Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Poetics

Poetics (15.10-15.11)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0086.tlg034.perseus-eng2:15.10-15.11
Refs {'start': {'reference': '15.10', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 15 Subchapter 10'}, 'end': {'reference': '15.11', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 15 Subchapter 11'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '15'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

In character-drawing just as much as in the arrangement of the incidents one should always seek what is inevitable or probable, so as to make it inevitable or probable that such and such a person should say or do such and such; and inevitable or probable that one thing should follow another.

Clearly therefore the denouement[*] of each play should also be the result of the plot itself and not produced mechanically as in the Medea and the incident of the embarkation in the Iliad.

1454b
1
[*]

The god in the car[*] should only be used to explain what lies outside the play, either what happened earlier and is therefore beyond human knowledge, or what happens later and needs to be foretold in a proclamation. For we ascribe to the gods the power of seeing everything.

There must, however, be nothing inexplicable in the incidents, or, if there is, it must lie outside the tragedy. There is an example in Sophocles Oedipus.[*]

Since tragedy is a representation of men better than ourselves we must copy the good portrait-painters who, while rendering the distinctive form and making a likeness, yet paint people better than they are. It is the same with the poet. When representing people who are hot-tempered or lazy, or have other such traits of character, he should make them such, yet men of worth [an example of hardness][*]; take the way in which Agathon and Homer portray Achilles.

