Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The Dependent Scholar

The Dependent Scholar (5-6)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0062.tlg033.perseus-eng4:5-6
Refs {'start': {'reference': '5', 'human_reference': 'Section 5'}, 'end': {'reference': '6', 'human_reference': 'Section 6'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

But the case of educated men, such as I have mentioned above, is another matter; it calls for our indignation, and for our utmost endeavours to restore them to liberty. I think it will not be amiss, if I first examine into the provocations under which they turn to a life of dependence. By showing how trivial, how inadequate these provocations are, I shall forestall the main argument used by the defenders of voluntary servitude, Most of them are content to cloak their desertion under the names of Poverty and Necessity. It is enough, they think, to plead in extenuation, that they sought to flee from this greatest of human ills, Poverty. Theognis comes pat to their purpose. His

Poverty, soul-subduing Poverty,
is in continual requisition, together with other fearful utterances of our most degenerate poets to the same effect. Now if I could see that they really found an escape from poverty in the lives they lead, I would not be too nice on the point of absolute freedom. But when we find them (to use the expression of a famous orator) faring like men that are sick,’ what conclusion is then left to us to draw? What but this, that here again they have been misled, the very evil which they sold their liberty to escape remaining as it was? Poverty unending is their lot. From the bare pittance they receive nothing can be set apart. Suppose it paid, and paid in full: the whole sum is swallowed up to the last farthing, before their necessities are supplied. I would advise them to think upon better expedients;
v.2.p.5
not such as are merely the protectors and accomplices of Poverty, but such as will make an end of her altogether. _ What say you, Theognis? Might this be a case for,
Steep plunge from crags into the teeming deep?
For when a pauper, a needy hireling, persuades himself that by being what he is he has escaped poverty, one cannot avoid the conclusion that he labours under some mistake.

Others tell a different tale. For them, mere poverty would have had no terrors, had they been able, like other men, to earn their bread by their labours. But, stricken as they were by age or infirmity, they turned to this as the easiest way of making a living. Now let us consider whether they are right. This easy way may be found to involve much labour before it yields any return; more labour perhaps than any other. To find money ready to ones hand, without toil or trouble on ones own part, would indeed be a dream of happiness. But the facts are otherwise. The toils and troubles of their situation are such as no words can adequately describe. Health, as it turns out, is nowhere more essential than in this vocation, in which a thousand daily labours combine to grind the victim down» and reduce him to utter exhaustion. These I shall describe in due course, when I come to speak of their other grievances. For the present let it suffice to have shown that this excuse for the sale of ones liberty is as untenable as the former.

