Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / For M. Tullius

For M. Tullius (36-40)

urn:cts:latinLit:phi0474.phi006.perseus-eng2:36-40
Refs {'start': {'reference': '36', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 36'}, 'end': {'reference': '40', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 40'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

If this were the only case, (it would be well, indeed, if it were,) but if it were, the only case, still you, O judges, being such as you are, ought to be unwilling that an affair of the greatest importance, affecting not only the welfare of the entire republic but also the fortunes of individualsthat a most dignified tribunal, one established with the greatest deliberation, and for the weightiest reasons, should appear to be put an end to by you. But this is not the only thing at stake. the decision in this case is waited for with so much anxiety as shows that it is expected to rule not one case only, but all cases.

Shall I say that violence was done by the household of Publius Fabius? Our adversaries do not deny it. That damage was done to Marcus Tullius? You grant thatI have carried one point. That this violence was done by armed men? You do not deny thatI have carried a second point. You deny that it was done with malice; on this point we join issue. Nor, indeed, do I see any need of looking for arguments by which that trivial and insignificant defence of his may be refuted and done away with.

And yet I must speak to the statements which Quinctius has made; not that they have anything to do with the matter, but that it may not be thought that anything has been granted by me, merely because it has been overlooked.

16

You say that inquiry ought to be instituted whether the men of Marcus Tullius were slain wrongfully or no. This is the first inquiry that I make about the matter,—whether that matter has come before the court or not. If it has not come, why then need we say anything about it, or why need they ask any questions about it? But if it has, what was your object in making such a long speech to the praetor, to beg him to add to the formula the word wrongfully,” and because you had not succeeded, to appeal to the tribunes of the people, and here before the court to complain of the injustice of the praetor because he did not add the word wrongfully.”

When you were requesting this of the praetor,—when you were appealing to the tribunes, you said that you ought to have an opportunity given to you of persuading the judges, if you could, that damage had not been done to Marcus Tullius wrongfully. Though, therefore, you wish that to be added to the formula of the trial, in order to be allowed to speak to that point before the judges; though it was not added, do you nevertheless speak to it as if you had gained the very thing which was refused to you?

17
But the same words which Metellus used in making his decree, the others, whom you appealed to, likewise used. Was not this the language of them all,—that although that which a household was said to have done by means of men armed and collected in a violent manner, could not possibly be done rightly, still they would add nothing, And they ware right, O judges. For if, when there is a refuge open to them, still slaves commit these wickednesses with the greatest audacity, and masters avow them with the greatest shamelessness, what do you think would be the case if the praetor were to decide that it is possible that such murders should be committed lawfully? Does it make any difference whether the magistrates establish a defence for a crime, or give people power and liberty to commit crime?

