Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Plutarch's Natural Questions

Plutarch's Natural Questions (8-11)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg125.perseus-eng2:8-11
Refs {'start': {'reference': '8', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 8'}, 'end': {'reference': '11', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 11'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
VIII.
WHY, SINCE ALL OTHER LIQUORS UPON MOVING AND STIRRING ABOUT GROW COLD, DOES THE SEA BY BEING TOSSED IN WAVES GROW HOT?

WHETHER that motion expels and dissipates the heat of other liquors as a thing adscititious, and the winds do rather excite and increase the innate heat of the sea? Its transparentness is an argument of heat; and so is its not being frozen, though it is terrene and heavy.

IX.
WHY IN WINTER IS THE SEA LEAST SALT AND BITTER TO THE TASTE? FOR THEY SAY THAT DIONYSIUS THE HYDRAGOGUE REPORTED THIS.

Is it that the bitterness of the sea is not devoid of all sweetness, as receiving so many rivers into it; but, since the sun exhales the sweet and potable water thereof, arising to the top by reason of its levity, and since this is done in summer more than in winter, when it affects the sea more weakly by reason of the debility of its heat, that so in winter a great deal of sweetness is left, which tempers and mitigates its excessive poisonous bitterness? And the same thing befalls potable waters; for in summer they are worse, the sun wasting the lightest and sweetest part of them. And a fresh sweetness returns in winter, of which the sea must needs participate, since it moves, and is carried with the rivers into the sea.

X.
WHY DO MEN POUR SEA-WATER UPON WINE, AND SAY THE FISHERMEN HAD AN ORACLE GIVEN THEM, WHEREBY THEY WERE BID TO DIP BACCHUS INTO THE SEA? AND WHY DO THEY THAT LIVE FAR FROM THE SEA CAST IN SOME ZACYNTHIAN EARTH TOASTED?

WHETHER that heat is good against cold? Or that it quenches heat, by diluting the wine and destroying its strength? Or that the aqueous and aerial part of wine (which is therefore prone to mutation) is stayed by the throwing in of terrene parts, whose nature it is to constipate and condense? Moreover, salts with the sea-water, attenuating and colliquating whatever is foreign and superfluous, suffer no fetidness or putrefaction to breed. Besides, the gross and terrene parts, being entangled with the heavy and sinking together, make a sediment or lees, and so make the wine fine.

XI.
WHY ARE THEY SICKER THAT SAIL ON THE SEA THAN THEY THAT SAIL IN FRESH RIVERS, EVEN IN CALM WEATHER?

OF all the senses, smelling causes nauseousness the most, and of all the passions of the mind, fear. For men tremble and shake and bewray themselves upon apprehension of great danger. They that sail in a river are troubled with neither of these. And the smell of sweet and potable water is familiar to all, and the voyage is without danger. On the sea an unusual smell is troublesome; and men are afraid, not knowing what the issue may be. Therefore tranquillity abroad avails not, while an estuating and disturbed mind disorders the body.

