In Defense of the Proposed Manilian Law (6-10)

urn:cts:latinLit:phi0474.phi009.perseus-eng2:6-10

Refs	`{'start': {'reference': '6', 'human_reference': 'Section 6'}, 'end': {'reference': '10', 'human_reference': 'Section 10'}}`
Ancestors	`[]`
Children	`[]`

plain text • XML

You see what the case is; now consider what you ought to do. It seems to me that I ought to speak in the first place of the sort of war that exists; in the second place, of its importance; and lastly, of the selection of a general. The kind of war is such as ought above all others to excite and inflame your minds to a determination to persevere in it. It is a war in which the glory of the Roman people is at stake; that glory which has been handed down to you from your ancestors, great indeed in everything, but most especially in military affairs. The safety of our friends and allies is at stake, in behalf of which your ancestors have waged many most important wars. The most certain and the largest revenues of the Roman people are at stake; and if they be lost, you will be at a loss for the luxuries of peace, and the sinews of war. The property of many citizens is at stake, which you ought greatly to regard, both for your own sake, and for that of the republic

And since you have at all times been covetous of glory and greedy of praise beyond all other nations, you have to wipe out that stain, received in the former Mithridates War, which has now fixed itself deeply and eaten its way into the Roman name, the stain arising from the fact that he, who in one day marked down by one order, and one single letter, all the Roman citizens in all Asia, scattered as they were over so many cities, for slaughter and butchery, has not only never yet suffered any chastisement worthy of his wickedness, but now, twenty-three years after that time, is still a king, and a king in such a way that he is not content to hide himself in Pontus, or in the recesses of Cappadocia, but he seeks to emerge from his hereditary kingdom, and to range among your revenues, in the broad light of Asia.

Indeed up to this time your generals have been, contending with the king so as to carry off tokens of victory rather than actual victory. Lucius Sulla has triumphed, Lucius Murena has triumphed over Mithridates, two most gallant men, and most consummate generals; but yet they have triumphed in such a way that he, though routed and defeated, was still king. Not but what praise is to be given to those generals for what they did. Pardon must be conceded to them for what they left undone; because the republic recalled Sulla from that war into Italy, and Sulla recalled Murena.

But Mithridates employed all the time which he had left to him, not in forgetting the old war, but in preparing for a new one; and, after he had built and equipped very large fleets, and had got together mighty armies from every nation he could, and had pretended to be preparing war against the tribes of the Bosphorus, his neighbours, sent ambassadors and letters as far as Spain to those chiefs with whom we were at war at the time, in order that, as you would by that means have war waged against you in the two parts of the world the furthest separated and most remote of all from one another, by two separate enemies warring against you with one uniform plan, you, hampered by the double enmity, might find that you were fighting for the empire itself.

However; the danger on one side, the danger from Sertorius and from Spain, which had much the most solid foundation and the most formidable strength, was warded off by the divine wisdom and extraordinary valour of Cnaeus Pompeius. And on the other side of the empire, affairs were so managed by Lucilius Lucullus, that most illustrious of men, that the beginning, of all those achievements in those countries, great and eminent as they were, deserve to be attributed not to his good fortune but to his valour; but the latter events which have taken place lately, ought to be imputed not to his fault, but to his ill-fortune. However, of Lucullus I will speak hereafter, and I will speak, O Romans, in such a manner, that his true glory shall not appear to be at all disparaged by my pleading, nor, on the other hand, shall any undeserved credit seem to be given to him.

