Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Plutarch's Natural Questions

Plutarch's Natural Questions (20-23)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg125.perseus-eng2:20-23
Refs {'start': {'reference': '20', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 20'}, 'end': {'reference': '23', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 23'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
XX.
WHAT IS THE REASON, THAT THE TEARS OF WILD BOARS ARE SWEET, AND THE TEARS OF THE HART SALT AND HURTFUL?

THE reason seems to be the heat and cold of these animals. For the hart is cold, and the boar is very hot and fiery; therefore the one flies from, the other defends himself against, his pursuers. Now when great store of heat comes to the eyes (as Homer says, with horrid bristles, and eyes darting fire), tears are sweet. Some are of Empedocless opinion, who thought that tears proceed from the disturbance of the blood, as whey does from the churning of milk; since therefore boars blood is harsh and black, and

harts blood thin and watery, it is consentaneous that the tears, which the one sheds when excited to anger, and the other when dejected with fear, should be of the same nature.

XXI.
WHY DO TAME SOWS FARROW OFTEN, SOME AT, ONE TIME AND OTHERS AT ANOTHER; AND THE WILD BUT ONCE A YEAR, AND ALL OF THEM ABOUT THE SAME TIME AT THE BEGINNING OF SUMMER, WHENCE IT IS SAID,—

The wild sow farrowing, that night falls no rain?

Is it because of plentiful feeding, as in very truth fulness doth produce wantonness? For abundance of nourishment breeds abundance of seed both in animals and plants. Now wild sows live by their own toil, and that with fear; the tame have always food enough, either by nature or given them. Or may it not be ascribed to their rest and exercise? For the tame do rest and go not far from their keepers; the wild get to the mountains, and run about, by which means they waste the nutriment, and consume it upon the whole body. Therefore either through continual converse, or abundance of seed, or because the females feed in herds with the males, the tame sows call to mind coition and stir up lust, as Empedocles talks of men. But in wild sows, which feed apart, desire is cold and dull for want of love and conversation. Or is it true, what Aristotle says, that Homer called the wild boar χλούνης, because he had but one stone? For most boars spoil their stones (he says) by rubbing them against stumps of trees.

XXII.
WHY ARE THE PAWS OF BEARS THE SWEETEST AND PLEASANTEST FOOD?

BECAUSE the flesh of those parts of the body which concoct aliment the best is sweetest; and that concocts best which transpires most by motion and exercise. But the bear uses the fore-feet most in going and running, and in managing of things, as it were with hands.

XXIII.
WHY ARE THE STEPS OF WILD BEASTS MOST DIFFICULTLY TRACED IN SPRING-TIME?

WHETHER the dogs, as Empedocles says, with noses find the steps of all wild beasts, and draw in those effluvia which the beasts leave in the ground; but the various smells of plants and flowers lying over the footsteps do in spring-time obscure and confound them, and put the dogs to a loss at winding them? Therefore about Etna in Sicily no man keeps any hunting dogs, because abundance of wild marjoram flourishes and grows there the year round, and the perpetual flagrancy of the place destroys the scent of the wild beasts. There is also a tale, how Proserpine, as she was gathering flowers thereabout, was ravished by Pluto; therefore people, revering that place as an asylum, do not catch any creature that feeds thereabout.

