Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Icaromenippus, an Aerial Expedition

Icaromenippus, an Aerial Expedition (7-8)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0062.tlg021.perseus-eng4:7-8
Refs {'start': {'reference': '7', 'human_reference': 'Section 7'}, 'end': {'reference': '8', 'human_reference': 'Section 8'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
Menippus

Then, how reasonable and modest of them, dealing with subjects so debatable, to issue their views without a hint of uncertainty; thus it must be and it shall be; contra genes they will have it so; they will tell you on oath the sun is a molten mass, the moon inhabited, and the stars water-drinkers, moisture being drawn up by the suns rope and bucket and equitably distributed among them.

Menippus

How their theories conflict is soon apparent; next-door neighbours? no, they are miles apart. In the first place, their views of the world differ. Some say it had no beginning, and cannot end; others boldly talk of its creator and his procedure; what particularly entertained me was that these latter set up a contriver of the universe, but fail to mention where he came from, or what he stood on while about his elaborate task, though it is by no means obvious how there could be place or time before the universe came into being.

Friend

You really do make them out very audacious conjurers.

Menippus

My dear fellow, I wish I could give you their lucubrations on ideas and incorporeals, on finite and infinite. Over that point, now, there is fierce battle; some circumscribe the All, others will have it unlimited. At the same time they declare for a plurality of worlds, and speak scornfully of others who make only one. And there is a bellicose person who maintains that war is the father of the universe 3.

Tokens

Menippus 1 w 8
Then 1 w 12
how 1 w 16
reasonable 1 w 26
and 1 w 29
modest 1 w 35
of 1 w 37
them 1 w 41
dealing 1 w 49
with 1 w 53
subjects 1 w 61
so 2 w 63
debatable 1 w 72
to 1 w 75
issue 1 w 80
their 1 w 85
views 1 w 90
without 1 w 97
a 7 w 98
hint 1 w 102
of 2 w 104
uncertainty 1 w 115
thus 1 w 120
it 3 w 122
must 1 w 126
be 1 w 128
and 2 w 131
it 4 w 133
shall 1 w 138
be 2 w 140
contra 1 w 147
genes 1 w 152
they 1 w 156
will 1 w 160
have 1 w 164
it 5 w 166
so 3 w 168
they 2 w 173
will 2 w 177
tell 1 w 181
you 1 w 184
on 3 w 186
oath 1 w 190
the 5 w 193
sun 1 w 196
is 2 w 198
a 14 w 199
molten 1 w 205
mass 1 w 209
the 6 w 213
moon 1 w 217
inhabited 1 w 226
and 3 w 230
the 7 w 233
stars 1 w 238
water-drinkers 1 w 252
moisture 1 w 261
being 1 w 266
drawn 1 w 271
up 1 w 273
by 1 w 275
the 8 w 278
sun 2 w 281
s 24 w 283
rope 1 w 287
and 4 w 290
bucket 1 w 296
and 5 w 299
equitably 1 w 308
distributed 1 w 319
among 1 w 324
them 2 w 328
Menippus 2 w 337
How 1 w 340
their 2 w 345
theories 1 w 353
conflict 1 w 361
is 5 w 363
soon 1 w 367
apparent 1 w 375
next-door 1 w 385
neighbours 1 w 395
no 1 w 398
they 3 w 403
are 2 w 406
miles 1 w 411
apart 1 w 416
In 1 w 419
the 13 w 422
first 1 w 427
place 1 w 432
their 3 w 438
views 2 w 443
of 3 w 445
the 15 w 448
world 1 w 453
differ 1 w 459
Some 1 w 464
say 1 w 467
it 8 w 469
had 1 w 472
no 2 w 474
beginning 1 w 483
and 6 w 487
cannot 1 w 493
end 1 w 496
others 1 w 503
boldly 1 w 509
talk 1 w 513
of 4 w 515
its 1 w 518
creator 1 w 525
and 7 w 528
his 1 w 531
procedure 1 w 540
what 1 w 545
particularly 1 w 557
entertained 1 w 568
me 2 w 570
was 1 w 573
that 1 w 577
these 1 w 582
latter 1 w 588
set 1 w 591
up 2 w 593
a 45 w 594
contriver 1 w 603
of 5 w 605
the 18 w 608
universe 1 w 616
but 2 w 620
fail 1 w 624
to 3 w 626
mention 1 w 633
where 1 w 638
he 21 w 640
came 1 w 644
from 1 w 648
or 5 w 651
what 2 w 655
he 22 w 657
stood 1 w 662
on 10 w 664
while 1 w 669
about 1 w 674
his 2 w 677
elaborate 1 w 686
task 1 w 690
though 1 w 697
it 10 w 699
is 8 w 701
by 2 w 703
no 4 w 705
means 1 w 710
obvious 1 w 717
how 2 w 720
there 1 w 725
could 1 w 730
be 5 w 732
place 2 w 737
or 7 w 739
time 1 w 743
before 1 w 749
the 20 w 752
universe 2 w 760
came 2 w 764
into 1 w 768
being 2 w 773
Friend 1 w 780
You 1 w 783
really 1 w 789
do 2 w 791
make 1 w 795
them 3 w 799
out 3 w 802
very 1 w 806
audacious 1 w 815
conjurers 1 w 824
Menippus 3 w 833
My 1 w 835
dear 1 w 839
fellow 1 w 845
I 2 w 847
wish 1 w 851
I 3 w 852
could 2 w 857
give 1 w 861
you 2 w 864
their 4 w 869
lucubrations 1 w 881
on 13 w 883
ideas 1 w 888
and 8 w 891
incorporeals 1 w 903
on 14 w 906
finite 1 w 912
and 9 w 915
infinite 1 w 923
Over 1 w 928
that 2 w 932
point 1 w 937
now 1 w 941
there 2 w 947
is 10 w 949
fierce 1 w 955
battle 1 w 961
some 1 w 966
circumscribe 1 w 978
the 24 w 981
All 1 w 984
others 2 w 991
will 3 w 995
have 2 w 999
it 13 w 1001
unlimited 1 w 1010
At 1 w 1013
the 26 w 1016
same 1 w 1020
time 2 w 1024
they 4 w 1028
declare 1 w 1035
for 2 w 1038
a 71 w 1039
plurality 1 w 1048
of 6 w 1050
worlds 1 w 1056
and 10 w 1060
speak 1 w 1065
scornfully 1 w 1075
of 7 w 1077
others 3 w 1083
who 1 w 1086
make 2 w 1090
only 1 w 1094
one 1 w 1097
And 1 w 1101
there 3 w 1106
is 11 w 1108
a 76 w 1109
bellicose 1 w 1118
person 1 w 1124
who 2 w 1127
maintains 1 w 1136
that 3 w 1140
war 1 w 1143
is 12 w 1145
the 30 w 1148
father 1 w 1154
of 8 w 1156
the 32 w 1159
universe 3 w 1167
3 1 w 1168