Tokens

If 1 w 2
this 1 w 6
were 1 w 10
the 1 w 13
only 1 w 17
case 1 w 21
it 1 w 25
would 1 w 30
be 1 w 32
well 1 w 36
indeed 1 w 43
if 1 w 46
it 2 w 48
were 2 w 52
but 1 w 57
if 2 w 59
it 3 w 61
were 3 w 65
the 2 w 69
only 2 w 73
case 2 w 77
still 1 w 83
you 1 w 86
O 1 w 88
judges 1 w 94
being 1 w 100
such 1 w 104
as 3 w 106
you 2 w 109
are 1 w 112
ought 1 w 118
to 1 w 120
be 3 w 122
unwilling 1 w 131
that 1 w 135
an 1 w 137
affair 1 w 143
of 1 w 145
the 3 w 148
greatest 1 w 156
importance 1 w 166
affecting 1 w 176
not 1 w 179
only 3 w 183
the 4 w 186
welfare 1 w 193
of 2 w 195
the 5 w 198
entire 1 w 204
republic 1 w 212
but 2 w 215
also 1 w 219
the 6 w 222
fortunes 1 w 230
of 3 w 232
individuals 1 w 243
that 2 w 248
a 16 w 249
most 1 w 253
dignified 1 w 262
tribunal 1 w 270
one 1 w 274
established 1 w 285
with 1 w 289
the 7 w 292
greatest 2 w 300
deliberation 1 w 312
and 1 w 316
for 2 w 319
the 8 w 322
weightiest 1 w 332
reasons 1 w 339
should 1 w 346
appear 1 w 352
to 2 w 354
be 5 w 356
put 1 w 359
an 4 w 361
end 1 w 364
to 3 w 366
by 1 w 368
you 3 w 371
But 1 w 375
this 2 w 379
is 4 w 381
not 2 w 384
the 9 w 387
only 4 w 391
thing 1 w 396
at 6 w 398
stake 1 w 403
the 10 w 407
decision 1 w 415
in 7 w 417
this 3 w 421
case 3 w 425
is 7 w 427
waited 1 w 433
for 3 w 436
with 2 w 440
so 3 w 442
much 1 w 446
anxiety 1 w 453
as 6 w 455
shows 1 w 460
that 3 w 464
it 7 w 466
is 8 w 468
expected 1 w 476
to 4 w 478
rule 1 w 482
not 3 w 485
one 2 w 488
case 4 w 492
only 5 w 496
but 3 w 500
all 1 w 503
cases 1 w 508
Shall 1 w 514
I 2 w 515
say 1 w 518
that 4 w 522
violence 1 w 530
was 1 w 533
done 1 w 537
by 2 w 539
the 11 w 542
household 1 w 551
of 4 w 553
Publius 1 w 560
Fabius 1 w 566
Our 1 w 570
adversaries 1 w 581
do 2 w 583
not 4 w 586
deny 1 w 590
it 8 w 592
That 1 w 597
damage 1 w 603
was 2 w 606
done 2 w 610
to 5 w 612
Marcus 1 w 618
Tullius 1 w 625
You 1 w 629
grant 1 w 634
that 5 w 638
I 3 w 640
have 1 w 644
carried 1 w 651
one 5 w 654
point 1 w 659
That 2 w 664
this 4 w 668
violence 2 w 676
was 3 w 679
done 3 w 683
by 3 w 685
armed 1 w 690
men 1 w 693
You 2 w 697
do 5 w 699
not 5 w 702
deny 2 w 706
that 6 w 710
I 4 w 712
have 2 w 716
carried 2 w 723
a 58 w 724
second 1 w 730
point 2 w 735
You 3 w 739
deny 3 w 743
that 7 w 747
it 9 w 749
was 4 w 752
done 4 w 756
with 3 w 760
malice 1 w 766
on 17 w 769
this 5 w 773
point 3 w 778
we 7 w 780
join 1 w 784
issue 1 w 789
Nor 1 w 793
indeed 2 w 800
do 7 w 803
I 5 w 804
see 1 w 807
any 1 w 810
need 1 w 814
of 5 w 816
looking 1 w 823
for 4 w 826
arguments 1 w 835
by 4 w 837
which 1 w 842
that 8 w 846
trivial 1 w 853
and 2 w 856
insignificant 1 w 869
defence 1 w 876
of 6 w 878
his 6 w 881
may 1 w 884
be 6 w 886
refuted 1 w 893
and 3 w 896
done 5 w 900
away 1 w 904
with 4 w 908
And 1 w 912
yet 1 w 915
I 6 w 916
must 1 w 920
speak 1 w 925
to 6 w 927
the 12 w 930
statements 1 w 940
