Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Plutarch's Natural Questions

Plutarch's Natural Questions (12-15)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg125.perseus-eng2:12-15
Refs {'start': {'reference': '12', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 12'}, 'end': {'reference': '15', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 15'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
XII.
WHY DOES POURING OIL ON THE SEA MAKE IT CLEAR AND CALM?

Is it for that the winds, slipping the smooth oil, have no force, nor cause any waves? This may be probably said in respect of things external; but they say that divers take oil in their mouths, and when they spout it out they have light at the bottom, and it makes the water transparent; so that the slipping of the winds will not hold good here for an argument. Therefore it is to be considered, whether the sea, which is terrene and uneven, is not compacted and made smooth by the dense oil; and so the sea, being compact in itself, leaves passes, and a pellucidity penetrable by the sight. Or whether that the air, which is naturally mixed with the sea, is lucid, but by being troubled grows unequal and shady; and so by the oils density, smoothing its inequality, the sea recovers its evenness and pellucidity.

XIII.
WHY DO FISHERMENS NETS ROOT MORE IN WINTER THAN IN SUMMER, SINCE OTHER THINGS ROT MORE IN SUMMER?

Is not that the cause which Theophrastus assigns,—that heat (to wit) shuns the cold, and is constrained by it on every side? Hence the waters are hottest in the bottom of the sea. And so it is on land; for springs are hotter in winter, and then lakes and rivers send up most vapors, because the heat is compelled to the bottom by the prevailing cold. Or it may be, nets do not rot at that time more than at another; but being frozen and dried in the cold, since they are therefore the more easily broken by the waves, they are liable to something like putrefaction

and rottenness. And they suffer most in the cold (as strained cords are aptest to break in such a season), because then there be most frequent storms at sea. Therefore fishermen guard their nets with certain tinctures, for fear they should break. Otherwise a net, neither tinged nor daubed with any thing, might more easily deceive the fish; since line is of an air color, and is not easily discerned in the sea.

XIV.
WHY DO THE DORIANS PRAY FOR BAD MAKING OF THEIR HAY?

Is it because hay rained upon is never well made? For the grass is cut down green and not dry, wherefore it putrefies when wet with rain water. But when before harvest it rains upon corn, this is a help to it against the hot south winds; which otherwise would not let the grain fill in the ear, but by their heat would hinder and destroy all coalition, unless by watering the earth there came a moisture to cool and moisten the ear.

XV.
WHY IS A FAT AND DEEP SOIL FRUITFUL OF WHEAT, AND A LEAN SOIL OF BARLEY?

Is it because a stronger grain needs more nourishment, and a weaker a light and thin one? Now barley is weaker and laxer than wheat, therefore it affords but little nourishment. And, as a farther testimony to this reason, wheat, that is ripe in three months, grows in dryer ground; because it is juiceless, and stands in need of less nourishment, and therefore is more easily brought to perfection.