You	1	w	3
see	1	w	6
what	1	w	10
the	1	w	13
case	1	w	17
is	1	w	19
now	1	w	23
consider	1	w	31
what	2	w	35
you	1	w	38
ought	1	w	43
to	1	w	45
do	1	w	47
It	1	w	50
seems	1	w	55
to	2	w	57
me	1	w	59
that	1	w	63
I	2	w	64
ought	2	w	69
to	3	w	71
speak	1	w	76
in	1	w	78
the	2	w	81
first	1	w	86
place	1	w	91
of	1	w	93
the	3	w	96
sort	1	w	100
of	2	w	102
war	1	w	105
that	2	w	109
exists	1	w	115
in	2	w	118
the	4	w	121
second	1	w	127
place	2	w	132
of	3	w	135
its	1	w	138
importance	1	w	148
and	1	w	152
lastly	1	w	158
of	4	w	161
the	5	w	164
selection	1	w	173
of	5	w	175
a	13	w	176
general	1	w	183
The	1	w	187
kind	1	w	191
of	6	w	193
war	2	w	196
is	3	w	198
such	1	w	202
as	3	w	204
ought	3	w	209
above	1	w	214
all	1	w	217
others	1	w	223
to	4	w	225
excite	1	w	231
and	2	w	234
inflame	1	w	241
your	1	w	245
minds	1	w	250
to	5	w	252
a	21	w	253
determination	1	w	266
to	6	w	268
persevere	1	w	277
in	7	w	279
it	3	w	281
It	2	w	284
is	4	w	286
a	23	w	287
war	3	w	290
in	8	w	292
which	1	w	297
the	7	w	300
glory	1	w	305
of	7	w	307
the	8	w	310
Roman	1	w	315
people	1	w	321
is	5	w	323
at	6	w	325
stake	1	w	330
that	3	w	335
glory	2	w	340
which	2	w	345
has	1	w	348
been	1	w	352
handed	1	w	358
down	1	w	362
to	7	w	364
you	3	w	367
from	1	w	371
your	2	w	375
ancestors	1	w	384
great	1	w	390
indeed	1	w	396
in	10	w	398
everything	1	w	408
but	1	w	412
most	1	w	416
especially	1	w	426
in	12	w	428
military	1	w	436
affairs	1	w	443
The	2	w	447
safety	1	w	453
of	8	w	455
our	3	w	458
friends	1	w	465
and	4	w	468
allies	1	w	474
is	6	w	476
at	9	w	478
stake	2	w	483
in	13	w	486
behalf	1	w	492
of	9	w	494
which	3	w	499
your	3	w	503
ancestors	2	w	512
have	1	w	516
waged	1	w	521
many	1	w	525
most	2	w	529
important	1	w	538
wars	1	w	542
The	3	w	546
most	3	w	550
certain	1	w	557
and	5	w	560
the	9	w	563
largest	1	w	570
revenues	1	w	578
of	10	w	580
the	10	w	583
Roman	2	w	588
people	2	w	594
are	1	w	597
at	10	w	599
stake	3	w	604
and	6	w	608
if	1	w	610
they	1	w	614
be	3	w	616
lost	1	w	620
you	6	w	624
will	1	w	628
be	4	w	630
at	11	w	632
a	58	w	633
loss	1	w	637
for	1	w	640
the	12	w	643
luxuries	1	w	651
of	11	w	653
peace	1	w	658
and	7	w	662
the	13	w	665
sinews	1	w	671
of	12	w	673
war	5	w	676
The	4	w	680
property	1	w	688
of	13	w	690
many	2	w	694
citizens	1	w	702
is	7	w	704
at	12	w	706
stake	4	w	711
which	4	w	717
you	7	w	720
ought	4	w	725
greatly	1	w	732
to	10	w	734
regard	1	w	740
both	1	w	745
for	2	w	748
your	4	w	752
own	2	w	755
sake	1	w	759
and	8	w	763
for	3	w	766
that	4	w	770
of	14	w	772
the	14	w	775
republic	1	w	783
And	1	w	786
since	1	w	791
you	9	w	794
have	2	w	798
at	15	w	800
all	4	w	803
times	1	w	808
been	2	w	812
covetous	1	w	820
of	15	w	822
glory	3	w	827