Tokens

VIII 1 w 4
WHY 1 w 8
SINCE 1 w 14
ALL 1 w 17
OTHER 1 w 22
LIQUORS 1 w 29
UPON 1 w 33
MOVING 1 w 39
AND 1 w 42
STIRRING 1 w 50
ABOUT 1 w 55
GROW 1 w 59
COLD 1 w 63
DOES 1 w 68
THE 2 w 71
SEA 1 w 74
BY 1 w 76
BEING 1 w 81
TOSSED 1 w 87
IN 5 w 89
WAVES 1 w 94
GROW 2 w 98
HOT 1 w 101
WHETHER 1 w 109
that 1 w 113
motion 1 w 119
expels 1 w 125
and 1 w 128
dissipates 1 w 138
the 1 w 141
heat 1 w 145
of 1 w 147
other 1 w 152
liquors 1 w 159
as 1 w 161
a 6 w 162
thing 1 w 167
adscititious 1 w 179
and 2 w 183
the 3 w 186
winds 1 w 191
do 1 w 193
rather 1 w 199
excite 1 w 205
and 3 w 208
increase 1 w 216
the 5 w 219
innate 1 w 225
heat 2 w 229
of 2 w 231
the 6 w 234
sea 1 w 237
Its 1 w 241
transparentness 1 w 256
is 2 w 258
an 5 w 260
argument 1 w 268
of 3 w 270
heat 3 w 274
and 4 w 278
so 1 w 280
is 3 w 282
its 1 w 285
not 1 w 288
being 1 w 293
frozen 1 w 299
though 1 w 306
it 5 w 308
is 4 w 310
terrene 1 w 317
and 5 w 320
heavy 1 w 325
IX 1 w 328
WHY 2 w 332
IN 6 w 334
WINTER 1 w 340
IS 1 w 342
THE 4 w 345
SEA 2 w 348
LEAST 1 w 353
SALT 1 w 357
AND 2 w 360
BITTER 1 w 366
TO 2 w 368
THE 5 w 371
TASTE 1 w 376
FOR 1 w 380
THEY 1 w 384
SAY 1 w 387
THAT 1 w 391
DIONYSIUS 1 w 400
THE 7 w 403
HYDRAGOGUE 1 w 413
REPORTED 1 w 421
THIS 1 w 425
Is 1 w 428
it 6 w 430
that 2 w 434
the 7 w 437
bitterness 1 w 447
of 4 w 449
the 8 w 452
sea 2 w 455
is 5 w 457
not 2 w 460
devoid 1 w 466
of 5 w 468
all 1 w 471
sweetness 1 w 480
as 3 w 483
receiving 1 w 492
so 2 w 494
many 1 w 498
rivers 1 w 504
into 1 w 508
it 8 w 510
but 1 w 514
since 1 w 520
the 9 w 523
sun 1 w 526
exhales 1 w 533
the 10 w 536
sweet 2 w 541
and 6 w 544
potable 1 w 551
water 1 w 556
thereof 1 w 563
arising 1 w 571
to 2 w 573
the 12 w 576
top 1 w 579
by 1 w 581
reason 1 w 587
of 7 w 589
its 2 w 592
levity 1 w 598
and 7 w 602
since 2 w 607
this 1 w 611
is 8 w 613
done 1 w 617
in 11 w 619
summer 1 w 625
more 1 w 629
than 1 w 633
in 12 w 635
winter 1 w 641
when 1 w 646
it 11 w 648
affects 1 w 655
the 13 w 658
sea 3 w 661
more 2 w 665
weakly 1 w 671
by 2 w 673
reason 2 w 679
of 8 w 681
the 14 w 684
debility 1 w 692
of 9 w 694
its 3 w 697
heat 4 w 701
that 3 w 706
so 5 w 708
in 14 w 710
winter 2 w 716
a 42 w 717
great 1 w 722
deal 1 w 726
of 10 w 728
sweetness 2 w 737
is 9 w 739
left 1 w 743
which 1 w 749
tempers 1 w 756
and 8 w 759
mitigates 1 w 768
its 4 w 771
excessive 1 w 780
poisonous 1 w 789
bitterness 2 w 799
And 1 w 803
the 15 w 806
same 1 w 810
thing 2 w 815
befalls 1 w 822
potable 2 w 829
waters 1 w 835
for 1 w 839
in 17 w 841
summer 2 w 847
they 1 w 851
are 2 w 854
worse 1 w 859
the 17 w 863
sun 2 w 866
wasting 1 w 873
the 18 w 876
lightest 1 w 884
and 9 w 887
sweetest 1 w 895
part 1 w 899
of 11 w 901
them 1 w 905
And 2 w 909
a 55 w 910
fresh 1 w 915
sweetness 3 w 924
returns 1 w 931
in 19 w 933
winter 3 w 939
of 12 w 942
which 2 w 947
the 20 w 950
sea 4 w 953
must 1 w 957
needs 1 w 962
participate 1 w 973
since 3 w 979
it 17 w 981
moves 1 w 986
and 10 w 990
is 11 w 992
carried 1 w 999
with 1 w 1003
the 21 w 1006
rivers 2 w 1012
into 2 w 1016
the 22 w 1019
sea 5 w 1022
X 2 w 1024
WHY 3 w 1028
DO 2 w 1030
MEN 1 w 1033
POUR 1 w 1037
SEA-WATER 1 w 1046
UPON 2 w 1050
WINE 1 w 1054
AND 3 w 1058
SAY 2 w 1061
THE 8 w 1064
FISHERMEN 1 w 1073
HAD 1 w 1076
AN 4 w 1078
ORACLE 1 w 1084
GIVEN 1 w 1089
THEM 1 w 1093
WHEREBY 1 w 1101
THEY 2 w 1105
WERE 1 w 1109
BID 1 w 1112
TO 3 w 1114
DIP 1 w 1117
BACCHUS 1 w 1124
