Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Plutarch's Natural Questions

Plutarch's Natural Questions (19-21)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg125.perseus-eng2:19-21
Refs {'start': {'reference': '19', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 19'}, 'end': {'reference': '21', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 21'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
XIX.
WHY DOES THE POLYPUS CHANGE COLOR?

WHETHER, as Theophrastus writes, because it is an animal by nature timorous; and therefore, being disturbed, it changes color with its spirit, as some men do, of whom it is said, an ill man ever changes color? But though this may serve as a reason for changing its color, it will not for the imitation of colors. For the polypus does so change its color, that it is of the color of every stone it comes nigh. Hence that of Pindar, Mind the color of the marine beast, and so converse cunningly in all cities; and that of Theognis:

Put on a mind like th polyp fish,—
And learn so to dissemble,—
Which of the rock whereto it sticks
The color doth resemble.
[*]
And they say, that such as are excellent at craftiness and juggling have this in their eye,—that they may the better cheat them they have to deal withal,—ever to imitate the polypus. Some think the polypus can use her skin as a garment, and can put it on or off at pleasure. But if fear occasions this change in the polypus, is not something else more properly the cause? Let us consider what Empedocles says, that effluvia proceed from all things whatever. For not only animals, plants, the earth and sea, but stones, and even brass and iron, do continually send out
many effluvia. For all things corrupt and smell, because there runneth always something from them, and they wear continually; insomuch that it is thought that by these effluvia come all attractions and insultations, some supposing embraces, others blows, some impulses, others circuitions. But especially about the sea rocks, when they are wet and cool by the waves (as is most likely), constantly some small particles are washed off, which do not incorporate with other bodies, but either pass by the smaller passages, or pass through the larger. Now the flesh of the polypus, as one may judge by the eye, is hollow, full of pores, and capable of effluvia. When therefore she is afraid, as her spirit changes she changes herself, and by straitening and contracting her body, she encloses the neighboring effluvia. And, as a good token of this argument, the polypus cannot imitate the color of every thing he comes near, nor the chameleon of any thing that is white; but each of these creatures is assimilated only to those things to whose effluvia it has pores proportionable.

XX.
WHAT IS THE REASON, THAT THE TEARS OF WILD BOARS ARE SWEET, AND THE TEARS OF THE HART SALT AND HURTFUL?

THE reason seems to be the heat and cold of these animals. For the hart is cold, and the boar is very hot and fiery; therefore the one flies from, the other defends himself against, his pursuers. Now when great store of heat comes to the eyes (as Homer says, with horrid bristles, and eyes darting fire), tears are sweet. Some are of Empedocless opinion, who thought that tears proceed from the disturbance of the blood, as whey does from the churning of milk; since therefore boars blood is harsh and black, and

harts blood thin and watery, it is consentaneous that the tears, which the one sheds when excited to anger, and the other when dejected with fear, should be of the same nature.

XXI.
WHY DO TAME SOWS FARROW OFTEN, SOME AT, ONE TIME AND OTHERS AT ANOTHER; AND THE WILD BUT ONCE A YEAR, AND ALL OF THEM ABOUT THE SAME TIME AT THE BEGINNING OF SUMMER, WHENCE IT IS SAID,—

The wild sow farrowing, that night falls no rain?

Is it because of plentiful feeding, as in very truth fulness doth produce wantonness? For abundance of nourishment breeds abundance of seed both in animals and plants. Now wild sows live by their own toil, and that with fear; the tame have always food enough, either by nature or given them. Or may it not be ascribed to their rest and exercise? For the tame do rest and go not far from their keepers; the wild get to the mountains, and run about, by which means they waste the nutriment, and consume it upon the whole body. Therefore either through continual converse, or abundance of seed, or because the females feed in herds with the males, the tame sows call to mind coition and stir up lust, as Empedocles talks of men. But in wild sows, which feed apart, desire is cold and dull for want of love and conversation. Or is it true, what Aristotle says, that Homer called the wild boar χλούνης, because he had but one stone? For most boars spoil their stones (he says) by rubbing them against stumps of trees.

