Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Gorgias

Gorgias (521)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0059.tlg023.perseus-eng2:521
Refs {'start': {'reference': '521', 'human_reference': 'Section 521'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
521
521a
Call.

It is.

Soc.

Then please specify to which of these two ministrations to the state you are inviting methat of struggling hard, like a doctor, with the Athenians to make them as good as possible, or that of seeking to serve their wants and humor them at every turn? Tell me the truth, Callicles; for it is only right that, as you began by speaking to me frankly, you should continue to tell me what you think. So now speak out like a good, generous man.

Call.

I say then, the way of seeking to serve them.

521b
Soc.

So it is to a flatterers work, most noble sir, that you invite me?

Call.

Work for a mean Mysian,[*] if you prefer the name, Socrates; for unless you do as I say

Soc.

Do not tell me, what you have so often repeated, that anyone who pleases will put me to death, lest I on my side should have to tell you that it will be a villain killing a good man; nor that anyone may strip me of whatever I have,

521c
lest I should have to say in my turn: Well, but when he has stripped me, he will not know what use to make of his spoil, but as he stripped me unjustly so will he use his spoil unjustly, and if unjustly, foully, and if foully, ill.

Call.

It quite strikes me, Socrates, that you believe not one of these troubles could befall you, as though you dwelt out of the way, and could never be dragged into a law court by some perhaps utterly paltry rascal.

Soc.

Then I am a fool, Callicles, in truth, if I do not suppose that in this city anyone, whoever he was, might find himself, as luck should have it, in any sort of plight. Of one thing, however, I am surethat if ever I am brought before the court and stand in any such danger as you mention, it will be some villain who brings me there,

521d
for no honest man would prosecute a person who had done no wrong; and it would be no marvel if I were put to death. Would you like me to tell you my reason for expecting this?

Call.

Do, by all means.

Soc.

I think I am one of few, not to say the only one, in Athens who attempts the true art of statesmanship, and the only man of the present time who manages affairs of state: hence, as the speeches that I make from time to time are not aimed at gratification, but at what is best instead of what is most pleasant, and as I do not care to deal in these pretty toys[*] that you recommend,

521e
I shall have not a word to say at the bar. The same case that I made out to Polus will apply to me; for I shall be like a doctor tried by a bench of children on a charge brought by a cook.[*]

