Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Defense Against a Charge of Subverting the Democracy

Defense Against a Charge of Subverting the Democracy (11-15)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0540.tlg025.perseus-eng2:11-15
Refs {'start': {'reference': '11', 'human_reference': 'None 11'}, 'end': {'reference': '15', 'human_reference': 'None 15'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Now, in my opinion, all those who had been disfranchised under the democracy, or deprived of their property, or subjected to any other misfortune of the sort, were bound to desire a different system, in the hope that the change would be some benefit to themselves. But in the case of those who have done the people many good services, and never a single hurt, and who deserve your grateful favors instead of punishment for what they have achieved, it is not fair to harbor the slanders aimed at them, not even if all who have charge of public affairs allege that they favor oligarchy.

Now I, gentlemen of the jury, never suffered any misfortune during that time,[*] either private or public, which could lead me, through eagerness to be relieved of present ills, to court a change in our system. I have equipped a warship five times, fought in four sea-battles, contributed to many war levies, and performed my other public services as amply as any citizen.

But my purpose in spending more than was enjoined upon me by the city was to raise myself the higher in your opinion, so that if any misfortune should chance to befall me I might defend myself on better terms. Of all this credit I was deprived under the oligarchy; for instead of regarding those who had bestowed some benefit on the people as worthy recipients of their favors, they placed in positions of honor the men who had done you most harm, as though this were a pledge by which they held us bound. You ought all to reflect on those facts and refuse to believe the statements of these men: you should rather judge each person by the record of his actions.

For I, gentlemen, was not one of the Four Hundred: I challenge anyone who wishes amongst my accusers to come forward and convict me of this. Neither, again, will anyone prove that, when the Thirty were established, I sat on the Council or held any office. Surely, if I chose not to hold office when I could have done so, I deserve to be honored by you today. If, on their part, the men who were in power at that time preferred not to give me a place in the government, could I find a more signal proof than this of the falsehood of my accusers?

Furthermore, gentlemen of the jury, you ought also to take account of the rest of my conduct. For amid the misfortunes of the city my behavior was such that, if everyone had been of one mind with me, not one of you would have experience of a single misfortune. I had no hand during the oligarchy, you will find, either in the arrest of anybody, or in taking vengeance upon any of my enemies, or in conferring a favor on any of my friends,

