Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The Fisher

The Fisher (41-45)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0062.tlg025.perseus-eng4:41-45
Refs {'start': {'reference': '41', 'human_reference': 'Section 41'}, 'end': {'reference': '45', 'human_reference': 'Section 45'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
Parrhesiades

Quite a simple matter. Oyez, oyez! All who profess philosophy and hold themselves entitled to the name of philosopher shall appear on the Acropolis for largesse; 8, with a sesame cake, to each. A long beard shall qualify for a square of compressed figs, in addition. Every applicant to have with him, of temperance, justice, and self-control, any __ that he is in possession of, it being clearly understood that these are not indispensable, and, of syllogisms, a complete set of five, these being the condition precedent of wisdom.

Two golden talents in the midst are set,
His prize who wrangles best amongst his peers.

Parrhesiades

Just look! the ascent packed with a pushing crowd, at the very first sound of my 8. More of them along the Pelasgicum, more by the temple of Asclepius, a bigger crowd still over the Areopagus. Why, positively there are a few at the tomb of Talos; and see those putting ladders against the temple of Castor and Pollux; up they climb, buzzing and clustering like

v.1.p.225
a swarm of bees. In Homeric phrase, on this side are exceeding many, and on that
Ten thousand, thick as leaves and flowers in spring.
Noisily they settle, the Acropolis is covered with them in a trice; everywhere wallet and beard, flattery and effrontery, staves and greed, logic and avarice. The little company which came up at the first proclamation is swamped beyond recovery, swallowed up in these later crowds; it is hopeless to find them, because of the external resemblance. That is the worst of it, Philosophy; you are really open to censure for not marking and labelling them; these impostors are often more convincing than the true philosophers.

Philosophy

It shall be done before long; at present let us receive them.

Platonists

Platonists first!

Pythagoreans

No, no; Pythagoreans first; our master is senior.

Stoics

Rubbish! the Porch is the best.

Peripatetics

Now, now, this is a question of money; Peripatetics first there!

Epicureans

Hand over those cakes and fig-squares; as to the money, Epicureans will not mind waiting till the last.

Academics

Where are the two talents? none can touch the Academy at a wrangle; we will soon show you that.

Stoics

Not if we know it.

Philosophy

Cease your strife. Cynics there, no more pushing! and keep those sticks quiet. You have mistaken the nature of this summons. We three, Philosophy, Virtue, and Truth, are about to decide which are the true philosophers; that done, those whose lives are found to be in accord with our pleasure will be made happy by our award; but the impostors who are not truly of our kin we shall crush as they deserve, that they may no more make vain claims to what is too high for them.

v.1.p.226
Ha! you fly? In good truth they do, jumping down the crags, most of them. Why, the Acropolis is deserted, except foryes, a few have stood their ground and are not afraid of the judgement.

Philosophy

Attendants, pick up the wallet which yonder flying Cynic has dropped. Let us see what it containsbeans? a book? some coarse crust?

Parrhesiades

Ohdear no. Here is gold; some scent; a mirror; dice.

Philosophy

Ah, good honest man! such were his little necessaries for the philosophic life, such his title to indulge in general abuse and instruct his neighbours.

Parrhesiades

There you have them. The problem before you is, how the general ignorance is to be dispersed, and other people enabled to discriminate between the genuine and the other sort. Find the solution, Truth; for indeed it concerns you; Falsehood must not prevail; shall Ignorance shield the base while they counterfeit the good, and you never know it?

