Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / To Prove that every Man who is virtuous is also free

To Prove that every Man who is virtuous is also free (51-55)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0018.tlg027.1st1K-eng1:51-55
Refs {'start': {'reference': '51', 'human_reference': 'Section 51'}, 'end': {'reference': '55', 'human_reference': 'Section 55'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
8

And from the same principle as a starting-point it will also be clearly shown that the foolish man is a slave; for as the laws which prevail with respect to music do not give those who are ignorant of it a right of speaking about it in terms of equality with those who are well versed in it; nor do the laws respecting grammar give those ignorant of that knowledge a right of speaking about it on terms of equality with those who are well skilled in it; nor, in short, does the law with respect to any art confer such a right on those who are ignorant of it towards those who are learned in it; so also

v.3.p.518
the law which relates to the establishing proper principles of life does not give those who are strangers to any such true principles a right of speaking freely on such topics to those who have studied and learnt them.

But to all free men, perfect equality of speech on all subjects is given by the law; and some virtuous men are free; and of the proper principles of life, the foolish are utterly ignorant, but the wise are most profoundly versed in them: therefore it is not the case that ever any foolish or wicked men are free, but they are all slaves.

And Zeno, as much as any one else, being under the influence of virtue, ventures boldly to assert that the wicked have not a right to any equality of speech towards the virtuous; for he says, "Shall not the wicked man suffer if he contradicts the virtuous man?" Therefore the wicked man has not a right to freedom of speech as respects the virtuous man.

I know that many persons will rail at this assertion as one which is dictated rather by self-conceit than by real wisdom. But if, after they have desisted from mocking and ridiculing it, they will condescend to investigate the matter and to examine clearly into what is really said, then, recognising and admiring its perfect truth, they will become aware that there is nothing for which a man will suffer more than for disregarding the words of a wise man.

For loss of money, and the brand of dishonour, and banishment, and insults by means of beating, and all other things of that sort, injure a man but little, or rather not at all, when compared with acts of wickedness and the things which are the results of acts of wickedness. But it happens that the generality of men, not being able to perceive the injuries of the soul by reason of the mutilated state of their reason, are grieved only at external calamities, being wholly deprived of the faculty of judging correctly, which is the only one by which they can comprehend the injury received by the intellect.

