Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Poetics

Poetics (9.3-9.7)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0086.tlg034.perseus-eng2:9.3-9.7
Refs {'start': {'reference': '9.3', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 9 Subchapter 3'}, 'end': {'reference': '9.7', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 9 Subchapter 7'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '9'}]
Children []
prev
plain text • XML
next

For this reason poetry is something more scientific and serious than history, because poetry tends to give general truths while history gives particular facts.

By a general truth I mean the sort of thing that a certain type of man will do or say either probably or necessarily. That is what poetry aims at in giving names to the characters.[*] A particular fact is what Alcibiades did or what was done to him.

In the case of comedy this has now become obvious, for comedians construct their plots out of probable incidents and then put in any names that occur to them. They do not, like the iambic satirists, write about individuals.[*]

In tragedy, on the other hand, they keep to real names. The reason is that what is possible carries conviction. If a thing has not happened, we do not yet believe in its possibility, but what has happened is obviously possible. Had it been impossible, it would not have happened.

20
It is true that in some tragedies one or two of the names are familiar and the rest invented; indeed in some they are all invented, as for instance in Agathon’s Antheus,[*] where both the incidents and the names are invented and yet it is none the less a favourite.

Tokens

For 1 w 3
this 1 w 7
reason 1 w 13
poetry 1 w 19
is 2 w 21
something 1 w 30
more 1 w 34
scientific 1 w 44
and 1 w 47
serious 1 w 54
than 1 w 58
history 1 w 65
because 1 w 73
poetry 2 w 79
tends 1 w 84
to 2 w 86
give 1 w 90
general 1 w 97
truths 1 w 103
while 1 w 108
history 2 w 115
gives 1 w 120
particular 1 w 130
facts 1 w 135
By 1 w 138
a 9 w 139
general 2 w 146
truth 2 w 151
I 1 w 152
mean 1 w 156
the 1 w 159
sort 1 w 163
of 1 w 165
thing 2 w 170
that 1 w 174
a 13 w 175
certain 1 w 182
type 1 w 186
of 2 w 188
man 1 w 191
will 1 w 195
do 1 w 197
or 6 w 199
say 1 w 202
either 1 w 208
probably 1 w 216
or 7 w 218
necessarily 1 w 229
That 1 w 234
is 5 w 236
what 1 w 240
poetry 3 w 246
aims 1 w 250
at 4 w 252
in 4 w 254
giving 1 w 260
names 1 w 265
to 4 w 267
the 3 w 270
characters 1 w 280
The 1 w 284
names 2 w 289
indicate 1 w 297
types 1 w 302
This 1 w 307
is 7 w 309
obvious 1 w 316
as 2 w 319
he 5 w 321
says 1 w 325
in 7 w 328
Comedy 1 w 334
and 2 w 337
is 8 w 339
also 1 w 343
true 1 w 347
of 3 w 349
Greek 1 w 354
Tragedy 1 w 361
which 1 w 367
although 1 w 376
it 2 w 378
deals 1 w 383
with 1 w 387
traditional 1 w 398
heroes 1 w 404
regarded 1 w 412
as 3 w 414
real 1 w 418
people 1 w 424
yet 1 w 428
keeps 1 w 433
to 5 w 435
a 40 w 436
few 1 w 439
stories 1 w 446
in 8 w 448
which 2 w 453
each 1 w 457
character 2 w 466
has 1 w 469
become 1 w 475
a 45 w 476
type 3 w 480
In 1 w 483
Chapter 1 w 490
17 1 w 492
the 4 w 496
dramatist 1 w 505
is 10 w 507
recommended 1 w 518
to 7 w 520
sketch 1 w 526
