Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The Roman Questions

The Roman Questions (94-95)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg084a.perseus-eng3:94-95
Refs {'start': {'reference': '94', 'human_reference': 'Section 94'}, 'end': {'reference': '95', 'human_reference': 'Section 95'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Why is the shrine of Aesculapius[*] outside the city?

Is it because they considered it more healthful to spend their time outside the city than within its walls? In fact the Greeks, as might be expected, have their shrines of Asclepius situated in places which are both clean and high.

Or is it because they believe that the god carne at their summons from Epidaurus, and the Epidauria. have their shrine of Asclepius not in the city, but at some distance?

Or is it because the serpent carne out from the trireme into the island,[*] and there disappeared, and thus they thought that the god himself was indicating to them the site for building?

Why is it the customary rule that those who are practising holy living must abstain from legumes?[*]

Did they, like the followers of Pythagoras,[*] religiously abstain from beans for the reasons which are commonly offered,[*] and from vetch and chickpea, because their names (lathyros and erebinthos) suggest Lethê and Erebus?

Or is it because they make particular use of legumes for funeral feasts and invocations of the dead?

Or is it rather because one must keep the body clean and light for purposes of holy living and lustration? Now legumes are a flatulent food and produce surplus matter that requires much purgation.

Or is it because the windy and flatulent quality of the food stimulates desire?