Tokens

Parrhesiades 1 w 12
Quite 1 w 17
a 3 w 18
simple 1 w 24
matter 1 w 30
Oyez 1 w 35
oyez 1 w 40
All 1 w 44
who 1 w 47
profess 1 w 54
philosophy 1 w 64
and 1 w 67
hold 1 w 71
themselves 1 w 81
entitled 1 w 89
to 1 w 91
the 2 w 94
name 1 w 98
of 2 w 100
philosopher 1 w 111
shall 1 w 116
appear 1 w 122
on 1 w 124
the 3 w 127
Acropolis 1 w 136
for 1 w 139
largesse 1 w 147
8 1 w 149
with 1 w 154
a 11 w 155
sesame 1 w 161
cake 1 w 165
to 2 w 168
each 1 w 172
A 3 w 174
long 1 w 178
beard 1 w 183
shall 2 w 188
qualify 1 w 195
for 2 w 198
a 18 w 199
square 1 w 205
of 3 w 207
compressed 1 w 217
figs 1 w 221
in 1 w 224
addition 1 w 232
Every 1 w 238
applicant 1 w 247
to 3 w 249
have 1 w 253
with 2 w 257
him 1 w 260
of 4 w 263
temperance 1 w 273
justice 1 w 281
and 2 w 285
self-control 1 w 297
any 1 w 301
that 1 w 309
he 6 w 311
is 2 w 313
in 2 w 315
possession 1 w 325
of 5 w 327
it 6 w 330
being 1 w 335
clearly 1 w 342
understood 1 w 352
that 2 w 356
these 1 w 361
are 2 w 364
not 1 w 367
indispensable 1 w 380
and 3 w 384
of 6 w 387
syllogisms 1 w 397
a 33 w 399
complete 1 w 407
set 1 w 410
of 7 w 412
five 1 w 416
these 2 w 422
being 2 w 427
the 6 w 430
condition 1 w 439
precedent 1 w 448
of 8 w 450
wisdom 1 w 456
Two 1 w 460
golden 1 w 466
talents 1 w 473
in 6 w 475
the 7 w 478
midst 1 w 483
are 3 w 486
set 2 w 489
His 1 w 493
prize 1 w 498
who 2 w 501
wrangles 1 w 509
best 1 w 513
amongst 1 w 520
his 1 w 523
peers 1 w 528
Parrhesiades 2 w 541
Just 1 w 545
look 1 w 549
the 8 w 553
ascent 1 w 559
packed 1 w 565
with 3 w 569
a 42 w 570
pushing 1 w 577
crowd 1 w 582
at 4 w 585
the 9 w 588
very 2 w 592
first 1 w 597
sound 1 w 602
of 9 w 604
my 1 w 606
8 2 w 607
More 1 w 612
of 10 w 614
them 2 w 618
along 1 w 623
the 11 w 626
Pelasgicum 1 w 636
more 1 w 641
by 1 w 643
the 12 w 646
temple 1 w 652
of 11 w 654
Asclepius 1 w 663
a 46 w 665
bigger 1 w 671
crowd 2 w 676
still 1 w 681
over 1 w 685
the 13 w 688
Areopagus 1 w 697
Why 1 w 701
positively 1 w 712
there 1 w 717
are 4 w 720
a 49 w 721
few 1 w 724
at 5 w 726
the 15 w 729
tomb 1 w 733
of 12 w 735
Talos 1 w 740
and 4 w 744
see 1 w 747
those 1 w 752
putting 1 w 759
ladders 1 w 766
against 1 w 773
the 16 w 776
temple 2 w 782
of 13 w 784
Castor 1 w 790
and 5 w 793
Pollux 1 w 799
up 1 w 802
they 1 w 806
climb 1 w 811
buzzing 1 w 819
and 6 w 822
clustering 1 w 832
like 1 w 836
a 59 w 837
swarm 1 w 842
of 14 w 844
bees 1 w 848
In 1 w 851
Homeric 1 w 858
phrase 1 w 864
on 10 w 867
this 1 w 871
side 1 w 875
are 5 w 878
exceeding 1 w 887
many 1 w 891
and 7 w 895
on 11 w 897
that 3 w 901
Ten 1 w 904
thousand 1 w 912
thick 1 w 918
as 5 w 920
leaves 1 w 926
and 9 w 929
flowers 1 w 936
in 13 w 938
spring 1 w 944
Noisily 1 w 952
they 2 w 956
settle 1 w 962
the 19 w 966
Acropolis 2 w 975
is 11 w 977
covered 1 w 984
with 4 w 988
them 3 w 992
in 15 w 994
a 70 w 995
trice 1 w 1000
everywhere 1 w 1011
wallet 1 w 1017
and 10 w 1020
beard 2 w 1025
flattery 1 w 1034
and 11 w 1037
effrontery 1 w 1047
