Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Cratylus

Cratylus (419)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0059.tlg005.perseus-eng2:419
Refs {'start': {'reference': '419', 'human_reference': 'Section 419'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Socrates. But it does not, if you employ the ancient word,
419
419a
which is more likely to be right than the present one. You will find that it agrees with the previous words for good, if instead of the epsilon you restore the iota, as it was in old times for διόν (going through), not δέον, signifies good, which the name-giver praises. And so the giver of names does not contradict himself, but δέον (obligation, right), ὠφέλιμον (useful), λυσιτελοῦν (profitable), κερδαλέον (gainful), ἀγαθόν (good), ξυμφέρον (advantageous), and εὔπορον (prosperous), are plainly identical, signifying under different names the principle of arrangement and motion which has constantly been praised,
419b
whereas the principle of constraint and bondage is found fault with. And likewise in the case of ζημιῶδες, if you restore the ancient delta in place of the zeta, you will see that the name, pronounced δημιῶδες, was given to that which binds motion (δοῦντι τὸ ἰόν).

Hermogenes. What of ἡδονή (pleasure) and λύπη (pain) and ἐπιθυμία (desire), and the like, Socrates?

Socrates. I do not think they are at all difficult, Hermogenes, for ἡδονή appears to have this name because it is the action that tends towards advantage ( πρὸς τὴν ὄνησιν τείνουσα); the delta is inserted, so that we say ἡδονή instead of ἡονή.
419c
Λύπη appears to have received its name from the dissolution (διάλυσις) of the body which takes place through pain. Ἀνία (sorrow) is that which hinders motion (ἰέναι). Ἀλγηδών (distress) is, I think, a foreign word, derived from ἀλγεινός (distressing). Ὀδύνη (grief) appears to be so called from the putting on of pain (τῆς ἐνδύσεως τῆς λύπης). Ἀχθηδών (vexation) has a name, as anyone can see, made in the likeness of the weight (ἄχθος, burden) which vexation imposes upon motion. Χαρά (joy) seems to have its name from the plenteous diffusion (διάχυσις) of the flow of the soul.
419d
Τέρψις (delight) is from τερπνόν (delightful); and τερπνόν is called from the creeping (ἕρψις) of the soul, which is likened to a breath (πνοή), and would properly be called ἕρπνουν, but the name has been changed in course of time to τερπνόν. Εὐφροσύνη(mirth) needs no explanation, for it is clear to anyone that from the motion of the soul in harmony (εὖ) with the universe, it received the name εὐφεροσύνη, as it rightfully is; but we call it ευφροσύνη.
419e
Nor is there any difficulty about ἐπιθυμία (desire), for this name was evidently given to the power that goes (ἰοῦσα) into the soul (θυμός). And θυμός has its name from the raging (θύσις) and boiling of the soul.

