Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The Roman Questions

The Roman Questions (96-97)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg084a.perseus-eng3:96-97
Refs {'start': {'reference': '96', 'human_reference': 'Section 96'}, 'end': {'reference': '97', 'human_reference': 'Section 97'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Why do they inflict no other punishment on those of the Holy Maidens[*] who have been seduced, but bury them alive?[*]

Is it because they cremate their dead, and to use fire in the burial of a woman who had not guarded the holy fire in purity was not right?

Or did they believe it to be against divine ordinance to annihilate a body that had been consecrated by the greatest of lustra! ceremonies, or to lay hands upon a holy woman? Accordingly they devised that she should die of herself; they conducted her underground into a chamber built there, in which had been placed a lighted lamp, a loaf of bread,

and some milk and water. Thereafter they covered over the top of the chamber with earth. And yet not even by this manner of avoiding the guilt have they escaped their superstitious fear, but even to this day the priests proceed to this place and make offerings to the dead.

Why is it that after the chariot-race on the Ides of December[*] the right-hand trace-horse of the winning team is sacrificed to Mars, and then someone cuts off its tail, and carries it to the place called Regia and sprinkles its blood on the altar, while some come down from the street called the Via Sacra, and some from the Subura, and fight for its head?

Is it, as some[*] say, that they believe Troy to have been taken by means of a horse: and therefore they punish it, since, forsooth, they are

Noble scions of Trojans commingled with children of Latins.[*]

Or is it because the horse is a spirited, warlike, and martial beast, and they sacrifice to the gods creatures that are particularly pleasing and appropriate for them: and the winner is sacrificed because Mars is the specific divinity of victory and prowess?

Or is it rather because the work of the god demands standing firm, and men that hold their ground defeat those that do not hold it, but flee? And is swiftness punished as being the cowards resource, and do they learn symbolically that there is no safety for those who flee?