Tokens

In 1 w 2
character-drawing 1 w 19
just 1 w 23
as 1 w 25
much 1 w 29
as 2 w 31
in 2 w 33
the 1 w 36
arrangement 1 w 47
of 1 w 49
the 2 w 52
incidents 1 w 61
one 1 w 64
should 1 w 70
always 1 w 76
seek 1 w 80
what 1 w 84
is 1 w 86
inevitable 1 w 96
or 1 w 98
probable 1 w 106
so 1 w 109
as 3 w 111
to 1 w 113
make 1 w 117
it 2 w 119
inevitable 2 w 129
or 2 w 131
probable 2 w 139
that 1 w 143
such 1 w 147
and 1 w 150
such 2 w 154
a 19 w 155
person 1 w 161
should 2 w 167
say 1 w 170
or 3 w 172
do 1 w 174
such 3 w 178
and 2 w 181
such 4 w 185
and 3 w 189
inevitable 3 w 199
or 4 w 201
probable 3 w 209
that 2 w 213
one 2 w 216
thing 1 w 221
should 3 w 227
follow 1 w 233
another 1 w 240
Clearly 1 w 248
therefore 1 w 257
the 5 w 260
denouement 1 w 270
Or 1 w 272
unravelling 1 w 283
of 2 w 286
each 1 w 290
play 1 w 294
should 4 w 300
also 1 w 304
be 1 w 306
the 6 w 309
result 1 w 315
of 3 w 317
the 7 w 320
plot 1 w 324
itself 1 w 330
and 4 w 333
not 2 w 336
produced 1 w 344
mechanically 1 w 356
as 4 w 358
in 9 w 360
the 8 w 363
Medea 1 w 368
and 5 w 371
the 9 w 374
incident 2 w 382
of 4 w 384
the 10 w 387
embarkation 1 w 398
in 11 w 400
the 11 w 403
Iliad 1 w 408
Hom 1 w 412
Il 2 w 415
2 1 w 417
155-181 1 w 425
where 1 w 431
it 6 w 433
is 2 w 435
only 1 w 439
the 12 w 442
arbitrary 1 w 451
i 26 w 453
e 51 w 455
uncaused 1 w 465
intervention 1 w 478
of 5 w 480
Athene 1 w 486
which 1 w 491
stays 1 w 496
the 14 w 499
flight 1 w 505
of 6 w 507
the 15 w 510
Greeks 1 w 516
In 2 w 519
the 16 w 522
Medea 2 w 527
the 17 w 530
heroine 1 w 537
having 1 w 544
killed 1 w 550
her 5 w 553
rival 1 w 558
and 6 w 561
her 6 w 564
children 1 w 572
is 3 w 575
spirited 1 w 583
away 1 w 587
in 15 w 589
the 18 w 592
chariot 1 w 599
ot 5 w 601
the 19 w 604
Sun 1 w 607
a 52 w 609
result 2 w 615
not 3 w 618
caused 2 w 624
by 1 w 626
what 2 w 630
has 1 w 633
gone 1 w 637
before 1 w 643
The 1 w 647
god 1 w 650
in 16 w 652
the 20 w 655
car 1 w 658
The 2 w 661
μηχανή 1 w 667
or 7 w 669
car 2 w 672
was 1 w 675
a 59 w 676
sort 1 w 680
of 7 w 682
crane 1 w 687
with 1 w 691
a 61 w 692
pulley 1 w 698
attached 1 w 706
which 2 w 712
was 2 w 715
fixed 1 w 720
at 7 w 722
the 21 w 725
top 1 w 728
of 8 w 730
the 22 w 733
back-scene 1 w 743
in 17 w 745
the 23 w 748
left 1 w 752
corner 1 w 758
of 9 w 760
the 24 w 763
stage 1 w 768
By 1 w 771
it 10 w 773
a 68 w 774
god 2 w 777
or 10 w 779
hero 2 w 783
could 1 w 788
be 3 w 790
lowered 1 w 797
or 11 w 799
raised 1 w 805
or 12 w 807
exhibited 1 w 816
motionless 1 w 826
in 18 w 828
mid-air 1 w 835
Weak 1 w 840
dramatists 1 w 850
thus 1 w 854
introduced 1 w 864
a 74 w 865
car 3 w 868
to 3 w 870
cut 1 w 873
the 25 w 876
knot 1 w 880
by 2 w 882
declaring 1 w 891
the 26 w 894
denouement 2 w 904
instead 1 w 911
of 10 w 913
unravelling 2 w 924
the 27 w 927
plot 2 w 931
by 3 w 933
the 28 w 936
logic 1 w 941
of 11 w 943
cause 3 w 948
and 7 w 951
effect 1 w 957
It 1 w 960
was 3 w 963
presumably 1 w 973
on 9 w 975
such 5 w 979
a 83 w 980
car 4 w 983
that 3 w 987
Medea 3 w 992
was 4 w 995
borne 1 w 1000
away 2 w 1004
should 5 w 1011
only 2 w 1015
be 4 w 1017
used 3 w 1021
to 4 w 1023
explain 1 w 1030
what 3 w 1034
lies 1 w 1038
outside 1 w 1045
the 29 w 1048
play 2 w 1052
either 1 w 1059
what 4 w 1063
happened 1 w 1071
earlier 1 w 1078
and 8 w 1081
is 6 w 1083
therefore 2 w 1092
beyond 1 w 1098
human 1 w 1103
knowledge 1 w 1112
or 15 w 1115
what 5 w 1119
happens 1 w 1126
later 1 w 1131
and 9 w 1134
needs 1 w 1139
to 5 w 1141