Tokens

XII 1 w 3
WHY 1 w 7
DOES 1 w 11
POURING 1 w 18
OIL 1 w 21
ON 1 w 23
THE 1 w 26
SEA 1 w 29
MAKE 1 w 33
IT 1 w 35
CLEAR 1 w 40
AND 1 w 43
CALM 1 w 47
Is 1 w 50
it 1 w 52
for 1 w 55
that 1 w 59
the 1 w 62
winds 1 w 67
slipping 1 w 76
the 2 w 79
smooth 1 w 85
oil 1 w 88
have 1 w 93
no 1 w 95
force 1 w 100
nor 1 w 104
cause 1 w 109
any 1 w 112
waves 1 w 117
This 1 w 122
may 1 w 125
be 1 w 127
probably 1 w 135
said 1 w 139
in 3 w 141
respect 1 w 148
of 1 w 150
things 1 w 156
external 1 w 164
but 1 w 168
they 1 w 172
say 1 w 175
that 2 w 179
divers 1 w 185
take 1 w 189
oil 2 w 192
in 5 w 194
their 1 w 199
mouths 1 w 205
and 1 w 209
when 1 w 213
they 2 w 217
spout 1 w 222
it 2 w 224
out 3 w 227
they 3 w 231
have 2 w 235
light 1 w 240
at 3 w 242
the 7 w 245
bottom 1 w 251
and 2 w 255
it 3 w 257
makes 1 w 262
the 8 w 265
water 1 w 270
transparent 1 w 281
so 1 w 284
that 3 w 288
the 9 w 291
slipping 2 w 299
of 2 w 301
the 10 w 304
winds 2 w 309
will 1 w 313
not 1 w 316
hold 1 w 320
good 1 w 324
here 1 w 328
for 3 w 331
an 5 w 333
argument 1 w 341
Therefore 1 w 351
it 4 w 353
is 2 w 355
to 2 w 357
be 2 w 359
considered 1 w 369
whether 1 w 377
the 12 w 380
sea 1 w 383
which 1 w 389
is 3 w 391
terrene 1 w 398
and 3 w 401
uneven 1 w 407
is 4 w 410
not 2 w 413
compacted 1 w 422
and 4 w 425
made 1 w 429
smooth 2 w 435
by 1 w 437
the 13 w 440
dense 1 w 445
oil 3 w 448
and 5 w 452
so 2 w 454
the 14 w 457
sea 2 w 460
being 1 w 466
compact 2 w 473
in 9 w 475
itself 1 w 481
leaves 1 w 488
passes 1 w 494
and 6 w 498
a 35 w 499
pellucidity 1 w 510
penetrable 1 w 520
by 2 w 522
the 15 w 525
sight 1 w 530
Or 1 w 533
whether 2 w 540
that 4 w 544
the 17 w 547
air 1 w 550
which 2 w 556
is 5 w 558
naturally 1 w 567
mixed 1 w 572
with 1 w 576
the 18 w 579
sea 3 w 582
is 6 w 585
lucid 2 w 590
but 2 w 594
by 3 w 596
being 2 w 601
troubled 1 w 609
grows 1 w 614
unequal 1 w 621
and 7 w 624
shady 1 w 629
and 8 w 633
so 3 w 635
by 4 w 637
the 19 w 640
oil 4 w 643
s 41 w 645
density 1 w 652
smoothing 1 w 662
its 2 w 665
inequality 1 w 675
the 20 w 679
sea 4 w 682
recovers 1 w 690
its 3 w 693
evenness 1 w 701
and 9 w 704
pellucidity 2 w 715
XIII 1 w 720
WHY 2 w 724
DO 2 w 726
FISHERMEN 1 w 735
S 4 w 737
NETS 1 w 741
ROOT 1 w 745
MORE 1 w 749
IN 2 w 751
WINTER 1 w 757
THAN 1 w 761
IN 4 w 763
SUMMER 1 w 769
SINCE 1 w 775
OTHER 1 w 780
THINGS 1 w 786
ROT 1 w 789
MORE 2 w 793
IN 7 w 795
SUMMER 2 w 801
Is 2 w 804
not 3 w 807
that 5 w 811
the 21 w 814
cause 2 w 819
which 3 w 824
Theophrastus 1 w 836
assigns 1 w 843
that 6 w 849
