

To be sure.

Soc.

And some of the effluences fit into various passages,

76d
while some are too small or too large?

Men.

That is so.

Soc.

And further, there is what you call sight?

Men.

Yes.

Soc.

So now

conceive my meaning,
as Pindar [*] says: color is an effluence of figures, commensurate with sight and sensible.

Men.

Your answer, Socrates, seems to me excellently put.

Soc.

Yes, for I expect you find its terms familiar; and at the same time I fancy you observe that it enables you to tell what sound and smell are, and numerous other

76e
things of the kind.

Men.

Certainly.

Soc.

It is an answer in the high poetic style, Meno, and so more agreeable to you than that about figure.

Men.

Yes, it is.

Soc.

But yet, son of Alexidemus, I am inclined to think the other was the better of the two; and I believe you also would prefer it, if you were not compelled, as you were saying yesterday, to go away before the mysteries, and could stay awhile and be initiated.

Tokens

Soc 1 w 3
Well 1 w 8
then 1 w 12
you 1 w 16
speak 1 w 21
of 1 w 23
a 2 w 24
surface 1 w 31
and 1 w 35
also 1 w 39
of 2 w 41
a 6 w 42
solid 1 w 47
the 2 w 51
terms 1 w 56
employed 1 w 64
in 1 w 66
geometrical 1 w 77
problems 1 w 85
Men 1 w 89
I 1 w 91
do 1 w 93
Soc 2 w 97
So 3 w 100
now 1 w 103
you 2 w 106
are 1 w 109
able 1 w 113
to 1 w 115
comprehend 1 w 125
from 1 w 129
all 1 w 132
this 1 w 136
what 1 w 140
I 2 w 141
mean 1 w 145
by 1 w 147
figure 1 w 153
In 1 w 156
every 1 w 161
instance 1 w 169
of 3 w 171
figure 2 w 177
I 4 w 178
call 1 w 182
that 1 w 186
figure 3 w 192
in 3 w 194
which 1 w 199
the 3 w 202
solid 2 w 207
ends 1 w 211
and 2 w 215
I 5 w 216
may 1 w 219
put 1 w 222
that 2 w 226
more 1 w 230
succinctly 1 w 240
by 2 w 242
saying 1 w 248
that 3 w 252
figure 4 w 258
is 2 w 260
limit 1 w 265
of 4 w 267
solid 3 w 272
Men 2 w 276
And 1 w 280
what 2 w 284
do 2 w 286
you 3 w 289
say 2 w 292
of 5 w 294
color 1 w 299
Socrates 1 w 308
Soc 4 w 312
How 1 w 316
overbearing 1 w 327
of 6 w 329
you 4 w 332
Meno 1 w 337
to 2 w 340
press 1 w 345
an 5 w 347
old 1 w 350
man 1 w 353
with 1 w 357
demands 1 w 364
for 1 w 367
answers 1 w 374
when 1 w 379
you 5 w 382
will 1 w 386
not 1 w 389
trouble 1 w 396
yourself 1 w 404
to 3 w 406
recollect 1 w 415
and 4 w 418
tell 1 w 422
me 3 w 424
what 3 w 428
account 1 w 435
Gorgias 1 w 442
gives 1 w 447
of 7 w 449
virtue 1 w 455
Men 4 w 459
When 1 w 464
you 7 w 467
have 1 w 471
answered 1 w 479
my 1 w 481
question 1 w 489
Socrates 2 w 498
I 6 w 500
will 2 w 504
answer 3 w 510
yours 2 w 515
Soc 6 w 519
One 1 w 523
might 1 w 528
tell 2 w 532
even 1 w 536
blindfolded 1 w 547
Meno 2 w 552
by 3 w 555
the 4 w 558
way 1 w 561
you 9 w 564
discuss 1 w 571
that 4 w 576