and	9	w	830
greedy	1	w	836
of	16	w	838
praise	1	w	844
beyond	1	w	850
all	5	w	853
other	2	w	858
nations	1	w	865
you	10	w	869
have	3	w	873
to	12	w	875
wipe	1	w	879
out	1	w	882
that	5	w	886
stain	1	w	891
received	1	w	900
in	18	w	902
the	16	w	905
former	1	w	911
Mithridates	1	w	922
War	1	w	925
which	5	w	931
has	2	w	934
now	2	w	937
fixed	1	w	942
itself	1	w	948
deeply	1	w	954
and	10	w	957
eaten	1	w	962
its	3	w	965
way	1	w	968
into	1	w	972
the	17	w	975
Roman	3	w	980
name	1	w	984
the	18	w	988
stain	2	w	993
arising	1	w	1000
from	2	w	1004
the	19	w	1007
fact	1	w	1011
that	6	w	1015
he	24	w	1017
who	1	w	1021
in	22	w	1023
one	1	w	1026
day	1	w	1029
marked	1	w	1035
down	2	w	1039
by	1	w	1041
one	2	w	1044
order	1	w	1049
and	11	w	1053
one	3	w	1056
single	1	w	1062
letter	1	w	1068
all	6	w	1072
the	20	w	1075
Roman	4	w	1080
citizens	2	w	1088
in	24	w	1090
all	7	w	1093
Asia	1	w	1097
scattered	1	w	1107
as	6	w	1109
they	2	w	1113
were	1	w	1117
over	1	w	1121
so	2	w	1123
many	3	w	1127
cities	1	w	1133
for	5	w	1137
slaughter	1	w	1146
and	12	w	1149
butchery	1	w	1157
has	3	w	1161
not	1	w	1164
only	1	w	1168
never	1	w	1173
yet	1	w	1176
suffered	1	w	1184
any	4	w	1187
chastisement	1	w	1199
worthy	1	w	1205
of	17	w	1207
his	1	w	1210
wickedness	1	w	1220
but	3	w	1224
now	3	w	1227
twenty-three	1	w	1240
years	1	w	1245
after	1	w	1250
that	7	w	1254
time	2	w	1258
is	12	w	1261
still	1	w	1266
a	110	w	1267
king	1	w	1271
and	13	w	1275
a	112	w	1276
king	2	w	1280
in	27	w	1282
such	2	w	1286
a	113	w	1287
way	2	w	1290
that	8	w	1294
he	28	w	1296
is	13	w	1298
not	2	w	1301
content	1	w	1308
to	14	w	1310
hide	1	w	1314
himself	1	w	1321
in	28	w	1323
Pontus	1	w	1329
or	16	w	1332
in	29	w	1334
the	22	w	1337
recesses	1	w	1345
of	18	w	1347
Cappadocia	1	w	1357
but	4	w	1361
he	30	w	1363
seeks	1	w	1368
to	15	w	1370
emerge	1	w	1376
from	3	w	1380
his	2	w	1383
hereditary	1	w	1393
kingdom	1	w	1400
and	14	w	1404
to	16	w	1406
range	1	w	1411
among	1	w	1416
your	5	w	1420
revenues	2	w	1428
in	31	w	1431
the	23	w	1434
broad	1	w	1439
light	1	w	1444
of	19	w	1446
Asia	2	w	1450
Indeed	1	w	1457
up	1	w	1459
to	17	w	1461
this	1	w	1465
time	3	w	1469
your	6	w	1473
generals	1	w	1481
have	4	w	1485
been	3	w	1489
contending	1	w	1500
with	1	w	1504
the	24	w	1507
king	4	w	1511
so	3	w	1513
as	9	w	1515
to	18	w	1517
carry	1	w	1522
off	1	w	1525
tokens	1	w	1531
of	21	w	1533
victory	1	w	1540
rather	1	w	1546
than	1	w	1550
actual	1	w	1556
victory	2	w	1563
Lucius	1	w	1570
Sulla	1	w	1575
has	5	w	1578
triumphed	1	w	1587
Lucius	2	w	1594
Murena	1	w	1600
has	6	w	1603
triumphed	2	w	1612
over	2	w	1616
Mithridates	2	w	1627
two	1	w	1631
most	4	w	1635
gallant	1	w	1642
men	2	w	1645
and	15	w	1649