Tokens

XX 1 w 2
WHAT 1 w 7
IS 1 w 9
THE 1 w 12
REASON 1 w 18
THAT 1 w 23
THE 2 w 26
TEARS 1 w 31
OF 1 w 33
WILD 1 w 37
BOARS 1 w 42
ARE 1 w 45
SWEET 1 w 50
AND 1 w 54
THE 3 w 57
TEARS 2 w 62
OF 2 w 64
THE 4 w 67
HART 1 w 71
SALT 1 w 75
AND 2 w 78
HURTFUL 1 w 85
THE 5 w 89
reason 1 w 95
seems 1 w 100
to 1 w 102
be 1 w 104
the 1 w 107
heat 1 w 111
and 1 w 114
cold 1 w 118
of 1 w 120
these 1 w 125
animals 1 w 132
For 1 w 136
the 3 w 139
hart 1 w 143
is 1 w 145
cold 2 w 149
and 2 w 153
the 4 w 156
boar 1 w 160
is 2 w 162
very 1 w 166
hot 1 w 169
and 3 w 172
fiery 1 w 177
therefore 1 w 187
the 6 w 190
one 1 w 193
flies 1 w 198
from 1 w 202
the 7 w 206
other 1 w 211
defends 1 w 218
himself 1 w 225
against 1 w 232
his 1 w 236
pursuers 1 w 244
Now 1 w 248
when 1 w 252
great 1 w 257
store 1 w 262
of 2 w 264
heat 2 w 268
comes 1 w 273
to 3 w 275
the 9 w 278
eyes 1 w 282
as 2 w 285
Homer 1 w 290
says 1 w 294
with 1 w 299
horrid 1 w 305
bristles 1 w 313
and 4 w 317
eyes 2 w 321
darting 1 w 328
fire 1 w 332
tears 1 w 339
are 1 w 342
sweet 1 w 347
Some 1 w 352
are 2 w 355
of 3 w 357
Empedocles 1 w 367
s 27 w 369
opinion 1 w 376
who 1 w 380
thought 1 w 387
that 1 w 391
tears 2 w 396
proceed 1 w 403
from 2 w 407
the 10 w 410
disturbance 1 w 421
of 4 w 423
the 11 w 426
blood 1 w 431
as 3 w 434
whey 1 w 438
does 1 w 442
from 3 w 446
the 12 w 449
churning 1 w 457
of 5 w 459
milk 1 w 463
since 1 w 469
therefore 2 w 478
boar 2 w 482
s 33 w 484
blood 2 w 489
is 6 w 491
harsh 1 w 496
and 5 w 499
black 1 w 504
and 6 w 508
hart 2 w 512
s 36 w 514
blood 3 w 519
thin 1 w 523
and 7 w 526
watery 1 w 532
it 2 w 535
is 7 w 537
consentaneous 1 w 550
that 2 w 554
the 14 w 557
tears 3 w 562
which 1 w 568
the 15 w 571
one 2 w 574
sheds 1 w 579
when 2 w 583
excited 1 w 590
to 4 w 592
anger 1 w 597
and 8 w 601
the 16 w 604
other 2 w 609
when 3 w 613
dejected 1 w 621
with 2 w 625
fear 1 w 629
should 1 w 636
be 2 w 638
of 6 w 640
the 18 w 643
same 1 w 647
nature 1 w 653
XXI 1 w 657
WHY 1 w 661
DO 1 w 663
TAME 1 w 667
SOWS 1 w 671
FARROW 1 w 677
OFTEN 1 w 682
SOME 1 w 687
AT 3 w 689
ONE 1 w 693
TIME 1 w 697
AND 3 w 700
OTHERS 1 w 706
AT 4 w 708
ANOTHER 1 w 715
AND 4 w 719
THE 8 w 722
WILD 2 w 726
BUT 1 w 729
ONCE 1 w 733
A 19 w 734
YEAR 1 w 738
AND 5 w 742
ALL 1 w 745
OF 4 w 747
THEM 1 w 751
ABOUT 1 w 756
THE 10 w 759
SAME 1 w 763
TIME 2 w 767
AT 5 w 769
THE 11 w 772
BEGINNING 1 w 781
OF 5 w 783
SUMMER 1 w 789
WHENCE 1 w 796
IT 1 w 798
IS 2 w 800
SAID 1 w 804
The 1 w 809
wild 1 w 813
sow 1 w 816
farrowing 1 w 825
that 3 w 830
night 1 w 835
falls 1 w 840
no 1 w 842
rain 1 w 846
Is 1 w 849
it 5 w 851
because 1 w 858
of 7 w 860
plentiful 1 w 869
feeding 1 w 876
as 4 w 879
in 10 w 881
very 2 w 885
truth 1 w 890
fulness 1 w 897