first 1 w 531
his 5 w 534
outline 1 w 541
plot 1 w 545
making 1 w 552
it 5 w 554
clear 1 w 559
and 3 w 562
coherent 1 w 570
before 1 w 577
he 9 w 579
puts 1 w 583
in 11 w 585
the 5 w 588
names 3 w 593
A 1 w 595
particular 2 w 605
fact 2 w 609
is 12 w 611
what 2 w 615
Alcibiades 1 w 625
did 1 w 628
or 10 w 630
what 3 w 634
was 1 w 637
done 1 w 641
to 8 w 643
him 1 w 646
In 2 w 649
the 6 w 652
case 1 w 656
of 4 w 658
comedy 1 w 664
this 2 w 668
has 2 w 671
now 1 w 674
become 2 w 680
obvious 2 w 687
for 2 w 691
comedians 1 w 700
construct 1 w 709
their 1 w 714
plots 1 w 719
out 2 w 722
of 5 w 724
probable 1 w 732
incidents 1 w 741
and 4 w 744
then 1 w 748
put 2 w 751
in 13 w 753
any 1 w 756
names 4 w 761
that 2 w 765
occur 1 w 770
to 9 w 772
them 1 w 776
They 1 w 781
do 3 w 783
not 1 w 786
like 1 w 791
the 10 w 794
iambic 1 w 800
satirists 1 w 809
write 1 w 815
about 1 w 820
individuals 1 w 831
Aristophanes 1 w 844
of 6 w 846
course 1 w 852
did 2 w 855
write 2 w 860
about 2 w 865
individuals 2 w 876
But 1 w 880
Aristotle 1 w 889
is 17 w 891
thinking 1 w 899
of 7 w 901
the 11 w 904
New 1 w 907
Comedy 2 w 913
where 1 w 919
the 12 w 922
names 5 w 927
of 8 w 929
the 13 w 932
characters 2 w 942
were 1 w 946
invented 1 w 954
by 1 w 956
the 14 w 959
author 1 w 965
and 5 w 968
there 1 w 973
was 2 w 976
no 3 w 978
reference 1 w 987
to 12 w 989
real 2 w 993
people 2 w 999
In 3 w 1002
tragedy 1 w 1009
on 5 w 1012
the 16 w 1015
other 1 w 1020
hand 1 w 1024
they 1 w 1029
keep 2 w 1033
to 13 w 1035
real 3 w 1039
names 6 w 1044
The 3 w 1048
reason 2 w 1054
is 18 w 1056
that 3 w 1060
what 4 w 1064
is 19 w 1066
possible 1 w 1074
carries 1 w 1081
conviction 1 w 1091
If 1 w 1094
a 90 w 1095
thing 3 w 1100
has 3 w 1103
not 2 w 1106
happened 1 w 1114
we 2 w 1117
do 4 w 1119
not 3 w 1122
yet 2 w 1125
believe 1 w 1132
in 20 w 1134
its 1 w 1137
possibility 1 w 1148
but 1 w 1152
what 5 w 1156
has 4 w 1159
happened 2 w 1167
is 20 w 1169
obviously 1 w 1178
possible 2 w 1186
Had 1 w 1190
it 10 w 1192
been 1 w 1196
impossible 1 w 1206
it 11 w 1209
would 1 w 1214
not 4 w 1217
have 1 w 1221
happened 3 w 1229
It 1 w 1232
is 21 w 1234
true 2 w 1238
that 4 w 1242
in 21 w 1244
some 2 w 1248
tragedies 1 w 1257
one 2 w 1260
or 13 w 1262
two 1 w 1265
of 9 w 1267
the 19 w 1270
names 7 w 1275
are 1 w 1278
familiar 1 w 1286
and 7 w 1289
the 20 w 1292
rest 1 w 1296
invented 2 w 1304
indeed 1 w 1311
in 24 w 1313
some 3 w 1317
they 2 w 1321
are 2 w 1324
all 1 w 1327
invented 3 w 1335
as 12 w 1338
for 3 w 1341
instance 1 w 1349
in 27 w 1351
Agathon 1 w 1358
s 98 w 1360
Antheus 1 w 1367
The 4 w 1371
name 8 w 1375
apparently 1 w 1386
of 10 w 1389
an 15 w 1391
imaginary 1 w 1400
hero 2 w 1404
The 5 w 1408
word 1 w 1412
might 1 w 1417
be 7 w 1419
Ἄνθος 1 w 1424
but 2 w 1428
The 6 w 1431
Flower 1 w 1437
is 22 w 1439
an 16 w 1441
unlikely 1 w 1449
title 1 w 1454
for 4 w 1457
a 118 w 1458
Greek 2 w 1463
tragedy 2 w 1470
where 2 w 1476
both 1 w 1480
the 23 w 1483
incidents 2 w 1492
and 8 w 1495
the 24 w 1498
names 8 w 1503
are 4 w 1506
invented 4 w 1514
and 9 w 1517
yet 3 w 1520
it 13 w 1522
is 23 w 1524
none 1 w 1528
the 25 w 1531
less 1 w 1535
a 124 w 1536
favourite 1 w 1545