Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Protagoras

Protagoras (321-322)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0059.tlg022.perseus-eng2:321-322
Refs {'start': {'reference': '321', 'human_reference': 'Section 321'}, 'end': {'reference': '322', 'human_reference': 'Section 322'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
Soc.

To those which he invested with smallness he dealt a winged escape or an underground habitation; those which he increased in largeness he preserved
321
321a
by this very means; and he dealt all the other properties on this plan of compensation. In contriving all this he was taking precaution that no kind should be extinguished; and when he had equipped them with avoidances of mutual destruction, he devised a provision against the seasons ordained by Heaven, in clothing them about with thick-set hair and solid hides, sufficient to ward off winter yet able to shield them also from the heats, and so that on going to their lairs they might find in these same things a bedding of their own that was native to each; and some he shod with hoofs,
321b
others with claws and solid, bloodless hides. Then he proceeded to furnish each of them with its proper food, some with pasture of the earth, others with fruits of trees, and others again with roots; and to a certain number for food he gave other creatures to devour: to some he attached a paucity in breeding, and to others, which were being consumed by these, a plenteous brood, and so procured survival of their kind. Now Epimetheus, being not so wise as he might be,
321c
heedlessly squandered his stock of properties on the brutes; he still had left unequipped the race of men, and was at a loss what to do with it. As he was casting about, Prometheus arrived to examine his distribution, and saw that whereas the other creatures were fully and suitably provided, man was naked, unshod, unbedded, unarmed; and already the destined day was come, whereon man like the rest should emerge from earth to light. Then Prometheus, in his perplexity as to what preservation he could devise for man, stole from Hephaestus and Athena wisdom in the arts
321d
together with firesince by no means without fire could it be acquired or helpfully used by anyand he handed it there and then as a gift to man. Now although man acquired in this way the wisdom of daily life, civic wisdom he had not, since this was in the possession of Zeus; Prometheus could not make so free as to enter the citadel which is the dwelling-place of Zeus, and moreover the guards of Zeus were terrible: but he entered unobserved the building shared by Athena and Hephaestus
321e
for the pursuit of their arts, and stealing Hephaestuss fiery art and all Athenas also he gave them to man, and hence it is
322
322a
that man gets facility for his livelihood, but Prometheus, through Epimetheus fault, later on (the story goes) stood his trial for theft.

Soc.

And now that man was partaker of a divine portion,[*] he, in the first place, by his nearness of kin to deity, was the only creature that worshipped gods, and set himself to establish altars and holy images; and secondly, he soon was enabled by his skill to articulate speech and words, and to invent dwellings, clothes, sandals, beds, and the foods that are of the earth. Thus far provided, men dwelt separately in the beginning, and cities there were none;
322b
so that they were being destroyed by the wild beasts, since these were in all ways stronger than they; and although their skill in handiwork was a sufficient aid in respect of food, in their warfare with the beasts it was defective; for as yet they had no civic art, which includes the art of war. So they sought to band themselves together and secure their lives by founding cities. Now as often as they were banded together they did wrong to one another through the lack of civic art,
322c
and thus they began to be scattered again and to perish. So Zeus, fearing that our race was in danger of utter destruction, sent Hermes to bring respect and right among men, to the end that there should be regulation of cities and friendly ties to draw them together. Then Hermes asked Zeus in what manner then was he to give men right and respect: Am I to deal them out as the arts have been dealt? That dealing was done in such wise that one man possessing medical art is able to treat many ordinary men, and so with the other craftsmen. Am I to place among men right and respect in this way also, or deal them out to all?
