Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Plutarch's Natural Questions

Plutarch's Natural Questions (16-18)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg125.perseus-eng2:16-18
Refs {'start': {'reference': '16', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 16'}, 'end': {'reference': '18', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 18'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
XVI.
WHY DO MEN SAY, SOW WHEAT IN CLAY AND BARLEY IN DUST?

Is the reason (as we said) because wheat takes up more nourishment; and barley cannot bear so much, but is choked with it? Or does wheat, because it is hard and ligneous, thrive better when it is softened and loosened in a moist soil; and barley at the first in a dry soil, because of its rarity? Or is the one temperament congruous and harmless to wheat, because it is hot; and the other to barley, because it is cold? Or are men afraid to sow wheat in a dry soil, because of the ants, which presently lie in wait for it; but they cannot so easily deal with barley nor carry it away, because it is a larger grain?

XVII.
WHY DO MEN USE THE HAIR OF HORSES RATHER THAN OF MARES FOR FISHING-LINES?

Is it that the males are stronger in those parts, as well as in others, than the females? Or is it that the females spoil the hair of their tails by their staling?

XVIII.
WHY IS THE SIGHT OF A CUTTLE-FISH A SIGN OF A GREAT STORM?

Is it because all fishes of the soft kind cannot endure cold, by reason of their nakedness and tenderness? For they are covered neither with shell, skin, or scale, though within they have hard and bony parts. Hence the Greeks call them soft fish. Therefore they easily perceive a storm

coming, since they are so soon affected by the cold. When the polypus gets to shore and embraces the rocks, it is a sign the wind is rising; but the cuttle-fish jumps up, to shun the cold and the trouble of the bottom of the sea; for, of all soft fishes, she is the tenderest and soonest hurt.