staves 1 w 1054
and 12 w 1057
greed 1 w 1062
logic 1 w 1068
and 13 w 1071
avarice 1 w 1078
The 1 w 1082
little 1 w 1088
company 1 w 1095
which 1 w 1100
came 1 w 1104
up 2 w 1106
at 8 w 1108
the 21 w 1111
first 2 w 1116
proclamation 1 w 1128
is 12 w 1130
swamped 1 w 1137
beyond 1 w 1143
recovery 1 w 1151
swallowed 1 w 1161
up 3 w 1163
in 16 w 1165
these 3 w 1170
later 1 w 1175
crowds 1 w 1181
it 12 w 1184
is 13 w 1186
hopeless 1 w 1194
to 7 w 1196
find 1 w 1200
them 4 w 1204
because 1 w 1212
of 15 w 1214
the 24 w 1217
external 1 w 1225
resemblance 1 w 1236
That 1 w 1241
is 14 w 1243
the 25 w 1246
worst 1 w 1251
of 16 w 1253
it 13 w 1255
Philosophy 1 w 1266
you 1 w 1270
are 6 w 1273
really 1 w 1279
open 1 w 1283
to 8 w 1285
censure 1 w 1292
for 3 w 1295
not 2 w 1298
marking 1 w 1305
and 14 w 1308
labelling 1 w 1317
them 5 w 1321
these 4 w 1327
impostors 1 w 1336
are 7 w 1339
often 1 w 1344
more 2 w 1348
convincing 1 w 1358
than 1 w 1362
the 28 w 1365
true 1 w 1369
philosophers 1 w 1381
Philosophy 2 w 1392
It 1 w 1394
shall 3 w 1399
be 10 w 1401
done 1 w 1405
before 1 w 1411
long 3 w 1415
at 12 w 1418
present 1 w 1425
let 3 w 1428
us 9 w 1430
receive 1 w 1437
them 6 w 1441
Platonists 1 w 1452
Platonists 2 w 1462
first 3 w 1467
Pythagoreans 1 w 1480
No 2 w 1482
no 3 w 1485
Pythagoreans 2 w 1498
first 4 w 1503
our 1 w 1507
master 1 w 1513
is 17 w 1515
senior 1 w 1521
Stoics 1 w 1528
Rubbish 1 w 1535
the 30 w 1539
Porch 1 w 1544
is 19 w 1546
the 31 w 1549
best 2 w 1553
Peripatetics 1 w 1566
Now 1 w 1569
now 1 w 1573
this 2 w 1578
is 21 w 1580
a 110 w 1581
question 1 w 1589
of 18 w 1591
money 1 w 1596
Peripatetics 2 w 1609
first 5 w 1614
there 2 w 1619
Epicureans 1 w 1630
Hand 1 w 1634
over 4 w 1638
those 2 w 1643
cakes 1 w 1648
and 16 w 1651
fig-squares 1 w 1662
as 7 w 1665
to 13 w 1667
the 33 w 1670
money 2 w 1675
Epicureans 2 w 1686
will 1 w 1690
not 3 w 1693
mind 1 w 1697
waiting 1 w 1704
till 2 w 1708
the 34 w 1711
last 1 w 1715
Academics 1 w 1725
Where 1 w 1730
are 9 w 1733
the 35 w 1736
two 1 w 1739
talents 2 w 1746
none 1 w 1751
can 2 w 1754
touch 1 w 1759
the 36 w 1762
Academy 1 w 1769
at 17 w 1771
a 127 w 1772
wrangle 2 w 1779
we 3 w 1782
will 2 w 1786
soon 1 w 1790
show 1 w 1794
you 2 w 1797
that 4 w 1801
Stoics 2 w 1808
Not 1 w 1811
if 2 w 1813
we 4 w 1815
know 1 w 1819
it 15 w 1821
Philosophy 3 w 1832
Cease 1 w 1837
your 1 w 1841
strife 1 w 1847
Cynics 1 w 1854
there 3 w 1859
no 8 w 1862
more 3 w 1866
pushing 2 w 1873
and 17 w 1877
keep 1 w 1881
those 3 w 1886
sticks 1 w 1892
quiet 1 w 1897
You 1 w 1901
have 2 w 1905
mistaken 1 w 1913
the 38 w 1916
nature 1 w 1922
of 19 w 1924
this 3 w 1928
summons 1 w 1935
We 1 w 1938
three 1 w 1943
Philosophy 4 w 1954
Virtue 1 w 1961
and 18 w 1965
Truth 1 w 1970
are 10 w 1974
about 1 w 1979
to 16 w 1981
decide 1 w 1987
which 2 w 1992
are 11 w 1995
the 39 w 1998
true 2 w 2002
philosophers 2 w 2014
that 5 w 2019
done 2 w 2023
those 4 w 2029
whose 1 w 2034
lives 1 w 2039
are 12 w 2042