Tokens

And 1 w 3
from 1 w 7
the 1 w 10
same 1 w 14
principle 1 w 23
as 1 w 25
a 3 w 26
starting-point 1 w 40
it 1 w 42
will 1 w 46
also 1 w 50
be 1 w 52
clearly 1 w 59
shown 1 w 64
that 1 w 68
the 2 w 71
foolish 1 w 78
man 1 w 81
is 2 w 83
a 9 w 84
slave 1 w 89
for 1 w 93
as 2 w 95
the 3 w 98
laws 1 w 102
which 1 w 107
prevail 1 w 114
with 1 w 118
respect 1 w 125
to 1 w 127
music 1 w 132
do 1 w 134
not 1 w 137
give 1 w 141
those 1 w 146
who 1 w 149
are 1 w 152
ignorant 1 w 160
of 1 w 162
it 3 w 164
a 16 w 165
right 1 w 170
of 2 w 172
speaking 1 w 180
about 1 w 185
it 4 w 187
in 5 w 189
terms 1 w 194
of 3 w 196
equality 1 w 204
with 2 w 208
those 2 w 213
who 2 w 216
are 2 w 219
well 1 w 223
versed 1 w 229
in 6 w 231
it 7 w 233
nor 2 w 237
do 2 w 239
the 4 w 242
laws 2 w 246
respecting 1 w 256
grammar 1 w 263
give 2 w 267
those 3 w 272
ignorant 2 w 280
of 4 w 282
that 2 w 286
knowledge 1 w 295
a 26 w 296
right 2 w 301
of 5 w 303
speaking 2 w 311
about 2 w 316
it 8 w 318
on 1 w 320
terms 2 w 325
of 6 w 327
equality 2 w 335
with 3 w 339
those 4 w 344
who 3 w 347
are 3 w 350
well 2 w 354
skilled 1 w 361
in 9 w 363
it 11 w 365
nor 4 w 369
in 10 w 372
short 1 w 377
does 1 w 382
the 5 w 385
law 3 w 388
with 4 w 392
respect 3 w 399
to 2 w 401
any 1 w 404
art 2 w 407
confer 1 w 413
such 1 w 417
a 34 w 418
right 3 w 423
on 3 w 425
those 5 w 430
who 4 w 433
are 4 w 436
ignorant 3 w 444
of 7 w 446
it 13 w 448
towards 1 w 455
those 6 w 460
who 5 w 463
are 5 w 466
learned 1 w 473
in 11 w 475
it 14 w 477
so 2 w 480
also 2 w 484
the 6 w 487
law 4 w 490
which 2 w 495
relates 1 w 502
to 4 w 504
the 7 w 507
establishing 1 w 519
proper 1 w 525
principles 1 w 535
of 8 w 537
life 1 w 541
does 2 w 545
not 2 w 548
give 3 w 552
those 7 w 557
who 6 w 560
are 6 w 563
strangers 1 w 572
to 5 w 574
any 2 w 577
such 2 w 581
true 1 w 585
principles 2 w 595
a 47 w 596
right 4 w 601
of 9 w 603
speaking 3 w 611
freely 1 w 617
on 4 w 619
such 3 w 623
topics 1 w 629
to 7 w 631
those 8 w 636
who 7 w 639
have 1 w 643
studied 1 w 650
and 1 w 653
learnt 1 w 659
them 1 w 663
But 1 w 667
to 8 w 669
all 1 w 672
free 2 w 676
men 1 w 679
perfect 1 w 687
equality 3 w 695
of 10 w 697
speech 1 w 703
on 5 w 705
all 2 w 708
subjects 1 w 716
is 4 w 718
given 1 w 723
by 1 w 725
the 9 w 728
law 5 w 731
and 2 w 735
some 1 w 739
virtuous 1 w 747
men 2 w 750
are 7 w 753
free 3 w 757
and 3 w 761
of 11 w 763
the 10 w 766
proper 2 w 772
principles 3 w 782
of 12 w 784
life 2 w 788
the 11 w 792
foolish 2 w 799
are 8 w 802
utterly 1 w 809
ignorant 4 w 817
but 1 w 821
the 12 w 824
wise 1 w 828
are 9 w 831
most 1 w 835
profoundly 1 w 845
versed 2 w 851
in 17 w 853
them 2 w 857
therefore 1 w 867
it 16 w 869
is 7 w 871
not 3 w 874
the 15 w 877
case 1 w 881
that 3 w 885
ever 1 w 889
any 3 w 892
foolish 3 w 899
or 10 w 901
wicked 1 w 907
men 3 w 910
are 10 w 913
free 4 w 917
but 2 w 921
they 1 w 925
are 11 w 928
all 3 w 931
slaves 1 w 937
And 2 w 941
Zeno 1 w 945
as 4 w 948
much 1 w 952
as 5 w 954
any 4 w 957
one 1 w 960
else 1 w 964
being 1 w 970
under 1 w 975
the 17 w 978
influence 1 w 987
of 14 w 989
virtue 1 w 995
ventures 1 w 1004
boldly 1 w 1010
to 9 w 1012
assert 1 w 1018
that 4 w 1022
the 18 w 1025
wicked 2 w 1031
have 2 w 1035
not 4 w 1038
a 75 w 1039
right 5 w 1044
to 10 w 1046
any 5 w 1049
equality 4 w 1057
of 15 w 1059