Tokens

XIX 1 w 3
WHY 1 w 7
DOES 1 w 11
THE 1 w 14
POLYPUS 1 w 21
CHANGE 1 w 27
COLOR 1 w 32
WHETHER 1 w 40
as 1 w 43
Theophrastus 1 w 55
writes 1 w 61
because 1 w 69
it 2 w 71
is 1 w 73
an 1 w 75
animal 1 w 81
by 1 w 83
nature 1 w 89
timorous 1 w 97
and 1 w 101
therefore 1 w 110
being 1 w 116
disturbed 1 w 125
it 3 w 128
changes 1 w 135
color 1 w 140
with 1 w 144
its 1 w 147
spirit 1 w 153
as 3 w 156
some 1 w 160
men 1 w 163
do 1 w 165
of 1 w 168
whom 1 w 172
it 7 w 174
is 3 w 176
said 1 w 180
an 5 w 183
ill 1 w 186
man 1 w 189
ever 1 w 193
changes 2 w 200
color 2 w 205
But 1 w 209
though 1 w 215
this 1 w 219
may 1 w 222
serve 1 w 227
as 4 w 229
a 17 w 230
reason 1 w 236
for 2 w 239
changing 1 w 247
its 2 w 250
color 3 w 255
it 9 w 258
will 1 w 262
not 1 w 265
for 3 w 268
the 2 w 271
imitation 1 w 280
of 2 w 282
colors 1 w 288
For 1 w 292
the 3 w 295
polypus 1 w 302
does 1 w 306
so 3 w 308
change 3 w 314
its 3 w 317
color 5 w 322
that 1 w 327
it 12 w 329
is 5 w 331
of 3 w 333
the 4 w 336
color 6 w 341
of 4 w 343
every 1 w 348
stone 1 w 353
it 13 w 355
comes 1 w 360
nigh 1 w 364
Hence 1 w 370
that 2 w 374
of 5 w 376
Pindar 1 w 382
Mind 1 w 387
the 5 w 390
color 7 w 395
of 6 w 397
the 6 w 400
marine 1 w 406
beast 1 w 411
and 2 w 415
so 4 w 417
converse 1 w 425
cunningly 1 w 434
in 7 w 436
all 1 w 439
cities 1 w 445
and 3 w 449
that 3 w 453
of 7 w 455
Theognis 1 w 463
Put 1 w 467
on 5 w 469
a 31 w 470
mind 1 w 474
like 1 w 478
th 13 w 480
polyp 2 w 486
fish 1 w 490
And 1 w 495
learn 1 w 500
so 5 w 502
to 2 w 504
dissemble 1 w 513
Which 1 w 520
of 8 w 522
the 7 w 525
rock 1 w 529
whereto 1 w 536
it 15 w 538
sticks 1 w 544
The 3 w 547
color 8 w 552
doth 1 w 556
resemble 1 w 564
Theognis 2 w 573
vs 1 w 576
215 1 w 580
And 2 w 584
they 1 w 588
say 1 w 591
that 4 w 596
such 1 w 600
as 7 w 602
are 1 w 605
excellent 1 w 614
at 7 w 616
craftiness 1 w 626
and 4 w 629
juggling 1 w 637
have 1 w 641
this 2 w 645
in 11 w 647
their 1 w 652
eye 1 w 655
that 5 w 661
they 2 w 665
may 2 w 668
the 11 w 671
better 1 w 677
cheat 1 w 682
them 1 w 686
they 3 w 690
have 2 w 694
to 4 w 696
deal 1 w 700
withal 1 w 706
ever 3 w 712
to 5 w 714
imitate 1 w 721
the 14 w 724
polypus 2 w 731
Some 1 w 736
think 1 w 741
the 15 w 744
polypus 3 w 751
can 1 w 754
use 2 w 757
her 3 w 760
skin 1 w 764
as 8 w 766
a 50 w 767
garment 1 w 774
and 5 w 778
can 2 w 781
put 1 w 784
it 18 w 786
on 6 w 788
or 14 w 790
off 1 w 793
at 11 w 795
pleasure 1 w 803
But 2 w 807
if 1 w 809
fear 1 w 813
occasions 1 w 822
this 3 w 826
change 4 w 832
in 14 w 834
the 16 w 837
polypus 4 w 844
is 12 w 847
not 2 w 850
something 1 w 859
else 1 w 863
more 1 w 867
properly 1 w 875
the 17 w 878
cause 2 w 883
Let 1 w 887
us 10 w 889
consider 1 w 897
what 1 w 901
Empedocles 1 w 911
says 1 w 915
that 6 w 920
effluvia 1 w 928
proceed 1 w 935
from 1 w 939
all 2 w 942