INTO 1 w 1128
THE 11 w 1131
SEA 4 w 1134
AND 4 w 1138
WHY 4 w 1141
DO 3 w 1143
THEY 3 w 1147
THAT 2 w 1151
LIVE 1 w 1155
FAR 1 w 1158
FROM 1 w 1162
THE 13 w 1165
SEA 5 w 1168
CAST 1 w 1172
IN 10 w 1174
SOME 1 w 1178
ZACYNTHIAN 1 w 1188
EARTH 1 w 1193
TOASTED 1 w 1200
WHETHER 2 w 1208
that 4 w 1212
heat 5 w 1216
is 12 w 1218
good 1 w 1222
against 1 w 1229
cold 1 w 1233
Or 1 w 1236
that 5 w 1240
it 19 w 1242
quenches 1 w 1250
heat 6 w 1254
by 3 w 1257
diluting 1 w 1265
the 23 w 1268
wine 1 w 1272
and 11 w 1275
destroying 1 w 1285
its 5 w 1288
strength 1 w 1296
Or 2 w 1299
that 6 w 1303
the 24 w 1306
aqueous 1 w 1313
and 12 w 1316
aerial 1 w 1322
part 3 w 1326
of 13 w 1328
wine 2 w 1332
which 3 w 1338
is 13 w 1340
therefore 1 w 1349
prone 1 w 1354
to 5 w 1356
mutation 1 w 1364
is 14 w 1367
stayed 1 w 1373
by 4 w 1375
the 26 w 1378
throwing 1 w 1386
in 29 w 1388
of 14 w 1390
terrene 2 w 1397
parts 1 w 1402
whose 1 w 1408
nature 1 w 1414
it 21 w 1416
is 15 w 1418
to 6 w 1420
constipate 1 w 1430
and 13 w 1433
condense 1 w 1441
Moreover 1 w 1450
salts 1 w 1456
with 2 w 1460
the 27 w 1463
sea-water 1 w 1472
attenuating 1 w 1484
and 14 w 1487
colliquating 1 w 1499
whatever 1 w 1507
is 16 w 1509
foreign 1 w 1516
and 15 w 1519
superfluous 1 w 1530
suffer 1 w 1537
no 4 w 1539
fetidness 1 w 1548
or 9 w 1550
putrefaction 1 w 1562
to 7 w 1564
breed 1 w 1569
Besides 1 w 1577
the 28 w 1581
gross 1 w 1586
and 16 w 1589
terrene 3 w 1596
parts 2 w 1601
being 2 w 1607
entangled 1 w 1616
with 3 w 1620
the 29 w 1623
heavy 2 w 1628
and 17 w 1631
sinking 1 w 1638
together 1 w 1646
make 1 w 1651
a 97 w 1652
sediment 1 w 1660
or 10 w 1662
lees 1 w 1666
and 18 w 1670
so 7 w 1672
make 2 w 1676
the 31 w 1679
wine 3 w 1683
fine 1 w 1687
XI 1 w 1690
WHY 5 w 1694
ARE 1 w 1697
THEY 4 w 1701
SICKER 1 w 1707
THAT 3 w 1711
SAIL 1 w 1715
ON 4 w 1717
THE 16 w 1720
SEA 6 w 1723
THAN 1 w 1727
THEY 5 w 1731
THAT 4 w 1735
SAIL 2 w 1739
IN 11 w 1741
FRESH 1 w 1746
RIVERS 1 w 1752
EVEN 1 w 1757
IN 12 w 1759
CALM 1 w 1763
WEATHER 1 w 1770
OF 1 w 1773
all 3 w 1776
the 32 w 1779
senses 1 w 1785
smelling 1 w 1794
causes 1 w 1800
nauseousness 1 w 1812
the 33 w 1815
most 1 w 1819
and 19 w 1823
of 15 w 1825
all 4 w 1828
the 34 w 1831
passions 1 w 1839
of 16 w 1841
the 35 w 1844
mind 1 w 1848
fear 1 w 1853
For 1 w 1857
men 3 w 1860
tremble 1 w 1867
and 20 w 1870
shake 1 w 1875
and 21 w 1878
bewray 1 w 1884
themselves 1 w 1894
upon 1 w 1898
apprehension 1 w 1910
of 17 w 1912
great 2 w 1917
danger 1 w 1923
They 1 w 1928
that 7 w 1932
sail 1 w 1936
in 39 w 1938
a 116 w 1939
river 3 w 1944
are 3 w 1947
troubled 1 w 1955
with 4 w 1959
neither 1 w 1966
of 18 w 1968
these 1 w 1973
And 3 w 1977
the 39 w 1980
smell 2 w 1985
of 19 w 1987
sweet 6 w 1992
and 22 w 1995
potable 3 w 2002
water 4 w 2007
is 17 w 2009
familiar 1 w 2017
to 9 w 2019
all 5 w 2022
and 23 w 2026
the 40 w 2029
voyage 1 w 2035
is 18 w 2037
without 1 w 2044
danger 2 w 2050
On 1 w 2053
the 41 w 2056
sea 7 w 2059
an 31 w 2061
unusual 1 w 2068
smell 3 w 2073
is 19 w 2075
troublesome 1 w 2086
and 24 w 2090
men 4 w 2093
are 4 w 2096
afraid 1 w 2102
not 3 w 2106
knowing 1 w 2113
what 2 w 2117
the 42 w 2120
issue 1 w 2125
may 1 w 2128
be 5 w 2130
Therefore 1 w 2140
tranquillity 1 w 2152
abroad 1 w 2158
avails 1 w 2164
not 4 w 2167
while 1 w 2173
an 34 w 2175
estuating 1 w 2184
and 25 w 2187
disturbed 1 w 2196
mind 2 w 2200
disorders 1 w 2209
the 43 w 2212
body 1 w 2216