Tokens

Call 1 w 4
It 1 w 7
is 1 w 9
Soc 1 w 13
Then 1 w 18
please 1 w 24
specify 1 w 31
to 1 w 33
which 1 w 38
of 1 w 40
these 1 w 45
two 1 w 48
ministrations 1 w 61
to 2 w 63
the 2 w 66
state 1 w 71
you 1 w 74
are 1 w 77
inviting 1 w 85
me 1 w 87
that 1 w 92
of 2 w 94
struggling 1 w 104
hard 1 w 108
like 1 w 113
a 8 w 114
doctor 1 w 120
with 1 w 125
the 3 w 128
Athenians 1 w 137
to 4 w 139
make 1 w 143
them 1 w 147
as 2 w 149
good 1 w 153
as 3 w 155
possible 1 w 163
or 2 w 166
that 2 w 170
of 3 w 172
seeking 1 w 179
to 5 w 181
serve 1 w 186
their 1 w 191
wants 1 w 196
and 1 w 199
humor 1 w 204
them 2 w 208
at 5 w 210
every 1 w 215
turn 1 w 219
Tell 1 w 224
me 2 w 226
the 8 w 229
truth 1 w 234
Callicles 1 w 244
for 1 w 248
it 3 w 250
is 3 w 252
only 1 w 256
right 1 w 261
that 3 w 265
as 4 w 268
you 2 w 271
began 1 w 276
by 1 w 278
speaking 1 w 286
to 6 w 288
me 3 w 290
frankly 1 w 297
you 3 w 301
should 1 w 307
continue 1 w 315
to 7 w 317
tell 1 w 321
me 4 w 323
what 1 w 327
you 4 w 330
think 1 w 335
So 2 w 338
now 1 w 341
speak 2 w 346
out 1 w 349
like 2 w 353
a 25 w 354
good 2 w 358
generous 1 w 367
man 1 w 370
Call 3 w 375
I 2 w 377
say 1 w 380
then 2 w 384
the 10 w 388
way 1 w 391
of 4 w 393
seeking 2 w 400
to 8 w 402
serve 2 w 407
them 3 w 411
Soc 2 w 415
So 4 w 418
it 4 w 420
is 4 w 422
to 9 w 424
a 30 w 425
flatterer 1 w 434
s 28 w 436
work 1 w 440
most 1 w 445
noble 1 w 450
sir 1 w 453
that 4 w 458
you 5 w 461
invite 1 w 467
me 5 w 469
Call 4 w 474
Work 1 w 479
for 2 w 482
a 34 w 483
mean 1 w 487
Mysian 1 w 493
The 2 w 497
Mysians 1 w 504
like 3 w 509
the 12 w 512
Carians 1 w 519
cf 1 w 522
Euthydemus 1 w 533
285 1 w 536
C 6 w 537
were 1 w 543
regarded 1 w 551
as 5 w 553
the 13 w 556
lowest 1 w 562
of 5 w 564
the 14 w 567
low 2 w 570
Callicles 2 w 580
heatedly 1 w 588
taunts 1 w 594
Socrates 1 w 602
with 2 w 606
putting 1 w 613
the 15 w 616
matter 1 w 622
in 12 w 624
its 1 w 627
worst 1 w 632
light 1 w 637
if 2 w 640
you 6 w 643
prefer 1 w 649
the 16 w 652
name 1 w 656
Socrates 2 w 665
for 3 w 669
unless 1 w 675
you 7 w 678
do 2 w 680
as 6 w 682
I 3 w 683
say 2 w 686
Soc 5 w 690
Do 1 w 693
not 1 w 696
tell 2 w 700
me 8 w 702
what 2 w 707
you 8 w 710
have 1 w 714
so 1 w 716
often 1 w 721
repeated 1 w 729
that 5 w 734
anyone 1 w 740
who 1 w 743
pleases 1 w 750
will 1 w 754
put 2 w 757
me 9 w 759
to 10 w 761
death 1 w 766
lest 1 w 771
I 4 w 772
on 5 w 774
my 1 w 776
side 1 w 780
should 2 w 786
have 2 w 790
to 11 w 792
tell 3 w 796
you 9 w 799
that 6 w 803
it 8 w 805
will 2 w 809
be 2 w 811
a 60 w 812
villain 1 w 819
killing 1 w 826
a 62 w 827
good 3 w 831
man 2 w 834
nor 1 w 838
that 7 w 842
anyone 2 w 848
may 1 w 851
strip 1 w 856
me 10 w 858
of 7 w 860
whatever 1 w 868
I 5 w 869
have 3 w 873
lest 2 w 878
I 6 w 879
should 3 w 885
have 4 w 889
to 12 w 891
say 3 w 894
in 15 w 896
my 2 w 898
turn 2 w 902
Well 1 w 907
but 1 w 911
when 1 w 915
he 21 w 917
has 1 w 920
stripped 1 w 928
me 11 w 930
he 22 w 933
will 3 w 937
not 2 w 940
know 1 w 944
what 4 w 948
use 1 w 951
to 13 w 953
make 2 w 957
of 8 w 959
his 1 w 962
spoil 1 w 967
but 2 w 971
as 9 w 973
he 23 w 975
stripped 2 w 983
me 12 w 985
unjustly 1 w 993
so 2 w 995
will 4 w 999
he 24 w 1001
use 2 w 1004
his 2 w 1007
spoil 2 w 1012
unjustly 2 w 1020
and 2 w 1024
if 3 w 1026
unjustly 3 w 1034
foully 1 w 1041
and 3 w 1045
if 4 w 1047
foully 2 w 1053
ill 7 w 1057
Call 6 w 1062
It 2 w 1065
quite 1 w 1070
strikes 1 w 1077
me 13 w 1079
Socrates 3 w 1088
that 8 w 1093
you 10 w 1096
believe 1 w 1103
not 3 w 1106
one 3 w 1109
of 9 w 1111
these 2 w 1116
troubles 1 w 1124
could 1 w 1129
befall 1 w 1135
you 11 w 1138
as 10 w 1141
though 1 w 1147
you 12 w 1150
dwelt 1 w 1155
out 2 w 1158
of 10 w 1160
the 18 w 1163
way 2 w 1166
and 4 w 1170
could 2 w 1175
never 1 w 1180
be 5 w 1182
dragged 1 w 1189
into 1 w 1193