you 10 w 579
are 2 w 582
handsome 1 w 590
and 6 w 593
still 1 w 598
have 2 w 602
lovers 1 w 608
Men 6 w 612
Why 1 w 616
so 6 w 618
Soc 7 w 622
Because 1 w 630
you 11 w 633
invariably 1 w 643
speak 2 w 648
in 9 w 650
a 47 w 651
peremptory 1 w 661
tone 1 w 665
after 1 w 671
the 5 w 674
fashion 1 w 681
of 8 w 683
spoilt 1 w 689
beauties 1 w 697
holding 1 w 705
as 3 w 707
they 1 w 711
do 3 w 713
a 52 w 714
despotic 1 w 722
power 1 w 727
so 7 w 729
long 1 w 733
as 4 w 735
their 1 w 740
bloom 1 w 745
is 4 w 747
on 5 w 749
them 1 w 753
You 1 w 757
have 3 w 761
also 2 w 765
I 7 w 767
daresay 1 w 774
made 1 w 779
a 59 w 780
note 1 w 784
of 9 w 786
my 2 w 788
weakness 1 w 796
for 2 w 799
handsome 2 w 807
people 1 w 813
So 9 w 816
I 8 w 817
will 3 w 821
indulge 1 w 828
you 12 w 831
and 8 w 835
answer 4 w 841
Men 7 w 845
You 2 w 849
must 1 w 853
certainly 1 w 862
indulge 2 w 869
me 6 w 871
Soc 8 w 875
Then 1 w 880
would 1 w 885
you 13 w 888
like 1 w 892
me 7 w 894
to 6 w 896
answer 5 w 902
you 14 w 905
in 14 w 907
the 9 w 910
manner 1 w 916
of 10 w 918
Gorgias 2 w 925
There 1 w 931
is 5 w 933
something 1 w 942
of 11 w 944
Gorgias 3 w 951
stately 1 w 959
style 1 w 964
in 16 w 966
the 10 w 969
definition 1 w 979
that 5 w 983
follows 1 w 990
but 1 w 994
the 11 w 997
implication 1 w 1008
seems 1 w 1013
mainly 1 w 1019
to 7 w 1021
be 3 w 1023
that 6 w 1027
the 12 w 1030
substance 1 w 1039
of 12 w 1041
it 4 w 1043
will 4 w 1047
be 4 w 1049
familiar 1 w 1057
to 8 w 1059
Meno 3 w 1063
because 1 w 1070
he 18 w 1072
was 1 w 1075
a 79 w 1076
pupil 1 w 1081
of 13 w 1083
Gorgias 4 w 1090
who 1 w 1094
had 1 w 1097
learnt 1 w 1103
his 2 w 1106
science 1 w 1113
from 2 w 1117
Empedocles 1 w 1127
which 2 w 1133
you 15 w 1136
would 2 w 1141
find 1 w 1145
easiest 1 w 1152
to 9 w 1154
follow 2 w 1160
Men 9 w 1164
I 9 w 1166
should 1 w 1172
like 2 w 1176
that 7 w 1180
of 14 w 1183
course 1 w 1189
Soc 9 w 1193
Do 1 w 1196
not 3 w 1199
both 1 w 1203
of 15 w 1205
you 16 w 1208
say 4 w 1211
there 1 w 1216
are 4 w 1219
certain 2 w 1226
effluences 1 w 1236
Empedocles 2 w 1246
taught 1 w 1252
that 8 w 1256
material 1 w 1264
objects 1 w 1271
are 5 w 1274
known 1 w 1279
to 10 w 1281
us 5 w 1283
by 4 w 1285
means 1 w 1290
of 16 w 1292
effluences 2 w 1302
or 10 w 1304
films 1 w 1309
given 1 w 1314
off 1 w 1317
by 5 w 1319
them 2 w 1323
and 9 w 1326
suited 1 w 1332
in 21 w 1334
various 1 w 1341
ways 1 w 1345
to 11 w 1347
our 4 w 1350
sense-organs 1 w 1362
of 18 w 1365
existent 1 w 1373
things 1 w 1379
as 10 w 1382
Empedocles 3 w 1392
held 1 w 1396
Men 10 w 1400
Certainly 1 w 1410
Soc 10 w 1414
And 2 w 1418
passages 1 w 1426
into 1 w 1430
which 3 w 1435
and 10 w 1438
through 1 w 1445
which 4 w 1450
the 15 w 1453