heat 1 w 853
to 3 w 856
wit 2 w 859
shuns 1 w 865
the 22 w 868
cold 1 w 872
and 10 w 876
is 7 w 878
constrained 1 w 889
by 5 w 891
it 14 w 893
on 3 w 895
every 1 w 900
side 2 w 904
Hence 1 w 910
the 23 w 913
waters 1 w 919
are 2 w 922
hottest 1 w 929
in 14 w 931
the 24 w 934
bottom 2 w 940
of 3 w 942
the 25 w 945
sea 5 w 948
And 1 w 952
so 4 w 954
it 15 w 956
is 8 w 958
on 4 w 960
land 1 w 964
for 5 w 968
springs 1 w 975
are 3 w 978
hotter 1 w 984
in 16 w 986
winter 1 w 992
and 12 w 996
then 1 w 1000
lakes 1 w 1005
and 13 w 1008
rivers 1 w 1014
send 1 w 1018
up 1 w 1020
most 1 w 1024
vapors 1 w 1030
because 1 w 1038
the 27 w 1041
heat 2 w 1045
is 9 w 1047
compelled 1 w 1056
to 5 w 1058
the 28 w 1061
bottom 3 w 1067
by 6 w 1069
the 29 w 1072
prevailing 1 w 1082
cold 2 w 1086
Or 2 w 1089
it 16 w 1091
may 2 w 1094
be 6 w 1096
nets 1 w 1101
do 1 w 1103
not 4 w 1106
rot 1 w 1109
at 13 w 1111
that 7 w 1115
time 1 w 1119
more 1 w 1123
than 1 w 1127
at 15 w 1129
another 1 w 1136
but 3 w 1140
being 3 w 1145
frozen 1 w 1151
and 14 w 1154
dried 1 w 1159
in 20 w 1161
the 31 w 1164
cold 3 w 1168
since 1 w 1174
they 4 w 1178
are 4 w 1181
therefore 1 w 1190
the 34 w 1193
more 2 w 1197
easily 1 w 1203
broken 1 w 1209
by 7 w 1211
the 35 w 1214
waves 2 w 1219
they 5 w 1224
are 5 w 1227
liable 1 w 1233
to 7 w 1235
something 1 w 1244
like 1 w 1248
putrefaction 1 w 1260
and 15 w 1263
rottenness 1 w 1273
And 2 w 1277
they 6 w 1281
suffer 1 w 1287
most 2 w 1291
in 23 w 1293
the 38 w 1296
cold 4 w 1300
as 5 w 1303
strained 2 w 1311
cords 1 w 1316
are 6 w 1319
aptest 1 w 1325
to 8 w 1327
break 1 w 1332
in 25 w 1334
such 1 w 1338
a 88 w 1339
season 1 w 1345
because 2 w 1354
then 2 w 1358
there 2 w 1363
be 9 w 1365
most 3 w 1369
frequent 1 w 1377
storms 1 w 1383
at 16 w 1385
sea 7 w 1388
Therefore 2 w 1398
fishermen 1 w 1407
guard 1 w 1412
their 2 w 1417
nets 2 w 1421
with 2 w 1425
certain 1 w 1432
tinctures 1 w 1441
for 8 w 1445
fear 1 w 1449
they 7 w 1453
should 1 w 1459
break 2 w 1464
Otherwise 1 w 1474
a 97 w 1475
net 4 w 1478
neither 1 w 1486
tinged 1 w 1492
nor 2 w 1495
daubed 1 w 1501
with 3 w 1505
any 2 w 1508
thing 4 w 1513
might 1 w 1519
more 3 w 1523
easily 2 w 1529
deceive 1 w 1536
the 45 w 1539
fish 2 w 1543
since 2 w 1549
line 1 w 1553
is 13 w 1555
of 4 w 1557
an 22 w 1559
air 2 w 1562
color 1 w 1567
and 16 w 1571
is 14 w 1573
not 6 w 1576
easily 3 w 1582
discerned 1 w 1591
in 32 w 1593
the 46 w 1596
sea 8 w 1599
XIV 1 w 1603
WHY 3 w 1607
DO 3 w 1609
THE 3 w 1612
DORIANS 1 w 1619
PRAY 1 w 1623