which 2 w 945
Quinctius 1 w 954
has 1 w 957
made 1 w 961
not 6 w 965
that 9 w 969
they 1 w 973
have 3 w 977
anything 1 w 985
to 7 w 987
do 9 w 989
with 5 w 993
the 14 w 996
matter 1 w 1002
but 4 w 1006
that 10 w 1010
it 13 w 1012
may 2 w 1015
not 7 w 1018
be 7 w 1020
thought 1 w 1027
that 11 w 1031
anything 2 w 1039
has 2 w 1042
been 1 w 1046
granted 1 w 1053
by 5 w 1055
me 5 w 1057
merely 1 w 1064
because 1 w 1071
it 14 w 1073
has 3 w 1076
been 2 w 1080
overlooked 1 w 1090
You 4 w 1094
say 2 w 1097
that 12 w 1101
inquiry 1 w 1108
ought 3 w 1113
to 8 w 1115
be 11 w 1117
instituted 1 w 1127
whether 1 w 1134
the 16 w 1137
men 4 w 1140
of 7 w 1142
Marcus 2 w 1148
Tullius 2 w 1155
were 4 w 1159
slain 1 w 1164
wrongfully 1 w 1174
or 7 w 1176
no 8 w 1178
This 1 w 1183
is 14 w 1185
the 17 w 1188
first 1 w 1193
inquiry 2 w 1200
that 13 w 1204
I 7 w 1205
make 1 w 1209
about 1 w 1214
the 18 w 1217
matter 2 w 1223
whether 2 w 1232
that 14 w 1236
matter 3 w 1242
has 4 w 1245
come 1 w 1249
before 1 w 1255
the 20 w 1258
court 1 w 1263
or 9 w 1265
not 8 w 1268
If 2 w 1271
it 16 w 1273
has 5 w 1276
not 9 w 1279
come 2 w 1283
why 1 w 1287
then 1 w 1291
need 2 w 1295
we 9 w 1297
say 3 w 1300
anything 3 w 1308
about 2 w 1313
it 17 w 1315
or 10 w 1318
why 2 w 1321
need 3 w 1325
they 2 w 1329
ask 1 w 1332
any 5 w 1335
questions 1 w 1344
about 3 w 1349
it 18 w 1351
But 2 w 1355
if 5 w 1357
it 19 w 1359
has 6 w 1362
what 1 w 1367
was 5 w 1370
your 1 w 1374
object 1 w 1380
in 23 w 1382
making 1 w 1388
such 2 w 1392
a 110 w 1393
long 1 w 1397
speech 1 w 1403
to 9 w 1405
the 23 w 1408
praetor 1 w 1415
to 11 w 1418
beg 1 w 1421
him 1 w 1424
to 12 w 1426
add 1 w 1429
to 13 w 1431
the 24 w 1434
formula 1 w 1441
the 25 w 1444
word 1 w 1448
wrongfully 2 w 1459
and 4 w 1464
because 2 w 1471
you 5 w 1474
had 1 w 1477
not 10 w 1480
succeeded 1 w 1489
to 14 w 1492
appeal 1 w 1498
to 15 w 1500
the 26 w 1503
tribunes 1 w 1511
of 8 w 1513
the 27 w 1516
people 1 w 1522
and 5 w 1526
here 1 w 1530
before 2 w 1536
the 28 w 1539
court 2 w 1544
to 16 w 1546
complain 1 w 1554
of 9 w 1556
the 29 w 1559
injustice 1 w 1568
of 10 w 1570
the 30 w 1573
praetor 2 w 1580
because 3 w 1587
he 35 w 1589
did 1 w 1592
not 11 w 1595
add 2 w 1598
the 31 w 1601
word 2 w 1605
wrongfully 3 w 1616
When 1 w 1622
you 6 w 1625
were 5 w 1629
requesting 1 w 1639
this 6 w 1643
of 11 w 1645
the 32 w 1648
praetor 3 w 1655
when 1 w 1661
you 7 w 1664
were 6 w 1668
appealing 1 w 1677
to 19 w 1679
the 33 w 1682
tribunes 2 w 1690
you 8 w 1694
said 1 w 1698
that 15 w 1702
you 9 w 1705
ought 4 w 1710
to 20 w 1712
have 4 w 1716
an 18 w 1718
opportunity 1 w 1729
given 1 w 1734
to 21 w 1736
you 10 w 1739
of 12 w 1741
persuading 1 w 1751
the 34 w 1754
judges 2 w 1760
if 6 w 1763
you 11 w 1766
could 1 w 1771
that 16 w 1776
damage 2 w 1782
had 2 w 1785
not 12 w 1788
been 3 w 1792
done 6 w 1796
to 22 w 1798