effluences 3 w 1463
pass 2 w 1467
Men 11 w 1471
To 1 w 1474
be 6 w 1476
sure 1 w 1480
Soc 11 w 1484
And 3 w 1488
some 4 w 1492
of 19 w 1494
the 16 w 1497
effluences 4 w 1507
fit 1 w 1510
into 2 w 1514
various 2 w 1521
passages 2 w 1529
while 1 w 1535
some 5 w 1539
are 6 w 1542
too 1 w 1545
small 1 w 1550
or 12 w 1552
too 2 w 1555
large 1 w 1560
Men 12 w 1564
That 1 w 1569
is 8 w 1571
so 13 w 1573
Soc 12 w 1577
And 4 w 1581
further 1 w 1588
there 2 w 1594
is 9 w 1596
what 4 w 1600
you 17 w 1603
call 2 w 1607
sight 1 w 1612
Men 13 w 1616
Yes 1 w 1620
Soc 13 w 1624
So 16 w 1627
now 3 w 1630
conceive 1 w 1638
my 3 w 1640
meaning 1 w 1647
as 14 w 1650
Pindar 1 w 1656
Fr 1 w 1658
82 1 w 1661
Bergk 1 w 1667
cf 1 w 1671
Aristoph 1 w 1680
Birds 1 w 1686
939 1 w 1689
says 1 w 1694
color 2 w 1700
is 11 w 1702
an 25 w 1704
effluence 5 w 1713
of 20 w 1715
figures 1 w 1722
commensurate 1 w 1735
with 2 w 1739
sight 2 w 1744
and 11 w 1747
sensible 1 w 1755
Men 14 w 1759
Your 1 w 1764
answer 6 w 1770
Socrates 3 w 1779
seems 2 w 1785
to 17 w 1787
me 14 w 1789
excellently 1 w 1800
put 2 w 1803
Soc 15 w 1807
Yes 2 w 1811
for 3 w 1815
I 10 w 1816
expect 1 w 1822
you 18 w 1825
find 2 w 1829
its 1 w 1832
terms 2 w 1837
familiar 2 w 1845
and 12 w 1849
at 21 w 1851
the 19 w 1854
same 1 w 1858
time 1 w 1862
I 11 w 1863
fancy 1 w 1868
you 19 w 1871
observe 1 w 1878
that 9 w 1882
it 9 w 1884
enables 1 w 1891
you 20 w 1894
to 18 w 1896
tell 3 w 1900
what 5 w 1904
sound 1 w 1909
and 13 w 1912
smell 1 w 1917
are 7 w 1920
and 14 w 1924
numerous 1 w 1932
other 1 w 1937
things 2 w 1943
of 21 w 1945
the 21 w 1948
kind 1 w 1952
Men 15 w 1956
Certainly 2 w 1966
Soc 16 w 1970
It 1 w 1973
is 12 w 1975
an 32 w 1977
answer 7 w 1983
in 32 w 1985
the 22 w 1988
high 1 w 1992
poetic 1 w 1998
style 2 w 2003
Meno 4 w 2008
and 15 w 2012
so 15 w 2014
more 2 w 2018
agreeable 1 w 2027
to 19 w 2029
you 21 w 2032
than 1 w 2036
that 10 w 2040
about 1 w 2045
figure 6 w 2051
Men 17 w 2055
Yes 3 w 2059
it 10 w 2062
is 13 w 2064
Soc 17 w 2068
But 1 w 2072
yet 1 w 2075
son 1 w 2079
of 22 w 2081
Alexidemus 1 w 2091
I 13 w 2093
am 4 w 2095
inclined 1 w 2103
to 20 w 2105
think 1 w 2110
the 23 w 2113
other 2 w 2118
was 2 w 2121
the 25 w 2124
better 1 w 2130
of 23 w 2132
the 26 w 2135
two 1 w 2138
and 16 w 2142
I 14 w 2143
believe 1 w 2150
you 22 w 2153
also 3 w 2157
would 3 w 2162
prefer 1 w 2168
it 11 w 2170
if 1 w 2173
you 23 w 2176
were 2 w 2180
not 4 w 2183
compelled 1 w 2192
as 16 w 2195
you 24 w 2198
were 3 w 2202
saying 2 w 2208
yesterday 1 w 2217
to 21 w 2220
go 1 w 2222
away 1 w 2226
before 1 w 2232
the 27 w 2235
mysteries 1 w 2244
and 17 w 2248
could 1 w 2253
stay 1 w 2257
awhile 1 w 2263
and 18 w 2266
be 10 w 2268
initiated 1 w 2277