322d
To all, replied Zeus; let all have their share: for cities cannot be formed if only a few have a share of these as of other arts. And make thereto a law of my ordaining, that he who cannot partake of respect and right shall die the death as a public pest. Hence it comes about, Socrates, that people in cities, and especially in Athens, consider it the concern of a few to advise on cases of artistic excellence or good craftsmanship,
322e
and if anyone outside the few gives advice they disallow it, as you say, and not without reason, as I think:

Tokens

Soc 1 w 3
To 1 w 6
those 1 w 11
which 1 w 16
he 1 w 18
invested 1 w 26
with 1 w 30
smallness 1 w 39
he 2 w 41
dealt 1 w 46
a 3 w 47
winged 1 w 53
escape 1 w 59
or 1 w 61
an 1 w 63
underground 1 w 74
habitation 1 w 84
those 2 w 90
which 2 w 95
he 3 w 97
increased 1 w 106
in 4 w 108
largeness 1 w 117
he 4 w 119
preserved 1 w 128
by 1 w 130
this 1 w 134
very 1 w 138
means 1 w 143
and 1 w 147
he 5 w 149
dealt 2 w 154
all 2 w 157
the 1 w 160
other 1 w 165
properties 1 w 175
on 2 w 177
this 2 w 181
plan 1 w 185
of 1 w 187
compensation 1 w 199
In 1 w 202
contriving 1 w 212
all 3 w 215
this 3 w 219
he 8 w 221
was 1 w 224
taking 1 w 230
precaution 1 w 240
that 1 w 244
no 1 w 246
kind 1 w 250
should 1 w 256
be 1 w 258
extinguished 1 w 270
and 2 w 274
when 1 w 278
he 11 w 280
had 1 w 283
equipped 1 w 291
them 1 w 295
with 2 w 299
avoidances 1 w 309
of 2 w 311
mutual 1 w 317
destruction 1 w 328
he 13 w 331
devised 1 w 338
a 26 w 339
provision 1 w 348
against 1 w 355
the 4 w 358
seasons 1 w 365
ordained 1 w 373
by 2 w 375
Heaven 1 w 381
in 11 w 384
clothing 1 w 392
them 2 w 396
about 1 w 401
with 3 w 405
thick-set 1 w 414
hair 1 w 418
and 3 w 421
solid 1 w 426
hides 1 w 431
sufficient 1 w 442
to 1 w 444
ward 1 w 448
off 1 w 451
winter 1 w 457
yet 1 w 460
able 1 w 464
to 2 w 466
shield 1 w 472
them 3 w 476
also 1 w 480
from 1 w 484
the 7 w 487
heats 1 w 492
and 4 w 496
so 4 w 498
that 2 w 502
on 9 w 504
going 1 w 509
to 3 w 511
their 1 w 516
lairs 1 w 521
they 1 w 525
might 1 w 530
find 1 w 534
in 16 w 536
these 1 w 541
same 1 w 545
things 1 w 551
a 43 w 552
bedding 1 w 559
of 4 w 561
their 2 w 566
own 1 w 569
that 3 w 573
was 2 w 576
native 1 w 582
to 4 w 584
each 1 w 588
and 5 w 592
some 1 w 596
he 23 w 598
shod 1 w 602
with 4 w 606
hoofs 1 w 611
others 1 w 618
with 5 w 622
claws 1 w 627
and 6 w 630
solid 2 w 635
bloodless 1 w 645
hides 2 w 650
Then 1 w 655
he 26 w 657
proceeded 1 w 666
to 5 w 668
furnish 1 w 675
each 2 w 679
of 6 w 681
them 4 w 685
with 6 w 689
its 1 w 692
proper 2 w 698