most	5	w	1653
consummate	1	w	1663
generals	2	w	1671
but	5	w	1675
yet	2	w	1678
they	3	w	1682
have	5	w	1686
triumphed	3	w	1695
in	34	w	1697
such	3	w	1701
a	144	w	1702
way	3	w	1705
that	9	w	1709
he	39	w	1711
though	1	w	1718
routed	1	w	1724
and	16	w	1727
defeated	1	w	1735
was	1	w	1739
still	2	w	1744
king	5	w	1748
Not	1	w	1752
but	6	w	1755
what	3	w	1759
praise	2	w	1765
is	17	w	1767
to	22	w	1769
be	8	w	1771
given	1	w	1776
to	23	w	1778
those	1	w	1783
generals	3	w	1791
for	6	w	1794
what	4	w	1798
they	4	w	1802
did	1	w	1805
Pardon	1	w	1812
must	1	w	1816
be	9	w	1818
conceded	1	w	1826
to	24	w	1828
them	1	w	1832
for	7	w	1835
what	5	w	1839
they	5	w	1843
left	1	w	1847
undone	1	w	1853
because	1	w	1861
the	30	w	1864
republic	2	w	1872
recalled	1	w	1880
Sulla	2	w	1885
from	4	w	1889
that	10	w	1893
war	6	w	1896
into	2	w	1900
Italy	1	w	1905
and	17	w	1909
Sulla	3	w	1914
recalled	2	w	1922
Murena	2	w	1928
But	1	w	1932
Mithridates	3	w	1943
employed	1	w	1951
all	11	w	1954
the	31	w	1957
time	4	w	1961
which	6	w	1966
he	45	w	1968
had	1	w	1971
left	2	w	1975
to	26	w	1977
him	2	w	1980
not	3	w	1984
in	37	w	1986
forgetting	1	w	1996
the	32	w	1999
old	1	w	2002
war	7	w	2005
but	7	w	2009
in	39	w	2011
preparing	1	w	2020
for	9	w	2023
a	171	w	2024
new	2	w	2027
one	5	w	2030
and	18	w	2034
after	2	w	2040
he	47	w	2042
had	2	w	2045
built	1	w	2050
and	19	w	2053
equipped	1	w	2061
very	2	w	2065
large	2	w	2070
fleets	1	w	2076
and	20	w	2080
had	3	w	2083
got	1	w	2086
together	1	w	2094
mighty	1	w	2100
armies	1	w	2106
from	5	w	2110
every	2	w	2115
nation	3	w	2121
he	49	w	2123
could	1	w	2128
and	21	w	2132
had	4	w	2135
pretended	1	w	2144
to	28	w	2146
be	11	w	2148
preparing	2	w	2157
war	8	w	2160
against	1	w	2167
the	34	w	2170
tribes	1	w	2176
of	22	w	2178
the	35	w	2181
Bosphorus	1	w	2190
his	4	w	2194
neighbours	1	w	2204
sent	1	w	2209
ambassadors	1	w	2220
and	22	w	2223
letters	1	w	2230
as	14	w	2232
far	1	w	2235
as	15	w	2237
Spain	1	w	2242
to	29	w	2244
those	2	w	2249
chiefs	1	w	2255
with	2	w	2259
whom	1	w	2263
we	3	w	2265
were	2	w	2269
at	35	w	2271
war	9	w	2274
at	36	w	2276
the	36	w	2279
time	5	w	2283
in	44	w	2286
order	2	w	2291
that	11	w	2295
as	16	w	2298
you	13	w	2301
would	1	w	2306
by	2	w	2308
that	12	w	2312
means	1	w	2317
have	6	w	2321
war	10	w	2324
waged	2	w	2329
against	2	w	2336
you	14	w	2339
in	46	w	2341
the	37	w	2344
two	2	w	2347
parts	1	w	2352
of	23	w	2354
the	38	w	2357
world	1	w	2362
the	39	w	2365
furthest	1	w	2373
separated	1	w	2382
and	23	w	2385
most	6	w	2389
remote	1	w	2395
of	24	w	2397
all	12	w	2400
from	6	w	2404
one	6	w	2407
another	1	w	2414
by	3	w	2417
two	3	w	2420
separate	2	w	2428
enemies	1	w	2435
warring	1	w	2442
