Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Poetics

Poetics (15.12-16.4)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0086.tlg034.perseus-eng2:15.12-16.4
Refs {'start': {'reference': '15.12', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 15 Subchapter 12'}, 'end': {'reference': '16.4', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 16 Subchapter 4'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '15'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Keep, then, a careful eye on these rules and also on the appeal to the eye[*] which is necessarily bound up with the poets business; for that offers many opportunities of going wrong. But this subject has been adequately discussed in the published treatises.[*]

What a Discovery is has been already stated.[*]

20
As for kinds of Discovery, first comes the least artistic kind, which is largely used owing to incompetencediscovery by tokens.

These may be congenital, like the spear the Earth-born bear or stars, like those which Carcinus[*] uses in his Thyestes[*];

or they may be acquired and these may be on the body, for instance, wounds, or external things like necklaces, and in the Tyro[*] the discovery by means of the boat.

There is a better and a worse way of using these tokens; for instance Odysseus, by means of his wound, was discovered in one way by the nurse and in another way by the swine-herds.[*]

Tokens

Keep 1 w 4
then 1 w 9
a 1 w 11
careful 1 w 18
eye 1 w 21
on 1 w 23
these 1 w 28
rules 1 w 33
and 1 w 36
also 1 w 40
on 2 w 42
the 3 w 45
appeal 1 w 51
to 1 w 53
the 4 w 56
eye 2 w 59
i 1 w 60
e 15 w 62
stage-craft 1 w 75
rather 1 w 81
than 1 w 85
staging 1 w 92
which 1 w 98
is 1 w 100
necessarily 1 w 111
bound 1 w 116
up 1 w 118
with 1 w 122
the 6 w 125
poet 1 w 129
s 9 w 131
business 1 w 139
for 1 w 143
that 1 w 147
offers 1 w 153
many 1 w 157
opportunities 1 w 170
of 2 w 172
going 1 w 177
wrong 1 w 182
But 1 w 186
this 1 w 190
subject 1 w 197
has 1 w 200
been 1 w 204
adequately 1 w 214
discussed 1 w 223
in 4 w 225
the 7 w 228
published 1 w 237
treatises 1 w 246
As 1 w 249
distinct 1 w 257
from 1 w 261
the 8 w 264
body 1 w 268
of 3 w 270
esoteric 1 w 278
doctrine 1 w 286
circulated 1 w 296
by 1 w 298
oral 1 w 302
teaching 1 w 310
among 1 w 315
Aristotle 1 w 324
s 28 w 326
pupils 1 w 332
What 1 w 337
a 24 w 338
Discovery 1 w 347
is 9 w 349
has 2 w 352
been 2 w 356
already 1 w 363
stated 1 w 369
In 1 w 372
chapter 1 w 379
11 1 w 381
As 2 w 384
for 2 w 387
kinds 1 w 392
of 4 w 394
Discovery 2 w 403
first 1 w 409
comes 1 w 414
the 9 w 417
least 1 w 422
artistic 1 w 430
kind 2 w 434
which 2 w 440
is 12 w 442
largely 1 w 449
used 1 w 453
owing 1 w 458
to 3 w 460
incompetence 1 w 472
discovery 1 w 482
by 2 w 484
tokens 1 w 490
These 1 w 496
may 1 w 499
be 3 w 501
congenital 1 w 511
like 1 w 516
the 10 w 519
spear 1 w 524
the 11 w 527
Earth-born 1 w 537
bear 1 w 541
or 6 w 543
stars 1 w 548
like 2 w 553
those 1 w 558
which 3 w 563
Carcinus 1 w 571
A 4 w 572
prolific 1 w 580
tragedian 1 w 589
of 5 w 591
the 12 w 594
early 1 w 599
fourth 1 w 605
century 1 w 612
The 2 w 616
family 1 w 622
are 2 w 625
agreeably 1 w 634
ridiculed 1 w 643
in 13 w 645
Aristophanes 1 w 657
Wasps 1 w 663
uses 1 w 668
in 14 w 670
his 2 w 673
Thyestes 1 w 681
These 2 w 686
were 1 w 690
birth-marks 1 w 701
The 4 w 705
spear-head 1 w 715
distinguished 1 w 728
the 13 w 731
descendants 1 w 742
of 6 w 744
the 14 w 747