found 1 w 2047
to 17 w 2049
be 13 w 2051
in 25 w 2053
accord 1 w 2059
with 5 w 2063
our 3 w 2066
pleasure 1 w 2074
will 3 w 2078
be 14 w 2080
made 1 w 2084
happy 1 w 2089
by 2 w 2091
our 4 w 2094
award 1 w 2099
but 1 w 2103
the 40 w 2106
impostors 2 w 2115
who 4 w 2118
are 13 w 2121
not 4 w 2124
truly 1 w 2129
of 20 w 2131
our 5 w 2134
kin 2 w 2137
we 5 w 2139
shall 4 w 2144
crush 1 w 2149
as 11 w 2151
they 3 w 2155
deserve 1 w 2162
that 6 w 2167
they 4 w 2171
may 1 w 2174
no 10 w 2176
more 4 w 2180
make 1 w 2184
vain 1 w 2188
claims 1 w 2194
to 19 w 2196
what 1 w 2200
is 24 w 2202
too 2 w 2205
high 1 w 2209
for 5 w 2212
them 7 w 2216
Ha 2 w 2219
you 4 w 2223
fly 1 w 2226
In 2 w 2229
good 1 w 2233
truth 1 w 2238
they 5 w 2242
do 4 w 2244
jumping 1 w 2252
down 1 w 2256
the 45 w 2259
crags 1 w 2264
most 1 w 2269
of 21 w 2271
them 8 w 2275
Why 2 w 2279
the 47 w 2283
Acropolis 3 w 2292
is 26 w 2294
deserted 1 w 2302
except 1 w 2309
for 6 w 2312
yes 1 w 2316
a 158 w 2318
few 2 w 2321
have 3 w 2325
stood 2 w 2330
their 1 w 2335
ground 1 w 2341
and 19 w 2344
are 14 w 2347
not 5 w 2350
afraid 1 w 2356
of 22 w 2358
the 49 w 2361
judgement 1 w 2370
Philosophy 5 w 2381
Attendants 1 w 2391
pick 1 w 2396
up 4 w 2398
the 50 w 2401
wallet 2 w 2407
which 3 w 2412
yonder 1 w 2418
flying 1 w 2424
Cynic 2 w 2429
has 1 w 2432
dropped 1 w 2439
Let 1 w 2443
us 12 w 2445
see 2 w 2448
what 2 w 2452
it 17 w 2454
contains 1 w 2462
beans 1 w 2468
a 170 w 2470
book 1 w 2474
some 1 w 2479
coarse 1 w 2485
crust 1 w 2490
Parrhesiades 3 w 2503
Ohdear 1 w 2509
no 12 w 2511
Here 1 w 2516
is 27 w 2518
gold 2 w 2522
some 2 w 2527
scent 2 w 2532
a 175 w 2534
mirror 1 w 2540
dice 1 w 2545
Philosophy 6 w 2556
Ah 1 w 2558
good 2 w 2563
honest 1 w 2569
man 2 w 2572
such 1 w 2577
were 1 w 2581
his 5 w 2584
little 2 w 2590
necessaries 1 w 2601
for 7 w 2604
the 51 w 2607
philosophic 1 w 2618
life 1 w 2622
such 2 w 2627
his 6 w 2630
title 2 w 2635
to 22 w 2637
indulge 1 w 2644
in 32 w 2646
general 1 w 2653
abuse 1 w 2658
and 20 w 2661
instruct 1 w 2669
his 7 w 2672
neighbours 1 w 2682
Parrhesiades 4 w 2695
There 1 w 2700
you 5 w 2703
have 4 w 2707
them 9 w 2711
The 3 w 2715
problem 1 w 2722
before 2 w 2728
you 6 w 2731
is 31 w 2733
how 2 w 2737
the 53 w 2740
general 2 w 2747
ignorance 1 w 2756
is 32 w 2758
to 23 w 2760
be 17 w 2762
dispersed 1 w 2771
and 21 w 2775
other 1 w 2780
people 1 w 2786
enabled 1 w 2793
to 24 w 2795
discriminate 1 w 2807
between 1 w 2814
the 55 w 2817
genuine 1 w 2824
and 22 w 2827
the 56 w 2830
other 2 w 2835
sort 1 w 2839
Find 1 w 2844
the 58 w 2847
solution 1 w 2855
Truth 2 w 2861
for 9 w 2865
indeed 1 w 2871
it 20 w 2873
concerns 1 w 2881
you 7 w 2884
Falsehood 1 w 2894
must 1 w 2898
not 6 w 2901
prevail 1 w 2908
shall 5 w 2914
Ignorance 1 w 2923
shield 1 w 2929
the 59 w 2932
base 1 w 2936
while 1 w 2941
they 6 w 2945
counterfeit 1 w 2956
the 61 w 2959
good 3 w 2963
and 23 w 2967
you 8 w 2970
never 1 w 2975
know 2 w 2979
it 22 w 2981