Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Euthydemus

Euthydemus (277)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0059.tlg021.perseus-eng2:277
Refs {'start': {'reference': '277', 'human_reference': 'Section 277'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
Soc.

Meanwhile Cleinias answered Euthydemus, that learners learnt what they did not know; so he had to meet the same course of questions as before:
277
277a
Well then, asked the other, do you not know your letters?
Yes,
he said.
All of them?
He admitted it.
Now when anyone dictates some piece or other, does he not dictate letters?
He admitted it.
And he dictates things of which you know something, since you know all of them?
He admitted this too.
Well now,
said the other,
surely you do not learn whatever such a person dictates; it is rather he who does not know his letters that learns?
No,
he replied;
I learn.
Then you learn what you know, since you know all your letters.
277b
He agreed.
So your answer was not correct,
he said.
The last word was hardly out of Euthydemus mouth when Dionysodorus caught, as it were, the ball of the argument and, aiming at the boy again, said:
Euthydemus is deceiving you, Cleinias. Tell me, is not learning the reception of knowledge of that which one learns?
Cleinias agreed.
And is not knowing, he went on, just having knowledge at the time?
He assented.
So that not knowing
277c
is not yet having knowledge?
He agreed with him.
Then are those who receive anything those who have it already, or those who have it not?
Those who have it not.
And you have admitted that those who do not know belong also to this class of those who have it not?
He nodded assent.
And the learners belong to the class of the receiving and not to that of the having?
He agreed.
Hence it is those who do not know that learn, Cleinias, and not those who know.
Euthydemus was proceeding to press the youth for the third fall, when I,
277d
perceiving the lad was going under, and wishing to give him some breathing-space lest he should shame us by losing heart, encouraged him with these words: Cleinias, do not be surprised that these arguments seem strange to you; for perhaps you do not discern what our two visitors are doing to you. They are acting just like the celebrants of the Corybantic rites, when they perform the enthronement of the person whom they are about to initiate. There, as you know, if you have been through it, they have dancing and merrymaking: so here these two
277e
are merely dancing about you and performing their sportive gambols with a view to your subsequent initiation. You must now, accordingly, suppose you are listening to the first part of the professorial mysteries.

Tokens

Soc 1 w 3
Meanwhile 1 w 13
Cleinias 1 w 21
answered 1 w 29
Euthydemus 1 w 39
that 1 w 44
learners 1 w 52
learnt 1 w 58
what 1 w 62
they 1 w 66
did 1 w 69
not 1 w 72
know 1 w 76
so 1 w 79
he 2 w 81
had 1 w 84