Marcus 3 w 1804
Tullius 3 w 1811
wrongfully 4 w 1821
Though 1 w 1828
therefore 1 w 1838
you 12 w 1842
wish 1 w 1846
that 17 w 1850
to 23 w 1852
be 18 w 1854
added 1 w 1859
to 24 w 1861
the 36 w 1864
formula 2 w 1871
of 13 w 1873
the 37 w 1876
trial 1 w 1881
in 30 w 1884
order 1 w 1889
to 25 w 1891
be 19 w 1893
allowed 1 w 1900
to 26 w 1902
speak 2 w 1907
to 27 w 1909
that 18 w 1913
point 4 w 1918
before 3 w 1924
the 38 w 1927
judges 3 w 1933
though 2 w 1940
it 21 w 1942
was 6 w 1945
not 13 w 1948
added 2 w 1953
do 11 w 1956
you 13 w 1959
nevertheless 1 w 1971
speak 3 w 1976
to 28 w 1978
it 22 w 1980
as 22 w 1982
if 7 w 1984
you 14 w 1987
had 3 w 1990
gained 1 w 1996
the 40 w 1999
very 1 w 2003
thing 5 w 2008
which 3 w 2013
was 7 w 2016
refused 1 w 2023
to 29 w 2025
you 15 w 2028
But 3 w 2032
the 41 w 2035
same 1 w 2039
words 1 w 2044
which 4 w 2049
Metellus 1 w 2057
used 2 w 2061
in 34 w 2063
making 2 w 2069
his 9 w 2072
decree 1 w 2078
the 42 w 2082
others 1 w 2088
whom 1 w 2093
you 16 w 2096
appealed 1 w 2104
to 30 w 2106
likewise 1 w 2115
used 3 w 2119
Was 1 w 2123
not 14 w 2126
this 7 w 2130
the 44 w 2133
language 1 w 2141
of 14 w 2143
them 1 w 2147
all 4 w 2150
that 19 w 2156
although 1 w 2164
that 20 w 2168
which 5 w 2173
a 162 w 2174
household 2 w 2183
was 8 w 2186
said 2 w 2190
to 31 w 2192
have 5 w 2196
done 7 w 2200
by 6 w 2202
means 1 w 2207
of 15 w 2209
men 5 w 2212
armed 2 w 2217
and 6 w 2220
collected 1 w 2229
in 36 w 2231
a 169 w 2232
violent 1 w 2239
manner 1 w 2245
could 2 w 2251
not 15 w 2254
possibly 1 w 2262
be 21 w 2264
done 8 w 2268
rightly 1 w 2275
still 2 w 2281
they 3 w 2285
would 2 w 2290
add 5 w 2293
nothing 1 w 2300
And 2 w 2304
they 4 w 2308
ware 1 w 2312
right 2 w 2317
O 3 w 2319
judges 4 w 2325
For 1 w 2329
if 8 w 2331
when 2 w 2336
there 2 w 2341
is 20 w 2343
a 173 w 2344
refuge 1 w 2350
open 1 w 2354
to 32 w 2356
them 2 w 2360
still 3 w 2366
slaves 1 w 2372
commit 1 w 2378
these 1 w 2383
wickednesses 1 w 2395
with 6 w 2399
the 51 w 2402
greatest 3 w 2410
audacity 1 w 2418
and 7 w 2422
masters 1 w 2429
avow 1 w 2433
them 3 w 2437
with 7 w 2441
the 53 w 2444
greatest 4 w 2452
shamelessness 1 w 2465
what 2 w 2470
do 14 w 2472
you 17 w 2475
think 1 w 2480
would 3 w 2485
be 22 w 2487
the 54 w 2490
case 6 w 2494
if 9 w 2496
the 55 w 2499
praetor 4 w 2506
were 7 w 2510
to 34 w 2512
decide 1 w 2518
that 21 w 2522
it 27 w 2524
is 21 w 2526
possible 1 w 2534
that 22 w 2538
such 3 w 2542
murders 1 w 2549
should 2 w 2555
be 23 w 2557
committed 1 w 2566
lawfully 1 w 2574
Does 1 w 2579
it 29 w 2581
make 2 w 2585
any 6 w 2588
difference 1 w 2598
whether 3 w 2605
the 57 w 2608
magistrates 1 w 2619
establish 2 w 2628
a 194 w 2629
defence 2 w 2636
for 11 w 2639
a 195 w 2640
crime 1 w 2645
or 27 w 2648
give 2 w 2652
people 2 w 2658
power 1 w 2663
and 8 w 2666
liberty 1 w 2673
to 35 w 2675
commit 3 w 2681
crime 2 w 2686