Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Icaromenippus, an Aerial Expedition

Icaromenippus, an Aerial Expedition (9-10)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0062.tlg021.perseus-eng4:9-10
Refs {'start': {'reference': '9', 'human_reference': 'Section 9'}, 'end': {'reference': '10', 'human_reference': 'Section 10'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
Menippus

As to Gods, I need hardly deal with that question. For some of them God is a number; some swear by dogs and geese and plane-trees?, Some again banish all other Gods, and attri- 1 Variously attributed to Heraclitus, who denies the possibility of repose, and insists that all things are in a state of flux; and to Empedocles, who makes all change and becoming depend on the interaction of the two principles, attraction and repulsion, 3 Socrates made a practice of substituting these for the names of Gods in his oaths,

v.3.p.131
bute the control of the universe to a single one; I .ot rather depressed on learning how small the supply of divinity was. But I was comforted by the lavish souls who not only make many, but classify; there was a First God, and second and third classes of divinity. Yet again, some regard the divine nature as unsubstantial and without form, while others conceive it as a substance. Then they were not all disposed to recognize a Providence; some relieve the Gods of all care, as we relieve the superannuated of their cjvic duties; in fact, they treat them exactly like supernumeraries on the stage. The last step is also taken, of saying that Gods do not exist at all, and leaving the world to drift along without a master or a guiding hand.

Menippus

Well, when I heard all this, I dared not disbelieve people whose voices and beards were equally suggestive of Zeus. But I knew not where to turn for a theory that was not open to exception, nor combated by one as soon as propounded by another, I found myself in the state Homer has described; many a time I would vigorously start believing one of these gentlemen; But then came second thoughts. So in my distress I began to despair of ever getting any knowledge about these things on earth; the only possible escape from perplexity would be to take to myself wings and go up to Heaven, Partly the wish was father to the thought; but it was confirmed by Aesops Fables, from which it appears that Heaven is accessible to eagles, beetles, and sometimes camels. It was pretty clear that I could not possibly develop feathers of my own. But if I were to wear vultures or eagles wings the only kinds equal to a mans weightI might perhaps succeed. I caught the birds, and effectually amputated the eagles right, and the vultures left wing. These I fastened together, attached them to my shoulders with broad thick straps, and provided grips for my hands near the end of the

v.3.p.132
quill-feathers. Then I made experiments, first jumping up and helping the jump by flapping my hands, or imitating the. way a goose raises itself without leaving the ground and combines running with flight. Finding the machine obedient, I next made a bolder venture, went up the Acropolis, and launched myself from the cliff right over the theatre.

