Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / To Prove that every Man who is virtuous is also free

To Prove that every Man who is virtuous is also free (56-60)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0018.tlg027.1st1K-eng1:56-60
Refs {'start': {'reference': '56', 'human_reference': 'Section 56'}, 'end': {'reference': '60', 'human_reference': 'Section 60'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

But if they were able to look up and see clearly, then, beholding the deceits which arise out of folly, and the perplexities which proceed from covetousness, and all the intoxicated folly to which intemperance gives rise, and all the transgressions of the law in which injustice indulges, they would be filled with interminable grief at the injuries sustained by the best portion of themselves, and would be incapable of receiving comfort by reason of the excessive greatness of the evil.

But Zeno appears to have drawn this maxim of his as it

v.3.p.519
were from the fountain of the legislation of the Jews, [*] in the history of which it is recorded that in a case where there were two brothers, the one temperate and the other intemperate, the common father of them both, taking pity on the intemperate one who did not walk in the path of virtue, prays that he may serve his brother, conceiving that service which appears in general to be the greatest of evils is the most perfect good to a foolish man, in order that thus he may be deprived of his independence of action, so as to be prevented from misconducting himself with impunity, and that he may be improved in his disposition by the superintending management of him who is appointed to be his master.

9

What has now then been said with the view of establishing the truth in the matter inquired into is, in my opinion, sufficient. But since physicians are accustomed to cure various diseases with still more various remedies, it is necessary that we should bring a series of proofs, keeping close to the subject, in order to establish those propositions which appear paradoxical by reason of their unusual character. For some people, even if they are convicted by ever so close a series of proofs, can hardly be brought to see their error.

Therefore, it is not an incorrect assertion that the man who does everything wisely does everything well; and he who does everything well does everything correctly; and he who does everything correctly does everything also in an unerring, and blameless, and irreproachable, and faultless, and beneficial manner: so that he will have free permission to do everything, and to live as he pleases. And he who has this liberty must be free. But the virtuous man does do everything wisely; therefore he alone is free.

And indeed the man whom it is not possible either to compel to do anything, or to prevent from doing anything, cannot possibly be a slave; and one cannot compel or prevent the virtuous man. Therefore the virtuous man cannot be a slave; and that he is never under compulsion or under any restraint is quite plain; for that man is under restraint who does not obtain what he desires. But the wise man only desires such things as proceed from virtue, in which it is impossible for him to be disappointed. And again, if he is under compulsion, then it is plain that he does something against his will; but in all cases where there are actions, they are either good ones proceeding from virtue, or evil ones [*]

v.3.p.520
proceeding from wickedness, or else they are of an intermediate and indifferent character.

