Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Cratylus

Cratylus (420)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0059.tlg005.perseus-eng2:420
Refs {'start': {'reference': '420', 'human_reference': 'Section 420'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Socrates. The name ἵμερος (longing) was given to the stream (ῥοῦς) which most draws the soul;
420
420a
for because it flows with a rush (ἱέμενος) and with a desire for things and thus draws the soul on through the impulse of its flowing, all this power gives it the name of ἵμερος. And the word πόθος (yearning) signifies that it pertains not to that which is present, but to that which is elsewhere (ἄλλοθί που) or absent, and therefore the same feeling which is called ἵμερος when its object is present, is called πόθος when it is absent. And ἔρως (love) is so called because it flows in (ἐσρεῖ) from without, and this flowing is not inherent in him who has it,
420b
but is introduced through the eyes; for this reason it was in ancient times called ἔσρος, from ἐσρεῖνfor we used to employ omicron instead of omegabut now it is called ἔρως through the change of omicron to omega. Well, what more is there that you want to examine?

Hermogenes. What is your view about δόξα (opinion) and the like?

Socrates.Δόξα is derived either from the pursuit (δίωξις) which the soul carries on as it pursues the knowledge of the nature of things, or from the shooting of the bow (τόξον); the latter is more likely; at any rate οἴησις (belief) supports this view,
420c
for it appears to mean the motion (οἶσις) of the soul towards the essential nature of every individual thing, just as βουλή (intention) denotes shooting (βολή) and βούλεσθαι (wish), as well as βουλεύεσθαι (plan), denotes aiming at something. All these words seem to follow δόξα and to express the idea of shooting, just as ἀβουλία (ill-advisedness), on the other hand, appears to be a failure to hit, as if a person did not shoot or hit that which he shot at or wished or planned or desired.
420d

Hermogenes. I think you are hurrying things a bit, Socrates.

Socrates. Yes, for I am running the last lap now. But I think I must still explain ἀνάγκη (compulsion) and ἑκούσιον (voluntary) because they naturally come next. Now by the word ἑκούσιον is expressed the yielding (εἶκον) and not opposing, but, as I say, yielding to the motion which is in accordance with the will; but the compulsory (τὸ ἀναγκαῖον) and resistant, being contrary to the will, is associated with error and ignorance; so it is likened to walking through ravines (ἄγκη),
420e
because they are hard to traverse, rough, and rugged, and retard motion; the word ἀναγκαῖον may, then, originate in a comparison with progress through a ravine. But let us not cease to use my strength, so long as it lasts and do not you cease from asking questions.