food 1 w 702
some 2 w 707
with 7 w 711
pasture 1 w 718
of 7 w 720
the 14 w 723
earth 1 w 728
others 2 w 735
with 8 w 739
fruits 1 w 745
of 8 w 747
trees 1 w 752
and 7 w 756
others 3 w 762
again 2 w 767
with 9 w 771
roots 1 w 776
and 8 w 780
to 6 w 782
a 58 w 783
certain 1 w 790
number 1 w 796
for 1 w 799
food 2 w 803
he 31 w 805
gave 1 w 809
other 5 w 814
creatures 1 w 823
to 7 w 825
devour 1 w 831
to 8 w 834
some 3 w 838
he 33 w 840
attached 1 w 848
a 64 w 849
paucity 1 w 856
in 21 w 858
breeding 1 w 866
and 9 w 870
to 9 w 872
others 4 w 878
which 3 w 884
were 1 w 888
being 1 w 893
consumed 1 w 901
by 3 w 903
these 2 w 908
a 67 w 910
plenteous 1 w 919
brood 1 w 924
and 10 w 928
so 9 w 930
procured 1 w 938
survival 1 w 946
of 9 w 948
their 3 w 953
kind 2 w 957
Now 1 w 961
Epimetheus 1 w 971
being 2 w 977
not 1 w 980
so 10 w 982
wise 1 w 986
as 6 w 988
he 39 w 990
might 2 w 995
be 6 w 997
heedlessly 1 w 1008
squandered 1 w 1018
his 4 w 1021
stock 1 w 1026
of 10 w 1028
properties 2 w 1038
on 11 w 1040
the 22 w 1043
brutes 1 w 1049
he 42 w 1052
still 1 w 1057
had 2 w 1060
left 1 w 1064
unequipped 1 w 1074
the 23 w 1077
race 1 w 1081
of 11 w 1083
men 1 w 1086
and 12 w 1090
was 3 w 1093
at 10 w 1095
a 77 w 1096
loss 1 w 1100
what 1 w 1104
to 11 w 1106
do 1 w 1108
with 10 w 1112
it 15 w 1114
As 1 w 1117
he 44 w 1119
was 4 w 1122
casting 1 w 1129
about 2 w 1134
Prometheus 1 w 1145
arrived 1 w 1152
to 12 w 1154
examine 1 w 1161
his 5 w 1164
distribution 1 w 1176
and 13 w 1180
saw 1 w 1183
that 4 w 1187
whereas 1 w 1194
the 25 w 1197
other 7 w 1202
creatures 2 w 1211
were 2 w 1215
fully 1 w 1220
and 14 w 1223
suitably 1 w 1231
provided 1 w 1239
man 1 w 1243
was 5 w 1246
naked 1 w 1251
unshod 1 w 1258
unbedded 1 w 1267
unarmed 1 w 1275
and 15 w 1279
already 1 w 1286
the 27 w 1289
destined 1 w 1297
day 1 w 1300
was 6 w 1303
come 1 w 1307
whereon 1 w 1315
man 2 w 1318
like 1 w 1322
the 28 w 1325
rest 1 w 1329
should 2 w 1335
emerge 1 w 1341
from 2 w 1345
earth 2 w 1350
to 13 w 1352
light 1 w 1357
Then 2 w 1362
Prometheus 2 w 1372
in 29 w 1375
his 6 w 1378
perplexity 1 w 1388
as 13 w 1390
to 14 w 1392
what 2 w 1396
preservation 1 w 1408
he 54 w 1410
could 1 w 1415
devise 2 w 1421
for 2 w 1424
man 3 w 1427
stole 1 w 1433
from 3 w 1437
Hephaestus 1 w 1447
and 16 w 1450
Athena 1 w 1456
wisdom 1 w 1462
in 30 w 1464
the 31 w 1467
arts 1 w 1471
together 1 w 1479
with 11 w 1483
fire 1 w 1487
since 1 w 1493
by 4 w 1495
no 3 w 1497
means 2 w 1502
without 1 w 1509
fire 2 w 1513
could 2 w 1518
it 20 w 1520
be 8 w 1522
acquired 1 w 1530
or 5 w 1532
helpfully 1 w 1541