to 1 w 86
meet 1 w 90
the 2 w 93
same 1 w 97
course 1 w 103
of 1 w 105
questions 1 w 114
as 2 w 116
before 1 w 122
Well 1 w 127
then 1 w 131
asked 1 w 137
the 4 w 140
other 1 w 145
do 1 w 148
you 1 w 151
not 2 w 154
know 2 w 158
your 1 w 162
letters 1 w 169
Yes 1 w 173
he 7 w 176
said 1 w 180
All 1 w 184
of 2 w 186
them 1 w 190
He 1 w 193
admitted 1 w 201
it 2 w 203
Now 1 w 207
when 1 w 211
anyone 1 w 217
dictates 1 w 225
some 1 w 229
piece 1 w 234
or 2 w 236
other 2 w 241
does 1 w 246
he 11 w 248
not 3 w 251
dictate 2 w 258
letters 2 w 265
He 2 w 268
admitted 2 w 276
it 4 w 278
And 1 w 282
he 12 w 284
dictates 2 w 292
things 1 w 298
of 3 w 300
which 1 w 305
you 3 w 308
know 3 w 312
something 1 w 321
since 1 w 327
you 4 w 330
know 4 w 334
all 1 w 337
of 4 w 339
them 2 w 343
He 3 w 346
admitted 3 w 354
this 1 w 358
too 1 w 361
Well 2 w 366
now 5 w 369
said 2 w 374
the 9 w 377
other 3 w 382
surely 1 w 389
you 5 w 392
do 3 w 394
not 4 w 397
learn 3 w 402
whatever 1 w 410
such 1 w 414
a 24 w 415
person 1 w 421
dictates 3 w 429
it 6 w 432
is 2 w 434
rather 1 w 440
he 17 w 442
who 1 w 445
does 2 w 449
not 5 w 452
know 5 w 456
his 2 w 459
letters 3 w 466
that 2 w 470
learns 1 w 476
No 2 w 479
he 18 w 482
replied 1 w 489
I 1 w 491
learn 5 w 496
Then 1 w 501
you 6 w 504
learn 6 w 509
what 3 w 513
you 7 w 516
know 6 w 520
since 2 w 526
you 8 w 529
know 7 w 533
all 2 w 536
your 2 w 540
letters 4 w 547
He 4 w 550
agreed 1 w 556
So 2 w 559
your 3 w 563
answer 2 w 569
was 1 w 572
not 6 w 575
correct 1 w 582
he 20 w 585
said 3 w 589
The 2 w 593
last 1 w 597
word 1 w 601
was 2 w 604
hardly 1 w 610
out 1 w 613
of 5 w 615
Euthydemus 2 w 625
mouth 1 w 631
when 2 w 635
Dionysodorus 1 w 647
caught 1 w 653
as 7 w 656
it 7 w 658
were 2 w 662
the 12 w 666
ball 1 w 670
of 6 w 672
the 13 w 675
argument 1 w 683
and 1 w 686
aiming 1 w 693
at 11 w 695
the 14 w 698
boy 1 w 701
again 1 w 706
said 4 w 711
Euthydemus 3 w 722
is 4 w 724
deceiving 1 w 733
you 11 w 736
Cleinias 2 w 745
Tell 1 w 750
me 6 w 752
is 5 w 755
not 7 w 758
learning 1 w 766
the 15 w 769
reception 1 w 778
of 7 w 780
knowledge 1 w 789
of 8 w 791
that 3 w 795
which 2 w 800
one 2 w 803
learns 2 w 809
Cleinias 3 w 818
agreed 2 w 824
And 2 w 828
is 6 w 830
not 8 w 833
knowing 1 w 840
he 27 w 843
went 1 w 847
on 7 w 849
just 1 w 854
having 1 w 860
knowledge 2 w 869
at 13 w 871
the 16 w 874
time 1 w 878
He 5 w 881
assented 1 w 889
So 3 w 892
that 4 w 896
not 9 w 899
knowing 2 w 906
is 7 w 908
not 10 w 911
yet 1 w 914
having 2 w 920
knowledge 3 w 929
He 6 w 932
agreed 3 w 938
with 1 w 942
him 1 w 945
Then 2 w 950
are 1 w 953
those 1 w 958
who 2 w 961
receive 1 w 968
anything 1 w 976
those 2 w 981
who 3 w 984
have 1 w 988
it 9 w 990
already 1 w 997
or 6 w 1000
those 3 w 1005
who 4 w 1008
have 2 w 1012
it 10 w 1014
not 11 w 1017
Those 1 w 1023
who 5 w 1026
have 3 w 1030
it 11 w 1032
not 12 w 1035
And 3 w 1039
you 12 w 1042
have 4 w 1046