Tokens

But 1 w 3
if 1 w 5
they 1 w 9
were 1 w 13
able 1 w 17
to 1 w 19
look 1 w 23
up 1 w 25
and 1 w 28
see 1 w 31
clearly 1 w 38
then 1 w 43
beholding 1 w 53
the 3 w 56
deceits 1 w 63
which 1 w 68
arise 1 w 73
out 1 w 76
of 1 w 78
folly 1 w 83
and 2 w 87
the 4 w 90
perplexities 1 w 102
which 2 w 107
proceed 1 w 114
from 1 w 118
covetousness 1 w 130
and 3 w 134
all 1 w 137
the 5 w 140
intoxicated 1 w 151
folly 2 w 156
to 4 w 158
which 3 w 163
intemperance 1 w 175
gives 1 w 180
rise 2 w 184
and 4 w 188
all 2 w 191
the 6 w 194
transgressions 1 w 208
of 2 w 210
the 7 w 213
law 1 w 216
in 4 w 218
which 4 w 223
injustice 1 w 232
indulges 1 w 240
they 2 w 245
would 1 w 250
be 2 w 252
filled 1 w 258
with 1 w 262
interminable 1 w 274
grief 1 w 279
at 2 w 281
the 9 w 284
injuries 1 w 292
sustained 1 w 301
by 1 w 303
the 10 w 306
best 1 w 310
portion 1 w 317
of 3 w 319
themselves 1 w 329
and 5 w 333
would 2 w 338
be 4 w 340
incapable 1 w 349
of 4 w 351
receiving 1 w 360
comfort 1 w 367
by 2 w 369
reason 1 w 375
of 5 w 377
the 12 w 380
excessive 1 w 389
greatness 1 w 398
of 6 w 400
the 13 w 403
evil 1 w 407
But 2 w 411
Zeno 1 w 415
appears 1 w 422
to 5 w 424
have 1 w 428
drawn 1 w 433
this 1 w 437
maxim 1 w 442
of 7 w 444
his 2 w 447
as 2 w 449
it 4 w 451
were 2 w 455
from 2 w 459
the 14 w 462
fountain 1 w 470
of 8 w 472
the 15 w 475
legislation 1 w 486
of 9 w 488
the 16 w 491
Jews 1 w 495
Genesis 1 w 503
xxviii 1 w 509
1 1 w 511
in 14 w 514
the 17 w 517
history 1 w 524
of 10 w 526
which 5 w 531
it 5 w 533
is 8 w 535
recorded 1 w 543
that 1 w 547
in 15 w 549
a 31 w 550
case 1 w 554
where 1 w 559
there 1 w 564
were 3 w 568
two 1 w 571
brothers 1 w 579
the 20 w 583
one 1 w 586
temperate 1 w 595
and 6 w 598
the 21 w 601
other 2 w 606
intemperate 1 w 617
the 23 w 621
common 1 w 627
father 1 w 633
of 11 w 635
them 2 w 639
both 1 w 643
taking 1 w 650
pity 1 w 654
on 7 w 656
the 26 w 659
intemperate 2 w 670
one 2 w 673
who 1 w 676
did 1 w 679
not 1 w 682
walk 1 w 686
in 19 w 688
the 27 w 691
path 1 w 695
of 12 w 697
virtue 1 w 703
prays 1 w 709
that 2 w 713
he 29 w 715
may 1 w 718
serve 1 w 723
his 4 w 726
brother 2 w 733
conceiving 1 w 744
that 3 w 748
service 1 w 755
which 6 w 760
appears 2 w 767
in 21 w 769
general 1 w 776
to 7 w 778
be 5 w 780
the 29 w 783
greatest 1 w 791
of 13 w 793
evils 1 w 798
is 10 w 800
the 30 w 803
most 1 w 807
perfect 1 w 814
good 1 w 818
to 8 w 820
a 49 w 821
foolish 1 w 828
man 1 w 831
in 22 w 834
order 1 w 839
that 4 w 843
thus 1 w 847
he 33 w 849
may 2 w 852
be 6 w 854
deprived 1 w 862
of 14 w 864
his 5 w 867
independence 1 w 879
of 15 w 881
action 1 w 887
so 2 w 890
as 4 w 892
to 9 w 894
be 7 w 896
prevented 1 w 905
from 3 w 909
misconducting 1 w 922
himself 1 w 929
with 2 w 933
impunity 1 w 941
and 7 w 945
that 5 w 949
he 34 w 951
may 3 w 954
be 8 w 956
improved 1 w 964
in 25 w 966
his 6 w 969
disposition 1 w 980
by 3 w 982
the 31 w 985
superintending 1 w 999
management 1 w 1009
of 16 w 1011
him 2 w 1014
who 2 w 1017
is 16 w 1019
appointed 1 w 1028
to 10 w 1030
be 9 w 1032
his 7 w 1035
master 1 w 1041
What 1 w 1046
has 1 w 1049
now 1 w 1052
then 2 w 1056
been 1 w 1060
said 1 w 1064
with 3 w 1068
the 33 w 1071
view 1 w 1075
of 17 w 1077
establishing 1 w 1089
the 34 w 1092
truth 1 w 1097
in 30 w 1099
the 35 w 1102
matter 1 w 1108
inquired 1 w 1116
into 2 w 1120
is 19 w 1122
in 33 w 1125
my 1 w 1127
opinion 1 w 1134
sufficient 1 w 1145
But 3 w 1149
since 1 w 1154
physicians 1 w 1164
are 1 w 1167
accustomed 1 w 1177
to 13 w 1179
cure 1 w 1183
various 1 w 1190
diseases 1 w 1198
with 4 w 1202
still 1 w 1207
more 1 w 1211
various 2 w 1218
remedies 1 w 1226
it 12 w 1229
is 21 w 1231
necessary 1 w 1240
that 6 w 1244
we 4 w 1246
should 1 w 1252
bring 1 w 1257
a 75 w 1258
series 1 w 1264
of 18 w 1266
proofs 1 w 1272
keeping 1 w 1280
close 1 w 1285
to 14 w 1287
the 36 w 1290
subject 1 w 1297
in 38 w 1300
order 2 w 1305
to 15 w 1307
establish 2 w 1316
those 1 w 1321