doth 1 w 901
produce 1 w 908
wantonness 1 w 918
For 2 w 922
abundance 1 w 931
of 8 w 933
nourishment 1 w 944
breeds 1 w 950
abundance 2 w 959
of 9 w 961
seed 1 w 965
both 1 w 969
in 11 w 971
animals 2 w 978
and 9 w 981
plants 1 w 987
Now 2 w 991
wild 2 w 995
sows 1 w 999
live 1 w 1003
by 1 w 1005
their 1 w 1010
own 1 w 1013
toil 1 w 1017
and 10 w 1021
that 4 w 1025
with 3 w 1029
fear 2 w 1033
the 20 w 1037
tame 1 w 1041
have 1 w 1045
always 1 w 1051
food 1 w 1055
enough 1 w 1061
either 1 w 1068
by 2 w 1070
nature 2 w 1076
or 7 w 1078
given 1 w 1083
them 1 w 1087
Or 1 w 1090
may 1 w 1093
it 8 w 1095
not 1 w 1098
be 4 w 1100
ascribed 1 w 1108
to 7 w 1110
their 2 w 1115
rest 1 w 1119
and 11 w 1122
exercise 1 w 1130
For 3 w 1134
the 24 w 1137
tame 2 w 1141
do 4 w 1143
rest 2 w 1147
and 12 w 1150
go 1 w 1152
not 2 w 1155
far 2 w 1158
from 4 w 1162
their 3 w 1167
keepers 1 w 1174
the 26 w 1178
wild 3 w 1182
get 1 w 1185
to 8 w 1187
the 27 w 1190
mountains 1 w 1199
and 13 w 1203
run 1 w 1206
about 1 w 1211
by 3 w 1214
which 2 w 1219
means 1 w 1224
they 1 w 1228
waste 1 w 1233
the 29 w 1236
nutriment 1 w 1245
and 14 w 1249
consume 1 w 1256
it 9 w 1258
upon 1 w 1262
the 30 w 1265
whole 1 w 1270
body 1 w 1274
Therefore 1 w 1284
either 2 w 1290
through 1 w 1297
continual 1 w 1306
converse 1 w 1314
or 10 w 1317
abundance 3 w 1326
of 10 w 1328
seed 2 w 1332
or 11 w 1335
because 2 w 1342
the 32 w 1345
females 1 w 1352
feed 2 w 1356
in 14 w 1358
herds 1 w 1363
with 4 w 1367
the 33 w 1370
males 2 w 1375
the 34 w 1379
tame 3 w 1383
sows 2 w 1387
call 1 w 1391
to 9 w 1393
mind 1 w 1397
coition 1 w 1404
and 15 w 1407
stir 1 w 1411
up 2 w 1413
lust 1 w 1417
as 7 w 1420
Empedocles 2 w 1430
talks 1 w 1435
of 11 w 1437
men 3 w 1440
But 1 w 1444
in 16 w 1446
wild 4 w 1450
sows 3 w 1454
which 3 w 1460
feed 3 w 1464
apart 1 w 1469
desire 1 w 1476
is 10 w 1478
cold 3 w 1482
and 16 w 1485
dull 1 w 1489
for 4 w 1492
want 2 w 1496
of 12 w 1498
love 1 w 1502
and 17 w 1505
conversation 1 w 1517
Or 2 w 1520
is 11 w 1522
it 13 w 1524
true 1 w 1528
what 1 w 1533
Aristotle 1 w 1542
says 2 w 1546
that 5 w 1551
Homer 2 w 1556
called 1 w 1562
the 35 w 1565
wild 5 w 1569
boar 3 w 1573
χλούνης 1 w 1580
because 3 w 1588
he 46 w 1590
had 1 w 1593
but 1 w 1596
one 3 w 1599
stone 1 w 1604
For 4 w 1608
most 1 w 1612
boars 1 w 1617
spoil 1 w 1622
their 4 w 1627
stones 1 w 1633
he 48 w 1636
says 3 w 1640
by 4 w 1643
rubbing 1 w 1650
them 2 w 1654
against 2 w 1661
stumps 1 w 1667
of 13 w 1669
trees 1 w 1674
XXII 1 w 1679
WHY 2 w 1683
ARE 2 w 1686
THE 12 w 1689
PAWS 1 w 1693
OF 6 w 1695
BEARS 1 w 1700
THE 13 w 1703
SWEETEST 1 w 1711
AND 6 w 1714
PLEASANTEST 1 w 1725
FOOD 1 w 1729
BECAUSE 1 w 1737
the 38 w 1740
flesh 1 w 1745
of 14 w 1747
