Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Poetics

Poetics (3.5-4.3)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0086.tlg034.perseus-eng2:3.5-4.3
Refs {'start': {'reference': '3.5', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 3 Subchapter 5'}, 'end': {'reference': '4.3', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 4 Subchapter 3'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '3'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

And for this reason the Dorians claim as their own both tragedy and comedycomedy is claimed both by the Megarians here in Greece, who say that it originated in the days of their democracy, and by the Megarians in Sicily,[*] for it was from there the poet Epicharmus[*] came, who was much earlier than Chionides and Magnes; and tragedy some of the Peloponnesians claim. Their evidence is the two names.

Their name, they say, for suburb villages is κῶμαιthe Athenians call them Demesand comedians are so called not from κωμάζειν, to revel, but because they were turned out of the towns and went strolling round the villages( κῶμαι).

1448b
1
Their word for action, they add, is δρᾶν, whereas the Athenian word is πράττειν. So much then for the differences, their number, and their nature.

Speaking generally, poetry seems to owe its origin to two particular causes, both natural.

From childhood men have an instinct for representation, and in this respect, differs from the other animals that he is far more imitative and learns his first lessons by representing things. And then there is the enjoyment people always get from representations.

What happens in actual experience proves this, for we enjoy looking at accurate likenesses of things which are themselves painful to see, obscene beasts, for instance, and corpses.