Tokens

XVI 1 w 3
WHY 1 w 7
DO 1 w 9
MEN 1 w 12
SAY 1 w 15
SOW 1 w 19
WHEAT 1 w 24
IN 1 w 26
CLAY 1 w 30
AND 1 w 33
BARLEY 1 w 39
IN 2 w 41
DUST 1 w 45
Is 1 w 48
the 1 w 51
reason 1 w 57
as 2 w 60
we 1 w 62
said 1 w 66
because 1 w 74
wheat 1 w 79
takes 1 w 84
up 1 w 86
more 1 w 90
nourishment 1 w 101
and 1 w 105
barley 1 w 111
cannot 1 w 117
bear 1 w 121
so 2 w 123
much 1 w 127
but 1 w 131
is 2 w 133
choked 1 w 139
with 1 w 143
it 2 w 145
Or 1 w 148
does 1 w 152
wheat 2 w 157
because 2 w 165
it 3 w 167
is 3 w 169
hard 1 w 173
and 2 w 176
ligneous 1 w 184
thrive 1 w 191
better 1 w 197
when 1 w 201
it 4 w 203
is 4 w 205
softened 1 w 213
and 3 w 216
loosened 1 w 224
in 1 w 226
a 16 w 227
moist 1 w 232
soil 1 w 236
and 4 w 240
barley 2 w 246
at 3 w 248
the 2 w 251
first 1 w 256
in 2 w 258
a 20 w 259
dry 1 w 262
soil 2 w 266
because 3 w 274
of 2 w 276
its 1 w 279
rarity 1 w 285
Or 2 w 288
is 6 w 290
the 3 w 293
one 1 w 296
temperament 1 w 307
congruous 1 w 316
and 5 w 319
harmless 1 w 327
to 1 w 329
wheat 3 w 334
because 4 w 342
it 7 w 344
is 7 w 346
hot 1 w 349
and 6 w 353
the 4 w 356
other 1 w 361
to 2 w 363
barley 3 w 369
because 5 w 377
it 8 w 379
is 8 w 381
cold 1 w 385
Or 3 w 388
are 1 w 391
men 3 w 394
afraid 1 w 400
to 3 w 402
sow 1 w 405
wheat 4 w 410
in 3 w 412
a 35 w 413
dry 2 w 416
soil 3 w 420
because 6 w 428
of 3 w 430
the 6 w 433
ants 1 w 437
which 1 w 443
presently 1 w 452
lie 1 w 455
in 4 w 457
wait 1 w 461
for 1 w 464
it 10 w 466
but 2 w 470
they 1 w 474
cannot 2 w 480
so 8 w 482
easily 1 w 488
deal 1 w 492
with 2 w 496
barley 4 w 502
nor 1 w 505
carry 1 w 510
it 12 w 512
away 1 w 516
because 7 w 524
it 13 w 526
is 9 w 528
a 47 w 529
larger 1 w 535
grain 1 w 540
XVII 1 w 545
WHY 2 w 549
DO 2 w 551
MEN 2 w 554
USE 1 w 557
THE 1 w 560
HAIR 1 w 564
OF 1 w 566
HORSES 1 w 572
RATHER 1 w 578
THAN 1 w 582
OF 2 w 584
MARES 1 w 589
FOR 1 w 592
FISHING-LINES 1 w 605
Is 2 w 608
it 14 w 610
that 1 w 614
the 8 w 617
males 1 w 622
are 2 w 625
stronger 1 w 633
in 6 w 635
those 1 w 640
parts 1 w 645
as 4 w 648
well 1 w 652
as 5 w 654
in 7 w 656
others 1 w 662
than 1 w 667
the 10 w 670
females 1 w 677
Or 4 w 680
is 10 w 682
it 15 w 684
that 2 w 688
the 11 w 691
females 2 w 698
spoil 1 w 703
the 12 w 706
hair 1 w 710
of 4 w 712
their 1 w 717
tails 1 w 722
by 1 w 724
their 2 w 729
staling 1 w 736
XVIII 1 w 742
WHY 3 w 746
IS 2 w 748
THE 3 w 751
SIGHT 1 w 756
OF 3 w 758
A 10 w 759
CUTTLE-FISH 1 w 770
A 11 w 771
SIGN 1 w 775
OF 4 w 777
A 12 w 778
GREAT 1 w 783
STORM 1 w 788
Is 3 w 791
it 16 w 793
because 8 w 800
all 1 w 803
fishes 1 w 809
of 5 w 811
the 15 w 814
soft 2 w 818
kind 1 w 822
cannot 3 w 828
endure 1 w 834
cold 2 w 838
by 2 w 841
reason 2 w 847
of 7 w 849
their 3 w 854
nakedness 1 w 863
and 7 w 866
tenderness 1 w 876
For 1 w 880
they 2 w 884
are 3 w 887
covered 1 w 894
neither 1 w 901
with 3 w 905
shell 1 w 910
skin 1 w 915
or 5 w 918
scale 1 w 923
though 1 w 930
within 1 w 936
they 3 w 940
have 1 w 944
hard 2 w 948
and 8 w 951
bony 1 w 955
parts 2 w 960
Hence 1 w 966
the 20 w 969
Greeks 1 w 975
call 1 w 979
them 1 w 983
soft 3 w 987
fish 2 w 991
Therefore 1 w 1001
they 4 w 1005
easily 2 w 1011
perceive 1 w 1019
a 77 w 1020
storm 1 w 1025
coming 1 w 1031
since 1 w 1037
they 5 w 1041
are 4 w 1044
so 12 w 1046
soon 1 w 1050
affected 1 w 1058
by 3 w 1060
the 24 w 1063
cold 3 w 1067
When 1 w 1072
the 25 w 1075
polypus 1 w 1082
gets 1 w 1086
to 5 w 1088
shore 1 w 1093
and 9 w 1096
embraces 1 w 1104
the 26 w 1107
rocks 1 w 1112
it 20 w 1115
is 13 w 1117
a 82 w 1118
sign 1 w 1122
the 27 w 1125
wind 1 w 1129
is 14 w 1131
rising 1 w 1137
but 3 w 1141
the 28 w 1144
cuttle-fish 1 w 1155
jumps 1 w 1160
up 2 w 1162
to 6 w 1165
shun 1 w 1169
the 29 w 1172
cold 4 w 1176
and 10 w 1179
the 30 w 1182
trouble 1 w 1189
of 9 w 1191
the 31 w 1194
bottom 1 w 1200
of 10 w 1202
the 32 w 1205
sea 1 w 1208
for 3 w 1212
of 11 w 1215
all 3 w 1218
soft 4 w 1222
fishes 2 w 1228
she 4 w 1232
is 18 w 1234
the 33 w 1237
tenderest 1 w 1246
and 11 w 1249
soonest 1 w 1256
hurt 1 w 1260