Spartoi 1 w 754
at 8 w 756
Thebes 1 w 762
the 15 w 766
star 2 w 770
or 7 w 772
bright 1 w 778
spot 1 w 782
on 6 w 784
the 16 w 787
descendants 2 w 798
of 7 w 800
Pelops 1 w 806
commemorated 1 w 818
his 3 w 821
ivory 1 w 826
shoulder 1 w 834
and 2 w 838
in 16 w 840
Carcinus 2 w 848
s 76 w 850
play 1 w 854
it 4 w 856
seems 1 w 861
to 7 w 863
have 1 w 867
survived 1 w 875
cooking 1 w 882
or 10 w 886
they 1 w 890
may 2 w 893
be 6 w 895
acquired 1 w 903
and 3 w 906
these 2 w 911
may 3 w 914
be 7 w 916
on 7 w 918
the 19 w 921
body 2 w 925
for 3 w 929
instance 1 w 937
wounds 1 w 944
or 12 w 947
external 1 w 955
things 1 w 961
like 3 w 965
necklaces 1 w 974
and 4 w 978
in 21 w 980
the 20 w 983
Tyro 1 w 987
A 6 w 988
play 2 w 992
by 3 w 994
Sophocles 1 w 1003
Tyro 2 w 1008
s 86 w 1010
twins 1 w 1015
by 4 w 1017
Poseidon 1 w 1025
who 1 w 1029
appeared 1 w 1037
to 8 w 1039
her 2 w 1042
in 23 w 1044
the 21 w 1047
guise 1 w 1052
of 8 w 1054
the 22 w 1057
river 1 w 1062
Enipeus 1 w 1069
were 2 w 1074
exposed 1 w 1081
in 24 w 1083
a 73 w 1084
little 1 w 1090
boat 1 w 1094
or 13 w 1096
ark 2 w 1099
like 4 w 1104
Moses 1 w 1109
in 25 w 1111
the 23 w 1114
bulrushes 1 w 1123
and 5 w 1127
this 2 w 1131
led 2 w 1134
to 9 w 1136
their 1 w 1141
identification 1 w 1155
the 25 w 1159
discovery 2 w 1168
by 5 w 1170
means 1 w 1175
of 9 w 1177
the 26 w 1180
boat 2 w 1184
There 1 w 1190
is 22 w 1192
a 80 w 1193
better 1 w 1199
and 6 w 1202
a 82 w 1203
worse 1 w 1208
way 1 w 1211
of 10 w 1213
using 1 w 1218
these 3 w 1223
tokens 2 w 1229
for 4 w 1233
instance 2 w 1241
Odysseus 1 w 1249
by 6 w 1252
means 2 w 1257
of 11 w 1259
his 5 w 1262
wound 2 w 1267
was 1 w 1271
discovered 1 w 1281
in 28 w 1283
one 1 w 1286
way 2 w 1289
by 7 w 1291
the 28 w 1294
nurse 1 w 1299
and 7 w 1302
in 29 w 1304
another 1 w 1311
way 3 w 1314
by 8 w 1316
the 30 w 1319
swine-herds 1 w 1330
Hom 1 w 1334
Od 2 w 1337
19 1 w 1340
386ff 1 w 1346
205ff 1 w 1353
The 7 w 1357
first 2 w 1362
came 1 w 1366
about 1 w 1371
automatically 1 w 1384
the 31 w 1388
second 1 w 1394
was 2 w 1397
a 97 w 1398
deliberate 1 w 1408
demonstration 1 w 1421
to 12 w 1423
prove 1 w 1428
the 32 w 1431
point 1 w 1436
Aristotle 2 w 1446
here 2 w 1450
distinguishes 1 w 1463
between 1 w 1470
a 100 w 1471
discovery 3 w 1480
inevitably 1 w 1490
produced 1 w 1498
by 9 w 1500
the 33 w 1503
logic 1 w 1508
of 12 w 1510
events 1 w 1516
e 192 w 1518
g 22 w 1520
it 7 w 1523
was 3 w 1526
inevitable 1 w 1536
or 16 w 1538
at 16 w 1540
least 2 w 1545
probable 1 w 1553
that 2 w 1557
Odysseus 2 w 1565
arriving 1 w 1574
as 9 w 1576
a 110 w 1577
strange 1 w 1584
traveller 1 w 1593
should 2 w 1600
be 11 w 1602
washed 1 w 1608
by 10 w 1610
Eurycleia 1 w 1619
and 8 w 1623
that 3 w 1627
she 6 w 1630
should 3 w 1636
thus 1 w 1640
see 2 w 1643
the 34 w 1646
old 1 w 1649
scar 1 w 1653
on 14 w 1655
his 6 w 1658
thigh 1 w 1663
and 9 w 1666
discover 5 w 1674
his 7 w 1677
identity 1 w 1685
and 10 w 1689
a 120 w 1690
discovery 4 w 1699
produced 2 w 1707
by 11 w 1709
a 121 w 1710
deliberate 2 w 1720
declaration 1 w 1731
e 216 w 1733
g 26 w 1735
Odysseus 3 w 1744
s 146 w 1746
declaration 2 w 1757
of 13 w 1759
his 8 w 1762
identity 2 w 1770
to 14 w 1772
Eumaeus 1 w 1779
The 8 w 1784
latter 1 w 1790
kind 3 w 1794
is 34 w 1796
manufactured 1 w 1808
by 12 w 1810
the 35 w 1813
poet 2 w 1817
not 2 w 1821
logically 1 w 1830
caused 1 w 1836
by 13 w 1838
what 1 w 1842
has 3 w 1845
gone 1 w 1849
before 1 w 1855