Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Plutarch's Platonic questions

Plutarch's Platonic questions (10.4)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg133.perseus-eng2:10.4
Refs {'start': {'reference': '10.4', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 10 Section 4'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '10'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Now neither an animal nor an instrument nor arms nor any thing else is more fine, efficacious, or graceful, for the loss of a part. Yet speech, by taking away conjunctions, often becomes more persuasive, as here:

One reard a dagger at a captives breast;
One held a living foe, that freshly bled
With new-made wounds; another draggd a dead.
[*]
And this of Demosthenes:

A bully in an assault may do much which his victim cannot even describe to another person,—by his mien, his look, his voice,—when he stings by insult, when he attacks as an avowed enemy, when he smites with his fist, when he gives a blow on the face. These rouse a man; these make a man beside himself who is unused to such foul abuse.

And again:

Not so with Midias; but from the very day, he talks, he abuses, he shouts. Is there an election of magistrates?

Midias the Anagyrrasian is nominated. He is the advocate of Plutarchus; he knows state secrets; the city cannot contain him.[*]

Therefore the figure asyndeton, whereby conjunctions are omitted, is highly commended by writers of rhetoric. But such as keep overstrict to the law, and (according to custom) omit not a conjunction, rhetoricians blame for using a dull, flat, tedious style, without any variety in it. And inasmuch as logicians mightily want conjunctions for the joining together their axioms, as much as charioteers want yokes, and Ulysses wanted withs to tie Cyclops sheep; this shows they are not parts of speech, but a conjunctive instrument thereof, as the word conjunction imports. Nor do conjunctions join all, but only such as are not spoken simply; unless you will make a cord part of the burthen, glue a part of a book, or distribution of money part of the government. For Demades says, that money which is given to the people out of the exchequer for public shows is the glue of a democracy. Now what conjunction does so of several propositions make one, by knitting and joining them together, as marble joins iron that is melted with it in the fire Yet the marble neither is nor is said to be part of the iron; although in this case the substances enter into the mixture and are melted together, so as to form a common substance from many and to be mutually affected. But there be some who think that conjunctions do not make any thing one, but that this kind of discourse is merely an enumeration, as when magistrates or days are reckoned in order.