Tokens

Why 1 w 3
do 1 w 5
they 1 w 9
inflict 1 w 16
no 1 w 18
other 1 w 23
punishment 1 w 33
on 1 w 35
those 1 w 40
of 1 w 42
the 3 w 45
Holy 1 w 49
Maidens 1 w 56
Plutarch 1 w 64
elsewhere 1 w 73
uses 1 w 77
a 3 w 78
similar 1 w 85
expression 1 w 95
παρθένος 1 w 104
ἱέρεια 1 w 110
for 1 w 114
the 4 w 117
vestal 1 w 123
virgins 1 w 130
e 16 w 132
g 2 w 134
in 3 w 137
his 1 w 140
Life 1 w 144
of 2 w 146
Publicola 1 w 155
chap 1 w 160
viii 1 w 165
101 1 w 170
b 2 w 171
or 2 w 174
Moralia 1 w 181
89 1 w 184
e 18 w 185
who 1 w 189
have 1 w 193
been 1 w 197
seduced 1 w 204
but 1 w 208
bury 1 w 212
them 1 w 216
alive 1 w 221
Cf 1 w 224
Life 2 w 229
of 3 w 231
Numa 1 w 235
chap 2 w 240
x 2 w 242
67 1 w 246
a-c 1 w 249
Ovid 1 w 255
Fasti 1 w 261
vi 4 w 264
457-460 1 w 272
Dionysius 1 w 282
of 4 w 284
Halicarnassus 1 w 297
Roman 1 w 303
Antiquities 1 w 314
ii 3 w 317
67 2 w 320
4 3 w 322
viii 2 w 327
89 2 w 330
5 2 w 332
Pliny 1 w 338
Epistles 1 w 347
iv 2 w 350
11 1 w 353
6 4 w 355
Is 1 w 358
it 2 w 360
because 1 w 367
they 2 w 371
cremate 1 w 378
their 1 w 383
dead 1 w 387
and 1 w 391
to 1 w 393
use 3 w 396
fire 1 w 400
in 5 w 402
the 8 w 405
burial 1 w 411
of 5 w 413
a 25 w 414
woman 1 w 419
who 2 w 422
had 1 w 425
not 1 w 428
guarded 1 w 435
the 9 w 438
holy 1 w 442
fire 2 w 446
in 6 w 448
purity 1 w 454
was 1 w 457
not 2 w 460
right 1 w 465
Or 1 w 468
did 1 w 471
they 3 w 475
believe 1 w 482
it 4 w 484
to 2 w 486
be 4 w 488
against 1 w 495
divine 1 w 501
ordinance 1 w 510
to 3 w 512
annihilate 1 w 522
a 35 w 523
body 1 w 527
that 1 w 531
had 2 w 534
been 2 w 538
consecrated 1 w 549
by 1 w 551
the 11 w 554
greatest 1 w 562
of 6 w 564
lustra 1 w 570
ceremonies 1 w 581
or 5 w 584
to 4 w 586
lay 1 w 589
hands 1 w 594
upon 1 w 598
a 43 w 599
holy 2 w 603
woman 2 w 608
Accordingly 1 w 620
they 4 w 624
devised 1 w 631
that 2 w 635
she 1 w 638
should 1 w 644
die 1 w 647
of 7 w 649
herself 1 w 656
they 5 w 661
conducted 1 w 670
her 4 w 673
underground 1 w 684
into 1 w 688
a 46 w 689
chamber 1 w 696
built 1 w 701
there 1 w 706
in 12 w 709
which 1 w 714
had 3 w 717
been 3 w 721
placed 1 w 727
a 50 w 728
lighted 1 w 735
lamp 1 w 739
a 52 w 741
loaf 1 w 745
of 8 w 747
bread 1 w 752
and 3 w 756
some 1 w 760
milk 1 w 764
and 4 w 767
water 1 w 772
Thereafter 1 w 783
they 6 w 787
covered 1 w 794
over 2 w 798
the 16 w 801
top 1 w 804
of 9 w 806
the 17 w 809
chamber 2 w 816
with 1 w 820
earth 1 w 825
And 1 w 829
yet 1 w 832
not 3 w 835
even 1 w 839
by 2 w 841
this 1 w 845
manner 1 w 851
of 10 w 853
avoiding 1 w 861
the 18 w 864
guilt 1 w 869
have 2 w 873
they 7 w 877
escaped 1 w 884
their 2 w 889
superstitious 1 w 902
fear 1 w 906
but 2 w 910
even 2 w 914
to 7 w 916
this 2 w 920
day 1 w 923
the 21 w 926
priests 1 w 933
proceed 1 w 940
to 8 w 942
this 3 w 946
place 2 w 951
and 5 w 954
make 1 w 958
offerings 1 w 967
to 9 w 969
the 22 w 972
dead 2 w 976
Why 2 w 980
is 8 w 982
it 7 w 984
that 3 w 988
after 2 w 993
the 23 w 996
chariot-race 1 w 1008
on 8 w 1010
the 24 w 1013
Ides 1 w 1017
of 12 w 1019
December 1 w 1027
Presumably 1 w 1037
an 12 w 1039
error 1 w 1044
of 13 w 1046
Plutarch 2 w 1054
s 51 w 1056
he 30 w 1059
means 1 w 1064
the 25 w 1067
tenth 1 w 1072
month 1 w 1077
October 1 w 1085
Cf 2 w 1088