Now 1 w 3
in 1 w 6
my 1 w 8
opinion 1 w 15
all 1 w 19
those 1 w 24
who 1 w 27
had 1 w 30
been 1 w 34
disfranchised 1 w 47
under 1 w 52
the 1 w 55
democracy 1 w 64
or 1 w 67
deprived 1 w 75
of 1 w 77
their 1 w 82
property 1 w 90
or 2 w 93
subjected 1 w 102
to 1 w 104
any 1 w 107
other 1 w 112
misfortune 1 w 122
of 2 w 124
the 4 w 127
sort 1 w 131
were 1 w 136
bound 1 w 141
to 2 w 143
desire 1 w 149
a 6 w 150
different 1 w 159
system 1 w 165
in 3 w 168
the 5 w 171
hope 1 w 175
that 1 w 179
the 6 w 182
change 1 w 188
would 1 w 193
be 2 w 195
some 1 w 199
benefit 1 w 206
to 3 w 208
themselves 1 w 218
But 1 w 222
in 4 w 224
the 8 w 227
case 1 w 231
of 3 w 233
those 2 w 238
who 2 w 241
have 1 w 245
done 1 w 249
the 9 w 252
people 1 w 258
many 1 w 262
good 1 w 266
services 1 w 274
and 1 w 278
never 1 w 283
a 13 w 284
single 1 w 290
hurt 1 w 294
and 2 w 298
who 3 w 301
deserve 1 w 308
your 1 w 312
grateful 1 w 320
favors 1 w 326
instead 1 w 333
of 4 w 335
punishment 1 w 345
for 2 w 348
what 1 w 352
they 1 w 356
have 2 w 360
achieved 1 w 368
it 2 w 371
is 5 w 373
not 1 w 376
fair 1 w 380
to 4 w 382
harbor 1 w 388
the 11 w 391
slanders 1 w 399
aimed 1 w 404
at 4 w 406
them 2 w 410
not 2 w 414
even 1 w 418
if 2 w 420
all 2 w 423
who 4 w 426
have 3 w 430
charge 1 w 436
of 5 w 438
public 1 w 444
affairs 1 w 451
allege 1 w 457
that 2 w 461
they 2 w 465
favor 2 w 470
oligarchy 1 w 479
Now 2 w 483
I 1 w 484
gentlemen 1 w 494
of 6 w 496
the 14 w 499
jury 1 w 503
never 2 w 509
suffered 1 w 517
any 3 w 520
misfortune 2 w 530
during 1 w 536
that 3 w 540
time 1 w 544
The 1 w 548
six 1 w 551
years 1 w 556
between 1 w 563
the 15 w 566
restoration 1 w 577
of 7 w 579
the 16 w 582
democracy 2 w 591
in 8 w 593
410 1 w 596
B 2 w 597
C 1 w 599
and 4 w 603
the 17 w 606
tyranny 1 w 613
of 8 w 615
the 18 w 618
Thirty 1 w 624
in 9 w 626
404 1 w 629
B 3 w 630
C 2 w 632
either 1 w 639
private 1 w 646
or 11 w 648
public 2 w 654
which 1 w 660
could 1 w 665
lead 1 w 669
me 6 w 671
through 1 w 679
eagerness 1 w 688
to 6 w 690
be 5 w 692
relieved 1 w 700
of 9 w 702
present 1 w 709
ills 1 w 713
to 7 w 716
court 1 w 721
a 45 w 722
change 2 w 728
in 10 w 730
our 3 w 733
system 2 w 739
I 2 w 741
have 4 w 745
equipped 1 w 753
a 48 w 754
warship 1 w 761
five 1 w 765
times 1 w 770
fought 1 w 777
in 11 w 779
four 1 w 783
sea-battles 1 w 794
contributed 1 w 806
to 8 w 808
many 2 w 812
war 2 w 815
levies 1 w 821
and 5 w 825
performed 1 w 834
my 2 w 836
other 2 w 841
public 3 w 847
services 2 w 855
as 2 w 857
amply 1 w 862
as 3 w 864
any 5 w 867
citizen 1 w 874
But 2 w 878
my 3 w 880
purpose 1 w 887
in 12 w 889
spending 1 w 897
more 1 w 901
than 1 w 905
was 1 w 908
enjoined 1 w 916
upon 1 w 920
me 9 w 922
by 1 w 924
the 21 w 927
city 1 w 931
was 2 w 934
to 9 w 936
raise 1 w 941
myself 1 w 947
the 22 w 950
higher 1 w 956
in 15 w 958
your 2 w 962
opinion 2 w 969
so 3 w 972
that 4 w 976
if 3 w 978
any 6 w 981
misfortune 3 w 991
should 1 w 997
chance 1 w 1003
to 10 w 1005
befall 1 w 1011
me 10 w 1013
I 3 w 1014
might 1 w 1019
defend 1 w 1025
myself 2 w 1031
on 7 w 1033
better 1 w 1039
terms 1 w 1044
Of 1 w 1047
all 5 w 1050
this 1 w 1054
credit 1 w 1060
I 4 w 1061
was 3 w 1064
deprived 2 w 1072
under 2 w 1077
the 23 w 1080
oligarchy 2 w 1089
for 6 w 1093
instead 2 w 1100
of 10 w 1102
regarding 1 w 1111
those 3 w 1116
who 5 w 1119
had 2 w 1122
bestowed 1 w 1130
some 2 w 1134
benefit 2 w 1141
on 8 w 1143
the 24 w 1146
people 2 w 1152
as 7 w 1154
worthy 1 w 1160
recipients 1 w 1170
of 11 w 1172
their 2 w 1177