Tokens

Why 1 w 3
is 1 w 5
the 1 w 8
shrine 1 w 14
of 1 w 16
Aesculapius 1 w 27
Cf 1 w 29
Pliny 1 w 35
Natural 1 w 43
History 1 w 50
xxix 1 w 55
1 1 w 57
16 1 w 60
4 1 w 63
72 1 w 66
Livy 1 w 72
x 4 w 74
47 1 w 77
Epitome 1 w 85
xi 2 w 88
outside 1 w 96
the 2 w 99
city 1 w 103
Is 1 w 106
it 3 w 108
because 1 w 115
they 1 w 119
considered 1 w 129
it 4 w 131
more 1 w 135
healthful 1 w 144
to 3 w 146
spend 1 w 151
their 1 w 156
time 1 w 160
outside 2 w 167
the 5 w 170
city 2 w 174
than 1 w 178
within 1 w 184
its 1 w 187
walls 1 w 192
In 1 w 195
fact 1 w 199
the 6 w 202
Greeks 1 w 208
as 1 w 211
might 1 w 216
be 2 w 218
expected 1 w 226
have 1 w 231
their 2 w 236
shrines 1 w 243
of 2 w 245
Asclepius 1 w 254
situated 1 w 262
in 5 w 264
places 1 w 270
which 1 w 275
are 1 w 278
both 1 w 282
clean 1 w 287
and 1 w 290
high 1 w 294
Or 1 w 297
is 3 w 299
it 9 w 301
because 2 w 308
they 2 w 312
believe 1 w 319
that 1 w 323
the 9 w 326
god 1 w 329
carne 1 w 334
at 4 w 336
their 3 w 341
summons 1 w 348
from 1 w 352
Epidaurus 1 w 361
and 2 w 365
the 11 w 368
Epidauria 1 w 377
have 2 w 382
their 4 w 387
shrine 3 w 393
of 3 w 395
Asclepius 2 w 404
not 1 w 407
in 7 w 409
the 13 w 412
city 3 w 416
but 1 w 420
at 5 w 422
some 1 w 426
distance 1 w 434
Or 2 w 437
is 5 w 439
it 11 w 441
because 3 w 448
the 14 w 451
serpent 1 w 458
carne 2 w 463
out 3 w 466
from 2 w 470
the 15 w 473
trireme 1 w 480
into 1 w 484
the 16 w 487
island 1 w 493
The 1 w 497
Insula 1 w 503
Tiberina 1 w 511
and 4 w 515
there 1 w 520
disappeared 1 w 531
and 5 w 535
thus 1 w 539
they 3 w 543
thought 1 w 550
that 2 w 554
the 19 w 557
god 2 w 560
himself 1 w 567
was 1 w 570
indicating 1 w 580
to 5 w 582
them 1 w 586
the 21 w 589
site 1 w 593
for 1 w 596
building 1 w 604
Why 2 w 608
is 8 w 610
it 13 w 612
the 22 w 615
customary 1 w 624
rule 1 w 628
that 3 w 632
those 1 w 637
who 1 w 640
are 3 w 643
practising 1 w 653
holy 1 w 657
living 1 w 663
must 1 w 667
abstain 1 w 674
from 3 w 678
legumes 1 w 685
Cf 2 w 688
Pliny 2 w 694
Natural 2 w 702
History 2 w 709
xviii 1 w 715
12 1 w 718
118-119 1 w 726
Aulus 1 w 733
Gellius 1 w 740
x 8 w 742
15 1 w 745
12 2 w 748
Did 1 w 752
they 4 w 756
like 1 w 761
the 24 w 764
followers 1 w 773
of 4 w 775
Pythagoras 1 w 785
Cf 3 w 788
for 2 w 793
example 1 w 800
Juvenal 1 w 808
xv 2 w 811
9 2 w 813
porrum 1 w 819
et 1 w 821
caepe 1 w 826
nefas 1 w 831
violare 1 w 838
et 2 w 840
frangere 1 w 848
morsu 1 w 853
Horace 1 w 860
Satires 1 w 868
ii 3 w 871
6 2 w 873
63 1 w 876
Epistles 1 w 885
i 78 w 887
12 3 w 890
21 1 w 893
religiously 1 w 905
abstain 2 w 912
from 4 w 916
beans 1 w 921
for 3 w 924
the 25 w 927
reasons 1 w 934
which 2 w 939
are 5 w 942
commonly 1 w 950
offered 1 w 957
The 2 w 961
numerous 1 w 969
reasons 2 w 976
suggested 1 w 985
may 1 w 988
be 8 w 990
found 1 w 995
in 18 w 997
Pauly-Wissowa 1 w 1010
Real-Encyclopadie 1 w 1028
vol 1 w 1032
iii 2 w 1036
coll 1 w 1041
619-620 1 w 1049
and 6 w 1053
from 5 w 1057
vetch 1 w 1062
and 7 w 1065
chickpea 1 w 1073
because 4 w 1081
their 5 w 1086
names 1 w 1091
lathyros 1 w 1100
and 8 w 1103
erebinthos 1 w 1113
suggest 2 w 1121
Lethê 1 w 1126
and 9 w 1129
Erebus 1 w 1135
Or 3 w 1138
is 13 w 1140
it 14 w 1142
because 5 w 1149
they 5 w 1153
make 1 w 1157
particular 1 w 1167
use 6 w 1170
of 6 w 1172
legumes 2 w 1179
for 4 w 1182
funeral 1 w 1189
feasts 1 w 1195
and 10 w 1198
invocations 1 w 1209
of 7 w 1211
the 28 w 1214
dead 1 w 1218
Or 4 w 1221
is 14 w 1223
it 15 w 1225
rather 1 w 1231
because 6 w 1238
one 1 w 1241
must 2 w 1245
keep 1 w 1249
the 30 w 1252
body 1 w 1256
clean 2 w 1261
and 11 w 1264
light 1 w 1269
for 5 w 1272
purposes 1 w 1280
of 8 w 1282
holy 2 w 1286
living 2 w 1292
and 12 w 1295
lustration 1 w 1305
Now 1 w 1309
legumes 3 w 1316
are 6 w 1319
a 92 w 1320
flatulent 1 w 1329
food 1 w 1333
and 13 w 1336
produce 1 w 1343
surplus 1 w 1350
matter 1 w 1356
that 4 w 1360
requires 1 w 1368
much 1 w 1372
purgation 1 w 1381
Or 5 w 1384
is 15 w 1386
it 16 w 1388
because 7 w 1395
the 31 w 1398
windy 1 w 1403
and 14 w 1406
flatulent 2 w 1415
quality 1 w 1422
of 9 w 1424
the 32 w 1427
food 2 w 1431
stimulates 1 w 1441
desire 1 w 1447