things 1 w 948
whatever 1 w 956
For 2 w 960
not 3 w 963
only 1 w 967
animals 1 w 974
plants 1 w 981
the 18 w 985
earth 1 w 990
and 6 w 993
sea 1 w 996
but 1 w 1000
stones 1 w 1006
and 7 w 1010
even 1 w 1014
brass 1 w 1019
and 8 w 1022
iron 1 w 1026
do 5 w 1029
continually 1 w 1040
send 1 w 1044
out 1 w 1047
many 1 w 1051
effluvia 2 w 1059
For 3 w 1063
all 4 w 1066
things 2 w 1072
corrupt 1 w 1079
and 9 w 1082
smell 1 w 1087
because 2 w 1095
there 2 w 1100
runneth 1 w 1107
always 1 w 1113
something 2 w 1122
from 2 w 1126
them 2 w 1130
and 10 w 1134
they 4 w 1138
wear 1 w 1142
continually 2 w 1153
insomuch 1 w 1162
that 7 w 1166
it 19 w 1168
is 13 w 1170
thought 1 w 1177
that 8 w 1181
by 2 w 1183
these 1 w 1188
effluvia 3 w 1196
come 2 w 1200
all 6 w 1203
attractions 1 w 1214
and 11 w 1217
insultations 1 w 1229
some 4 w 1234
supposing 1 w 1243
embraces 1 w 1251
others 1 w 1258
blows 1 w 1263
some 5 w 1268
impulses 1 w 1276
others 2 w 1283
circuitions 1 w 1294
But 3 w 1298
especially 1 w 1308
about 1 w 1313
the 25 w 1316
sea 2 w 1319
rocks 1 w 1324
when 1 w 1329
they 5 w 1333
are 2 w 1336
wet 1 w 1339
and 12 w 1342
cool 1 w 1346
by 3 w 1348
the 27 w 1351
waves 1 w 1356
as 12 w 1359
is 14 w 1361
most 1 w 1365
likely 1 w 1371
constantly 1 w 1383
some 6 w 1387
small 1 w 1392
particles 1 w 1401
are 3 w 1404
washed 1 w 1410
off 2 w 1413
which 1 w 1419
do 6 w 1421
not 4 w 1424
incorporate 1 w 1435
with 3 w 1439
other 3 w 1444
bodies 1 w 1450
but 2 w 1454
either 1 w 1460
pass 1 w 1464
by 4 w 1466
the 30 w 1469
smaller 1 w 1476
passages 1 w 1484
or 21 w 1487
pass 3 w 1491
through 1 w 1498
the 31 w 1501
larger 1 w 1507
Now 1 w 1511
the 32 w 1514
flesh 1 w 1519
of 11 w 1521
the 33 w 1524
polypus 5 w 1531
as 17 w 1534
one 3 w 1537
may 3 w 1540
judge 1 w 1545
by 5 w 1547
the 34 w 1550
eye 2 w 1553
is 15 w 1556
hollow 1 w 1562
full 1 w 1567
of 12 w 1569
pores 1 w 1574
and 13 w 1578
capable 1 w 1585
of 13 w 1587
effluvia 4 w 1595
When 1 w 1600
therefore 2 w 1609
she 2 w 1612
is 16 w 1614
afraid 1 w 1620
as 18 w 1623
her 10 w 1626
spirit 2 w 1632
changes 3 w 1639
she 3 w 1642
changes 4 w 1649
herself 1 w 1656
and 14 w 1660
by 6 w 1662
straitening 1 w 1673
and 15 w 1676
contracting 1 w 1687
her 12 w 1690
body 1 w 1694
she 4 w 1698
encloses 1 w 1706
the 36 w 1709
neighboring 1 w 1720
effluvia 5 w 1728
And 3 w 1732
as 19 w 1735
a 131 w 1736
good 1 w 1740
token 1 w 1745
of 14 w 1747
this 4 w 1751
argument 1 w 1759
the 37 w 1763
polypus 6 w 1770
cannot 1 w 1776
imitate 2 w 1783
the 38 w 1786
color 9 w 1791
of 15 w 1793
every 2 w 1798
thing 5 w 1803
he 55 w 1805
comes 2 w 1810
near 1 w 1814
nor 1 w 1818
the 39 w 1821
chameleon 1 w 1830
of 16 w 1832
any 2 w 1835
thing 6 w 1840
that 9 w 1844
is 18 w 1846
white 1 w 1851
but 3 w 1855
each 1 w 1859
of 17 w 1861
these 2 w 1866
creatures 1 w 1875
is 19 w 1877
assimilated 1 w 1888
