Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Plutarch's Platonic questions

Plutarch's Platonic questions (10.1)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg133.perseus-eng2:10.1
Refs {'start': {'reference': '10.1', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 10 Section 1'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '10'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

WHY SAID PLATO, THAT SPEECH WAS COMPOSED OF NOUNS AND VERBS?[*]

For he seems to make no other parts of speech but them. But Homer in a sportive humor has comprehended them all in one verse:

Αὐτός ἰὼν κλισίηνδε τὸ σὸν γέρας, ὄφρ εὖ εἰδῇς.
[*]
For in it there is pronoun, participle, noun, preposition, article, conjunction, adverb, and verb, the particle -δε being put instead of the preposition εἰς; for κλισίηνδε, to the tent, is said in the same sense as Ἀθηνάζε to Athens. What then shall we say for Plato?

Is it that at first the ancients called that λόγος, or speech, which once was called protasis and now is called axiom or proposition,—which as soon as a man speaks, he speaks either true or false? This consists of a noun and verb, which logicians call the subject and predicate. For when we hear this said, Socrates philosophizeth or Socrates is changed, requiring nothing more, we say the one is true, the other false. For very likely in the beginning men wanted speech and articulate voice, to enable them to express clearly at once the passions and the patients, the actions and the agents. Now, since actions and affections are sufficiently expressed by verbs, and they that act and are affected by nouns, as he says, these seem to signify. And one may say, the rest signify not. For instance, the groans and shrieks of stage-players, and even their smiles and reticence, make their discourse more emphatic. But they have no necessary power to signify any thing, as a noun and verb have, but only an ascititious power to vary speech; just as they vary letters who mark spirits and quantities upon letters, these being the accidents and differences of letters. This the ancients have made manifest, whom sixteen letters sufficed to speak and write any thing.

