Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Poetics

Poetics (8.2-9.2)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0086.tlg034.perseus-eng2:8.2-9.2
Refs {'start': {'reference': '8.2', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 8 Subchapter 2'}, 'end': {'reference': '9.2', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 9 Subchapter 2'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '8'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

20
It seems therefore that all those poets are wrong who have written a Heracleid or Theseid or other such poems.[*] They think that because Heracles was a single individual the plot must for that reason have unity.

But Homer, supreme also in all other respects, was apparently well aware of this truth either by instinct or from knowledge of his art. For in writing an Odyssey he did not put in all that ever happened to Odysseus, his being wounded on Parnassus, for instance, or his feigned madness when the host was gathered(these being events neither of which necessarily or probably led to the other), but he constructed his Odyssey round a single action in our sense of the phrase. And the Iliad the same.

As then in the other arts of representation a single representation means a representation of a single object, so too the plot being a representation of a piece of action must represent a single piece of action and the whole of it; and the component incidents must be so arranged that if one of them be transposed or removed, the unity of the whole is dislocated and destroyed. For if the presence or absence of a thing makes no visible difference, then it is not an integral part of the whole.

What we have said already makes it further clear that a poets object is not to tell what actually happened but what could and would happen either probably or inevitably.

The difference between a historian and a poet is not that one writes in prose and the other in verse

1451b
1
indeed the writings of Herodotus could be put into verse and yet would still be a kind of history, whether written in metre or not. The real difference is this, that one tells what happened and the other what might happen.