Tokens

Socrates 1 w 8
The 1 w 12
name 1 w 16
ἵμερος 1 w 22
longing 1 w 30
was 1 w 34
given 1 w 39
to 1 w 41
the 1 w 44
stream 1 w 50
ῥοῦς 1 w 55
which 1 w 61
most 1 w 65
draws 1 w 70
the 2 w 73
soul 1 w 77
for 1 w 81
because 1 w 88
it 1 w 90
flows 1 w 95
with 1 w 99
a 7 w 100
rush 1 w 104
ἱέμενος 1 w 112
and 1 w 116
with 2 w 120
a 9 w 121
desire 1 w 127
for 2 w 130
things 1 w 136
and 2 w 139
thus 1 w 143
draws 2 w 148
the 3 w 151
soul 2 w 155
on 2 w 157
through 1 w 164
the 4 w 167
impulse 1 w 174
of 1 w 176
its 1 w 179
flowing 1 w 186
all 1 w 190
this 1 w 194
power 1 w 199
gives 1 w 204
it 5 w 206
the 5 w 209
name 2 w 213
of 2 w 215
ἵμερος 2 w 221
And 1 w 225
the 6 w 228
word 1 w 232
πόθος 1 w 237
yearning 1 w 246
signifies 1 w 256
that 1 w 260
it 6 w 262
pertains 1 w 270
not 1 w 273
to 2 w 275
that 2 w 279
which 2 w 284
is 2 w 286
present 1 w 293
but 1 w 297
to 3 w 299
that 3 w 303
which 3 w 308
is 3 w 310
elsewhere 1 w 319
ἄλλοθί 1 w 326
που 1 w 329
or 4 w 332
absent 1 w 338
and 3 w 342
therefore 1 w 351
the 8 w 354
same 1 w 358
feeling 1 w 365
which 4 w 370
is 4 w 372
called 1 w 378
ἵμερος 3 w 384
when 1 w 388
its 2 w 391
object 1 w 397
is 5 w 399
present 2 w 406
is 6 w 409
called 2 w 415
πόθος 2 w 420
when 2 w 424
it 8 w 426
is 7 w 428
absent 2 w 434
And 2 w 438
ἔρως 1 w 442
love 1 w 447
is 8 w 450
so 3 w 452
called 3 w 458
because 2 w 465
it 9 w 467
flows 2 w 472
in 7 w 474
ἐσρεῖ 1 w 480
from 1 w 485
without 1 w 492
and 4 w 496
this 2 w 500
flowing 2 w 507
is 10 w 509
not 2 w 512
inherent 1 w 520
in 10 w 522
him 1 w 525
who 1 w 528
has 1 w 531
it 11 w 533
but 2 w 537
is 11 w 539
introduced 1 w 549
through 2 w 556
the 9 w 559
eyes 1 w 563
for 4 w 567
this 3 w 571
reason 1 w 577
it 12 w 579
was 2 w 582
in 12 w 584
ancient 1 w 591
times 1 w 596
called 4 w 602
ἔσρος 1 w 607
from 2 w 612
ἐσρεῖν 1 w 618
for 5 w 622
we 2 w 624
used 1 w 628
to 4 w 630
employ 1 w 636
omicron 1 w 643
instead 1 w 650
of 3 w 652
omega 1 w 657
but 3 w 661
now 1 w 664
it 13 w 666
is 13 w 668
called 5 w 674
ἔρως 2 w 678
through 3 w 685
the 10 w 688
change 1 w 694
of 4 w 696
omicron 2 w 703
to 5 w 705
omega 2 w 710
Well 1 w 715
what 1 w 720
more 1 w 724
is 14 w 726
there 2 w 731
that 4 w 735
you 1 w 738
want 1 w 742
to 6 w 744
examine 1 w 751
Hermogenes 1 w 762
What 1 w 767
is 15 w 769
your 1 w 773
view 1 w 777
about 1 w 782
δόξα 1 w 786
opinion 1 w 794
and 5 w 798
the 12 w 801
like 1 w 805
Socrates 2 w 814
Δόξα 1 w 819
is 16 w 821
derived 1 w 828
either 1 w 834
from 3 w 838
the 14 w 841
pursuit 1 w 848
δίωξις 1 w 855
which 5 w 861
the 15 w 864
soul 3 w 868
carries 1 w 875
on 7 w 877
as 5 w 879
it 16 w 881
pursues 1 w 888
the 16 w 891
knowledge 1 w 900
of 5 w 902
the 17 w 905
nature 1 w 911
of 6 w 913
things 2 w 919
or 9 w 922
from 4 w 926
the 18 w 929
shooting 1 w 937
of 7 w 939
the 19 w 942
bow 1 w 945
τόξον 1 w 951
the 20 w 956
latter 1 w 962
is 17 w 964
more 2 w 968
likely 1 w 974
at 11 w 977
any 1 w 980
rate 3 w 984
οἴησις 1 w 990
belief 1 w 997
supports 1 w 1006
this 4 w 1010
view 2 w 1014
for 6 w 1018
it 17 w 1020
appears 1 w 1027
to 7 w 1029
mean 1 w 1033
the 21 w 1036
motion 1 w 1042
οἶσις 1 w 1048
of 8 w 1051
the 22 w 1054
soul 4 w 1058