Tokens

Socrates 1 w 8
But 1 w 12
it 1 w 14
does 1 w 18
not 1 w 21
if 1 w 24
you 1 w 27
employ 1 w 33
the 1 w 36
ancient 1 w 43
word 1 w 47
which 1 w 53
is 1 w 55
more 1 w 59
likely 1 w 65
to 1 w 67
be 1 w 69
right 1 w 74
than 1 w 78
the 2 w 81
present 1 w 88
one 1 w 91
You 1 w 95
will 1 w 99
find 1 w 103
that 1 w 107
it 2 w 109
agrees 1 w 115
with 1 w 119
the 3 w 122
previous 1 w 130
words 1 w 135
for 1 w 138
good 1 w 142
if 2 w 145
instead 1 w 152
of 1 w 154
the 4 w 157
epsilon 1 w 164
you 2 w 167
restore 1 w 174
the 5 w 177
iota 1 w 181
as 1 w 184
it 4 w 186
was 1 w 189
in 3 w 191
old 1 w 194
times 1 w 199
for 2 w 202
διόν 1 w 206
going 1 w 212
through 1 w 219
not 2 w 224
δέον 1 w 228
signifies 1 w 238
good 2 w 242
which 2 w 248
the 6 w 251
name-giver 1 w 261
praises 1 w 268
And 1 w 272
so 1 w 274
the 7 w 277
giver 2 w 282
of 2 w 284
names 1 w 289
does 2 w 293
not 3 w 296
contradict 1 w 306
himself 1 w 313
but 1 w 317
δέον 2 w 321
obligation 1 w 332
right 2 w 338
ὠφέλιμον 1 w 348
useful 1 w 355
λυσιτελοῦν 1 w 367
profitable 1 w 378
κερδαλέον 1 w 389
gainful 1 w 397
ἀγαθόν 1 w 405
good 3 w 410
ξυμφέρον 1 w 420
advantageous 1 w 433
and 1 w 438
εὔπορον 1 w 445
prosperous 1 w 456
are 1 w 461
plainly 1 w 468
identical 1 w 477
signifying 1 w 488
under 1 w 493
different 1 w 502
names 2 w 507
the 8 w 510
principle 1 w 519
of 4 w 521
arrangement 1 w 532
and 2 w 535
motion 1 w 541
which 3 w 546
has 1 w 549
constantly 1 w 559
been 1 w 563
praised 1 w 570
whereas 1 w 578
the 9 w 581
principle 2 w 590
of 5 w 592
constraint 1 w 602
and 3 w 605
bondage 1 w 612
is 4 w 614
found 1 w 619
fault 1 w 624
with 2 w 628
And 2 w 632
likewise 1 w 640
in 11 w 642
the 10 w 645
case 1 w 649
of 6 w 651
ζημιῶδες 1 w 659
if 6 w 662
you 3 w 665
restore 2 w 672
the 11 w 675
ancient 2 w 682
delta 1 w 687
in 12 w 689
place 1 w 694
of 7 w 696
the 12 w 699
zeta 1 w 703
you 4 w 707
will 2 w 711
see 1 w 714
that 2 w 718
the 13 w 721
name 4 w 725
pronounced 1 w 736
δημιῶδες 1 w 744
was 2 w 748
given 1 w 753
to 4 w 755
that 3 w 759
which 4 w 764
binds 1 w 769
motion 2 w 775
δοῦντι 1 w 782
τὸ 1 w 784
ἰόν 1 w 787
Hermogenes 1 w 799
What 1 w 804
of 8 w 806
ἡδονή 1 w 811
pleasure 1 w 820
and 4 w 824
λύπη 1 w 828
pain 1 w 833
and 5 w 837
ἐπιθυμία 1 w 845
desire 1 w 852
and 6 w 857
the 14 w 860
like 3 w 864
Socrates 2 w 873
Socrates 3 w 882
I 1 w 884
do 3 w 886
not 4 w 889
think 1 w 894
they 1 w 898
are 2 w 901
at 9 w 903
all 1 w 906
difficult 1 w 915
Hermogenes 2 w 926
for 3 w 930
ἡδονή 2 w 935
appears 1 w 942
to 5 w 944
have 1 w 948
this 1 w 952
name 5 w 956
because 1 w 963
it 7 w 965
is 7 w 967
the 16 w 970
action 1 w 976
that 4 w 980
tends 1 w 985
towards 1 w 992
advantage 2 w 1001
3 w 1003
πρὸς 1 w 1007
τὴν 1 w 1010
ὄνησιν 1 w 1016
τείνουσα 1 w 1024
the 17 w 1029
delta 2 w 1034
is 8 w 1036
inserted 1 w 1044
so 2 w 1047
that 5 w 1051
we 1 w 1053
say 1 w 1056
ἡδονή 3 w 1061
instead 2 w 1068
of 9 w 1070
ἡονή 1 w 1074
Λύπη 1 w 1079
appears 2 w 1086
to 7 w 1088
have 2 w 1092
received 1 w 1100
its 1 w 1103
name 6 w 1107
from 1 w 1111