against	3	w	2449
you	15	w	2452
with	3	w	2456
one	7	w	2459
uniform	1	w	2466
plan	1	w	2470
you	16	w	2474
hampered	1	w	2483
by	4	w	2485
the	42	w	2488
double	1	w	2494
enmity	1	w	2500
might	2	w	2506
find	1	w	2510
that	13	w	2514
you	17	w	2517
were	3	w	2521
fighting	1	w	2529
for	11	w	2532
the	43	w	2535
empire	1	w	2541
itself	2	w	2547
However	1	w	2555
the	44	w	2559
danger	1	w	2565
on	23	w	2567
one	8	w	2570
side	2	w	2574
the	45	w	2578
danger	2	w	2584
from	7	w	2588
Sertorius	1	w	2597
and	24	w	2600
from	8	w	2604
Spain	2	w	2609
which	7	w	2615
had	5	w	2618
much	1	w	2622
the	46	w	2625
most	7	w	2629
solid	1	w	2634
foundation	1	w	2644
and	25	w	2647
the	47	w	2650
most	8	w	2654
formidable	1	w	2664
strength	1	w	2672
was	2	w	2676
warded	1	w	2682
off	2	w	2685
by	5	w	2687
the	48	w	2690
divine	1	w	2696
wisdom	1	w	2702
and	26	w	2705
extraordinary	1	w	2718
valour	1	w	2724
of	26	w	2726
Cnaeus	1	w	2732
Pompeius	1	w	2740
And	2	w	2744
on	26	w	2746
the	49	w	2749
other	4	w	2754
side	3	w	2758
of	27	w	2760
the	51	w	2763
empire	2	w	2769
affairs	2	w	2777
were	4	w	2781
so	5	w	2783
managed	1	w	2790
by	6	w	2792
Lucilius	1	w	2800
Lucullus	1	w	2808
that	14	w	2813
most	9	w	2817
illustrious	1	w	2828
of	28	w	2830
men	3	w	2833
that	15	w	2838
the	52	w	2841
beginning	1	w	2850
of	29	w	2853
all	13	w	2856
those	3	w	2861
achievements	1	w	2873
in	56	w	2875
those	4	w	2880
countries	1	w	2889
great	3	w	2895
and	27	w	2898
eminent	1	w	2905
as	18	w	2907
they	6	w	2911
were	5	w	2915
deserve	1	w	2923
to	31	w	2925
be	14	w	2927
attributed	1	w	2937
not	5	w	2940
to	32	w	2942
his	5	w	2945
good	1	w	2949
fortune	1	w	2956
but	9	w	2959
to	33	w	2961
his	6	w	2964
valour	2	w	2970
but	10	w	2974
the	54	w	2977
latter	1	w	2983
events	1	w	2989
which	8	w	2994
have	7	w	2998
taken	1	w	3003
place	3	w	3008
lately	1	w	3014
ought	5	w	3020
to	34	w	3022
be	15	w	3024
imputed	1	w	3031
not	6	w	3034
to	35	w	3036
his	7	w	3039
fault	1	w	3044
but	11	w	3048
to	36	w	3050
his	8	w	3053
ill-fortune	1	w	3064
However	2	w	3072
of	30	w	3075
Lucullus	2	w	3083
I	6	w	3084
will	2	w	3088
speak	2	w	3093
hereafter	1	w	3102
and	28	w	3106
I	7	w	3107
will	3	w	3111
speak	3	w	3116
O	1	w	3118
Romans	1	w	3124
in	58	w	3127
such	4	w	3131
a	260	w	3132
manner	1	w	3138
that	16	w	3143
his	9	w	3146
true	1	w	3150
glory	4	w	3155
shall	1	w	3160
not	7	w	3163
appear	1	w	3169
to	37	w	3171
be	16	w	3173
at	50	w	3175
all	15	w	3178
disparaged	1	w	3188
by	7	w	3190
my	1	w	3192
pleading	1	w	3200
nor	1	w	3204
on	27	w	3207
the	55	w	3210
other	5	w	3215
hand	2	w	3219
shall	2	w	3225
any	5	w	3228
undeserved	1	w	3238
credit	1	w	3244
seem	2	w	3248
to	38	w	3250
be	17	w	3252
given	2	w	3257
to	39	w	3259
him	3	w	3262