Tokens

It 1 w 2
seems 1 w 7
therefore 1 w 16
that 1 w 20
all 1 w 23
those 1 w 28
poets 1 w 33
are 1 w 36
wrong 1 w 41
who 1 w 44
have 1 w 48
written 1 w 55
a 5 w 56
Heracleid 1 w 65
or 2 w 67
Theseid 1 w 74
or 3 w 76
other 1 w 81
such 1 w 85
poems 1 w 90
Aristotle 1 w 100
condemns 1 w 108
them 1 w 112
all 2 w 115
assuming 1 w 124
or 4 w 127
perhaps 1 w 134
assured 1 w 141
by 1 w 143
experience 1 w 153
that 2 w 158
their 1 w 163
sole 1 w 167
claim 1 w 172
to 2 w 174
unity 1 w 179
lay 1 w 182
in 2 w 184
the 5 w 187
fact 1 w 191
that 3 w 195
all 3 w 198
the 6 w 201
stories 1 w 208
in 3 w 210
the 7 w 213
poem 2 w 217
had 1 w 220
a 18 w 221
common 1 w 227
hero 1 w 231
They 1 w 236
think 1 w 241
that 4 w 245
because 1 w 252
Heracles 1 w 260
was 1 w 263
a 23 w 264
single 1 w 270
individual 1 w 280
the 8 w 283
plot 1 w 287
must 1 w 291
for 2 w 294
that 5 w 298
reason 1 w 304
have 2 w 308
unity 2 w 313
But 1 w 317
Homer 1 w 322
supreme 1 w 330
also 1 w 334
in 7 w 336
all 4 w 339
other 2 w 344
respects 1 w 352
was 2 w 356
apparently 1 w 366
well 1 w 370
aware 1 w 375
of 1 w 377
this 1 w 381
truth 1 w 386
either 1 w 392
by 2 w 394
instinct 1 w 402
or 7 w 404
from 1 w 408
knowledge 1 w 417
of 2 w 419
his 2 w 422
art 1 w 425
For 1 w 429
in 10 w 431
writing 1 w 438
an 1 w 440
Odyssey 1 w 447
he 14 w 449
did 1 w 452
not 1 w 455
put 1 w 458
in 12 w 460
all 5 w 463
that 6 w 467
ever 1 w 471
happened 1 w 479
to 4 w 481
Odysseus 1 w 489
his 3 w 493
being 1 w 498
wounded 1 w 505
on 5 w 507
Parnassus 1 w 516
for 3 w 520
instance 1 w 528
or 10 w 531
his 4 w 534
feigned 1 w 541
madness 1 w 548
when 1 w 552
the 11 w 555
host 1 w 559
was 3 w 562
gathered 1 w 570
these 1 w 576
being 2 w 581
events 1 w 587
neither 1 w 594
of 3 w 596
which 1 w 601
necessarily 1 w 612
or 11 w 614
probably 1 w 622
led 2 w 625
to 5 w 627
the 15 w 630
other 3 w 635
but 1 w 640
he 22 w 642
constructed 1 w 653
his 5 w 656
Odyssey 2 w 663
round 1 w 668
a 48 w 669
single 2 w 675
action 1 w 681
in 17 w 683
our 1 w 686
sense 1 w 691
of 4 w 693
the 17 w 696
phrase 1 w 702
And 1 w 706
the 18 w 709
Iliad 1 w 714
the 19 w 717
same 1 w 721
As 1 w 724
then 1 w 728
in 18 w 730
the 21 w 733
other 4 w 738
arts 1 w 742
of 5 w 744
representation 1 w 758
a 55 w 759
single 3 w 765
representation 2 w 779
means 1 w 784
a 58 w 785
representation 3 w 799
of 6 w 801
a 60 w 802
single 4 w 808
object 1 w 814
so 4 w 817
too 1 w 820
the 23 w 823
plot 2 w 827
being 3 w 832
a 61 w 833
representation 4 w 847
of 7 w 849
a 63 w 850
piece 1 w 855
of 8 w 857
action 2 w 863
must 2 w 867
represent 5 w 876
a 65 w 877
single 5 w 883
piece 2 w 888
of 9 w 890
action 3 w 896
and 1 w 899
the 24 w 902
whole 1 w 907
of 10 w 909
it 7 w 911
and 2 w 915
the 25 w 918
component 1 w 927
incidents 1 w 936
must 3 w 940
be 5 w 942
so 5 w 944
arranged 1 w 952
that 7 w 956
if 1 w 958
one 2 w 961
of 11 w 963
them 2 w 967
be 6 w 969
transposed 1 w 979
or 12 w 981
removed 1 w 988
the 27 w 992
unity 3 w 997
of 12 w 999
the 28 w 1002
whole 2 w 1007
is 7 w 1009
dislocated 1 w 1019
and 3 w 1022
destroyed 1 w 1031
For 2 w 1035
if 2 w 1037
the 29 w 1040
presence 1 w 1048
or 14 w 1050
absence 1 w 1057
of 13 w 1059
a 76 w 1060
thing 1 w 1065
makes 1 w 1070
no 3 w 1072
visible 1 w 1079
difference 1 w 1089
then 2 w 1094
it 9 w 1096
is 10 w 1098
not 2 w 1101
an 9 w 1103
integral 1 w 1111
part 1 w 1115
of 14 w 1117
the 31 w 1120
whole 3 w 1125
What 1 w 1130
we 2 w 1132
have 3 w 1136
said 1 w 1140
already 1 w 1147
makes 2 w 1152
it 10 w 1154
further 1 w 1161
clear 1 w 1166
that 8 w 1170
a 89 w 1171
poet 2 w 1175
s 88 w 1177
object 2 w 1183
is 11 w 1185
not 3 w 1188
to 7 w 1190
tell 1 w 1194
what 1 w 1198
actually 1 w 1206
happened 2 w 1214
but 2 w 1217
what 2 w 1221
could 1 w 1226
and 4 w 1229
would 1 w 1234
happen 3 w 1240
either 3 w 1246
probably 2 w 1254
or 15 w 1256
inevitably 1 w 1266
The 3 w 1270
difference 2 w 1280
between 1 w 1287
a 99 w 1288
historian 1 w 1297
and 5 w 1300
a 102 w 1301
poet 3 w 1305
is 13 w 1307
not 4 w 1310
that 9 w 1314
one 3 w 1317
writes 1 w 1323
in 27 w 1325
prose 1 w 1330
and 6 w 1333
the 34 w 1336
other 5 w 1341
in 28 w 1343
verse 1 w 1348
indeed 1 w 1355
the 36 w 1358
writings 1 w 1366
of 15 w 1368
Herodotus 1 w 1377
could 2 w 1382
be 8 w 1384
put 2 w 1387
into 1 w 1391
verse 2 w 1396
and 7 w 1399
yet 1 w 1402
would 2 w 1407
still 1 w 1412
be 9 w 1414
a 106 w 1415
kind 1 w 1419
of 16 w 1421
history 1 w 1428
whether 1 w 1436
written 2 w 1443
in 33 w 1445
metre 1 w 1450
or 18 w 1452
not 5 w 1455
The 4 w 1459
real 1 w 1463
difference 3 w 1473
is 15 w 1475
this 2 w 1479
that 10 w 1484
one 4 w 1487
tells 1 w 1492
what 3 w 1496
happened 3 w 1504
and 8 w 1507
the 38 w 1510
other 6 w 1515
what 4 w 1519
might 1 w 1524
happen 5 w 1530