Tokens

Now 1 w 3
neither 1 w 10
an 1 w 12
animal 1 w 18
nor 1 w 21
an 3 w 23
instrument 1 w 33
nor 2 w 36
arms 1 w 40
nor 3 w 43
any 1 w 46
thing 1 w 51
else 1 w 55
is 1 w 57
more 1 w 61
fine 1 w 65
efficacious 1 w 77
or 5 w 80
graceful 1 w 88
for 1 w 92
the 2 w 95
loss 1 w 99
of 1 w 101
a 9 w 102
part 1 w 106
Yet 1 w 110
speech 1 w 116
by 1 w 119
taking 1 w 125
away 1 w 129
conjunctions 1 w 141
often 1 w 147
becomes 1 w 154
more 2 w 158
persuasive 1 w 168
as 2 w 171
here 1 w 175
One 1 w 179
rear 1 w 183
d 1 w 185
a 17 w 186
dagger 1 w 192
at 1 w 194
a 20 w 195
captive 1 w 202
s 14 w 204
breast 1 w 210
One 2 w 214
held 1 w 218
a 23 w 219
living 1 w 225
foe 1 w 228
that 1 w 233
freshly 1 w 240
bled 1 w 244
With 1 w 248
new-made 1 w 256
wounds 1 w 262
another 1 w 270
dragg 1 w 275
d 8 w 277
a 28 w 278
dead 1 w 282
Il 1 w 285
XVIII 1 w 291
536 1 w 295
And 1 w 299
this 1 w 303
of 3 w 305
Demosthenes 1 w 316
A 2 w 318
bully 1 w 323
in 6 w 325
an 6 w 327
assault 1 w 334
may 1 w 337
do 1 w 339
much 1 w 343
which 1 w 348
his 2 w 351
victim 1 w 357
cannot 1 w 363
even 1 w 367
describe 1 w 375
to 1 w 377
another 2 w 384
person 1 w 390
by 2 w 394
his 3 w 397
mien 1 w 401
his 4 w 405
look 1 w 409
his 5 w 413
voice 1 w 418
when 1 w 424
he 9 w 426
stings 1 w 432
by 3 w 434
insult 1 w 440
when 2 w 445
he 11 w 447
attacks 1 w 454
as 5 w 456
an 9 w 458
avowed 1 w 464
enemy 1 w 469
when 3 w 474
he 13 w 476
smites 1 w 482
with 1 w 486
his 6 w 489
fist 1 w 493
when 4 w 498
he 15 w 500
gives 1 w 505
a 41 w 506
blow 1 w 510
on 4 w 512
the 6 w 515
face 1 w 519
These 1 w 525
rouse 1 w 530
a 43 w 531
man 1 w 534
these 1 w 540
make 1 w 544
a 46 w 545
man 2 w 548
beside 1 w 554
himself 1 w 561
who 1 w 564
is 9 w 566
unused 1 w 572
to 2 w 574
such 1 w 578
foul 1 w 582
abuse 1 w 587
And 2 w 591
again 1 w 596
Not 1 w 600
so 2 w 602
with 2 w 606
Midias 1 w 612
but 1 w 616
from 1 w 620
the 8 w 623
very 1 w 627
day 1 w 630
he 20 w 633
talks 1 w 638
he 21 w 641
abuses 1 w 647
he 22 w 650
shouts 1 w 656
Is 1 w 659
there 1 w 664
an 12 w 666
election 1 w 674
of 4 w 676
magistrates 1 w 687
Midias 2 w 694
the 10 w 697
Anagyrrasian 1 w 709
is 11 w 711
nominated 1 w 720
He 1 w 723
is 12 w 725
the 11 w 728
advocate 1 w 736
of 5 w 738
Plutarchus 1 w 748
he 26 w 751
knows 1 w 756
state 1 w 761
secrets 1 w 768
the 12 w 772
city 1 w 776
cannot 2 w 782
contain 1 w 789
him 2 w 792
Demosthenes 2 w 804
against 1 w 811
Midias 3 w 817
p 6 w 819
537 1 w 823
25 1 w 826
and 1 w 830
p 7 w 831
578 1 w 835
29 1 w 838
Therefore 1 w 848
the 14 w 851
figure 1 w 857
asyndeton 1 w 866
whereby 1 w 874
conjunctions 2 w 886
are 1 w 889
omitted 1 w 896
is 13 w 899
highly 1 w 905
commended 1 w 914
by 5 w 916
writers 1 w 923
of 6 w 925
rhetoric 1 w 933
But 1 w 937
such 2 w 941
as 11 w 943
keep 1 w 947
overstrict 1 w 957
to 5 w 959
the 15 w 962
law 1 w 965
and 2 w 969
according 1 w 979
to 6 w 981
custom 1 w 987
omit 2 w 992
not 5 w 995
a 79 w 996
conjunction 3 w 1007
rhetoricians 1 w 1020
blame 1 w 1025
for 3 w 1028
using 1 w 1033
a 82 w 1034
dull 1 w 1038
flat 1 w 1043
tedious 1 w 1051
style 1 w 1056
without 1 w 1064
any 2 w 1067