Tokens

But 1 w 3
the 1 w 6
case 1 w 10
of 1 w 12
educated 1 w 20
men 1 w 23
such 1 w 28
as 2 w 30
I 1 w 31
have 1 w 35
mentioned 1 w 44
above 1 w 49
is 1 w 52
another 1 w 59
matter 1 w 65
it 1 w 68
calls 1 w 73
for 1 w 76
our 1 w 79
indignation 1 w 90
and 1 w 94
for 2 w 97
our 2 w 100
utmost 1 w 106
endeavours 1 w 116
to 1 w 118
restore 1 w 125
them 1 w 129
to 3 w 131
liberty 1 w 138
I 2 w 140
think 1 w 145
it 2 w 147
will 1 w 151
not 2 w 154
be 2 w 156
amiss 1 w 161
if 1 w 164
I 3 w 165
first 1 w 170
examine 1 w 177
into 1 w 181
the 4 w 184
provocations 1 w 196
under 1 w 201
which 1 w 206
they 1 w 210
turn 1 w 214
to 5 w 216
a 15 w 217
life 1 w 221
of 2 w 223
dependence 1 w 233
By 1 w 236
showing 1 w 243
how 2 w 246
trivial 1 w 253
how 3 w 257
inadequate 1 w 267
these 1 w 272
provocations 2 w 284
are 1 w 287
I 4 w 289
shall 1 w 294
forestall 1 w 303
the 7 w 306
main 1 w 310
argument 1 w 318
used 1 w 322
by 1 w 324
the 8 w 327
defenders 1 w 336
of 3 w 338
voluntary 1 w 347
servitude 1 w 356
Most 1 w 361
of 4 w 363
them 2 w 367
are 2 w 370
content 1 w 377
to 6 w 379
cloak 1 w 384
their 1 w 389
desertion 1 w 398
under 2 w 403
the 11 w 406
names 1 w 411
of 5 w 413
Poverty 1 w 420
and 2 w 423
Necessity 1 w 432
It 1 w 435
is 3 w 437
enough 1 w 443
they 2 w 448
think 2 w 453
to 7 w 456
plead 1 w 461
in 9 w 463
extenuation 1 w 474
that 1 w 479
they 3 w 483
sought 1 w 489
to 8 w 491
flee 1 w 495
from 1 w 499
this 1 w 503
greatest 1 w 511
of 6 w 513
human 1 w 518
ills 1 w 522
Poverty 2 w 530
Theognis 1 w 539
comes 1 w 544
pat 1 w 547
to 9 w 549
their 2 w 554
purpose 1 w 561
His 1 w 565
Poverty 3 w 572
soul-subduing 1 w 586
Poverty 4 w 593
is 7 w 596
in 11 w 598
continual 1 w 607
requisition 1 w 618
together 1 w 627
with 1 w 631
other 2 w 636
fearful 1 w 643
utterances 1 w 653
of 7 w 655
our 4 w 658
most 2 w 662
degenerate 1 w 672
poets 1 w 677
to 11 w 679
the 17 w 682
same 1 w 686
effect 1 w 692
Now 1 w 696
if 3 w 698
I 6 w 699
could 1 w 704
see 1 w 707
that 2 w 711
they 4 w 715
really 1 w 721
found 1 w 726
an 6 w 728
escape 1 w 734
from 2 w 738
poverty 1 w 745
in 13 w 747
the 19 w 750
lives 1 w 755
they 5 w 759
lead 2 w 763
I 7 w 765
would 1 w 770
not 3 w 773
be 3 w 775
too 1 w 778
nice 1 w 782
on 10 w 784
the 21 w 787
point 1 w 792
of 8 w 794
absolute 1 w 802
freedom 1 w 809
But 2 w 813
when 1 w 817
we 1 w 819
find 1 w 823
them 3 w 827
to 13 w 830
use 2 w 833
the 23 w 836
expression 1 w 846
of 9 w 848
a 47 w 849
famous 1 w 855
orator 1 w 861
faring 1 w 869
like 1 w 873
men 4 w 876
that 3 w 880
are 3 w 883
sick 1 w 887
what 1 w 893
conclusion 1 w 903
is 9 w 905
then 1 w 909
left 1 w 913
to 15 w 915
us 5 w 917
to 16 w 919
draw 1 w 923
What 1 w 928
but 1 w 931
this 2 w 935
that 4 w 940
here 1 w 944
again 1 w 949
they 6 w 953
have 2 w 957
been 1 w 961
misled 1 w 967
the 26 w 971
very 1 w 975
evil 1 w 979
which 2 w 984
they 7 w 988
sold 1 w 992
their 3 w 997
liberty 2 w 1004
to 17 w 1006
escape 2 w 1012
remaining 1 w 1021
as 3 w 1023
it 7 w 1025
was 1 w 1028
Poverty 5 w 1036
unending 1 w 1044
is 12 w 1046
their 4 w 1051
lot 1 w 1054
From 1 w 1059
the 30 w 1062
bare 1 w 1066
pittance 1 w 1074
they 8 w 1078
receive 1 w 1085
nothing 1 w 1092
can 1 w 1095
be 6 w 1097
set 1 w 1100
apart 1 w 1105
Suppose 1 w 1113
it 9 w 1115
paid 1 w 1119
and 3 w 1123
paid 2 w 1127
in 22 w 1129
full 1 w 1133
the 32 w 1137
whole 1 w 1142
sum 1 w 1145
is 13 w 1147
swallowed 1 w 1156
up 2 w 1158
to 18 w 1160
the 33 w 1163
last 1 w 1167
farthing 1 w 1175
before 1 w 1182
their 5 w 1187
necessities 1 w 1198
are 5 w 1201
supplied 1 w 1209
I 8 w 1211
would 2 w 1216
advise 1 w 1222
them 4 w 1226
to 19 w 1228
think 3 w 1233
upon 1 w 1237
better 1 w 1243
expedients 1 w 1253
not 5 w 1257
such 2 w 1261
as 6 w 1263
are 6 w 1266
merely 1 w 1272