only 2 w 1892
to 8 w 1894
those 1 w 1899
things 3 w 1905
to 9 w 1907
whose 1 w 1912
effluvia 6 w 1920
it 27 w 1922
has 1 w 1925
pores 2 w 1930
proportionable 1 w 1944
XX 1 w 1947
WHAT 1 w 1952
IS 1 w 1954
THE 3 w 1957
REASON 1 w 1963
THAT 1 w 1968
THE 4 w 1971
TEARS 1 w 1976
OF 1 w 1978
WILD 1 w 1982
BOARS 1 w 1987
ARE 1 w 1990
SWEET 1 w 1995
AND 1 w 1999
THE 5 w 2002
TEARS 2 w 2007
OF 2 w 2009
THE 6 w 2012
HART 1 w 2016
SALT 1 w 2020
AND 2 w 2023
HURTFUL 1 w 2030
THE 7 w 2034
reason 2 w 2040
seems 1 w 2045
to 10 w 2047
be 7 w 2049
the 41 w 2052
heat 2 w 2056
and 16 w 2059
cold 1 w 2063
of 18 w 2065
these 3 w 2070
animals 2 w 2077
For 4 w 2081
the 43 w 2084
hart 1 w 2088
is 20 w 2090
cold 2 w 2094
and 17 w 2098
the 44 w 2101
boar 1 w 2105
is 21 w 2107
very 3 w 2111
hot 1 w 2114
and 18 w 2117
fiery 1 w 2122
therefore 3 w 2132
the 46 w 2135
one 4 w 2138
flies 1 w 2143
from 3 w 2147
the 47 w 2151
other 4 w 2156
defends 1 w 2163
himself 1 w 2170
against 1 w 2177
his 5 w 2181
pursuers 1 w 2189
Now 2 w 2193
when 2 w 2197
great 1 w 2202
store 1 w 2207
of 19 w 2209
heat 3 w 2213
comes 3 w 2218
to 12 w 2220
the 49 w 2223
eyes 1 w 2227
as 23 w 2230
Homer 1 w 2235
says 2 w 2239
with 4 w 2244
horrid 1 w 2250
bristles 1 w 2258
and 19 w 2262
eyes 2 w 2266
darting 1 w 2273
fire 1 w 2277
tears 1 w 2284
are 4 w 2287
sweet 1 w 2292
Some 2 w 2297
are 5 w 2300
of 20 w 2302
Empedocles 2 w 2312
s 179 w 2314
opinion 1 w 2321
who 3 w 2325
thought 2 w 2332
that 10 w 2336
tears 2 w 2341
proceed 2 w 2348
from 4 w 2352
the 50 w 2355
disturbance 1 w 2366
of 21 w 2368
the 51 w 2371
blood 1 w 2376
as 24 w 2379
whey 1 w 2383
does 2 w 2387
from 5 w 2391
the 52 w 2394
churning 1 w 2402
of 22 w 2404
milk 1 w 2408
since 1 w 2414
therefore 4 w 2423
boar 2 w 2427
s 185 w 2429
blood 2 w 2434
is 25 w 2436
harsh 1 w 2441
and 20 w 2444
black 1 w 2449
and 21 w 2453
hart 2 w 2457
s 188 w 2459
blood 3 w 2464
thin 9 w 2468
and 22 w 2471
watery 1 w 2477
it 29 w 2480
is 26 w 2482
consentaneous 1 w 2495
that 11 w 2499
the 54 w 2502
tears 3 w 2507
which 2 w 2513
the 55 w 2516
one 5 w 2519
sheds 1 w 2524
when 3 w 2528
excited 1 w 2535
to 13 w 2537
anger 1 w 2542
and 23 w 2546
the 56 w 2549
other 5 w 2554
when 4 w 2558
dejected 1 w 2566
with 5 w 2570
fear 2 w 2574
should 1 w 2581
be 8 w 2583
of 23 w 2585
the 58 w 2588
same 1 w 2592
nature 2 w 2598
XXI 1 w 2602
WHY 2 w 2606
DO 2 w 2608
TAME 1 w 2612
SOWS 1 w 2616
FARROW 1 w 2622
OFTEN 1 w 2627
SOME 1 w 2632
AT 3 w 2634
ONE 1 w 2638
TIME 1 w 2642
AND 3 w 2645
OTHERS 1 w 2651
AT 4 w 2653
ANOTHER 1 w 2660
AND 4 w 2664
THE 10 w 2667
WILD 2 w 2671
BUT 1 w 2674
ONCE 1 w 2678
A 23 w 2679
YEAR 1 w 2683
AND 5 w 2687
ALL 1 w 2690
OF 4 w 2692
THEM 1 w 2696
ABOUT 1 w 2701
THE 12 w 2704
SAME 1 w 2708
TIME 2 w 2712
AT 5 w 2714
THE 13 w 2717
BEGINNING 1 w 2726
OF 5 w 2728
SUMMER 1 w 2734
WHENCE 1 w 2741
IT 1 w 2743
IS 2 w 2745
