Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Plutarch's Platonic questions

Plutarch's Platonic questions (9.2)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg133.perseus-eng2:9.2
Refs {'start': {'reference': '9.2', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 9 Section 2'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '9'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

But it may be ridiculous to describe the first, middle, and last by their place; since we see hypate highest in the harp, lowest in the pipe; and wheresoever you place the mese in the harp, provided it is tunable, it sounds more acute than hypate, and more grave than nete. Nor does the eye possess the same place in all animals; but whereever it is placed, it is natural for it to see. So a pedagogue, though he goes not foremost but follows behind, is said to lead (ἄγειν), as the general of the Trojan army,

Now in the front, now in the rear was seen,
And kept command;
[*]
but wherever he was, he was first and chief in power. So the faculties of the soul are not to be ranged by mere force in order of place or name, but according to their
power and analogy. For that in the body of man reason is in the highest place, is accidental. But it holds the chief and highest power, as mese to hypate, in respect of the concupiscent; as mese to nete, in respect of the irascible; insomuch as it depresses and heightens,—and in fine makes a harmony,—by abating what is too much and by not suffering them to flatten and grow dull. For what is moderate and symmetrous is defined by mediocrity. Still more is it the object of the rational faculty to reduce the passions to moderation, which is called sacred, as effecting a harmony of the extremes with reason, and through reason with each other. For in chariots the best of the beasts is not in the middle; nor is the skill of driving to be placed as an extreme, but it is a mediocrity between the inequality of the swiftness and the slowness of the horses. So the force of reason takes up the passions irrationally moved, and reducing them to measure, constitutes a mediocrity betwixt too much and too little.