towards 1 w 1065
the 23 w 1068
essential 1 w 1077
nature 2 w 1083
of 9 w 1085
every 1 w 1090
individual 1 w 1100
thing 3 w 1105
just 1 w 1110
as 6 w 1112
βουλή 1 w 1117
intention 1 w 1127
denotes 1 w 1135
shooting 2 w 1143
βολή 1 w 1148
and 6 w 1152
βούλεσθαι 1 w 1161
wish 1 w 1166
as 7 w 1170
well 1 w 1174
as 8 w 1176
βουλεύεσθαι 1 w 1187
plan 1 w 1192
denotes 2 w 1201
aiming 1 w 1207
at 14 w 1209
something 1 w 1218
All 1 w 1222
these 1 w 1227
words 1 w 1232
seem 1 w 1236
to 9 w 1238
follow 1 w 1244
δόξα 2 w 1248
and 7 w 1251
to 10 w 1253
express 1 w 1260
the 25 w 1263
idea 1 w 1267
of 10 w 1269
shooting 3 w 1277
just 2 w 1282
as 9 w 1284
ἀβουλία 1 w 1291
ill-advisedness 1 w 1307
on 10 w 1311
the 26 w 1314
other 1 w 1319
hand 1 w 1323
appears 2 w 1331
to 11 w 1333
be 4 w 1335
a 74 w 1336
failure 1 w 1343
to 12 w 1345
hit 1 w 1348
as 10 w 1351
if 2 w 1353
a 77 w 1354
person 1 w 1360
did 1 w 1363
not 5 w 1366
shoot 4 w 1371
or 14 w 1373
hit 2 w 1376
that 5 w 1380
which 6 w 1385
he 33 w 1387
shot 1 w 1391
at 16 w 1393
or 15 w 1395
wished 1 w 1401
or 16 w 1403
planned 1 w 1410
or 17 w 1412
desired 1 w 1419
Hermogenes 2 w 1430
I 1 w 1432
think 1 w 1437
you 3 w 1440
are 1 w 1443
hurrying 1 w 1451
things 3 w 1457
a 82 w 1458
bit 1 w 1461
Socrates 3 w 1470
Socrates 4 w 1479
Yes 1 w 1483
for 7 w 1487
I 2 w 1488
am 6 w 1490
running 1 w 1497
the 28 w 1500
last 1 w 1504
lap 1 w 1507
now 3 w 1510
But 1 w 1514
I 3 w 1515
think 2 w 1520
I 4 w 1521
must 1 w 1525
still 1 w 1530
explain 1 w 1537
ἀνάγκη 1 w 1543
compulsion 1 w 1554
and 9 w 1558
ἑκούσιον 1 w 1566
voluntary 1 w 1576
because 3 w 1584
they 1 w 1588
naturally 1 w 1597
come 1 w 1601
next 1 w 1605
Now 1 w 1609
by 1 w 1611
the 30 w 1614
word 3 w 1618
ἑκούσιον 2 w 1626
is 22 w 1628
expressed 1 w 1637
the 31 w 1640
yielding 1 w 1648
εἶκον 1 w 1654
and 10 w 1658
not 6 w 1661
opposing 1 w 1669
but 4 w 1673
as 12 w 1676
I 5 w 1677
say 1 w 1680
yielding 2 w 1689
to 13 w 1691
the 32 w 1694
motion 2 w 1700
which 7 w 1705
is 23 w 1707
in 34 w 1709
accordance 1 w 1719
with 4 w 1723
the 33 w 1726
will 1 w 1730
but 5 w 1734
the 34 w 1737
compulsory 1 w 1747
τὸ 1 w 1750
ἀναγκαῖον 1 w 1759
and 11 w 1763
resistant 1 w 1772
being 1 w 1778
contrary 1 w 1786
to 14 w 1788
the 35 w 1791
will 2 w 1795
is 25 w 1798
associated 1 w 1808
with 5 w 1812
error 1 w 1817
and 12 w 1820
ignorance 1 w 1829
so 11 w 1832
it 23 w 1834
is 26 w 1836
likened 1 w 1843
to 15 w 1845
walking 1 w 1852
through 4 w 1859
ravines 1 w 1866
ἄγκη 1 w 1871
because 4 w 1880
they 2 w 1884
are 2 w 1887
hard 1 w 1891
to 16 w 1893
traverse 1 w 1901
rough 5 w 1907
and 13 w 1911
rugged 1 w 1917
and 14 w 1921
retard 1 w 1927
motion 3 w 1933
the 37 w 1937
word 4 w 1941
ἀναγκαῖον 2 w 1950
may 1 w 1953
then 1 w 1958
originate 1 w 1968
in 39 w 1970
a 117 w 1971
comparison 1 w 1981
with 6 w 1985
progress 1 w 1993
through 5 w 2000
a 119 w 2001
ravine 2 w 2007
But 2 w 2011
let 1 w 2014
us 11 w 2016
not 7 w 2019
cease 1 w 2024
to 17 w 2026
use 6 w 2029
my 1 w 2031
strength 1 w 2039
so 13 w 2042
long 2 w 2046
as 15 w 2048
it 25 w 2050
lasts 1 w 2055
and 15 w 2058
do 1 w 2060
not 8 w 2063
you 4 w 2066
cease 2 w 2071
from 5 w 2075
asking 1 w 2081
questions 1 w 2090