the 18 w 1114
dissolution 1 w 1125
διάλυσις 1 w 1134
of 10 w 1137
the 19 w 1140
body 1 w 1144
which 5 w 1149
takes 1 w 1154
place 2 w 1159
through 2 w 1166
pain 2 w 1170
Ἀνία 1 w 1175
sorrow 1 w 1182
is 10 w 1185
that 6 w 1189
which 6 w 1194
hinders 1 w 1201
motion 3 w 1207
ἰέναι 1 w 1213
Ἀλγηδών 1 w 1222
distress 1 w 1231
is 12 w 1234
I 2 w 1236
think 2 w 1241
a 79 w 1243
foreign 1 w 1250
word 3 w 1254
derived 1 w 1262
from 2 w 1266
ἀλγεινός 1 w 1274
distressing 1 w 1286
Ὀδύνη 1 w 1293
grief 1 w 1299
appears 3 w 1307
to 8 w 1309
be 4 w 1311
so 5 w 1313
called 1 w 1319
from 3 w 1323
the 20 w 1326
putting 1 w 1333
on 14 w 1335
of 11 w 1337
pain 3 w 1341
τῆς 1 w 1345
ἐνδύσεως 1 w 1353
τῆς 2 w 1356
λύπης 1 w 1361
Ἀχθηδών 1 w 1370
vexation 1 w 1379
has 2 w 1383
a 86 w 1384
name 7 w 1388
as 9 w 1391
anyone 1 w 1397
can 1 w 1400
see 2 w 1403
made 1 w 1408
in 24 w 1410
the 21 w 1413
likeness 1 w 1421
of 12 w 1423
the 22 w 1426
weight 1 w 1432
ἄχθος 1 w 1438
burden 1 w 1445
which 7 w 1451
vexation 2 w 1459
imposes 1 w 1466
upon 1 w 1470
motion 4 w 1476
Χαρά 1 w 1481
joy 1 w 1485
seems 1 w 1491
to 9 w 1493
have 3 w 1497
its 2 w 1500
name 8 w 1504
from 4 w 1508
the 23 w 1511
plenteous 1 w 1520
diffusion 1 w 1529
διάχυσις 1 w 1538
of 13 w 1541
the 24 w 1544
flow 1 w 1548
of 14 w 1550
the 25 w 1553
soul 1 w 1557
Τέρψις 1 w 1564
delight 1 w 1572
is 14 w 1575
from 5 w 1579
τερπνόν 1 w 1586
delightful 1 w 1597
and 7 w 1602
τερπνόν 2 w 1609
is 15 w 1611
called 2 w 1617
from 6 w 1621
the 26 w 1624
creeping 1 w 1632
ἕρψις 1 w 1638
of 15 w 1641
the 27 w 1644
soul 2 w 1648
which 8 w 1654
is 16 w 1656
likened 1 w 1663
to 10 w 1665
a 97 w 1666
breath 1 w 1672
πνοή 1 w 1677
and 8 w 1682
would 1 w 1687
properly 1 w 1695
be 5 w 1697
called 3 w 1703
ἕρπνουν 1 w 1710
but 2 w 1714
the 28 w 1717
name 9 w 1721
has 3 w 1724
been 2 w 1728
changed 1 w 1735
in 26 w 1737
course 1 w 1743
of 16 w 1745
time 2 w 1749
to 11 w 1751
τερπνόν 3 w 1758
Εὐφροσύνη 1 w 1768
mirth 1 w 1774
needs 1 w 1780
no 6 w 1782
explanation 1 w 1793
for 5 w 1797
it 10 w 1799
is 17 w 1801
clear 1 w 1806
to 12 w 1808
anyone 2 w 1814
that 7 w 1818
from 7 w 1822
the 29 w 1825
motion 5 w 1831
of 17 w 1833
the 30 w 1836
soul 3 w 1840
in 27 w 1842
harmony 1 w 1849
εὖ 1 w 1852
with 3 w 1857
the 31 w 1860
universe 1 w 1868
it 12 w 1871
received 2 w 1879
the 32 w 1882
name 10 w 1886
εὐφεροσύνη 1 w 1896
as 11 w 1899
it 13 w 1901
rightfully 1 w 1911
is 18 w 1913
but 3 w 1917
we 3 w 1919
call 4 w 1923
it 14 w 1925
ευφροσύνη 1 w 1934
Nor 1 w 1938
is 19 w 1940
there 1 w 1945
any 3 w 1948
difficulty 1 w 1958
about 1 w 1963
ἐπιθυμία 2 w 1971
desire 2 w 1978
for 6 w 1983
this 2 w 1987
name 11 w 1991
was 3 w 1994
evidently 1 w 2003
given 2 w 2008
to 13 w 2010
the 34 w 2013
power 1 w 2018
that 8 w 2022
goes 1 w 2026
ἰοῦσα 1 w 2032
into 1 w 2037
the 35 w 2040
soul 4 w 2044
θυμός 1 w 2050
And 3 w 2055
θυμός 2 w 2060
has 4 w 2063
its 3 w 2066
name 12 w 2070
from 8 w 2074
the 36 w 2077
raging 1 w 2083
θύσις 1 w 2089
and 9 w 2093
boiling 1 w 2100
of 18 w 2102
the 37 w 2105
soul 5 w 2109