Festus 1 w 1095
s 55 w 1097
v 19 w 1099
October 2 w 1107
equus 1 w 1112
p 16 w 1114
178 1 w 1118
5 3 w 1120
the 26 w 1124
right-hand 1 w 1134
trace-horse 1 w 1145
of 14 w 1147
the 27 w 1150
winning 1 w 1157
team 1 w 1161
is 9 w 1163
sacrificed 1 w 1173
to 12 w 1175
Mars 1 w 1179
and 7 w 1183
then 1 w 1187
someone 1 w 1194
cuts 1 w 1198
off 2 w 1201
its 1 w 1204
tail 1 w 1208
and 8 w 1212
carries 1 w 1219
it 9 w 1221
to 13 w 1223
the 29 w 1226
place 3 w 1231
called 1 w 1237
Regia 1 w 1242
and 9 w 1245
sprinkles 1 w 1254
its 2 w 1257
blood 1 w 1262
on 11 w 1264
the 30 w 1267
altar 1 w 1272
while 1 w 1278
some 3 w 1282
come 1 w 1286
down 1 w 1290
from 1 w 1294
the 31 w 1297
street 1 w 1303
called 2 w 1309
the 32 w 1312
Via 1 w 1315
Sacra 1 w 1320
and 10 w 1324
some 4 w 1328
from 2 w 1332
the 33 w 1335
Subura 1 w 1341
and 11 w 1345
fight 1 w 1350
for 2 w 1353
its 3 w 1356
head 1 w 1360
Is 2 w 1363
it 12 w 1365
as 4 w 1368
some 5 w 1372
Such 1 w 1376
as 5 w 1378
the 34 w 1381
historian 1 w 1390
Timaeus 1 w 1397
Cf 3 w 1400
Polybius 1 w 1409
xii 1 w 1412
4b 1 w 1415
say 1 w 1419
that 4 w 1424
they 8 w 1428
believe 2 w 1435
Troy 1 w 1439
to 15 w 1441
have 3 w 1445
been 4 w 1449
taken 1 w 1454
by 3 w 1456
means 2 w 1461
of 16 w 1463
a 111 w 1464
horse 2 w 1469
and 12 w 1473
therefore 1 w 1482
they 9 w 1486
punish 2 w 1492
it 13 w 1494
since 1 w 1500
forsooth 1 w 1509
they 10 w 1514
are 1 w 1517
Noble 1 w 1522
scions 1 w 1528
of 17 w 1530
Trojans 1 w 1537
commingled 1 w 1547
with 2 w 1551
children 1 w 1559
of 18 w 1561
Latins 1 w 1567
A 4 w 1569
verse 1 w 1574
made 1 w 1578
in 21 w 1580
imitation 1 w 1589
of 19 w 1591
Homer 1 w 1596
Il 1 w 1599
xviii 1 w 1605
337 1 w 1609
or 14 w 1612
xxiii 1 w 1617
23 1 w 1620
blended 1 w 1629
with 3 w 1633
a 118 w 1634
part 1 w 1638
of 20 w 1640
x 7 w 1641
424 1 w 1645
Or 2 w 1648
is 12 w 1650
it 17 w 1652
because 2 w 1659
the 39 w 1662
horse 3 w 1667
is 13 w 1669
a 121 w 1670
spirited 1 w 1678
warlike 1 w 1686
and 13 w 1690
martial 1 w 1697
beast 1 w 1702
and 14 w 1706
they 11 w 1710
sacrifice 2 w 1719
to 16 w 1721
the 41 w 1724
gods 1 w 1728
creatures 1 w 1737
that 5 w 1741
are 2 w 1744
particularly 1 w 1756
pleasing 1 w 1764
and 15 w 1767
appropriate 1 w 1778
for 5 w 1781
them 2 w 1785
and 16 w 1789
the 43 w 1792
winner 1 w 1798
is 14 w 1800
sacrificed 2 w 1810
because 3 w 1817
Mars 2 w 1821
is 15 w 1823
the 44 w 1826
specific 1 w 1834
divinity 1 w 1842
of 21 w 1844
victory 1 w 1851
and 17 w 1854
prowess 1 w 1861
Or 3 w 1864
is 16 w 1866
it 20 w 1868
rather 1 w 1874
because 4 w 1881
the 46 w 1884
work 1 w 1888
of 22 w 1890
the 47 w 1893
god 2 w 1896
demands 1 w 1903
standing 1 w 1911
firm 1 w 1915
and 20 w 1919
men 2 w 1922
that 6 w 1926
hold 1 w 1930
their 3 w 1935
ground 2 w 1941
defeat 1 w 1947
those 2 w 1952
that 7 w 1956
do 3 w 1958
not 4 w 1961
hold 2 w 1965
it 21 w 1967
but 3 w 1971
flee 1 w 1975
And 2 w 1979
is 17 w 1981
swiftness 1 w 1990
punished 1 w 1998
as 8 w 2000
being 1 w 2005
the 49 w 2008
coward 1 w 2014
s 119 w 2016
resource 1 w 2024
and 21 w 2028
do 4 w 2030
they 12 w 2034
learn 1 w 2039
symbolically 1 w 2051
that 8 w 2055
there 3 w 2060
is 19 w 2062
no 6 w 2064
safety 1 w 2070
for 6 w 2073
those 3 w 2078
who 3 w 2081
flee 2 w 2085