favors 2 w 1183
they 3 w 1188
placed 1 w 1194
in 19 w 1196
positions 1 w 1205
of 12 w 1207
honor 1 w 1212
the 27 w 1215
men 3 w 1218
who 6 w 1221
had 3 w 1224
done 2 w 1228
you 3 w 1231
most 1 w 1235
harm 1 w 1239
as 8 w 1242
though 1 w 1248
this 2 w 1252
were 2 w 1256
a 79 w 1257
pledge 1 w 1263
by 2 w 1265
which 2 w 1270
they 4 w 1274
held 1 w 1278
us 1 w 1280
bound 2 w 1285
You 1 w 1289
ought 2 w 1294
all 6 w 1297
to 12 w 1299
reflect 1 w 1306
on 12 w 1308
those 4 w 1313
facts 1 w 1318
and 6 w 1321
refuse 1 w 1327
to 13 w 1329
believe 1 w 1336
the 29 w 1339
statements 1 w 1349
of 13 w 1351
these 1 w 1356
men 5 w 1359
you 4 w 1363
should 2 w 1369
rather 1 w 1375
judge 1 w 1380
each 1 w 1384
person 1 w 1390
by 3 w 1392
the 32 w 1395
record 1 w 1401
of 14 w 1403
his 4 w 1406
actions 1 w 1413
For 1 w 1417
I 5 w 1418
gentlemen 2 w 1428
was 4 w 1432
not 3 w 1435
one 3 w 1438
of 15 w 1440
the 33 w 1443
Four 1 w 1447
Hundred 1 w 1454
I 6 w 1456
challenge 1 w 1465
anyone 1 w 1471
who 7 w 1474
wishes 1 w 1480
amongst 1 w 1487
my 6 w 1489
accusers 1 w 1497
to 14 w 1499
come 1 w 1503
forward 1 w 1510
and 7 w 1513
convict 1 w 1520
me 17 w 1522
of 16 w 1524
this 3 w 1528
Neither 1 w 1536
again 1 w 1542
will 1 w 1547
anyone 2 w 1553
prove 1 w 1558
that 5 w 1562
when 1 w 1567
the 35 w 1570
Thirty 2 w 1576
were 3 w 1580
established 1 w 1591
I 7 w 1593
sat 1 w 1596
on 20 w 1598
the 36 w 1601
Council 1 w 1608
or 22 w 1610
held 2 w 1614
any 9 w 1617
office 1 w 1623
Surely 1 w 1630
if 4 w 1633
I 8 w 1634
chose 1 w 1639
not 4 w 1642
to 15 w 1644
hold 1 w 1648
office 2 w 1654
when 2 w 1658
I 9 w 1659
could 2 w 1664
have 5 w 1668
done 3 w 1672
so 6 w 1674
I 10 w 1676
deserve 2 w 1683
to 16 w 1685
be 11 w 1687
honored 1 w 1694
by 4 w 1696
you 5 w 1699
today 1 w 1704
If 1 w 1707
on 23 w 1710
their 3 w 1715
part 1 w 1719
the 38 w 1723
men 7 w 1726
who 8 w 1729
were 4 w 1733
in 21 w 1735
power 1 w 1740
at 15 w 1742
that 6 w 1746
time 3 w 1750
preferred 1 w 1759
not 5 w 1762
to 18 w 1764
give 1 w 1768
me 20 w 1770
a 106 w 1771
place 2 w 1776
in 22 w 1778
the 39 w 1781
government 1 w 1791
could 3 w 1797
I 12 w 1798
find 1 w 1802
a 108 w 1803
more 2 w 1807
signal 1 w 1813
proof 1 w 1818
than 2 w 1822
this 4 w 1826
of 20 w 1828
the 40 w 1831
falsehood 1 w 1840
of 21 w 1842
my 7 w 1844
accusers 2 w 1852
Furthermore 1 w 1864
gentlemen 3 w 1874
of 22 w 1876
the 42 w 1879
jury 2 w 1883
you 6 w 1887
ought 3 w 1892
also 1 w 1896
to 19 w 1898
take 1 w 1902
account 1 w 1909
of 23 w 1911
the 43 w 1914
rest 2 w 1918
of 24 w 1920
my 8 w 1922
conduct 1 w 1929
For 2 w 1933
amid 1 w 1937
the 44 w 1940
misfortunes 1 w 1951
of 25 w 1953
the 45 w 1956
city 2 w 1960
my 9 w 1962
behavior 1 w 1970
was 5 w 1973
such 1 w 1977
that 7 w 1981
if 5 w 1984
everyone 1 w 1992
had 4 w 1995
been 2 w 1999
of 26 w 2001
one 8 w 2004
mind 1 w 2008
with 1 w 2012
me 23 w 2014
not 6 w 2018
one 9 w 2021
of 27 w 2023
you 7 w 2026
would 2 w 2031
have 6 w 2035
experience 1 w 2045
of 28 w 2047
a 122 w 2048
single 2 w 2054
misfortune 5 w 2064
I 13 w 2066
had 5 w 2069
no 9 w 2071
hand 1 w 2075
during 2 w 2081
the 46 w 2084
oligarchy 3 w 2093
you 8 w 2097
will 2 w 2101
find 2 w 2105
either 3 w 2112
in 28 w 2114
the 48 w 2117
arrest 1 w 2123
of 29 w 2125
anybody 1 w 2132
or 30 w 2135
in 29 w 2137
taking 1 w 2143
vengeance 1 w 2152
upon 2 w 2156
any 11 w 2159
of 30 w 2161
my 10 w 2163
enemies 1 w 2170
or 31 w 2173
in 31 w 2175
conferring 1 w 2185
a 131 w 2186
favor 4 w 2191
on 30 w 2193
any 12 w 2196
of 31 w 2198
my 11 w 2200
friends 1 w 2207