used 1 w 1545
by 5 w 1547
any 1 w 1550
and 17 w 1554
he 59 w 1556
handed 1 w 1562
it 21 w 1564
there 1 w 1569
and 19 w 1572
then 2 w 1576
as 14 w 1578
a 117 w 1579
gift 1 w 1583
to 17 w 1585
man 4 w 1588
Now 2 w 1592
although 1 w 1600
man 5 w 1603
acquired 2 w 1611
in 32 w 1613
this 4 w 1617
way 1 w 1620
the 35 w 1623
wisdom 2 w 1629
of 12 w 1631
daily 1 w 1636
life 1 w 1640
civic 1 w 1646
wisdom 3 w 1652
he 63 w 1654
had 3 w 1657
not 2 w 1660
since 2 w 1666
this 5 w 1670
was 7 w 1673
in 34 w 1675
the 36 w 1678
possession 1 w 1688
of 13 w 1690
Zeus 1 w 1694
Prometheus 3 w 1705
could 3 w 1710
not 3 w 1713
make 1 w 1717
so 11 w 1719
free 1 w 1723
as 16 w 1725
to 18 w 1727
enter 1 w 1732
the 38 w 1735
citadel 1 w 1742
which 4 w 1747
is 19 w 1749
the 39 w 1752
dwelling-place 1 w 1766
of 14 w 1768
Zeus 2 w 1772
and 20 w 1776
moreover 1 w 1784
the 40 w 1787
guards 1 w 1793
of 15 w 1795
Zeus 3 w 1799
were 3 w 1803
terrible 1 w 1811
but 2 w 1815
he 69 w 1817
entered 1 w 1824
unobserved 1 w 1834
the 41 w 1837
building 1 w 1845
shared 1 w 1851
by 6 w 1853
Athena 2 w 1859
and 21 w 1862
Hephaestus 2 w 1872
for 3 w 1875
the 43 w 1878
pursuit 1 w 1885
of 16 w 1887
their 4 w 1892
arts 2 w 1896
and 22 w 1900
stealing 1 w 1908
Hephaestus 3 w 1918
s 140 w 1920
fiery 1 w 1925
art 5 w 1928
and 23 w 1931
all 4 w 1934
Athena 3 w 1940
s 141 w 1942
also 2 w 1946
he 75 w 1948
gave 2 w 1952
them 5 w 1956
to 19 w 1958
man 6 w 1961
and 24 w 1965
hence 1 w 1970
it 24 w 1972
is 20 w 1974
that 5 w 1978
man 7 w 1981
gets 1 w 1985
facility 1 w 1993
for 4 w 1996
his 9 w 1999
livelihood 1 w 2009
but 3 w 2013
Prometheus 4 w 2023
through 1 w 2031
Epimetheus 2 w 2041
fault 1 w 2047
later 1 w 2053
on 16 w 2055
the 49 w 2059
story 1 w 2064
goes 1 w 2068
stood 1 w 2074
his 10 w 2077
trial 1 w 2082
for 5 w 2085
theft 1 w 2090
Soc 2 w 2094
And 1 w 2098
now 1 w 2101
that 6 w 2105
man 8 w 2108
was 8 w 2111
partaker 1 w 2119
of 17 w 2121
a 159 w 2122
divine 1 w 2128
portion 1 w 2135
i 148 w 2137
e 265 w 2139
of 18 w 2143
arts 3 w 2147
originally 1 w 2157
apportioned 1 w 2168
to 22 w 2170
gods 1 w 2174
alone 1 w 2179
he 82 w 2182
in 40 w 2185
the 51 w 2188
first 1 w 2193
place 2 w 2198
by 7 w 2201
his 11 w 2204
nearness 1 w 2212
of 19 w 2214
kin 4 w 2217
to 23 w 2219
deity 1 w 2224
was 9 w 2228
the 52 w 2231
only 1 w 2235
creature 3 w 2243
that 7 w 2247
worshipped 1 w 2257
gods 2 w 2261
and 25 w 2265
set 2 w 2268
himself 1 w 2275
to 24 w 2277
establish 1 w 2286
altars 1 w 2292
and 26 w 2295
holy 1 w 2299
images 1 w 2305
and 27 w 2309
secondly 1 w 2317
he 85 w 2320
soon 1 w 2324
