Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Icaromenippus, an Aerial Expedition

Icaromenippus, an Aerial Expedition (5-6)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0062.tlg021.perseus-eng4:5-6
Refs {'start': {'reference': '5', 'human_reference': 'Section 5'}, 'end': {'reference': '6', 'human_reference': 'Section 6'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
Menippus

In this state of mind, the best I could think of was to get at the truth of it all from the people called philosophers; they of course would be able to give it me. So I selected the best of them, if solemnity of visage, pallor of complexion and length of beard are any criterionfor there could not be a moments doubt of their soaring words and heaven-high thoughtsand in their hands I placed myself. For a considerable sum down, and more to be paid when they should have perfected me in wisdom, I was to be made an airy metaphysician and instructed in the order of the universe. Unfortunately, so far from dispelling my previous ignorance, they perplexed me more and more, with their daily drenches of beginnings and ends, atoms and voids, matters and forms. My greatest difficulty was that, though they differed among themselves, and all they said was full of inconsistency and contradiction, they expected me to believe them, each pulling me in his own direction.

Friend

How absurd that wise men should quarrel about facts, and hold different opinions on the same things!

Menippus

Ah, but keep your laughter till you have heard something of their pretentious mystifications. To begin with, their feet are on the ground; they are no taller than the rest of us men that walk the earth’; they are no sharper-sighted than their neighbours, some of them purblind, indeed, with age or indolence; and yet they say they can distinguish the limits of the sky, they measure the suns circumference, take their walks in the supra-lunar regions, and specify the sizes and shapes of the stars as though they had fallen from them; often one of them could not tell you correctly the number of miles from Megara to Athens, but has no hesitation about the distance in feet from the sun to the moon. How high the atmosphere is, how deep the sea, how far it is round the earththey have the figures for all that; and moreover, they have only to draw some circles, arrange a few triangles and squares, add certain

v.3.p.130
complicated spheres, and lo, they have the cubic contents of Heaven.