Tokens

And 1 w 3
for 1 w 6
this 1 w 10
reason 1 w 16
the 1 w 19
Dorians 1 w 26
claim 1 w 31
as 2 w 33
their 1 w 38
own 1 w 41
both 1 w 45
tragedy 1 w 52
and 1 w 55
comedy 1 w 61
comedy 2 w 68
is 2 w 70
claimed 1 w 77
both 2 w 81
by 1 w 83
the 3 w 86
Megarians 1 w 95
here 1 w 99
in 1 w 101
Greece 1 w 107
who 1 w 111
say 1 w 114
that 1 w 118
it 1 w 120
originated 1 w 130
in 3 w 132
the 4 w 135
days 1 w 139
of 1 w 141
their 2 w 146
democracy 1 w 155
and 2 w 159
by 2 w 161
the 6 w 164
Megarians 2 w 173
in 4 w 175
Sicily 1 w 181
The 1 w 185
inhabitants 1 w 196
of 2 w 198
Megara 1 w 204
Hyblaea 1 w 211
for 2 w 215
it 3 w 217
was 1 w 220
from 1 w 224
there 1 w 229
the 8 w 232
poet 1 w 236
Epicharmus 1 w 246
Epicharmus 2 w 256
of 3 w 258
Cos 1 w 261
wrote 1 w 266
in 6 w 268
Sicily 2 w 274
burlesques 1 w 284
and 3 w 287
mimes 1 w 292
depicting 1 w 301
scenes 1 w 307
of 4 w 309
daily 1 w 314
life 1 w 318
He 1 w 321
and 4 w 324
Phormis 1 w 331
were 1 w 335
originators 1 w 346
of 5 w 348
comedy 3 w 354
in 9 w 356
that 2 w 360
they 1 w 364
sketched 1 w 372
types 1 w 377
instead 1 w 384
of 6 w 386
lampooning 1 w 396
individuals 1 w 407
cf 1 w 410
Aristot 1 w 418
Poet 1 w 423
5 1 w 425
5 2 w 427
of 7 w 431
Chionides 1 w 440
and 5 w 443
Magnes 1 w 449
we 2 w 451
only 1 w 455
know 1 w 459
that 3 w 463
they 2 w 467
were 2 w 471
early 1 w 476
comedians 1 w 485
i 44 w 487
e 54 w 489
in 13 w 493
the 11 w 496
first 1 w 501
half 1 w 505
of 8 w 507
the 12 w 510
fifth 1 w 515
century 1 w 522
B 1 w 523
C 3 w 525
came 1 w 530
who 2 w 534
was 2 w 537
much 1 w 541
earlier 1 w 548
than 1 w 552
Chionides 2 w 561
and 6 w 564
Magnes 2 w 570
and 7 w 574
tragedy 2 w 581
some 1 w 585
of 9 w 587
the 13 w 590
Peloponnesians 1 w 604
claim 3 w 609
Their 1 w 615
evidence 1 w 623
is 5 w 625
the 14 w 628
two 1 w 631
names 1 w 636
Their 2 w 642
name 2 w 646
they 3 w 651
say 2 w 654
for 3 w 658
suburb 1 w 664
villages 1 w 672
is 6 w 674
κῶμαι 1 w 679
the 16 w 683
Athenians 1 w 692
call 1 w 696
them 1 w 700
Demes 1 w 705
and 8 w 709
comedians 2 w 718
are 1 w 721
so 3 w 723
called 1 w 729
not 1 w 732
from 2 w 736
κωμάζειν 1 w 744
to 3 w 747
revel 1 w 752
but 1 w 756
because 1 w 763
they 4 w 767
were 3 w 771
turned 1 w 777
out 1 w 780
of 10 w 782
the 20 w 785
towns 1 w 790
and 9 w 793
went 1 w 797
strolling 1 w 806
round 1 w 811
the 21 w 814
villages 2 w 822
κῶμαι 2 w 828
Their 3 w 835
word 1 w 839
for 4 w 842
action 1 w 848
they 5 w 853
add 1 w 856
is 7 w 859
δρᾶν 1 w 863
whereas 1 w 871
the 23 w 874
Athenian 2 w 882
word 2 w 886
is 8 w 888
πράττειν 1 w 896
So 1 w 899
much 2 w 903
then 3 w 907
for 5 w 910
the 26 w 913
differences 1 w 924
their 3 w 930
number 1 w 936
and 10 w 940
their 4 w 945
nature 1 w 951
Speaking 1 w 960
generally 1 w 969
poetry 1 w 976
seems 1 w 981
to 5 w 983
owe 1 w 986
its 1 w 989
origin 3 w 995
to 6 w 997
two 2 w 1000
particular 1 w 1010
causes 1 w 1016
both 3 w 1021
natural 1 w 1028
From 1 w 1033
childhood 1 w 1042
men 1 w 1045
have 1 w 1049
an 21 w 1051
instinct 1 w 1059
for 6 w 1062
representation 1 w 1076
and 11 w 1080
in 19 w 1082
this 2 w 1086
respect 1 w 1093
differs 1 w 1101
from 3 w 1105
the 29 w 1108
other 1 w 1113
animals 1 w 1120
that 4 w 1124
he 38 w 1126
is 10 w 1128
far 1 w 1131
more 1 w 1135
imitative 1 w 1144
and 12 w 1147
learns 1 w 1153
his 3 w 1156
first 2 w 1161
lessons 1 w 1168
by 3 w 1170
representing 1 w 1182
things 1 w 1188
And 2 w 1192
then 4 w 1196
there 2 w 1201
is 12 w 1203
the 33 w 1206
enjoyment 1 w 1215
people 1 w 1221
always 1 w 1227
get 1 w 1230
from 4 w 1234
representations 1 w 1249
What 1 w 1254
happens 1 w 1261
in 22 w 1263
actual 1 w 1269
experience 1 w 1279
proves 1 w 1285
this 3 w 1289
for 7 w 1293
we 7 w 1295
enjoy 2 w 1300
looking 1 w 1307
at 13 w 1309
accurate 1 w 1317
likenesses 1 w 1327
of 11 w 1329
things 2 w 1335
which 1 w 1340
are 2 w 1343
themselves 1 w 1353
painful 1 w 1360
to 7 w 1362
see 2 w 1365
obscene 1 w 1373
beasts 1 w 1379
for 8 w 1383
instance 1 w 1391
and 13 w 1395
corpses 1 w 1402