propositions 1 w 1333
which 7 w 1338
appear 3 w 1344
paradoxical 1 w 1355
by 4 w 1357
reason 2 w 1363
of 20 w 1365
their 1 w 1370
unusual 1 w 1377
character 1 w 1386
For 1 w 1390
some 1 w 1394
people 1 w 1400
even 2 w 1405
if 2 w 1407
they 3 w 1411
are 2 w 1414
convicted 1 w 1423
by 5 w 1425
ever 1 w 1429
so 5 w 1431
close 2 w 1436
a 87 w 1437
series 2 w 1443
of 21 w 1445
proofs 2 w 1451
can 1 w 1455
hardly 1 w 1461
be 11 w 1463
brought 1 w 1470
to 16 w 1472
see 2 w 1475
their 2 w 1480
error 1 w 1485
Therefore 1 w 1495
it 14 w 1498
is 23 w 1500
not 2 w 1503
an 14 w 1505
incorrect 1 w 1514
assertion 1 w 1523
that 7 w 1527
the 40 w 1530
man 3 w 1533
who 3 w 1536
does 1 w 1540
everything 1 w 1550
wisely 1 w 1556
does 2 w 1560
everything 2 w 1570
well 1 w 1574
and 8 w 1578
he 46 w 1580
who 4 w 1583
does 3 w 1587
everything 3 w 1597
well 2 w 1601
does 4 w 1605
everything 4 w 1615
correctly 1 w 1624
and 9 w 1628
he 47 w 1630
who 5 w 1633
does 5 w 1637
everything 5 w 1647
correctly 2 w 1656
does 6 w 1660
everything 6 w 1670
also 1 w 1674
in 46 w 1676
an 18 w 1678
unerring 1 w 1686
and 10 w 1690
blameless 1 w 1699
and 11 w 1703
irreproachable 1 w 1717
and 12 w 1721
faultless 1 w 1730
and 13 w 1734
beneficial 1 w 1744
manner 1 w 1750
so 7 w 1753
that 8 w 1757
he 48 w 1759
will 1 w 1763
have 2 w 1767
free 1 w 1771
permission 1 w 1781
to 17 w 1783
do 8 w 1785
everything 7 w 1795
and 14 w 1799
to 18 w 1801
live 1 w 1805
as 10 w 1807
he 49 w 1809
pleases 1 w 1816
And 1 w 1820
he 50 w 1822
who 6 w 1825
has 2 w 1828
this 2 w 1832
liberty 1 w 1839
must 1 w 1843
be 14 w 1845
free 2 w 1849
But 4 w 1853
the 41 w 1856
virtuous 1 w 1864
man 5 w 1867
does 7 w 1871
do 10 w 1873
everything 8 w 1883
wisely 2 w 1889
therefore 1 w 1899
he 53 w 1901
alone 1 w 1906
is 28 w 1908
free 3 w 1912
And 2 w 1916
indeed 1 w 1922
the 43 w 1925
man 6 w 1928
whom 1 w 1932
it 15 w 1934
is 29 w 1936
not 3 w 1939
possible 1 w 1947
either 1 w 1953
to 19 w 1955
compel 1 w 1961
to 20 w 1963
do 11 w 1965
anything 1 w 1973
or 15 w 1976
to 21 w 1978
prevent 2 w 1985
from 4 w 1989
doing 1 w 1994
anything 2 w 2002
cannot 1 w 2009
possibly 1 w 2017
be 15 w 2019
a 120 w 2020
slave 1 w 2025
and 15 w 2029
one 4 w 2032
cannot 2 w 2038
compel 2 w 2044
or 16 w 2046
prevent 3 w 2053
the 45 w 2056
virtuous 2 w 2064
man 7 w 2067
Therefore 2 w 2077
the 46 w 2080
virtuous 3 w 2088
man 8 w 2091
cannot 3 w 2097
be 16 w 2099
a 127 w 2100
slave 2 w 2105
and 16 w 2109
that 9 w 2113
he 59 w 2115
is 30 w 2117
never 1 w 2122
under 1 w 2127
compulsion 1 w 2137
or 18 w 2139
under 2 w 2144
any 3 w 2147
restraint 1 w 2156
is 31 w 2158
quite 1 w 2163
plain 1 w 2168
for 5 w 2172
that 10 w 2176
man 9 w 2179
is 32 w 2181
under 3 w 2186
restraint 2 w 2195
who 8 w 2198
does 8 w 2202
not 7 w 2205
obtain 1 w 2211
what 1 w 2215
he 60 w 2217
desires 1 w 2224
But 5 w 2228
the 47 w 2231
wise 3 w 2235
man 10 w 2238
only 1 w 2242
desires 2 w 2249
such 1 w 2253
things 1 w 2259
as 13 w 2261
proceed 2 w 2268
from 5 w 2272
virtue 2 w 2278
in 59 w 2281
which 8 w 2286
it 18 w 2288
is 34 w 2290
impossible 1 w 2300
for 6 w 2303
him 3 w 2306
to 22 w 2308
be 17 w 2310
disappointed 1 w 2322
And 3 w 2326
again 1 w 2331
if 3 w 2334
he 62 w 2336
is 36 w 2338
under 4 w 2343
compulsion 2 w 2353
then 3 w 2358
it 19 w 2360
is 37 w 2362
plain 2 w 2367
that 11 w 2371
he 64 w 2373
does 9 w 2377
something 1 w 2386
against 1 w 2393
his 9 w 2396
will 2 w 2400
but 1 w 2404
in 65 w 2406
all 3 w 2409
cases 1 w 2414
where 2 w 2419
there 3 w 2424
are 3 w 2427
actions 1 w 2434
they 4 w 2439
are 4 w 2442
either 2 w 2448
good 2 w 2452
ones 1 w 2456
proceeding 1 w 2466
from 6 w 2470
virtue 3 w 2476
or 21 w 2479
evil 3 w 2483
ones 2 w 2487
Genesis 2 w 2494
xxviii 2 w 2500
1 2 w 2502
proceeding 2 w 2513
from 7 w 2517
wickedness 1 w 2527
or 22 w 2530
else 1 w 2534
they 5 w 2538
are 5 w 2541
of 23 w 2543
an 39 w 2545
intermediate 1 w 2557
and 17 w 2560
indifferent 1 w 2571
character 2 w 2580