FOR 1 w 1626
BAD 1 w 1629
MAKING 1 w 1635
OF 1 w 1637
THEIR 1 w 1642
HAY 1 w 1645
Is 3 w 1648
it 20 w 1650
because 3 w 1657
hay 1 w 1660
rained 3 w 1666
upon 1 w 1670
is 16 w 1672
never 1 w 1677
well 1 w 1681
made 2 w 1685
For 1 w 1689
the 47 w 1692
grass 1 w 1697
is 17 w 1699
cut 1 w 1702
down 1 w 1706
green 1 w 1711
and 17 w 1714
not 7 w 1717
dry 1 w 1720
wherefore 1 w 1730
it 21 w 1732
putrefies 1 w 1741
when 2 w 1745
wet 1 w 1748
with 4 w 1752
rain 4 w 1756
water 3 w 1761
But 1 w 1765
when 3 w 1769
before 1 w 1775
harvest 1 w 1782
it 23 w 1784
rains 1 w 1789
upon 2 w 1793
corn 1 w 1797
this 1 w 1802
is 19 w 1804
a 116 w 1805
help 1 w 1809
to 10 w 1811
it 24 w 1813
against 1 w 1820
the 48 w 1823
hot 3 w 1826
south 1 w 1831
winds 3 w 1836
which 4 w 1842
otherwise 1 w 1851
would 1 w 1856
not 8 w 1859
let 1 w 1862
the 50 w 1865
grain 1 w 1870
fill 1 w 1874
in 39 w 1876
the 51 w 1879
ear 2 w 1882
but 4 w 1886
by 8 w 1888
their 3 w 1893
heat 3 w 1897
would 2 w 1902
hinder 1 w 1908
and 18 w 1911
destroy 1 w 1918
all 2 w 1921
coalition 1 w 1930
unless 1 w 1937
by 9 w 1939
watering 1 w 1947
the 53 w 1950
earth 1 w 1955
there 3 w 1960
came 1 w 1964
a 128 w 1965
moisture 1 w 1973
to 11 w 1975
cool 1 w 1979
and 19 w 1982
moisten 1 w 1989
the 55 w 1992
ear 4 w 1995
XV 1 w 1998
WHY 4 w 2002
IS 2 w 2004
A 14 w 2005
FAT 1 w 2008
AND 2 w 2011
DEEP 1 w 2015
SOIL 1 w 2019
FRUITFUL 1 w 2027
OF 2 w 2029
WHEAT 1 w 2034
AND 3 w 2038
A 19 w 2039
LEAN 1 w 2043
SOIL 2 w 2047
OF 3 w 2049
BARLEY 1 w 2055
Is 4 w 2058
it 26 w 2060
because 4 w 2067
a 132 w 2068
stronger 1 w 2076
grain 2 w 2081
needs 1 w 2086
more 4 w 2090
nourishment 1 w 2101
and 20 w 2105
a 135 w 2106
weaker 1 w 2112
a 137 w 2113
light 2 w 2118
and 21 w 2121
thin 5 w 2125
one 1 w 2128
Now 1 w 2132
barley 1 w 2138
is 24 w 2140
weaker 2 w 2146
and 22 w 2149
laxer 1 w 2154
than 2 w 2158
wheat 1 w 2163
therefore 2 w 2173
it 27 w 2175
affords 1 w 2182
but 5 w 2185
little 1 w 2191
nourishment 2 w 2202
And 3 w 2206
as 10 w 2209
a 147 w 2210
farther 1 w 2217
testimony 1 w 2226
to 12 w 2228
this 2 w 2232
reason 1 w 2238
wheat 2 w 2244
that 8 w 2249
is 27 w 2251
ripe 1 w 2255
in 44 w 2257
three 1 w 2262
months 1 w 2268
grows 2 w 2274
in 45 w 2276
dryer 1 w 2281
ground 1 w 2287
because 5 w 2295
it 29 w 2297
is 28 w 2299
juiceless 1 w 2308
and 23 w 2312
stands 1 w 2318
in 46 w 2320
need 2 w 2324
of 5 w 2326
less 3 w 2330
nourishment 3 w 2341
and 25 w 2345
therefore 3 w 2354
is 30 w 2356
more 5 w 2360
easily 4 w 2366
brought 1 w 2373
to 13 w 2375
perfection 1 w 2385