was 10 w 2327
enabled 1 w 2334
by 8 w 2336
his 12 w 2339
skill 1 w 2344
to 25 w 2346
articulate 1 w 2356
speech 1 w 2362
and 28 w 2365
words 1 w 2370
and 29 w 2374
to 26 w 2376
invent 1 w 2382
dwellings 1 w 2391
clothes 1 w 2399
sandals 1 w 2407
beds 1 w 2412
and 31 w 2416
the 54 w 2419
foods 1 w 2424
that 8 w 2428
are 2 w 2431
of 20 w 2433
the 55 w 2436
earth 3 w 2441
Thus 1 w 2446
far 1 w 2449
provided 2 w 2457
men 2 w 2461
dwelt 1 w 2466
separately 1 w 2476
in 44 w 2478
the 56 w 2481
beginning 1 w 2490
and 32 w 2494
cities 1 w 2500
there 2 w 2505
were 4 w 2509
none 1 w 2513
so 14 w 2516
that 9 w 2520
they 2 w 2524
were 5 w 2528
being 3 w 2533
destroyed 1 w 2542
by 9 w 2544
the 59 w 2547
wild 1 w 2551
beasts 1 w 2557
since 3 w 2563
these 3 w 2568
were 6 w 2572
in 49 w 2574
all 6 w 2577
ways 1 w 2581
stronger 1 w 2589
than 1 w 2593
they 3 w 2597
and 33 w 2601
although 2 w 2609
their 5 w 2614
skill 2 w 2619
in 50 w 2621
handiwork 1 w 2630
was 11 w 2633
a 201 w 2634
sufficient 2 w 2644
aid 1 w 2647
in 51 w 2649
respect 1 w 2656
of 21 w 2658
food 4 w 2662
in 52 w 2665
their 6 w 2670
warfare 1 w 2677
with 13 w 2681
the 64 w 2684
beasts 2 w 2690
it 29 w 2692
was 12 w 2695
defective 1 w 2704
for 6 w 2708
as 24 w 2710
yet 2 w 2713
they 4 w 2717
had 4 w 2720
no 9 w 2722
civic 2 w 2727
art 10 w 2730
which 5 w 2736
includes 1 w 2744
the 66 w 2747
art 11 w 2750
of 22 w 2752
war 3 w 2755
So 3 w 2758
they 5 w 2762
sought 1 w 2768
to 27 w 2770
band 1 w 2774
themselves 1 w 2784
together 2 w 2792
and 36 w 2795
secure 1 w 2801
their 7 w 2806
lives 1 w 2811
by 10 w 2813
founding 1 w 2821
cities 2 w 2827
Now 3 w 2831
as 25 w 2833
often 1 w 2838
as 26 w 2840
they 6 w 2844
were 7 w 2848
banded 1 w 2854
together 3 w 2862
they 7 w 2866
did 1 w 2869
wrong 1 w 2874
to 30 w 2876
one 4 w 2879
another 1 w 2886
through 2 w 2893
the 75 w 2896
lack 1 w 2900
of 24 w 2902
civic 3 w 2907
art 12 w 2910
and 38 w 2914
thus 1 w 2918
they 8 w 2922
began 1 w 2927
to 31 w 2929
be 15 w 2931
scattered 1 w 2940
again 3 w 2945
and 39 w 2948
to 32 w 2950
perish 1 w 2956
So 4 w 2959
Zeus 4 w 2963
fearing 1 w 2971
that 10 w 2975
our 2 w 2978
race 2 w 2982
was 13 w 2985
in 57 w 2987
danger 1 w 2993
of 25 w 2995
utter 1 w 3000
destruction 2 w 3011
sent 1 w 3016
Hermes 1 w 3022
to 33 w 3024
bring 1 w 3029
respect 2 w 3036
and 40 w 3039
right 1 w 3044
among 1 w 3049
men 3 w 3052
to 34 w 3055
the 77 w 3058
end 1 w 3061
that 11 w 3065
there 3 w 3070
should 3 w 3076
be 16 w 3078
regulation 1 w 3088
of 26 w 3090
cities 3 w 3096
and 41 w 3099
friendly 1 w 3107
ties 6 w 3111
to 35 w 3113