those 1 w 1752
parts 1 w 1757
of 15 w 1759
the 39 w 1762
body 2 w 1766
which 4 w 1771
concoct 1 w 1778
aliment 1 w 1785
the 40 w 1788
best 1 w 1792
is 13 w 1794
sweetest 1 w 1802
and 18 w 1806
that 6 w 1810
concocts 1 w 1818
best 2 w 1822
which 5 w 1827
transpires 1 w 1837
most 2 w 1841
by 5 w 1843
motion 1 w 1849
and 19 w 1852
exercise 2 w 1860
But 2 w 1864
the 41 w 1867
bear 1 w 1871
uses 1 w 1875
the 42 w 1878
fore-feet 1 w 1887
most 3 w 1891
in 19 w 1893
going 1 w 1898
and 20 w 1901
running 1 w 1908
and 21 w 1912
in 22 w 1914
managing 1 w 1922
of 16 w 1924
things 1 w 1930
as 8 w 1933
it 14 w 1935
were 1 w 1939
with 5 w 1943
hands 1 w 1948
XXIII 1 w 1954
WHY 3 w 1958
ARE 3 w 1961
THE 14 w 1964
STEPS 1 w 1969
OF 7 w 1971
WILD 3 w 1975
BEASTS 1 w 1981
MOST 1 w 1985
DIFFICULTLY 1 w 1996
TRACED 1 w 2002
IN 3 w 2004
SPRING-TIME 1 w 2015
WHETHER 1 w 2023
the 43 w 2026
dogs 1 w 2030
as 9 w 2033
Empedocles 3 w 2043
says 4 w 2047
with 6 w 2052
noses 1 w 2057
find 1 w 2061
the 44 w 2064
steps 1 w 2069
of 17 w 2071
all 4 w 2074
wild 6 w 2078
beasts 1 w 2084
and 23 w 2088
draw 1 w 2092
in 26 w 2094
those 2 w 2099
effluvia 1 w 2107
which 6 w 2112
the 45 w 2115
beasts 2 w 2121
leave 1 w 2126
in 27 w 2128
the 46 w 2131
ground 1 w 2137
but 2 w 2141
the 47 w 2144
various 1 w 2151
smells 1 w 2157
of 18 w 2159
plants 2 w 2165
and 24 w 2168
flowers 1 w 2175
lying 1 w 2180
over 1 w 2184
the 48 w 2187
footsteps 1 w 2196
do 8 w 2198
in 29 w 2200
spring-time 1 w 2211
obscure 1 w 2218
and 25 w 2221
confound 1 w 2229
them 3 w 2233
and 26 w 2237
put 1 w 2240
the 50 w 2243
dogs 2 w 2247
to 13 w 2249
a 131 w 2250
loss 1 w 2254
at 15 w 2256
winding 1 w 2263
them 4 w 2267
Therefore 2 w 2277
about 2 w 2282
Etna 1 w 2286
in 33 w 2288
Sicily 1 w 2294
no 7 w 2296
man 2 w 2299
keeps 1 w 2304
any 1 w 2307
hunting 1 w 2314
dogs 3 w 2318
because 4 w 2326
abundance 4 w 2335
of 19 w 2337
wild 7 w 2341
marjoram 1 w 2349
flourishes 1 w 2359
and 27 w 2362
grows 1 w 2367
there 3 w 2372
the 53 w 2375
year 1 w 2379
round 2 w 2384
and 28 w 2388
the 54 w 2391
perpetual 1 w 2400
flagrancy 1 w 2409
of 20 w 2411
the 55 w 2414
place 1 w 2419
destroys 1 w 2427
the 56 w 2430
scent 1 w 2435
of 21 w 2437
the 57 w 2440
wild 8 w 2444
beasts 3 w 2450
There 3 w 2456
is 16 w 2458
also 1 w 2462
a 151 w 2463
tale 1 w 2467
how 1 w 2471
Proserpine 1 w 2481
as 13 w 2484
she 3 w 2487
was 2 w 2490
gathering 1 w 2499
flowers 2 w 2506
thereabout 1 w 2516
was 3 w 2520
ravished 1 w 2528
by 6 w 2530
Pluto 1 w 2535
therefore 3 w 2545
people 1 w 2551
revering 1 w 2560
that 7 w 2564
place 2 w 2569
as 16 w 2571
an 48 w 2573
asylum 1 w 2579
do 11 w 2582
not 3 w 2585
catch 1 w 2590
any 2 w 2593
creature 1 w 2601
that 8 w 2605
feeds 1 w 2610
thereabout 2 w 2620