Tokens

Menippus 1 w 8
As 1 w 10
to 1 w 12
Gods 1 w 16
I 1 w 18
need 1 w 22
hardly 1 w 28
deal 1 w 32
with 1 w 36
that 1 w 40
question 1 w 48
For 1 w 52
some 1 w 56
of 1 w 58
them 1 w 62
God 2 w 65
is 1 w 67
a 4 w 68
number 1 w 74
some 2 w 79
swear 1 w 84
by 1 w 86
dogs 1 w 90
and 1 w 93
geese 1 w 98
and 2 w 101
plane-trees 1 w 112
Some 1 w 118
again 1 w 123
banish 1 w 129
all 1 w 132
other 1 w 137
Gods 2 w 141
and 3 w 145
attri- 1 w 151
1 1 w 152
Variously 1 w 161
attributed 1 w 171
to 2 w 173
Heraclitus 1 w 183
who 1 w 187
denies 1 w 193
the 3 w 196
possibility 1 w 207
of 2 w 209
repose 1 w 215
and 4 w 219
insists 1 w 226
that 2 w 230
all 2 w 233
things 1 w 239
are 1 w 242
in 4 w 244
a 22 w 245
state 1 w 250
of 3 w 252
flux 1 w 256
and 5 w 260
to 3 w 262
Empedocles 1 w 272
who 2 w 276
makes 1 w 281
all 3 w 284
change 1 w 290
and 6 w 293
becoming 1 w 301
depend 1 w 307
on 2 w 309
the 4 w 312
interaction 1 w 323
of 4 w 325
the 5 w 328
two 1 w 331
principles 1 w 341
attraction 1 w 352
and 7 w 355
repulsion 1 w 364
3 1 w 366
Socrates 1 w 374
made 1 w 378
a 35 w 379
practice 1 w 387
of 5 w 389
substituting 1 w 401
these 1 w 406
for 1 w 409
the 7 w 412
names 1 w 417
of 6 w 419
Gods 3 w 423
in 9 w 425
his 1 w 428
oaths 1 w 433
bute 2 w 438
the 8 w 441
control 1 w 448
of 7 w 450
the 9 w 453
universe 1 w 461
to 4 w 463
a 39 w 464
single 1 w 470
one 1 w 473
I 2 w 475
ot 2 w 478
rather 1 w 484
depressed 1 w 493
on 8 w 495
learning 1 w 503
how 1 w 506
small 1 w 511
the 11 w 514
supply 1 w 520
of 8 w 522
divinity 1 w 530
was 1 w 533
But 1 w 537
I 3 w 538
was 2 w 541
comforted 1 w 550
by 2 w 552
the 12 w 555
lavish 1 w 561
souls 1 w 566
who 3 w 569
not 1 w 572
only 1 w 576
make 2 w 580
many 1 w 584
but 3 w 588
classify 1 w 596
there 1 w 602
was 3 w 605
a 50 w 606
First 1 w 611
God 5 w 614
and 8 w 618
second 1 w 624
and 9 w 627
third 1 w 632
classes 1 w 639
of 9 w 641
divinity 2 w 649
Yet 1 w 653
again 2 w 658
some 3 w 663
regard 1 w 669
the 14 w 672
divine 1 w 678
nature 1 w 684
as 6 w 686
unsubstantial 1 w 699
and 10 w 702
without 1 w 709
form 1 w 713
while 1 w 719
others 1 w 725
conceive 1 w 733
it 8 w 735
as 7 w 737
a 63 w 738
substance 1 w 747
Then 1 w 752
they 1 w 756
were 1 w 760
not 2 w 763
all 5 w 766
disposed 1 w 774
to 5 w 776
recognize 1 w 785
a 66 w 786
Providence 1 w 796
some 4 w 801
relieve 1 w 808
the 17 w 811
Gods 4 w 815
of 10 w 817
all 6 w 820
care 1 w 824
as 8 w 827
we 3 w 829
relieve 2 w 836
the 18 w 839
superannuated 1 w 852
of 11 w 854
their 1 w 859
cjvic 1 w 864
duties 1 w 870
in 16 w 873
fact 1 w 877
they 2 w 882
treat 1 w 887
them 2 w 891
exactly 1 w 898
like 1 w 902
supernumeraries 1 w 917
on 12 w 919
the 22 w 922
stage 1 w 927
The 2 w 931
last 1 w 935
step 1 w 939
is 7 w 941
also 1 w 945
taken 1 w 950
of 12 w 953
saying 1 w 959
that 3 w 963
Gods 5 w 967
do 3 w 969
not 3 w 972
exist 1 w 977
at 14 w 979
all 7 w 982
and 11 w 986
leaving 1 w 993
the 23 w 996
world 1 w 1001
to 6 w 1003
drift 1 w 1008
along 1 w 1013
without 2 w 1020
a 87 w 1021
master 1 w 1027
or 6 w 1029
a 89 w 1030
guiding 1 w 1037
hand 1 w 1041
Menippus 2 w 1050
Well 1 w 1054
when 1 w 1059
I 4 w 1060
heard 1 w 1065
all 8 w 1068
this 1 w 1072
I 5 w 1074
dared 1 w 1079
not 4 w 1082
disbelieve 1 w 1092
people 1 w 1098
whose 1 w 1103
voices 1 w 1109
and 13 w 1112
beards 1 w 1118
were 2 w 1122
equally 1 w 1129
suggestive 1 w 1139
of 13 w 1141
Zeus 1 w 1145
But 2 w 1149
I 6 w 1150
knew 1 w 1154
not 5 w 1157
where 1 w 1162
to 7 w 1164
turn 1 w 1168
for 4 w 1171
a 97 w 1172
theory 1 w 1178
that 4 w 1182
was 4 w 1185
not 6 w 1188