be 6 w 1143
foretold 1 w 1151
in 24 w 1153
a 102 w 1154
proclamation 1 w 1166
For 1 w 1170
we 2 w 1172
ascribe 1 w 1179
to 7 w 1181
the 32 w 1184
gods 1 w 1188
the 33 w 1191
power 1 w 1196
of 12 w 1198
seeing 1 w 1204
everything 1 w 1214
There 1 w 1220
must 1 w 1224
however 1 w 1232
be 8 w 1235
nothing 1 w 1242
inexplicable 1 w 1254
in 29 w 1256
the 34 w 1259
incidents 2 w 1268
or 18 w 1271
if 1 w 1274
there 3 w 1279
is 7 w 1281
it 13 w 1284
must 2 w 1288
lie 3 w 1291
outside 2 w 1298
the 36 w 1301
tragedy 1 w 1308
There 2 w 1314
is 8 w 1316
an 15 w 1318
example 1 w 1325
in 31 w 1327
Sophocles 1 w 1336
Oedipus 1 w 1344
i 85 w 1346
e 176 w 1348
Oedipus 2 w 1357
had 1 w 1360
killed 2 w 1366
Laius 1 w 1371
in 32 w 1373
a 112 w 1374
wayside 1 w 1381
quarrel 1 w 1388
not 6 w 1392
knowing 1 w 1399
who 1 w 1402
he 47 w 1404
was 5 w 1407
When 1 w 1412
his 1 w 1415
subjects 1 w 1423
at 15 w 1425
Thebes 1 w 1431
crave 1 w 1436
his 2 w 1439
help 1 w 1443
to 8 w 1445
remove 1 w 1451
the 37 w 1454
curse 1 w 1459
which 3 w 1464
is 11 w 1466
blighting 1 w 1475
their 1 w 1480
crops 1 w 1485
he 53 w 1488
pledges 1 w 1495
himself 1 w 1502
to 9 w 1504
discover 1 w 1512
the 39 w 1515
murderer 1 w 1523
of 13 w 1525
Laius 2 w 1530
It 2 w 1533
may 1 w 1536
seem 1 w 1540
odd 1 w 1543
that 4 w 1547
he 55 w 1549
should 6 w 1555
not 7 w 1558
know 3 w 1562
enough 1 w 1568
about 1 w 1573
the 40 w 1576
details 1 w 1583
of 14 w 1585
the 41 w 1588
murder 2 w 1594
to 10 w 1596
connect 1 w 1603
it 14 w 1605
in 35 w 1607
his 3 w 1610
mind 1 w 1614
with 2 w 1618
his 4 w 1621
own 1 w 1624
murderous 1 w 1633
quarrel 2 w 1640
But 1 w 1644
that 5 w 1648
was 6 w 1651
long 1 w 1655
ago 1 w 1658
and 10 w 1662
neither 1 w 1669
an 17 w 1671
audience 1 w 1679
nor 1 w 1682
a 130 w 1683
novel-reader 1 w 1695
is 15 w 1697
critical 1 w 1705
about 2 w 1710
incidents 3 w 1719
which 4 w 1724
occur 1 w 1729
long 2 w 1733
before 2 w 1739
the 43 w 1742
point 1 w 1747
at 18 w 1749
which 5 w 1754
the 44 w 1757
story 1 w 1762
begins 1 w 1768
See 1 w 1772
chapter 1 w 1779
Aristot 1 w 1786
Poet 1 w 1791
24 1 w 1794
20 1 w 1797
Since 1 w 1803
tragedy 2 w 1810
is 17 w 1812
a 137 w 1813
representation 1 w 1827
of 15 w 1829
men 4 w 1832
better 1 w 1838
than 1 w 1842
ourselves 1 w 1851
we 5 w 1853
must 3 w 1857
copy 1 w 1861
the 45 w 1864
good 1 w 1868
portrait-painters 1 w 1885
who 2 w 1888
while 1 w 1894
rendering 1 w 1903
the 46 w 1906
distinctive 1 w 1917
form 1 w 1921
and 11 w 1924
making 1 w 1930
a 144 w 1931
likeness 1 w 1939
yet 1 w 1943
paint 2 w 1948
people 1 w 1954
better 2 w 1960
than 2 w 1964
they 1 w 1968
are 1 w 1971
It 3 w 1974
is 19 w 1976
the 48 w 1979
same 1 w 1983
with 3 w 1987
the 49 w 1990
poet 1 w 1994
When 2 w 1999
representing 1 w 2011
people 2 w 2017
who 3 w 2020
are 2 w 2023
hot-tempered 1 w 2035
or 24 w 2037
lazy 1 w 2041
or 25 w 2044
have 1 w 2048
other 2 w 2053
such 6 w 2057
traits 1 w 2063
of 16 w 2065
character 2 w 2074
he 68 w 2077
should 7 w 2083
make 2 w 2087
them 1 w 2091
such 7 w 2095
yet 2 w 2099
men 5 w 2102
of 17 w 2104
worth 1 w 2109
an 21 w 2112
example 2 w 2119
of 18 w 2121
hardness 1 w 2129
Apparently 1 w 2140
a 160 w 2141
note 1 w 2145
on 17 w 2147
Achilles 1 w 2155
which 6 w 2160
has 2 w 2163
been 1 w 2167
copied 1 w 2173
by 4 w 2175
mistake 1 w 2182
into 1 w 2186
the 52 w 2189
text 1 w 2193
take 2 w 2199
the 53 w 2202
way 5 w 2205
in 48 w 2207
which 7 w 2212
Agathon 1 w 2219
and 12 w 2222
Homer 1 w 2227
portray 1 w 2234
Achilles 2 w 2242