Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Apology

Apology (35)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0059.tlg002.perseus-eng2:35
Refs {'start': {'reference': '35', 'human_reference': 'Section 35'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

If then those of you who are supposed to be superior either in wisdom or in courage or in any other virtue whatsoever are to behave in such a way, it would be disgraceful. Why, I have often seen men who have some reputation behaving in the strangest manner, when they were on trial, as if they thought they were going to suffer something terrible if they were put to death, just as if they would be immortal if you did not kill them. It seems to me that they are a disgrace to the state and that any stranger might say that those of the Athenians who excel

35b
in virtue, men whom they themselves honor with offices and other marks of esteem, are no better than women. Such acts, men of Athens, we who have any reputation at all ought not to commit, and if we commit them you ought not to allow it, but you should make it clear that you will be much more ready to condemn a man who puts before you such pitiable scenes and makes the city ridiculous than one who keeps quiet.
But apart from the question of reputation, gentlemen, I think it is not right
35c
to implore the judge or to get acquitted by begging; we ought to inform and convince him. For the judge is not here to grant favors in matters of justice, but to give judgement; and his oath binds him not to do favors according to his pleasure, but to judge according to the laws; therefore, we ought not to get you into the habit of breaking your oaths, nor ought you to fall into that habit; for neither of us would be acting piously. Do not, therefore, men of Athens, demand of me that I act before you in a way which I consider neither honorable nor right nor pious,
35d
especially when impiety is the very thing for which Meletus here has brought me to trial. For it is plain that if by persuasion and supplication I forced you to break your oaths I should teach you to disbelieve in the existence of the gods and in making my defence should accuse myself of not believing in them. But that is far from the truth; for I do believe in them, men of Athens, more than any of my accusers, and I entrust my case to you and to God to decide it as shall be best for me and for you.

