Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / For Aulus Caecina

For Aulus Caecina (5-8)

urn:cts:latinLit:phi0474.phi008.perseus-eng2:5-8
Refs {'start': {'reference': '5', 'human_reference': 'Section 5'}, 'end': {'reference': '8', 'human_reference': 'Section 8'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

And in this case, if I had to plead the cause of Aulus Caecina alone, I should profess myself a sufficiently capable defender of it, because I had behaved with the greatest good faith and diligence; and when these qualities are found in an advocate, there is no reason, especially in a plain and simple matter, for requiring any extraordinary ability. But as I have now to speak of those rights which concern all men,—which were established by our ancestors, and have been preserved to this time; while, if they were taken away, not only would some part of our rights be diminished, but also that violence, which is the greatest enemy to law, would seem to be strengthened by that decision,—I see that the cause is one requiring the greatest abilities, not in order to demonstrate what is before men's eyes, but to prevent (if any mistake is made by you in so important a matter) every one from thinking that I have been wanting to the cause, rather than that you have to your religious obligations.

Although I am persuaded, O judges, that you have not now doubted about the same cause twice, on account of the obscure and uncertain state of the law, so much as because this trial appears to affect that man's personal character; and on that account you have delayed condemning him, and have also given him time to recollect himself. And since that custom has now become a usual one, and since good men,— men like yourselves.—do the same when sitting as judges, it is, perhaps, less blamable. But still it appears a thing to be complained of, because all judicial proceedings have been devised either for the sake of putting an end to disputes, or of punishing crimes, of which the first is the least important object, because it is less severe on individuals, and because it is often terminated by some friendly mediator. The other is most formidable, because it relates to more important matters, and requires not the honorary assistance of some friend, but the severity and vigour of a judge.

That which was the more important, and on account of which judicial proceedings were most especially instituted, has been long abolished by evil customs. For the more disgraceful a thing is, the more severely and the more promptly ought it to be punished; and yet those things which involve danger to a man's character are the slowest to be punished.

3
How, then, can it be right that the same cause which prompted the institution of legal proceedings, should also cause the delay that exists in coming to a decision? If any one, when he has given security,—when he has bound himself by one word, does not do what he has rendered himself liable to do, then he is condemned by the natural course of justice without any appeal to the severity of the judge. If a man, as a guardian, or as a partner, or as a person in a place of trust, or as any one's agent, has cheated any one, the greater his offence is, the slower is his punishment.

Yes, for the sentence is a sentence of infamy.” Yes, if it arises from an infamous action.” See, then, how iniquitously it happens, that because an action is infamous, therefore a discreditable reputation should attach to it, but that a scandalous action is not to be punished, because, if it were, it would involve a loss of reputation. It is just as if any judex or recuperator were to say to me, Why, you might have tried it in an inferior court,—you might have obtained your rights by an easier and more convenient process; therefore, either change your form of action, or else do not press me to give my decision.” And yet he would appear more timid than a bold judge ought to appear, or more covetous than it is right for a wise judge to be, if he were either to prescribe to me how I should follow up my own rights, or if he were to be afraid himself to give his decision in a matter which was brought before him. In truth, if the praetor, who allows the trials to proceed, never prescribes to a claimant what form of action he wishes him to adopt, consider how scandalous a thing it must be, when the matter is so far settled, for a judge to ask what might have been done, or what can be done now, and not what has been done.