Tokens

WHY 1 w 3
SAID 1 w 7
PLATO 1 w 12
THAT 1 w 17
SPEECH 1 w 23
WAS 1 w 26
COMPOSED 1 w 34
OF 1 w 36
NOUNS 1 w 41
AND 1 w 44
VERBS 1 w 49
Plato 1 w 55
s 1 w 57
Sophist 1 w 64
p 2 w 66
262 1 w 70
A 6 w 71
For 1 w 75
he 1 w 77
seems 1 w 82
to 2 w 84
make 1 w 88
no 1 w 90
other 1 w 95
parts 1 w 100
of 1 w 102
speech 1 w 108
but 1 w 111
them 1 w 115
But 1 w 119
Homer 1 w 124
in 1 w 126
a 4 w 127
sportive 1 w 135
humor 1 w 140
has 1 w 143
comprehended 1 w 155
them 2 w 159
all 1 w 162
in 2 w 164
one 1 w 167
verse 1 w 172
Αὐτός 1 w 178
ἰὼν 1 w 181
κλισίηνδε 1 w 190
τὸ 1 w 192
σὸν 1 w 195
γέρας 1 w 200
ὄφρ 1 w 204
εὖ 1 w 206
εἰδῇς 1 w 211
Il 1 w 214
I 3 w 216
185 1 w 220
For 2 w 224
in 3 w 226
it 1 w 228
there 1 w 233
is 2 w 235
pronoun 1 w 242
participle 1 w 253
noun 2 w 258
preposition 1 w 270
article 1 w 278
conjunction 1 w 290
adverb 1 w 297
and 1 w 301
verb 2 w 305
the 5 w 309
particle 1 w 317
δε 2 w 320
being 1 w 325
put 1 w 328
instead 1 w 335
of 2 w 337
the 6 w 340
preposition 2 w 351
εἰς 1 w 354
for 1 w 358
κλισίηνδε 2 w 367
to 3 w 370
the 7 w 373
tent 1 w 377
is 3 w 380
said 1 w 384
in 6 w 386
the 8 w 389
same 1 w 393
sense 1 w 398
as 2 w 400
Ἀθηνάζε 1 w 407
to 4 w 409
Athens 1 w 415
What 1 w 420
then 2 w 424
shall 1 w 429
we 1 w 431
say 1 w 434
for 2 w 437
Plato 2 w 442
Is 1 w 445
it 4 w 447
that 1 w 451
at 5 w 453
first 1 w 458
the 11 w 461
ancients 1 w 469
called 1 w 475
that 2 w 479
λόγος 1 w 484
or 7 w 487
speech 2 w 493
which 1 w 499
once 1 w 503
was 1 w 506
called 2 w 512
protasis 1 w 520
and 2 w 523
now 1 w 526
is 5 w 528
called 3 w 534
axiom 1 w 539
or 8 w 541
proposition 1 w 552
which 2 w 559
as 5 w 561
soon 1 w 565
as 6 w 567
a 33 w 568
man 1 w 571
speaks 1 w 577
he 14 w 580
speaks 2 w 586
either 1 w 592
true 1 w 596
or 9 w 598
false 1 w 603
This 1 w 608
consists 1 w 616
of 3 w 618
a 38 w 619
noun 3 w 623
and 3 w 626
verb 3 w 630
which 3 w 636
logicians 1 w 645
call 4 w 649
the 13 w 652
subject 1 w 659
and 4 w 662
predicate 1 w 671
For 3 w 675
when 1 w 679
we 2 w 681
hear 1 w 685
this 1 w 689
said 2 w 693
Socrates 1 w 702
philosophizeth 1 w 716
or 11 w 718
Socrates 2 w 726
is 9 w 728
changed 1 w 735
requiring 1 w 745
nothing 1 w 752
more 1 w 756
we 3 w 759
say 2 w 762
the 14 w 765
one 2 w 768
is 10 w 770
true 2 w 774
the 15 w 778
other 2 w 783
false 2 w 788
For 4 w 792
very 1 w 796
likely 1 w 802
in 9 w 804
the 17 w 807
beginning 1 w 816
men 1 w 819
wanted 1 w 825
speech 3 w 831
and 5 w 834
articulate 1 w 844
voice 1 w 849
to 6 w 852
enable 1 w 858
them 3 w 862
to 7 w 864
express 1 w 871
clearly 1 w 878
at 11 w 880
once 2 w 884
the 19 w 887
passions 1 w 895
and 6 w 898
the 20 w 901
patients 1 w 909
the 21 w 913
actions 1 w 920
and 7 w 923
the 22 w 926
agents 1 w 932
Now 1 w 936
since 1 w 942
actions 2 w 949
and 8 w 952
affections 1 w 962
are 1 w 965
sufficiently 1 w 977
expressed 1 w 986
by 1 w 988
verbs 1 w 993
and 9 w 997
they 1 w 1001
that 3 w 1005
act 3 w 1008
and 10 w 1011
are 2 w 1014
affected 1 w 1022
by 2 w 1024
nouns 1 w 1029
as 8 w 1032
he 29 w 1034
says 1 w 1038
these 1 w 1044
seem 2 w 1048
to 8 w 1050
signify 1 w 1057
And 1 w 1061
one 3 w 1064
may 1 w 1067
say 4 w 1070
the 25 w 1074
rest 1 w 1078
signify 2 w 1085
not 2 w 1088
For 5 w 1092
instance 1 w 1100
the 26 w 1104
groans 1 w 1110
and 11 w 1113
shrieks 1 w 1120
of 4 w 1122
stage-players 1 w 1135
and 12 w 1139
even 1 w 1143
their 1 w 1148
smiles 1 w 1154
and 13 w 1157
reticence 1 w 1166
make 2 w 1171
their 2 w 1176
discourse 1 w 1185
more 2 w 1189
emphatic 1 w 1197
But 2 w 1201
they 2 w 1205
have 1 w 1209
no 9 w 1211
necessary 1 w 1220
power 1 w 1225
to 9 w 1227
signify 3 w 1234
any 1 w 1237
thing 2 w 1242
as 9 w 1245
a 91 w 1246
noun 5 w 1250
and 14 w 1253
verb 5 w 1257
have 2 w 1261
but 2 w 1265
only 1 w 1269
an 23 w 1271
ascititious 1 w 1282
power 2 w 1287
to 10 w 1289
vary 1 w 1293
speech 4 w 1299
just 1 w 1304
as 11 w 1306
they 3 w 1310
vary 2 w 1314
letters 1 w 1321
who 1 w 1324
mark 1 w 1328
spirits 1 w 1335
and 15 w 1338
quantities 1 w 1348
upon 1 w 1352
letters 2 w 1359
these 2 w 1365
being 2 w 1370
the 32 w 1373
accidents 1 w 1382
and 16 w 1385
differences 1 w 1396
of 5 w 1398
letters 3 w 1405
This 2 w 1410
the 33 w 1413
ancients 2 w 1421
have 3 w 1425
made 1 w 1429
manifest 1 w 1437
whom 1 w 1442
sixteen 1 w 1449
letters 4 w 1456
sufficed 1 w 1464
to 11 w 1466
speak 3 w 1471
and 17 w 1474
write 1 w 1479
any 2 w 1482
thing 3 w 1487