variety 1 w 1074
in 15 w 1076
it 11 w 1078
And 3 w 1082
inasmuch 1 w 1090
as 13 w 1092
logicians 1 w 1101
mightily 1 w 1109
want 1 w 1113
conjunctions 3 w 1125
for 4 w 1128
the 16 w 1131
joining 1 w 1138
together 1 w 1146
their 1 w 1151
axioms 1 w 1157
as 14 w 1160
much 3 w 1164
as 15 w 1166
charioteers 1 w 1177
want 2 w 1181
yokes 1 w 1186
and 3 w 1190
Ulysses 1 w 1197
wanted 1 w 1203
withs 1 w 1208
to 10 w 1210
tie 1 w 1213
Cyclop 1 w 1219
s 96 w 1221
sheep 1 w 1226
this 2 w 1231
shows 1 w 1236
they 1 w 1240
are 2 w 1243
not 6 w 1246
parts 1 w 1251
of 7 w 1253
speech 2 w 1259
but 2 w 1263
a 99 w 1264
conjunctive 1 w 1275
instrument 2 w 1285
thereof 1 w 1292
as 16 w 1295
the 21 w 1298
word 1 w 1302
conjunction 5 w 1313
imports 1 w 1320
Nor 1 w 1324
do 2 w 1326
conjunctions 4 w 1338
join 2 w 1342
all 1 w 1345
but 3 w 1349
only 1 w 1353
such 3 w 1357
as 17 w 1359
are 3 w 1362
not 7 w 1365
spoken 1 w 1371
simply 1 w 1377
unless 1 w 1384
you 1 w 1387
will 1 w 1391
make 2 w 1395
a 105 w 1396
cord 2 w 1400
part 3 w 1404
of 9 w 1406
the 22 w 1409
burthen 1 w 1416
glue 1 w 1421
a 107 w 1422
part 4 w 1426
of 10 w 1428
a 109 w 1429
book 1 w 1433
or 18 w 1436
distribution 1 w 1448
of 11 w 1450
money 1 w 1455
part 5 w 1459
of 12 w 1461
the 24 w 1464
government 1 w 1474
For 1 w 1478
Demades 1 w 1485
says 1 w 1489
that 2 w 1494
money 2 w 1499
which 2 w 1504
is 16 w 1506
given 1 w 1511
to 11 w 1513
the 25 w 1516
people 1 w 1522
out 3 w 1525
of 13 w 1527
the 26 w 1530
exchequer 1 w 1539
for 5 w 1542
public 1 w 1548
shows 2 w 1553
is 17 w 1555
the 27 w 1558
glue 2 w 1562
of 14 w 1564
a 114 w 1565
democracy 1 w 1574
Now 2 w 1578
what 1 w 1582
conjunction 7 w 1593
does 1 w 1597
so 3 w 1599
of 15 w 1601
several 1 w 1608
propositions 1 w 1620
make 3 w 1624
one 3 w 1627
by 6 w 1630
knitting 1 w 1638
and 4 w 1641
joining 2 w 1648
them 1 w 1652
together 2 w 1660
as 18 w 1663
marble 1 w 1669
joins 1 w 1674
iron 1 w 1678
that 3 w 1682
is 18 w 1684
melted 1 w 1690
with 5 w 1694
it 16 w 1696
in 25 w 1698
the 30 w 1701
fire 1 w 1705
Yet 2 w 1708
the 31 w 1711
marble 2 w 1717
neither 2 w 1724
is 19 w 1726
nor 4 w 1729
is 20 w 1731
said 1 w 1735
to 13 w 1737
be 4 w 1739
part 6 w 1743
of 16 w 1745
the 33 w 1748
iron 2 w 1752
although 1 w 1761
in 26 w 1763
this 3 w 1767
case 1 w 1771
the 34 w 1774
substances 1 w 1784
enter 1 w 1789
into 1 w 1793
the 35 w 1796
mixture 1 w 1803
and 5 w 1806
are 4 w 1809
melted 2 w 1815
together 3 w 1823
so 4 w 1826
as 20 w 1828
to 16 w 1830
form 1 w 1834
a 132 w 1835
common 1 w 1841
substance 2 w 1850
from 2 w 1854
many 1 w 1858
and 6 w 1861
to 17 w 1863
be 5 w 1865
mutually 1 w 1873
affected 1 w 1881
But 2 w 1885
there 3 w 1890
be 6 w 1892
some 1 w 1896
who 2 w 1899
think 1 w 1904
that 4 w 1908
conjunctions 5 w 1920
do 4 w 1922
not 8 w 1925
make 4 w 1929
any 4 w 1932
thing 2 w 1937
one 4 w 1940
but 5 w 1944
that 5 w 1948
this 4 w 1952
kind 1 w 1956
of 17 w 1958
discourse 1 w 1967
is 24 w 1969
merely 1 w 1975
an 31 w 1977
enumeration 1 w 1988
as 21 w 1991
when 5 w 1995
magistrates 2 w 2006
or 23 w 2008
days 1 w 2012
are 5 w 2015
reckoned 1 w 2023
in 31 w 2025
order 1 w 2030