Tokens

And 1 w 3
in 1 w 5
this 1 w 9
case 1 w 13
if 1 w 16
I 1 w 17
had 1 w 20
to 1 w 22
plead 1 w 27
the 1 w 30
cause 1 w 35
of 1 w 37
Aulus 1 w 42
Caecina 1 w 49
alone 1 w 54
I 2 w 56
should 1 w 62
profess 1 w 69
myself 1 w 75
a 8 w 76
sufficiently 1 w 88
capable 1 w 95
defender 1 w 103
of 3 w 105
it 1 w 107
because 1 w 115
I 3 w 116
had 2 w 119
behaved 1 w 126
with 1 w 130
the 2 w 133
greatest 1 w 141
good 1 w 145
faith 1 w 150
and 1 w 153
diligence 1 w 162
and 2 w 166
when 1 w 170
these 1 w 175
qualities 1 w 184
are 1 w 187
found 1 w 192
in 3 w 194
an 3 w 196
advocate 1 w 204
there 1 w 210
is 2 w 212
no 1 w 214
reason 1 w 220
especially 1 w 231
in 4 w 233
a 25 w 234
plain 1 w 239
and 3 w 242
simple 1 w 248
matter 1 w 254
for 1 w 258
requiring 1 w 267
any 1 w 270
extraordinary 1 w 283
ability 1 w 290
But 1 w 294
as 3 w 296
I 4 w 297
have 2 w 301
now 1 w 304
to 2 w 306
speak 1 w 311
of 4 w 313
those 1 w 318
rights 1 w 324
which 1 w 329
concern 1 w 336
all 2 w 339
men 1 w 342
which 2 w 349
were 1 w 353
established 1 w 364
by 1 w 366
our 1 w 369
ancestors 1 w 378
and 4 w 382
have 3 w 386
been 1 w 390
preserved 1 w 399
to 4 w 401
this 2 w 405
time 1 w 409
while 1 w 415
if 2 w 418
they 1 w 422
were 2 w 426
taken 1 w 431
away 1 w 435
not 1 w 439
only 1 w 443
would 1 w 448
some 1 w 452
part 1 w 456
of 5 w 458
our 2 w 461
rights 2 w 467
be 4 w 469
diminished 1 w 479
but 1 w 483
also 1 w 487
that 1 w 491
violence 1 w 499
which 3 w 505
is 6 w 507
the 6 w 510
greatest 2 w 518
enemy 1 w 523
to 5 w 525
law 1 w 528
would 2 w 534
seem 1 w 538
to 6 w 540
be 5 w 542
strengthened 1 w 554
by 2 w 556
that 2 w 560
decision 1 w 568
I 5 w 571
see 2 w 574
that 3 w 578
the 8 w 581
cause 3 w 586
is 8 w 588
one 2 w 591
requiring 2 w 600
the 9 w 603
greatest 3 w 611
abilities 1 w 620
not 2 w 624
in 10 w 626
order 1 w 631
to 7 w 633
demonstrate 1 w 644
what 1 w 648
is 9 w 650
before 1 w 656
men 2 w 659
s 44 w 661
eyes 1 w 665
but 2 w 669
to 8 w 671
prevent 1 w 678
if 3 w 681
any 2 w 684
mistake 1 w 691
is 11 w 693
made 1 w 697
by 3 w 699
you 1 w 702
in 11 w 704
so 4 w 706
important 1 w 715
a 60 w 716
matter 2 w 722
every 1 w 728
one 3 w 731
from 1 w 735
thinking 1 w 743
that 4 w 747
I 6 w 748
have 4 w 752
been 2 w 756
wanting 1 w 763
to 9 w 765
the 10 w 768
cause 4 w 773
rather 1 w 780
than 1 w 784
that 5 w 788
you 2 w 791
have 5 w 795
to 10 w 797
your 1 w 801
religious 1 w 810
obligations 1 w 821
Although 1 w 830
I 7 w 831
am 1 w 833
persuaded 1 w 842
O 1 w 844
judges 1 w 850
that 6 w 855
you 4 w 858
have 6 w 862
not 3 w 865
now 2 w 868
doubted 1 w 875
about 1 w 880
the 12 w 883
same 1 w 887
cause 5 w 892
twice 1 w 897
on 10 w 900
account 1 w 907
of 6 w 909
the 13 w 912
obscure 1 w 919
and 5 w 922
uncertain 1 w 931
state 1 w 936
of 7 w 938
the 14 w 941
law 2 w 944
so 5 w 947
much 1 w 951
as 4 w 953
because 2 w 960
this 3 w 964
trial 1 w 969
appears 1 w 976
to 11 w 978
affect 1 w 984
that 7 w 988
man 1 w 991
s 63 w 993
personal 1 w 1001
character 1 w 1010
and 6 w 1014
on 12 w 1016
that 8 w 1020
account 2 w 1027
you 5 w 1030
have 7 w 1034