Tokens

Menippus 1 w 8
In 1 w 10
this 1 w 14
state 1 w 19
of 1 w 21
mind 1 w 25
the 1 w 29
best 1 w 33
I 2 w 34
could 1 w 39
think 1 w 44
of 2 w 46
was 1 w 49
to 1 w 51
get 1 w 54
at 2 w 56
the 2 w 59
truth 1 w 64
of 3 w 66
it 1 w 68
all 1 w 71
from 1 w 75
the 3 w 78
people 1 w 84
called 1 w 90
philosophers 1 w 102
they 1 w 107
of 4 w 109
course 1 w 115
would 1 w 120
be 2 w 122
able 1 w 126
to 2 w 128
give 1 w 132
it 2 w 134
me 1 w 136
So 1 w 139
I 3 w 140
selected 1 w 148
the 5 w 151
best 2 w 155
of 5 w 157
them 1 w 161
if 1 w 164
solemnity 1 w 173
of 6 w 175
visage 1 w 181
pallor 1 w 188
of 7 w 190
complexion 1 w 200
and 1 w 203
length 1 w 209
of 8 w 211
beard 1 w 216
are 1 w 219
any 1 w 222
criterion 1 w 231
for 1 w 235
there 1 w 240
could 2 w 245
not 1 w 248
be 5 w 250
a 13 w 251
moment 1 w 257
s 13 w 259
doubt 1 w 264
of 9 w 266
their 1 w 271
soaring 1 w 278
words 1 w 283
and 2 w 286
heaven-high 1 w 297
thoughts 1 w 305
and 3 w 309
in 4 w 311
their 2 w 316
hands 1 w 321
I 4 w 322
placed 1 w 328
myself 1 w 334
For 1 w 338
a 20 w 339
considerable 1 w 351
sum 1 w 354
down 1 w 358
and 5 w 362
more 1 w 366
to 3 w 368
be 6 w 370
paid 1 w 374
when 1 w 378
they 2 w 382
should 1 w 388
have 1 w 392
perfected 1 w 401
me 3 w 403
in 5 w 405
wisdom 1 w 411
I 5 w 413
was 2 w 416
to 4 w 418
be 7 w 420
made 1 w 424
an 7 w 426
airy 1 w 430
metaphysician 1 w 443
and 6 w 446
instructed 1 w 456
in 7 w 458
the 11 w 461
order 1 w 466
of 10 w 468
the 12 w 471
universe 1 w 479
Unfortunately 1 w 493
so 4 w 496
far 1 w 499
from 2 w 503
dispelling 1 w 513
my 2 w 515
previous 1 w 523
ignorance 1 w 532
they 3 w 537
perplexed 1 w 546
me 5 w 548
more 2 w 552
and 7 w 555
more 3 w 559
with 1 w 564
their 3 w 569
daily 1 w 574
drenches 1 w 582
of 11 w 584
beginnings 1 w 594
and 8 w 597
ends 1 w 601
atoms 1 w 607
and 9 w 610
voids 1 w 615
matters 1 w 623
and 10 w 626
forms 1 w 631
My 1 w 634
greatest 1 w 642
difficulty 1 w 652
was 3 w 655
that 1 w 659
though 2 w 666
they 4 w 670
differed 1 w 678
among 1 w 683
themselves 1 w 693
and 11 w 697
all 4 w 700
they 5 w 704
said 1 w 708
was 4 w 711
full 1 w 715
of 12 w 717
inconsistency 1 w 730
and 12 w 733
contradiction 1 w 746
they 6 w 751
expected 1 w 759
me 6 w 761
to 6 w 763
believe 1 w 770
them 3 w 774
each 1 w 779
pulling 1 w 786
me 7 w 788
in 13 w 790
his 2 w 793
own 2 w 796
direction 1 w 805
Friend 1 w 812
How 1 w 815
absurd 1 w 821
that 2 w 825
wise 1 w 829
men 2 w 832
should 2 w 838
quarrel 1 w 845
about 1 w 850
facts 1 w 855
and 13 w 859
hold 1 w 863
different 1 w 872
opinions 1 w 880
on 10 w 882
the 20 w 885
same 1 w 889
things 1 w 895
Menippus 2 w 904
Ah 1 w 906
but 1 w 910
keep 1 w 914
your 1 w 918
laughter 1 w 926
till 1 w 930
you 2 w 933
have 2 w 937
heard 1 w 942
something 1 w 951
of 13 w 954
their 4 w 959
pretentious 1 w 970
mystifications 1 w 984
To 1 w 987
begin 2 w 992
with 2 w 996
their 5 w 1002
feet 1 w 1006
are 2 w 1009
on 12 w 1011
the 23 w 1014
ground 1 w 1020
they 7 w 1025
are 3 w 1028
no 3 w 1030
taller 1 w 1036
than 1 w 1040
the 25 w 1043
rest 1 w 1047
of 14 w 1049
us 5 w 1051
men 3 w 1055
that 3 w 1059
walk 1 w 1063
the 26 w 1066
earth 1 w 1071
they 8 w 1077
are 4 w 1080
no 4 w 1082
sharper-sighted 1 w 1097
than 2 w 1101
their 6 w 1106
neighbours 1 w 1116
some 2 w 1121
of 15 w 1123
them 4 w 1127
purblind 1 w 1135
indeed 1 w 1142
with 3 w 1147
age 2 w 1150
or 12 w 1152
indolence 1 w 1161
and 14 w 1165
yet 1 w 1168
they 9 w 1172
say 1 w 1175
they 10 w 1179
can 1 w 1182
distinguish 1 w 1193
the 32 w 1196
limits 1 w 1202
of 16 w 1204
the 33 w 1207
sky 1 w 1210
they 11 w 1215
measure 1 w 1222
the 35 w 1225
sun 1 w 1228
s 71 w 1230
circumference 1 w 1243
take 1 w 1248
their 7 w 1253
walks 1 w 1258
in 22 w 1260
the 37 w 1263
supra-lunar 1 w 1274
regions 1 w 1281
and 15 w 1285
specify 1 w 1292
the 38 w 1295
sizes 1 w 1300
and 16 w 1303
shapes 1 w 1309
of 17 w 1311
the 39 w 1314
stars 1 w 1319
as 6 w 1321
though 3 w 1327
they 12 w 1331
had 1 w 1334
fallen 1 w 1340
from 3 w 1344
them 5 w 1348
often 1 w 1354
one 1 w 1357
of 19 w 1359
them 6 w 1363
could 3 w 1368
not 2 w 1371
tell 1 w 1375
you 3 w 1378
correctly 1 w 1387
the 43 w 1390
number 1 w 1396
of 20 w 1398
miles 1 w 1403
from 4 w 1407
Megara 1 w 1413
to 7 w 1415
Athens 1 w 1421
but 2 w 1425
has 1 w 1428
no 6 w 1430
hesitation 1 w 1440
about 2 w 1445
the 45 w 1448
distance 1 w 1456
in 23 w 1458
feet 2 w 1462
from 5 w 1466
the 46 w 1469
sun 2 w 1472
to 8 w 1474
the 47 w 1477
moon 1 w 1481
How 2 w 1485
high 2 w 1489
the 48 w 1492
atmosphere 1 w 1502
is 11 w 1504
how 1 w 1508
deep 1 w 1512
the 49 w 1515
sea 1 w 1518
how 2 w 1522
far 2 w 1525
it 10 w 1527
is 12 w 1529
round 2 w 1534
the 50 w 1537
earth 2 w 1542
they 13 w 1547
have 3 w 1551
the 52 w 1554
figures 1 w 1561
for 4 w 1564
all 7 w 1567
that 4 w 1571
and 17 w 1575
moreover 1 w 1583
they 14 w 1588
have 4 w 1592
only 1 w 1596
to 9 w 1598
draw 1 w 1602
some 3 w 1606
circles 1 w 1613
arrange 1 w 1621
a 108 w 1622
few 1 w 1625
triangles 1 w 1634
and 18 w 1637
squares 1 w 1644
add 1 w 1648
certain 1 w 1655
complicated 1 w 1666
spheres 1 w 1673
and 19 w 1677
lo 3 w 1679
they 15 w 1684
have 5 w 1688
the 55 w 1691
cubic 1 w 1696
contents 1 w 1704
of 21 w 1706
Heaven 1 w 1712