Tokens

But 1 w 3
it 1 w 5
may 1 w 8
be 1 w 10
ridiculous 1 w 20
to 1 w 22
describe 1 w 30
the 1 w 33
first 1 w 38
middle 1 w 45
and 1 w 49
last 1 w 53
by 1 w 55
their 1 w 60
place 1 w 65
since 1 w 71
we 1 w 73
see 1 w 76
hypate 1 w 82
highest 1 w 89
in 2 w 91
the 3 w 94
harp 1 w 98
lowest 1 w 105
in 3 w 107
the 4 w 110
pipe 1 w 114
and 2 w 118
wheresoever 1 w 129
you 1 w 132
place 2 w 137
the 5 w 140
mese 1 w 144
in 4 w 146
the 6 w 149
harp 2 w 153
provided 1 w 162
it 2 w 164
is 1 w 166
tunable 1 w 173
it 3 w 176
sounds 1 w 182
more 1 w 186
acute 1 w 191
than 1 w 195
hypate 2 w 201
and 3 w 205
more 2 w 209
grave 1 w 214
than 2 w 218
nete 1 w 222
Nor 1 w 226
does 1 w 230
the 7 w 233
eye 1 w 236
possess 1 w 243
the 8 w 246
same 1 w 250
place 3 w 255
in 5 w 257
all 1 w 260
animals 1 w 267
but 1 w 271
whereever 1 w 280
it 4 w 282
is 2 w 284
placed 1 w 290
it 5 w 293
is 3 w 295
natural 1 w 302
for 1 w 305
it 6 w 307
to 2 w 309
see 2 w 312
So 1 w 315
a 25 w 316
pedagogue 1 w 325
though 1 w 332
he 12 w 334
goes 1 w 338
not 1 w 341
foremost 1 w 349
but 2 w 352
follows 1 w 359
behind 1 w 365
is 4 w 368
said 1 w 372
to 3 w 374
lead 1 w 378
ἄγειν 1 w 384
as 2 w 388
the 9 w 391
general 1 w 398
of 1 w 400
the 10 w 403
Trojan 1 w 409
army 1 w 413
Now 1 w 417
in 7 w 419
the 11 w 422
front 1 w 427
now 1 w 431
in 8 w 433
the 12 w 436
rear 1 w 440
was 1 w 443
seen 1 w 447
And 1 w 451
kept 1 w 455
command 1 w 462
Il 1 w 465
XI 1 w 468
64 1 w 471
but 3 w 475
wherever 1 w 483
he 18 w 485
was 2 w 488
he 19 w 491
was 3 w 494
first 2 w 499
and 5 w 502
chief 1 w 507
in 9 w 509
power 1 w 514
So 2 w 517
the 13 w 520
faculties 1 w 529
of 2 w 531
the 14 w 534
soul 1 w 538
are 1 w 541
not 2 w 544
to 4 w 546
be 4 w 548
ranged 1 w 554
by 2 w 556
mere 1 w 560
force 1 w 565
in 10 w 567
order 1 w 572
of 3 w 574
place 5 w 579
or 8 w 581
name 1 w 585
but 4 w 589
according 1 w 598
to 5 w 600
their 2 w 605
power 2 w 610
and 6 w 613
analogy 1 w 620
For 1 w 624
that 1 w 628
in 12 w 630
the 16 w 633
body 1 w 637
of 4 w 639
man 2 w 642
reason 1 w 648
is 5 w 650
in 13 w 652
the 17 w 655
highest 2 w 662
place 6 w 667
is 6 w 670
accidental 1 w 680
But 2 w 684
it 7 w 686
holds 1 w 691
the 18 w 694
chief 2 w 699
and 7 w 702
highest 3 w 709
power 3 w 714
as 7 w 717
mese 2 w 721
to 6 w 723
hypate 3 w 729
in 14 w 732
respect 1 w 739
of 5 w 741
the 19 w 744
concupiscent 1 w 756
as 8 w 759
mese 3 w 763
to 7 w 765
nete 2 w 769
in 15 w 772
respect 2 w 779
of 6 w 781
the 20 w 784
irascible 1 w 793
insomuch 1 w 802
as 10 w 804
it 8 w 806
depresses 1 w 815
and 8 w 818
heightens 1 w 827
and 9 w 832
in 17 w 834
fine 1 w 838
makes 1 w 843
a 63 w 844
harmony 1 w 851
by 3 w 855
abating 1 w 862
what 1 w 866
is 8 w 868
too 1 w 871
much 2 w 875
and 10 w 878
by 4 w 880
not 3 w 883
suffering 1 w 892
them 1 w 896
to 9 w 898
flatten 1 w 905
and 11 w 908
grow 1 w 912
dull 1 w 916
For 2 w 920
what 2 w 924
is 9 w 926
moderate 1 w 934
and 12 w 937
symmetrous 1 w 947
is 10 w 949
defined 1 w 956
by 5 w 958
mediocrity 1 w 968
Still 1 w 974
more 3 w 978
is 11 w 980
it 10 w 982
the 22 w 985
object 1 w 991
of 7 w 993
the 23 w 996
rational 1 w 1004
faculty 1 w 1011
to 10 w 1013
reduce 1 w 1019
the 24 w 1022
passions 1 w 1030
to 11 w 1032
moderation 1 w 1042
which 1 w 1048
is 12 w 1050
called 1 w 1056
sacred 1 w 1062
as 12 w 1065
effecting 1 w 1074
a 82 w 1075
harmony 2 w 1082
of 8 w 1084
the 25 w 1087
extremes 1 w 1095
with 1 w 1099
reason 2 w 1105
and 13 w 1109
through 1 w 1116
reason 3 w 1122
with 2 w 1126
each 1 w 1130
other 1 w 1135
For 3 w 1139
in 23 w 1141
chariots 1 w 1149
the 27 w 1152
best 1 w 1156
of 9 w 1158
the 28 w 1161
beasts 1 w 1167
is 13 w 1169
not 4 w 1172
in 24 w 1174
the 29 w 1177
middle 2 w 1183
nor 1 w 1187
is 14 w 1189
the 30 w 1192
skill 1 w 1197
of 10 w 1199
driving 1 w 1206
to 12 w 1208
be 7 w 1210
placed 2 w 1216
as 16 w 1218
an 21 w 1220
extreme 2 w 1227
but 5 w 1231
it 13 w 1233
is 15 w 1235
a 93 w 1236
mediocrity 2 w 1246
between 1 w 1253
the 31 w 1256
inequality 1 w 1266
of 11 w 1268
the 32 w 1271
swiftness 1 w 1280
and 14 w 1283
the 33 w 1286
slowness 1 w 1294
of 12 w 1296
the 34 w 1299
horses 1 w 1305
So 3 w 1308
the 35 w 1311
force 2 w 1316
of 13 w 1318
reason 4 w 1324
takes 1 w 1329
up 2 w 1331
the 36 w 1334
passions 2 w 1342
irrationally 1 w 1354
moved 1 w 1359
and 15 w 1363
reducing 1 w 1371
them 2 w 1375
to 13 w 1377
measure 1 w 1384
constitutes 1 w 1396
a 103 w 1397
mediocrity 3 w 1407
betwixt 1 w 1414
too 2 w 1417
much 3 w 1421
and 16 w 1424
too 3 w 1427
little 1 w 1433