Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / On the Property of Aristophanes

On the Property of Aristophanes (26-30)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0540.tlg019.perseus-eng2:26-30
Refs {'start': {'reference': '26', 'human_reference': 'None 26'}, 'end': {'reference': '30', 'human_reference': 'None 30'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Then Aristophanes, on hearing this proposal from Demus and a request from me,—although he was to have the gold cup in his hands and receive four minae as interest,— said that it was impossible, and he swore that he had already gone elsewhere to borrow more for these foreigners; since, but for that, nobody alive, he declared, would have been more delighted than he to take that credential forthwith and to comply with our request.

To show the truth of this, I will produce to you witnesses.

Witnesses

So then, that Aristophanes did not leave any silver or gold is easily concluded from what I have stated and from these testimonies. Of fine[*] bronze plate he possessed but little: when he was entertaining the envoys of Evagoras, he had to use what he could borrow. The list of the pieces that he left shall be read to you.

Inventory of Bronze Plate

Perhaps to some of you, gentlemen of the jury, they appear few: but bear in mind the fact that before Conon won his victory at sea,[*] Aristophanes had no land except a small plot at Rhamnus.[*] Now the sea-fight occurred in the archonship of Eubulides;

and in four or five years it was a difficult thing, gentlemen, when he had no wealth to start with, to be twice a producer of tragedies, on his fathers account as well as his own; to equip a warship for three years in succession; to have been a contributor to special levies on many occasions; to purchase a house for fifty minae; and to acquire more than three hundred plethra[*] of land. Do you suppose that, besides doing all this, he must have left many personal effects?

Why, even people credited with long-established wealth may fail to produce any that are of value: for at times, however much one may desire it, one cannot buy things of the sort that, once acquired, will be a permanent source of pleasure.