a 85 w 1194
law 1 w 1197
court 1 w 1202
by 2 w 1204
some 1 w 1208
perhaps 1 w 1215
utterly 1 w 1222
paltry 1 w 1228
rascal 1 w 1234
Soc 7 w 1238
Then 2 w 1243
I 8 w 1244
am 2 w 1246
a 92 w 1247
fool 1 w 1251
Callicles 3 w 1261
in 17 w 1264
truth 2 w 1269
if 5 w 1272
I 9 w 1273
do 3 w 1275
not 4 w 1278
suppose 1 w 1285
that 9 w 1289
in 18 w 1291
this 1 w 1295
city 1 w 1299
anyone 3 w 1305
whoever 1 w 1313
he 28 w 1315
was 1 w 1318
might 1 w 1324
find 1 w 1328
himself 1 w 1335
as 13 w 1338
luck 1 w 1342
should 4 w 1348
have 5 w 1352
it 11 w 1354
in 20 w 1357
any 4 w 1360
sort 1 w 1364
of 11 w 1366
plight 1 w 1372
Of 1 w 1375
one 5 w 1378
thing 1 w 1383
however 1 w 1391
I 10 w 1393
am 3 w 1395
sure 1 w 1399
that 10 w 1404
if 6 w 1406
ever 6 w 1410
I 11 w 1411
am 4 w 1413
brought 1 w 1420
before 1 w 1426
the 19 w 1429
court 2 w 1434
and 5 w 1437
stand 1 w 1442
in 22 w 1444
any 5 w 1447
such 1 w 1451
danger 1 w 1457
as 14 w 1459
you 13 w 1462
mention 1 w 1469
it 12 w 1472
will 5 w 1476
be 7 w 1478
some 2 w 1482
villain 2 w 1489
who 3 w 1492
brings 1 w 1498
me 17 w 1500
there 1 w 1505
for 5 w 1509
no 9 w 1511
honest 1 w 1517
man 3 w 1520
would 1 w 1525
prosecute 1 w 1534
a 110 w 1535
person 1 w 1541
who 4 w 1544
had 1 w 1547
done 1 w 1551
no 10 w 1553
wrong 1 w 1558
and 7 w 1562
it 13 w 1564
would 2 w 1569
be 8 w 1571
no 11 w 1573
marvel 1 w 1579
if 7 w 1581
I 12 w 1582
were 2 w 1586
put 3 w 1589
to 15 w 1591
death 2 w 1596
Would 1 w 1602
you 14 w 1605
like 4 w 1609
me 18 w 1611
to 16 w 1613
tell 4 w 1617
you 15 w 1620
my 3 w 1622
reason 1 w 1628
for 6 w 1631
expecting 1 w 1640
this 2 w 1644
Call 8 w 1649
Do 2 w 1652
by 3 w 1655
all 10 w 1658
means 1 w 1663
Soc 8 w 1667
I 13 w 1669
think 2 w 1674
I 14 w 1675
am 5 w 1677
one 8 w 1680
of 12 w 1682
few 1 w 1685
not 5 w 1689
to 17 w 1691
say 4 w 1694
the 21 w 1697
only 2 w 1701
one 9 w 1704
in 27 w 1707
Athens 1 w 1713
who 5 w 1716
attempts 1 w 1724
the 23 w 1727
true 1 w 1731
art 1 w 1734
of 13 w 1736
statesmanship 1 w 1749
and 8 w 1753
the 24 w 1756
only 3 w 1760
man 5 w 1763
of 14 w 1765
the 25 w 1768
present 1 w 1775
time 1 w 1779
who 6 w 1782
manages 1 w 1789
affairs 1 w 1796
of 15 w 1798
state 3 w 1803
hence 1 w 1809
as 16 w 1812
the 26 w 1815
speeches 1 w 1823
that 11 w 1827
I 15 w 1828
make 3 w 1832
from 1 w 1836
time 2 w 1840
to 18 w 1842
time 3 w 1846
are 2 w 1849
not 6 w 1852
aimed 1 w 1857
at 31 w 1859
gratification 1 w 1872
but 3 w 1876
at 34 w 1878
what 5 w 1882
is 9 w 1884
best 1 w 1888
instead 1 w 1895
of 16 w 1897
what 6 w 1901
is 10 w 1903
most 2 w 1907
pleasant 1 w 1915
and 9 w 1919
as 18 w 1921
I 16 w 1922
do 5 w 1924
not 7 w 1927
care 1 w 1931
to 19 w 1933
deal 1 w 1937
in 29 w 1939
these 3 w 1944
pretty 1 w 1950
toys 1 w 1954
Socrates 4 w 1962
retorts 1 w 1969
the 28 w 1972
phrase 1 w 1978
of 17 w 1980
Euripides 1 w 1989
which 2 w 1995
Callicles 4 w 2004
applied 1 w 2011
above 1 w 2017
Plat 1 w 2022
Gorg 1 w 2027
486c 1 w 2032
to 22 w 2035
philosophic 1 w 2046
debate 1 w 2052
upon 1 w 2057
the 29 w 2060
practical 1 w 2069
pursuits 1 w 2077
which 3 w 2082
Callicles 5 w 2091
recommended 1 w 2102
that 12 w 2107
you 16 w 2110
recommend 2 w 2119
I 17 w 2121
shall 1 w 2126
have 6 w 2130
not 8 w 2133
a 163 w 2134
word 1 w 2138
to 23 w 2140
say 5 w 2143
at 41 w 2145
the 30 w 2148
bar 1 w 2151
The 4 w 2155
same 1 w 2159
case 1 w 2163
that 13 w 2167
I 18 w 2168
made 1 w 2172
out 3 w 2175
to 24 w 2177
Polus 1 w 2182
will 6 w 2186
apply 1 w 2191
to 25 w 2193
me 27 w 2195
for 7 w 2199
I 19 w 2200
shall 2 w 2205
be 10 w 2207
like 5 w 2211
a 173 w 2212
doctor 2 w 2218
tried 1 w 2223
by 4 w 2225
a 174 w 2226
bench 1 w 2231
of 18 w 2233
children 1 w 2241
on 22 w 2243
a 175 w 2244
charge 1 w 2250
brought 2 w 2257
by 5 w 2259
a 177 w 2260
cook 1 w 2264
Cf 1 w 2267
Plat 2 w 2272
Gorg 2 w 2277
464d 1 w 2282