admitted 4 w 1054
that 5 w 1058
those 4 w 1063
who 6 w 1066
do 6 w 1068
not 13 w 1071
know 13 w 1075
belong 1 w 1081
also 1 w 1085
to 3 w 1087
this 2 w 1091
class 1 w 1096
of 9 w 1098
those 5 w 1103
who 7 w 1106
have 5 w 1110
it 13 w 1112
not 14 w 1115
He 7 w 1118
nodded 1 w 1124
assent 2 w 1130
And 4 w 1134
the 17 w 1137
learners 2 w 1145
belong 2 w 1151
to 4 w 1153
the 18 w 1156
class 2 w 1161
of 10 w 1163
the 19 w 1166
receiving 1 w 1175
and 2 w 1178
not 15 w 1181
to 5 w 1183
that 6 w 1187
of 11 w 1189
the 20 w 1192
having 3 w 1198
He 8 w 1201
agreed 4 w 1207
Hence 1 w 1213
it 14 w 1215
is 9 w 1217
those 6 w 1222
who 8 w 1225
do 7 w 1227
not 16 w 1230
know 14 w 1234
that 7 w 1238
learn 10 w 1243
Cleinias 4 w 1252
and 3 w 1256
not 17 w 1259
those 7 w 1264
who 9 w 1267
know 15 w 1271
Euthydemus 4 w 1282
was 3 w 1285
proceeding 1 w 1295
to 6 w 1297
press 1 w 1302
the 21 w 1305
youth 1 w 1310
for 2 w 1313
the 22 w 1316
third 1 w 1321
fall 1 w 1325
when 3 w 1330
I 2 w 1331
perceiving 1 w 1342
the 23 w 1345
lad 1 w 1348
was 4 w 1351
going 1 w 1356
under 1 w 1361
and 4 w 1365
wishing 1 w 1372
to 7 w 1374
give 1 w 1378
him 2 w 1381
some 3 w 1385
breathing-space 1 w 1400
lest 1 w 1404
he 38 w 1406
should 1 w 1412
shame 1 w 1417
us 7 w 1419
by 1 w 1421
losing 1 w 1427
heart 1 w 1432
encouraged 1 w 1443
him 3 w 1446
with 2 w 1450
these 1 w 1455
words 1 w 1460
Cleinias 5 w 1469
do 8 w 1472
not 18 w 1475
be 4 w 1477
surprised 1 w 1486
that 8 w 1490
these 2 w 1495
arguments 1 w 1504
seem 1 w 1508
strange 1 w 1515
to 8 w 1517
you 14 w 1520
for 3 w 1524
perhaps 1 w 1531
you 15 w 1534
do 9 w 1536
not 19 w 1539
discern 1 w 1546
what 4 w 1550
our 6 w 1553
two 1 w 1556
visitors 1 w 1564
are 2 w 1567
doing 1 w 1572
to 10 w 1574
you 16 w 1577
They 1 w 1582
are 3 w 1585
acting 1 w 1591
just 2 w 1595
like 1 w 1599
the 26 w 1602
celebrants 1 w 1612
of 12 w 1614
the 27 w 1617
Corybantic 1 w 1627
rites 1 w 1632
when 4 w 1637
they 2 w 1641
perform 1 w 1648
the 29 w 1651
enthronement 1 w 1663
of 13 w 1665
the 30 w 1668
person 2 w 1674
whom 1 w 1678
they 3 w 1682
are 4 w 1685
about 1 w 1690
to 11 w 1692
initiate 1 w 1700
There 1 w 1706
as 18 w 1709
you 17 w 1712
know 16 w 1716
if 1 w 1719
you 18 w 1722
have 6 w 1726
been 1 w 1730
through 1 w 1737
it 19 w 1739
they 4 w 1744
have 7 w 1748
dancing 1 w 1755
and 5 w 1758
merrymaking 1 w 1769
so 9 w 1772
here 2 w 1776
these 3 w 1781
two 2 w 1784
are 5 w 1787
merely 1 w 1793
dancing 2 w 1800
about 2 w 1805
you 19 w 1808
and 6 w 1811
performing 1 w 1821
their 1 w 1826
sportive 1 w 1834
gambols 1 w 1841
with 3 w 1845
a 121 w 1846
view 1 w 1850
to 12 w 1852
your 4 w 1856
subsequent 1 w 1866
initiation 1 w 1876
You 1 w 1880
must 1 w 1884
now 18 w 1887
accordingly 1 w 1899
suppose 1 w 1907
you 21 w 1910
are 6 w 1913
listening 1 w 1922
to 13 w 1924
the 35 w 1927
first 1 w 1932
part 1 w 1936
of 14 w 1938
the 36 w 1941
professorial 1 w 1953
mysteries 1 w 1962