speech 2 w 1065
towards 2 w 1072
the 19 w 1075
virtuous 2 w 1083
for 3 w 1087
he 20 w 1089
says 1 w 1093
Shall 1 w 1100
not 5 w 1103
the 20 w 1106
wicked 3 w 1112
man 2 w 1115
suffer 1 w 1121
if 3 w 1123
he 22 w 1125
contradicts 1 w 1136
the 21 w 1139
virtuous 3 w 1147
man 3 w 1150
Therefore 1 w 1161
the 22 w 1164
wicked 4 w 1170
man 4 w 1173
has 1 w 1176
not 6 w 1179
a 86 w 1180
right 6 w 1185
to 12 w 1187
freedom 1 w 1194
of 16 w 1196
speech 3 w 1202
as 8 w 1204
respects 1 w 1212
the 23 w 1215
virtuous 4 w 1223
man 5 w 1226
I 1 w 1228
know 2 w 1232
that 5 w 1236
many 1 w 1240
persons 1 w 1247
will 2 w 1251
rail 1 w 1255
at 7 w 1257
this 1 w 1261
assertion 1 w 1270
as 10 w 1272
one 2 w 1275
which 3 w 1280
is 10 w 1282
dictated 1 w 1290
rather 1 w 1296
by 2 w 1298
self-conceit 1 w 1310
than 1 w 1314
by 3 w 1316
real 1 w 1320
wisdom 1 w 1326
But 2 w 1330
if 4 w 1332
after 1 w 1338
they 2 w 1342
have 3 w 1346
desisted 1 w 1354
from 2 w 1358
mocking 1 w 1365
and 4 w 1368
ridiculing 1 w 1378
it 19 w 1380
they 3 w 1385
will 3 w 1389
condescend 1 w 1399
to 13 w 1401
investigate 1 w 1412
the 27 w 1415
matter 1 w 1421
and 5 w 1424
to 14 w 1426
examine 1 w 1433
clearly 2 w 1440
into 1 w 1444
what 1 w 1448
is 13 w 1450
really 1 w 1456
said 1 w 1460
then 1 w 1465
recognising 1 w 1477
and 6 w 1480
admiring 1 w 1488
its 1 w 1491
perfect 2 w 1498
truth 1 w 1503
they 4 w 1508
will 4 w 1512
become 1 w 1518
aware 1 w 1523
that 6 w 1527
there 2 w 1532
is 15 w 1534
nothing 1 w 1541
for 5 w 1544
which 4 w 1549
a 115 w 1550
man 7 w 1553
will 5 w 1557
suffer 2 w 1563
more 1 w 1567
than 2 w 1571
for 6 w 1574
disregarding 1 w 1586
the 31 w 1589
words 1 w 1594
of 17 w 1596
a 119 w 1597
wise 2 w 1601
man 8 w 1604
For 1 w 1608
loss 1 w 1612
of 18 w 1614
money 1 w 1619
and 7 w 1623
the 32 w 1626
brand 1 w 1631
of 19 w 1633
dishonour 1 w 1642
and 9 w 1646
banishment 1 w 1656
and 10 w 1660
insults 1 w 1667
by 4 w 1669
means 1 w 1674
of 20 w 1676
beating 1 w 1683
and 11 w 1687
all 6 w 1690
other 1 w 1695
things 1 w 1701
of 21 w 1703
that 7 w 1707
sort 1 w 1711
injure 1 w 1718
a 131 w 1719
man 9 w 1722
but 3 w 1725
little 1 w 1731
or 19 w 1734
rather 2 w 1740
not 8 w 1743
at 17 w 1745
all 7 w 1748
when 1 w 1753
compared 1 w 1761
with 5 w 1765
acts 1 w 1769
of 22 w 1771
wickedness 1 w 1781
and 12 w 1784
the 35 w 1787
things 2 w 1793
which 5 w 1798
are 14 w 1801
the 36 w 1804
results 1 w 1811
of 23 w 1813
acts 2 w 1817
of 24 w 1819
wickedness 2 w 1829
But 3 w 1833
it 23 w 1835
happens 1 w 1842
that 8 w 1846
the 37 w 1849
generality 1 w 1859
of 25 w 1861
men 5 w 1864
not 9 w 1868
being 2 w 1873
able 1 w 1877
to 16 w 1879
perceive 1 w 1887
the 38 w 1890
injuries 1 w 1898
of 26 w 1900
the 39 w 1903
soul 1 w 1907
by 5 w 1909
reason 1 w 1915
of 27 w 1917
the 40 w 1920
mutilated 1 w 1929
state 1 w 1934
of 28 w 1936
their 1 w 1941
reason 2 w 1947
are 15 w 1951
grieved 1 w 1958
only 1 w 1962
at 21 w 1964
external 1 w 1972
calamities 1 w 1982
being 3 w 1988
wholly 1 w 1994
deprived 1 w 2002
of 29 w 2004
the 42 w 2007
faculty 1 w 2014
of 30 w 2016
judging 1 w 2023
correctly 1 w 2032
which 6 w 2038
is 20 w 2040
the 43 w 2043
only 2 w 2047
one 4 w 2050
by 6 w 2052
which 7 w 2057
they 5 w 2061
can 1 w 2064
comprehend 1 w 2074
the 45 w 2077
injury 1 w 2083
received 1 w 2091
by 7 w 2093
the 46 w 2096
intellect 1 w 2105