Tokens

If 1 w 2
then 1 w 6
those 1 w 11
of 1 w 13
you 1 w 16
who 1 w 19
are 1 w 22
supposed 1 w 30
to 1 w 32
be 1 w 34
superior 1 w 42
either 1 w 48
in 1 w 50
wisdom 1 w 56
or 2 w 58
in 2 w 60
courage 1 w 67
or 3 w 69
in 3 w 71
any 1 w 74
other 1 w 79
virtue 1 w 85
whatsoever 1 w 95
are 2 w 98
to 2 w 100
behave 1 w 106
in 4 w 108
such 1 w 112
a 7 w 113
way 1 w 116
it 2 w 119
would 1 w 124
be 3 w 126
disgraceful 1 w 137
Why 1 w 141
I 2 w 143
have 2 w 147
often 1 w 152
seen 1 w 156
men 1 w 159
who 2 w 162
have 3 w 166
some 1 w 170
reputation 1 w 180
behaving 1 w 188
in 6 w 190
the 4 w 193
strangest 1 w 202
manner 1 w 208
when 1 w 213
they 1 w 217
were 1 w 221
on 2 w 223
trial 1 w 228
as 1 w 231
if 1 w 233
they 2 w 237
thought 1 w 244
they 3 w 248
were 2 w 252
going 1 w 257
to 3 w 259
suffer 1 w 265
something 1 w 274
terrible 1 w 282
if 2 w 284
they 4 w 288
were 3 w 292
put 2 w 295
to 4 w 297
death 1 w 302
just 1 w 307
as 2 w 309
if 3 w 311
they 5 w 315
would 2 w 320
be 5 w 322
immortal 1 w 330
if 4 w 332
you 2 w 335
did 1 w 338
not 1 w 341
kill 1 w 345
them 1 w 349
It 1 w 352
seems 1 w 357
to 5 w 359
me 4 w 361
that 1 w 365
they 6 w 369
are 3 w 372
a 23 w 373
disgrace 2 w 381
to 6 w 383
the 12 w 386
state 1 w 391
and 1 w 394
that 2 w 398
any 2 w 401
stranger 1 w 409
might 1 w 414
say 1 w 417
that 3 w 421
those 2 w 426
of 3 w 428
the 13 w 431
Athenians 1 w 440
who 3 w 443
excel 1 w 448
in 9 w 450
virtue 2 w 456
men 2 w 460
whom 1 w 464
they 7 w 468
themselves 1 w 478
honor 1 w 483
with 1 w 487
offices 1 w 494
and 2 w 497
other 2 w 502
marks 1 w 507
of 5 w 509
esteem 1 w 515
are 4 w 519
no 3 w 521
better 1 w 527
than 1 w 531
women 1 w 536
Such 1 w 541
acts 1 w 545
men 4 w 549
of 6 w 551
Athens 1 w 557
we 4 w 560
who 5 w 563
have 4 w 567
any 3 w 570
reputation 2 w 580
at 9 w 582
all 1 w 585
ought 2 w 590
not 2 w 593
to 7 w 595
commit 1 w 601
and 3 w 605
if 5 w 607
we 5 w 609
commit 2 w 615
them 3 w 619
you 3 w 622
ought 3 w 627
not 3 w 630
to 8 w 632
allow 1 w 637
it 6 w 639
but 1 w 643
you 4 w 646
should 1 w 652
make 1 w 656
it 7 w 658
clear 1 w 663
that 4 w 667
you 5 w 670
will 1 w 674
be 7 w 676
much 1 w 680
more 1 w 684
ready 1 w 689
to 9 w 691
condemn 1 w 698
a 49 w 699
man 2 w 702
who 6 w 705
puts 1 w 709
before 1 w 715
you 6 w 718
such 2 w 722
pitiable 1 w 730
scenes 1 w 736
and 4 w 739
makes 1 w 744
the 20 w 747
city 1 w 751
ridiculous 1 w 761
than 2 w 765
one 1 w 768
who 7 w 771
keeps 1 w 776
quiet 1 w 781
But 1 w 785
apart 1 w 790
from 1 w 794
the 21 w 797
question 1 w 805
of 7 w 807
reputation 3 w 817
gentlemen 1 w 827
I 4 w 829
think 1 w 834
it 10 w 836
is 4 w 838
not 4 w 841
right 1 w 846
to 10 w 848
implore 1 w 855
the 22 w 858
judge 1 w 863
or 9 w 865
to 11 w 867
get 1 w 870
acquitted 1 w 879
by 1 w 881
begging 1 w 888
we 6 w 891
ought 4 w 896
to 12 w 898
inform 1 w 904
and 5 w 907
convince 1 w 915
him 1 w 918
For 1 w 922
the 23 w 925
judge 2 w 930
is 5 w 932
not 5 w 935
here 1 w 939
to 13 w 941
grant 1 w 946
favors 1 w 952
in 14 w 954
matters 1 w 961
of 8 w 963
justice 1 w 970
but 2 w 974
to 14 w 976
give 1 w 980
judgement 1 w 989
and 6 w 993
his 1 w 996
oath 1 w 1000
binds 1 w 1005
him 2 w 1008
not 6 w 1011
to 15 w 1013
do 2 w 1015
favors 2 w 1021
according 1 w 1030
to 16 w 1032
his 2 w 1035
pleasure 1 w 1043
but 3 w 1047
to 17 w 1049
judge 4 w 1054
according 2 w 1063
to 18 w 1065
the 24 w 1068
laws 1 w 1072
therefore 1 w 1082
we 7 w 1085
ought 5 w 1090
not 7 w 1093
to 19 w 1095
get 2 w 1098
you 7 w 1101
into 1 w 1105
the 26 w 1108
habit 1 w 1113
of 9 w 1115
breaking 1 w 1123
your 1 w 1127
oaths 1 w 1132
nor 2 w 1136
ought 6 w 1141
you 9 w 1144
to 21 w 1146
fall 1 w 1150
into 2 w 1154
that 5 w 1158
habit 2 w 1163
for 4 w 1167
neither 1 w 1174
of 10 w 1176
us 4 w 1178
would 3 w 1183
be 10 w 1185
acting 1 w 1191
piously 1 w 1198
Do 1 w 1201
not 8 w 1204
therefore 2 w 1214
men 7 w 1218
of 11 w 1220
Athens 2 w 1226
demand 1 w 1233
of 12 w 1235
me 11 w 1237
that 6 w 1241
I 5 w 1242
act 3 w 1245
before 2 w 1251
you 10 w 1254
in 22 w 1256
a 80 w 1257
way 2 w 1260
which 1 w 1265
I 6 w 1266
consider 1 w 1274
neither 2 w 1281
honorable 1 w 1290
nor 4 w 1293
right 2 w 1298
nor 5 w 1301
pious 2 w 1306
especially 1 w 1317
when 2 w 1321
impiety 1 w 1328
is 8 w 1330
the 31 w 1333
very 1 w 1337
thing 2 w 1342
for 7 w 1345
which 2 w 1350
Meletus 1 w 1357
here 4 w 1361
has 1 w 1364
brought 1 w 1371
me 12 w 1373
to 23 w 1375
trial 2 w 1380
For 2 w 1384
it 16 w 1386
is 9 w 1388
plain 1 w 1393
that 7 w 1397
if 6 w 1399
by 2 w 1401
persuasion 1 w 1411
and 8 w 1414
supplication 1 w 1426
I 7 w 1427
forced 1 w 1433
you 11 w 1436
to 24 w 1438
break 2 w 1443
your 2 w 1447
oaths 2 w 1452
I 8 w 1453
should 2 w 1459
teach 1 w 1464
you 13 w 1467
to 25 w 1469
disbelieve 1 w 1479
in 25 w 1481
the 32 w 1484
existence 1 w 1493
of 13 w 1495
the 33 w 1498
gods 1 w 1502
and 9 w 1505
in 26 w 1507
making 1 w 1513
my 1 w 1515
defence 1 w 1522
should 3 w 1528
accuse 1 w 1534
myself 1 w 1540
of 14 w 1542
not 9 w 1545
believing 1 w 1554
in 29 w 1556
them 4 w 1560
But 2 w 1564
that 8 w 1568
is 12 w 1570
far 1 w 1573
from 2 w 1577
the 35 w 1580
truth 1 w 1585
for 9 w 1589
I 9 w 1590
do 3 w 1592
believe 2 w 1599
in 30 w 1601
them 5 w 1605
men 8 w 1609
of 15 w 1611
Athens 3 w 1617
more 2 w 1622
than 3 w 1626
any 4 w 1629
of 16 w 1631
my 3 w 1633
accusers 1 w 1641
and 10 w 1645
I 10 w 1646
entrust 1 w 1653
my 4 w 1655
case 1 w 1659
to 26 w 1661
you 14 w 1664
and 11 w 1667
to 27 w 1669
God 1 w 1672
to 28 w 1674
decide 1 w 1680
it 17 w 1682
as 7 w 1684
shall 1 w 1689
be 15 w 1691
best 1 w 1695
for 10 w 1698
me 14 w 1700
and 12 w 1703
for 11 w 1706
you 15 w 1709