draw 1 w 3117
them 7 w 3121
together 4 w 3129
Then 3 w 3134
Hermes 2 w 3140
asked 1 w 3145
Zeus 5 w 3149
in 59 w 3151
what 3 w 3155
manner 1 w 3161
then 5 w 3165
was 14 w 3168
he 116 w 3170
to 37 w 3172
give 1 w 3176
men 4 w 3179
right 2 w 3184
and 42 w 3187
respect 3 w 3194
Am 1 w 3197
I 2 w 3198
to 38 w 3200
deal 3 w 3204
them 8 w 3208
out 4 w 3211
as 30 w 3213
the 83 w 3216
arts 4 w 3220
have 1 w 3224
been 1 w 3228
dealt 3 w 3233
That 1 w 3238
dealing 1 w 3245
was 15 w 3248
done 1 w 3252
in 61 w 3254
such 1 w 3258
wise 2 w 3262
that 12 w 3266
one 6 w 3269
man 10 w 3272
possessing 1 w 3282
medical 1 w 3289
art 14 w 3292
is 28 w 3294
able 3 w 3298
to 39 w 3300
treat 1 w 3305
many 1 w 3309
ordinary 1 w 3317
men 5 w 3320
and 43 w 3324
so 16 w 3326
with 14 w 3330
the 84 w 3333
other 9 w 3338
craftsmen 1 w 3347
Am 2 w 3350
I 3 w 3351
to 40 w 3353
place 3 w 3358
among 2 w 3363
men 7 w 3366
right 3 w 3371
and 44 w 3374
respect 4 w 3381
in 64 w 3383
this 6 w 3387
way 3 w 3390
also 3 w 3394
or 19 w 3397
deal 6 w 3401
them 9 w 3405
out 5 w 3408
to 41 w 3410
all 7 w 3413
To 2 w 3416
all 8 w 3419
replied 1 w 3427
Zeus 6 w 3431
let 1 w 3435
all 9 w 3438
have 2 w 3442
their 8 w 3447
share 2 w 3452
for 7 w 3456
cities 4 w 3462
cannot 1 w 3468
be 18 w 3470
formed 1 w 3476
if 3 w 3478
only 2 w 3482
a 272 w 3483
few 1 w 3486
have 3 w 3490
a 274 w 3491
share 3 w 3496
of 27 w 3498
these 4 w 3503
as 32 w 3505
of 28 w 3507
other 10 w 3512
arts 5 w 3516
And 2 w 3520
make 2 w 3524
thereto 1 w 3531
a 279 w 3532
law 2 w 3535
of 29 w 3537
my 1 w 3539
ordaining 1 w 3548
that 13 w 3553
he 126 w 3555
who 1 w 3558
cannot 2 w 3564
partake 2 w 3571
of 30 w 3573
respect 5 w 3580
and 45 w 3583
right 4 w 3588
shall 1 w 3593
die 1 w 3596
the 91 w 3599
death 1 w 3604
as 33 w 3606
a 290 w 3607
public 1 w 3613
pest 1 w 3617
Hence 1 w 3623
it 34 w 3625
comes 1 w 3630
about 3 w 3635
Socrates 1 w 3644
that 14 w 3649
people 1 w 3655
in 67 w 3657
cities 5 w 3663
and 46 w 3667
especially 1 w 3677
in 68 w 3679
Athens 1 w 3685
consider 1 w 3694
it 36 w 3696
the 93 w 3699
concern 1 w 3706
of 31 w 3708
a 296 w 3709
few 2 w 3712
to 43 w 3714
advise 1 w 3720
on 36 w 3722
cases 1 w 3727
of 32 w 3729
artistic 1 w 3737
excellence 1 w 3747
or 23 w 3749
good 1 w 3753
craftsmanship 1 w 3766
and 47 w 3770
if 4 w 3772
anyone 1 w 3778
outside 1 w 3785
the 94 w 3788
few 3 w 3791
gives 1 w 3796
advice 1 w 3802
they 9 w 3806
disallow 1 w 3814
it 37 w 3816
as 35 w 3819
you 1 w 3822
say 1 w 3825
and 48 w 3829
not 7 w 3832
without 2 w 3839
reason 1 w 3845
as 37 w 3848
I 4 w 3849
think 1 w 3854