open 1 w 1192
to 8 w 1194
exception 1 w 1203
nor 1 w 1207
combated 1 w 1215
by 3 w 1217
one 2 w 1220
as 12 w 1222
soon 1 w 1226
as 13 w 1228
propounded 1 w 1238
by 4 w 1240
another 1 w 1247
I 7 w 1249
found 1 w 1254
myself 1 w 1260
in 20 w 1262
the 26 w 1265
state 2 w 1270
Homer 1 w 1275
has 1 w 1278
described 1 w 1287
many 2 w 1292
a 107 w 1293
time 1 w 1297
I 8 w 1298
would 1 w 1303
vigorously 1 w 1313
start 1 w 1318
believing 1 w 1327
one 3 w 1330
of 14 w 1332
these 2 w 1337
gentlemen 1 w 1346
But 3 w 1350
then 1 w 1354
came 1 w 1358
second 2 w 1364
thoughts 1 w 1372
So 3 w 1376
in 22 w 1378
my 2 w 1380
distress 1 w 1388
I 9 w 1389
began 1 w 1394
to 9 w 1396
despair 1 w 1403
of 15 w 1405
ever 1 w 1409
getting 1 w 1416
any 3 w 1419
knowledge 1 w 1428
about 1 w 1433
these 3 w 1438
things 2 w 1444
on 19 w 1446
earth 1 w 1451
the 30 w 1455
only 2 w 1459
possible 1 w 1467
escape 1 w 1473
from 1 w 1477
perplexity 1 w 1487
would 2 w 1492
be 8 w 1494
to 10 w 1496
take 2 w 1500
to 11 w 1502
myself 2 w 1508
wings 1 w 1513
and 14 w 1516
go 2 w 1518
up 4 w 1520
to 12 w 1522
Heaven 1 w 1528
Partly 1 w 1535
the 31 w 1538
wish 1 w 1542
was 5 w 1545
father 1 w 1551
to 13 w 1553
the 33 w 1556
thought 2 w 1563
but 4 w 1567
it 11 w 1569
was 6 w 1572
confirmed 1 w 1581
by 5 w 1583
Aesop 1 w 1588
s 119 w 1590
Fables 1 w 1596
from 2 w 1601
which 1 w 1606
it 12 w 1608
appears 1 w 1615
that 5 w 1619
Heaven 2 w 1625
is 13 w 1627
accessible 1 w 1637
to 14 w 1639
eagles 1 w 1645
beetles 1 w 1653
and 15 w 1657
sometimes 1 w 1666
camels 1 w 1672
It 1 w 1675
was 7 w 1678
pretty 1 w 1684
clear 1 w 1689
that 6 w 1693
I 11 w 1694
could 1 w 1699
not 8 w 1702
possibly 1 w 1710
develop 1 w 1717
feathers 1 w 1725
of 16 w 1727
my 4 w 1729
own 1 w 1732
But 4 w 1736
if 3 w 1738
I 12 w 1739
were 3 w 1743
to 15 w 1745
wear 2 w 1749
vulture 1 w 1756
s 134 w 1758
or 11 w 1760
eagle 2 w 1765
s 135 w 1767
wings 2 w 1772
the 35 w 1776
only 3 w 1780
kinds 1 w 1785
equal 2 w 1790
to 16 w 1792
a 139 w 1793
man 3 w 1796
s 138 w 1798
weight 1 w 1804
I 13 w 1806
might 1 w 1811
perhaps 1 w 1818
succeed 1 w 1825
I 14 w 1827
caught 1 w 1833
the 36 w 1836
birds 1 w 1841
and 16 w 1845
effectually 1 w 1856
amputated 1 w 1865
the 37 w 1868
eagle 3 w 1873
s 142 w 1875
right 1 w 1880
and 17 w 1884
the 38 w 1887
vulture 2 w 1894
s 143 w 1896
left 1 w 1900
wing 3 w 1904
These 1 w 1910
I 15 w 1911
fastened 1 w 1919
together 1 w 1927
attached 1 w 1936
them 3 w 1940
to 18 w 1942
my 5 w 1944
shoulders 1 w 1953
with 4 w 1957
broad 1 w 1962
thick 1 w 1967
straps 1 w 1973
and 18 w 1977
provided 1 w 1985
grips 1 w 1990
for 5 w 1993
my 6 w 1995
hands 1 w 2000
near 1 w 2004
the 41 w 2007
end 2 w 2010
of 17 w 2012
the 42 w 2015
quill-feathers 1 w 2029
Then 2 w 2034
I 16 w 2035
made 2 w 2039
experiments 1 w 2050
first 1 w 2056
jumping 1 w 2063
up 5 w 2065
and 20 w 2068
helping 1 w 2075
the 44 w 2078
jump 2 w 2082
by 6 w 2084
flapping 1 w 2092
my 7 w 2094
hands 2 w 2099
or 13 w 2102
imitating 1 w 2111
the 45 w 2114
way 1 w 2118
a 164 w 2119
goose 1 w 2124
raises 1 w 2130
itself 1 w 2136
without 3 w 2143
leaving 2 w 2150
the 46 w 2153
ground 1 w 2159
and 22 w 2162
combines 1 w 2170
running 1 w 2177
with 6 w 2181
flight 1 w 2187
Finding 1 w 2195
the 47 w 2198
machine 1 w 2205
obedient 1 w 2213
I 17 w 2215
next 1 w 2219
made 3 w 2223
a 170 w 2224
bolder 1 w 2230
venture 1 w 2237
went 1 w 2242
up 6 w 2244
the 48 w 2247
Acropolis 1 w 2256
and 23 w 2260
launched 1 w 2268
myself 3 w 2274
from 3 w 2278
the 49 w 2281
cliff 1 w 2286
right 2 w 2291
over 1 w 2295
the 50 w 2298
theatre 1 w 2305