the 36 w 1275
protectors 1 w 1285
and 4 w 1288
accomplices 1 w 1299
of 10 w 1301
Poverty 6 w 1308
but 2 w 1312
such 3 w 1316
as 7 w 1318
will 2 w 1322
make 1 w 1326
an 11 w 1328
end 5 w 1331
of 11 w 1333
her 5 w 1336
altogether 1 w 1346
What 2 w 1353
say 1 w 1356
you 1 w 1359
Theognis 2 w 1368
Might 1 w 1374
this 3 w 1378
be 9 w 1380
a 87 w 1381
case 2 w 1385
for 5 w 1388
Steep 1 w 1394
plunge 1 w 1400
from 3 w 1404
crags 1 w 1409
into 2 w 1413
the 38 w 1416
teeming 1 w 1423
deep 1 w 1427
For 1 w 1431
when 2 w 1435
a 90 w 1436
pauper 1 w 1442
a 92 w 1444
needy 1 w 1449
hireling 1 w 1457
persuades 1 w 1467
himself 1 w 1474
that 5 w 1478
by 2 w 1480
being 1 w 1485
what 2 w 1489
he 45 w 1491
is 17 w 1493
he 46 w 1495
has 1 w 1498
escaped 1 w 1505
poverty 2 w 1512
one 2 w 1516
cannot 1 w 1522
avoid 1 w 1527
the 39 w 1530
conclusion 2 w 1540
that 6 w 1544
he 48 w 1546
labours 1 w 1553
under 3 w 1558
some 1 w 1562
mistake 1 w 1569
Others 1 w 1576
tell 1 w 1580
a 103 w 1581
different 1 w 1590
tale 1 w 1594
For 2 w 1598
them 5 w 1602
mere 2 w 1607
poverty 3 w 1614
would 3 w 1619
have 3 w 1623
had 1 w 1626
no 8 w 1628
terrors 1 w 1635
had 2 w 1639
they 9 w 1643
been 2 w 1647
able 1 w 1651
like 2 w 1656
other 3 w 1661
men 5 w 1664
to 23 w 1667
earn 1 w 1671
their 6 w 1676
bread 1 w 1681
by 3 w 1683
their 7 w 1688
labours 2 w 1695
But 3 w 1699
stricken 1 w 1708
as 10 w 1710
they 10 w 1714
were 1 w 1718
by 4 w 1720
age 1 w 1723
or 13 w 1725
infirmity 1 w 1734
they 11 w 1739
turned 1 w 1745
to 24 w 1747
this 4 w 1751
as 11 w 1753
the 48 w 1756
easiest 1 w 1763
way 1 w 1766
of 12 w 1768
making 1 w 1774
a 118 w 1775
living 1 w 1781
Now 2 w 1785
let 1 w 1788
us 7 w 1790
consider 1 w 1798
whether 1 w 1805
they 12 w 1809
are 7 w 1812
right 1 w 1817
This 1 w 1822
easy 1 w 1827
way 2 w 1831
may 1 w 1834
be 12 w 1836
found 2 w 1841
to 25 w 1843
involve 1 w 1850
much 1 w 1854
labour 3 w 1860
before 2 w 1866
it 12 w 1868
yields 1 w 1874
any 1 w 1877
return 1 w 1883
more 1 w 1888
labour 4 w 1894
perhaps 1 w 1901
than 1 w 1905
any 2 w 1908
other 4 w 1913
To 1 w 1916
find 2 w 1920
money 1 w 1925
ready 1 w 1930
to 26 w 1932
one 4 w 1935
s 110 w 1937
hand 1 w 1941
without 1 w 1949
toil 1 w 1953
or 16 w 1955
trouble 1 w 1962
on 21 w 1964
one 5 w 1967
s 111 w 1969
own 1 w 1972
part 2 w 1976
would 4 w 1982
indeed 1 w 1988
be 14 w 1990
a 132 w 1991
dream 1 w 1996
of 13 w 1998
happiness 1 w 2007
But 4 w 2011
the 52 w 2014
facts 1 w 2019
are 8 w 2022
otherwise 1 w 2031
The 3 w 2035
toils 1 w 2040
and 6 w 2043
troubles 1 w 2051
of 14 w 2053
their 8 w 2058
situation 1 w 2067
are 9 w 2070
such 4 w 2074
as 14 w 2076
no 9 w 2078
words 1 w 2083
can 3 w 2086
adequately 1 w 2096
describe 1 w 2104
Health 1 w 2111
as 15 w 2114
it 15 w 2116
turns 1 w 2121
out 2 w 2124
is 22 w 2127
nowhere 1 w 2134
more 2 w 2138
essential 1 w 2147
than 2 w 2151
in 36 w 2153
this 5 w 2157
vocation 3 w 2165
in 37 w 2168
which 3 w 2173
a 149 w 2174
thousand 1 w 2182
daily 1 w 2187
labours 3 w 2194
combine 1 w 2201
to 29 w 2203
grind 1 w 2208
the 55 w 2211
victim 1 w 2217
down 1 w 2221
and 8 w 2225
reduce 1 w 2231
him 2 w 2234
to 30 w 2236
utter 2 w 2241
exhaustion 1 w 2251
These 1 w 2257
I 9 w 2258
shall 2 w 2263
describe 2 w 2271
in 40 w 2273
due 1 w 2276
course 1 w 2282
when 3 w 2287
I 10 w 2288
come 2 w 2292
to 31 w 2294
speak 1 w 2299
of 15 w 2301
their 9 w 2306
other 6 w 2311
grievances 1 w 2321
For 3 w 2325
the 58 w 2328
present 1 w 2335
let 2 w 2338
it 16 w 2340
suffice 1 w 2347
to 32 w 2349
have 4 w 2353
shown 1 w 2358
that 7 w 2362
this 6 w 2366
excuse 1 w 2372
for 7 w 2375
the 59 w 2378
sale 1 w 2382
of 16 w 2384
one 6 w 2387
s 144 w 2389
liberty 3 w 2396
is 25 w 2398
as 16 w 2400
untenable 1 w 2409
as 17 w 2411
the 60 w 2414
former 1 w 2420