SAID 1 w 2749
The 5 w 2754
wild 1 w 2758
sow 1 w 2761
farrowing 1 w 2770
that 12 w 2775
night 1 w 2780
falls 1 w 2785
no 7 w 2787
rain 1 w 2791
Is 1 w 2794
it 32 w 2796
because 3 w 2803
of 24 w 2805
plentiful 1 w 2814
feeding 1 w 2821
as 25 w 2824
in 40 w 2826
very 4 w 2830
truth 1 w 2835
fulness 1 w 2842
doth 2 w 2846
produce 1 w 2853
wantonness 1 w 2863
For 5 w 2867
abundance 1 w 2876
of 25 w 2878
nourishment 1 w 2889
breeds 1 w 2895
abundance 2 w 2904
of 26 w 2906
seed 1 w 2910
both 1 w 2914
in 41 w 2916
animals 3 w 2923
and 24 w 2926
plants 2 w 2932
Now 3 w 2936
wild 2 w 2940
sows 1 w 2944
live 1 w 2948
by 7 w 2950
their 2 w 2955
own 1 w 2958
toil 1 w 2962
and 25 w 2966
that 13 w 2970
with 6 w 2974
fear 3 w 2978
the 60 w 2982
tame 1 w 2986
have 3 w 2990
always 2 w 2996
food 1 w 3000
enough 1 w 3006
either 2 w 3013
by 8 w 3015
nature 3 w 3021
or 35 w 3023
given 1 w 3028
them 3 w 3032
Or 1 w 3035
may 4 w 3038
it 35 w 3040
not 6 w 3043
be 10 w 3045
ascribed 1 w 3053
to 16 w 3055
their 3 w 3060
rest 1 w 3064
and 26 w 3067
exercise 1 w 3075
For 6 w 3079
the 64 w 3082
tame 2 w 3086
do 10 w 3088
rest 2 w 3092
and 27 w 3095
go 2 w 3097
not 7 w 3100
far 2 w 3103
from 6 w 3107
their 4 w 3112
keepers 1 w 3119
the 66 w 3123
wild 3 w 3127
get 1 w 3130
to 17 w 3132
the 67 w 3135
mountains 1 w 3144
and 28 w 3148
run 2 w 3151
about 2 w 3156
by 9 w 3159
which 3 w 3164
means 1 w 3169
they 6 w 3173
waste 1 w 3178
the 69 w 3181
nutriment 1 w 3190
and 29 w 3194
consume 1 w 3201
it 36 w 3203
upon 1 w 3207
the 70 w 3210
whole 1 w 3215
body 2 w 3219
Therefore 1 w 3229
either 3 w 3235
through 2 w 3242
continual 3 w 3251
converse 2 w 3259
or 38 w 3262
abundance 3 w 3271
of 27 w 3273
seed 2 w 3277
or 39 w 3280
because 4 w 3287
the 72 w 3290
females 1 w 3297
feed 2 w 3301
in 44 w 3303
herds 1 w 3308
with 7 w 3312
the 73 w 3315
males 2 w 3320
the 74 w 3324
tame 3 w 3328
sows 2 w 3332
call 1 w 3336
to 18 w 3338
mind 2 w 3342
coition 1 w 3349
and 30 w 3352
stir 1 w 3356
up 4 w 3358
lust 1 w 3362
as 28 w 3365
Empedocles 3 w 3375
talks 1 w 3380
of 28 w 3382
men 6 w 3385
But 4 w 3389
in 46 w 3391
wild 4 w 3395
sows 3 w 3399
which 4 w 3405
feed 3 w 3409
apart 1 w 3414
desire 1 w 3421
is 29 w 3423
cold 3 w 3427
and 31 w 3430
dull 1 w 3434
for 8 w 3437
want 2 w 3441
of 29 w 3443
love 1 w 3447
and 32 w 3450
conversation 1 w 3462
Or 2 w 3465
is 30 w 3467
it 40 w 3469
true 1 w 3473
what 3 w 3478
Aristotle 1 w 3487
says 3 w 3491
that 14 w 3496
Homer 2 w 3501
called 1 w 3507
the 75 w 3510
wild 5 w 3514
boar 3 w 3518
χλούνης 1 w 3525
because 5 w 3533
he 103 w 3535
had 1 w 3538
but 4 w 3541
one 6 w 3544
stone 3 w 3549
For 7 w 3553
most 2 w 3557
boars 1 w 3562
spoil 1 w 3567
their 5 w 3572
stones 2 w 3578
he 105 w 3581
says 4 w 3585
by 10 w 3588
rubbing 1 w 3595
them 4 w 3599
against 2 w 3606
stumps 1 w 3612
of 30 w 3614
trees 1 w 3619