Tokens

Then 1 w 4
Aristophanes 1 w 16
on 1 w 19
hearing 1 w 26
this 1 w 30
proposal 1 w 38
from 1 w 42
Demus 1 w 47
and 1 w 50
a 5 w 51
request 1 w 58
from 2 w 62
me 1 w 64
although 1 w 74
he 3 w 76
was 1 w 79
to 2 w 81
have 1 w 85
the 1 w 88
gold 1 w 92
cup 1 w 95
in 2 w 97
his 2 w 100
hands 1 w 105
and 3 w 108
receive 1 w 115
four 1 w 119
minae 1 w 124
as 2 w 126
interest 1 w 134
said 1 w 140
that 1 w 144
it 1 w 146
was 2 w 149
impossible 1 w 159
and 4 w 163
he 5 w 165
swore 1 w 170
that 2 w 174
he 6 w 176
had 1 w 179
already 1 w 186
gone 1 w 190
elsewhere 1 w 199
to 3 w 201
borrow 1 w 207
more 1 w 211
for 1 w 214
these 1 w 219
foreigners 1 w 229
since 1 w 235
but 1 w 239
for 3 w 242
that 3 w 246
nobody 1 w 253
alive 1 w 258
he 9 w 261
declared 1 w 269
would 1 w 275
have 2 w 279
been 1 w 283
more 2 w 287
delighted 1 w 296
than 1 w 300
he 10 w 302
to 4 w 304
take 1 w 308
that 4 w 312
credential 1 w 322
forthwith 1 w 331
and 5 w 334
to 5 w 336
comply 1 w 342
with 2 w 346
our 2 w 349
request 2 w 356
To 1 w 359
show 1 w 363
the 3 w 366
truth 1 w 371
of 1 w 373
this 2 w 377
I 1 w 379
will 1 w 383
produce 1 w 390
to 6 w 392
you 1 w 395
witnesses 1 w 404
Witnesses 1 w 414
So 1 w 416
then 1 w 420
that 5 w 425
Aristophanes 2 w 437
did 1 w 440
not 1 w 443
leave 1 w 448
any 1 w 451
silver 1 w 457
or 9 w 459
gold 2 w 463
is 6 w 465
easily 1 w 471
concluded 1 w 480
from 3 w 484
what 1 w 488
I 2 w 489
have 3 w 493
stated 1 w 499
and 6 w 502
from 4 w 506
these 2 w 511
testimonies 1 w 522
Of 1 w 525
fine 1 w 529
Containing 1 w 539
an 11 w 541
admixture 1 w 550
of 2 w 552
gold 3 w 556
and 7 w 559
silver 2 w 565
bronze 1 w 572
plate 1 w 577
he 14 w 579
possessed 1 w 588
but 2 w 591
little 1 w 597
when 1 w 602
he 16 w 604
was 3 w 607
entertaining 1 w 619
the 6 w 622
envoys 1 w 628
of 3 w 630
Evagoras 1 w 638
he 18 w 641
had 2 w 644
to 8 w 646
use 1 w 649
what 2 w 653
he 19 w 655
could 1 w 660
borrow 2 w 666
The 2 w 670
list 1 w 674
of 4 w 676
the 7 w 679
pieces 1 w 685
that 6 w 689
he 22 w 691
left 1 w 695
shall 1 w 700
be 2 w 702
read 2 w 706
to 9 w 708
you 2 w 711
Inventory 1 w 721
of 5 w 723
Bronze 1 w 729
Plate 1 w 734
Perhaps 1 w 741
to 11 w 743
some 1 w 747
of 6 w 749
you 3 w 752
gentlemen 1 w 762
of 7 w 764
the 8 w 767
jury 1 w 771
they 1 w 776
appear 1 w 782
few 1 w 785
but 3 w 789
bear 1 w 793
in 11 w 795
mind 1 w 799
the 10 w 802
fact 1 w 806
that 7 w 810
before 1 w 816
Conon 1 w 821
won 1 w 824
his 4 w 827
victory 1 w 834
at 13 w 836
sea 1 w 839
At 1 w 842
Cnidus 1 w 848
394 1 w 852
B 2 w 853
C 4 w 855
Aristophanes 3 w 868
had 3 w 871
no 4 w 873
land 1 w 877
except 1 w 883
a 65 w 884
small 1 w 889
plot 1 w 893
at 14 w 895
Rhamnus 1 w 902
A 5 w 904
district 1 w 912
of 8 w 914
Attica 1 w 920
Now 1 w 924
the 11 w 927
sea-fight 1 w 936
occurred 1 w 944
in 13 w 946
the 12 w 949
archonship 1 w 959
of 9 w 961
Eubulides 1 w 970
and 9 w 974
in 14 w 976
four 2 w 980
or 15 w 982
five 1 w 986
years 1 w 991
it 7 w 993
was 4 w 996
a 75 w 997
difficult 1 w 1006
thing 1 w 1011
gentlemen 2 w 1021
when 2 w 1026
he 29 w 1028
had 4 w 1031
no 5 w 1033
wealth 1 w 1039
to 14 w 1041
start 1 w 1046
with 3 w 1050
to 15 w 1053
be 5 w 1055
twice 1 w 1060
a 79 w 1061
producer 1 w 1069
of 10 w 1071
tragedies 1 w 1080
on 12 w 1083
his 5 w 1086
father 1 w 1092
s 69 w 1094
account 1 w 1101
as 8 w 1103
well 1 w 1107
as 9 w 1109
his 6 w 1112
own 1 w 1115
to 16 w 1118
equip 1 w 1123
a 85 w 1124
warship 1 w 1131
for 6 w 1134
three 1 w 1139
years 2 w 1144
in 16 w 1146
succession 1 w 1156
to 17 w 1159
have 4 w 1163
been 2 w 1167
a 89 w 1168
contributor 1 w 1179
to 19 w 1181
special 1 w 1188
levies 1 w 1194
on 15 w 1196
many 1 w 1200
occasions 1 w 1209
to 20 w 1212
purchase 1 w 1220
a 94 w 1221
house 1 w 1226
for 7 w 1229
fifty 1 w 1234
minae 2 w 1239
and 10 w 1243
to 21 w 1245
acquire 1 w 1252
more 3 w 1256
than 2 w 1260
three 2 w 1265
hundred 1 w 1272
plethra 1 w 1279
Amounting 1 w 1288
to 22 w 1290
about 1 w 1295
80 1 w 1297
acres 1 w 1302
of 11 w 1305
land 2 w 1309
Do 1 w 1312
you 4 w 1315
suppose 1 w 1322
that 8 w 1326
besides 1 w 1334
doing 1 w 1339
all 3 w 1342
this 3 w 1346
he 31 w 1349
must 1 w 1353
have 5 w 1357
left 2 w 1361
many 2 w 1365
personal 1 w 1373
effects 1 w 1380
Why 1 w 1384
even 1 w 1389
people 1 w 1395
credited 1 w 1403
with 4 w 1407
long-established 1 w 1423
wealth 2 w 1429
may 1 w 1432
fail 1 w 1436
to 23 w 1438
produce 3 w 1445
any 4 w 1448
that 9 w 1452
are 2 w 1455
of 12 w 1457
value 1 w 1462
for 8 w 1466
at 18 w 1468
times 1 w 1473
however 1 w 1481
much 1 w 1485
one 2 w 1488
may 2 w 1491
desire 1 w 1497
it 11 w 1499
one 3 w 1503
cannot 1 w 1509
buy 1 w 1512
things 1 w 1518
of 13 w 1520
the 14 w 1523
sort 1 w 1527
that 10 w 1531
once 1 w 1536
acquired 1 w 1544
will 2 w 1549
be 8 w 1551
a 121 w 1552
permanent 1 w 1561
source 1 w 1567
of 14 w 1569
pleasure 1 w 1577