delayed 1 w 1041
condemning 1 w 1051
him 1 w 1054
and 7 w 1058
have 8 w 1062
also 2 w 1066
given 1 w 1071
him 2 w 1074
time 2 w 1078
to 12 w 1080
recollect 1 w 1089
himself 1 w 1096
And 2 w 1100
since 1 w 1105
that 9 w 1109
custom 1 w 1115
has 1 w 1118
now 3 w 1121
become 1 w 1127
a 104 w 1128
usual 1 w 1133
one 4 w 1136
and 8 w 1140
since 2 w 1145
good 2 w 1149
men 3 w 1152
men 4 w 1157
like 1 w 1161
yourselves 1 w 1171
do 2 w 1175
the 15 w 1178
same 2 w 1182
when 2 w 1186
sitting 1 w 1193
as 6 w 1195
judges 2 w 1201
it 8 w 1204
is 13 w 1206
perhaps 1 w 1214
less 1 w 1219
blamable 1 w 1227
But 2 w 1231
still 1 w 1236
it 9 w 1238
appears 2 w 1245
a 114 w 1246
thing 1 w 1251
to 14 w 1253
be 10 w 1255
complained 1 w 1265
of 8 w 1267
because 3 w 1275
all 3 w 1278
judicial 1 w 1286
proceedings 1 w 1297
have 9 w 1301
been 3 w 1305
devised 1 w 1312
either 1 w 1318
for 3 w 1321
the 17 w 1324
sake 1 w 1328
of 9 w 1330
putting 1 w 1337
an 17 w 1339
end 2 w 1342
to 15 w 1344
disputes 1 w 1352
or 8 w 1355
of 10 w 1357
punishing 1 w 1366
crimes 1 w 1372
of 11 w 1375
which 4 w 1380
the 18 w 1383
first 1 w 1388
is 17 w 1390
the 19 w 1393
least 1 w 1398
important 2 w 1407
object 1 w 1413
because 4 w 1421
it 11 w 1423
is 18 w 1425
less 2 w 1429
severe 1 w 1435
on 15 w 1437
individuals 1 w 1448
and 9 w 1452
because 5 w 1459
it 12 w 1461
is 19 w 1463
often 1 w 1468
terminated 1 w 1478
by 4 w 1480
some 2 w 1484
friendly 1 w 1492
mediator 1 w 1500
The 1 w 1504
other 1 w 1509
is 20 w 1511
most 1 w 1515
formidable 1 w 1525
because 6 w 1533
it 13 w 1535
relates 1 w 1542
to 17 w 1544
more 1 w 1548
important 3 w 1557
matters 1 w 1564
and 10 w 1568
requires 1 w 1576
not 4 w 1579
the 21 w 1582
honorary 1 w 1590
assistance 1 w 1600
of 13 w 1602
some 3 w 1606
friend 2 w 1612
but 3 w 1616
the 22 w 1619
severity 1 w 1627
and 11 w 1630
vigour 1 w 1636
of 14 w 1638
a 140 w 1639
judge 3 w 1644
That 1 w 1649
which 5 w 1654
was 1 w 1657
the 23 w 1660
more 2 w 1664
important 4 w 1673
and 12 w 1677
on 17 w 1679
account 3 w 1686
of 15 w 1688
which 6 w 1693
judicial 2 w 1701
proceedings 2 w 1712
were 3 w 1716
most 2 w 1720
especially 2 w 1730
instituted 1 w 1740
has 2 w 1744
been 4 w 1748
long 1 w 1752
abolished 1 w 1761
by 5 w 1763
evil 1 w 1767
customs 1 w 1774
For 1 w 1778
the 24 w 1781
more 3 w 1785
disgraceful 1 w 1796
a 151 w 1797
thing 2 w 1802
is 24 w 1804
the 25 w 1808
more 4 w 1812
severely 1 w 1820
and 13 w 1823
the 26 w 1826
more 5 w 1830
promptly 1 w 1838
ought 1 w 1843
it 16 w 1845
to 19 w 1847
be 17 w 1849
punished 1 w 1857
and 14 w 1861
yet 1 w 1864
those 2 w 1869
things 1 w 1875
which 7 w 1880
involve 1 w 1887
danger 1 w 1893
to 20 w 1895
a 155 w 1896
man 2 w 1899
s 130 w 1901
character 2 w 1910
are 2 w 1913
the 27 w 1916
slowest 1 w 1923
to 21 w 1925
be 18 w 1927
punished 2 w 1935
How 1 w 1939
then 2 w 1944
can 1 w 1948
it 17 w 1950
be 19 w 1952
right 3 w 1957
that 10 w 1961
the 29 w 1964
same 3 w 1968
cause 11 w 1973
which 8 w 1978
prompted 1 w 1986
the 30 w 1989
institution 1 w 2000
of 16 w 2002
legal 1 w 2007
proceedings 3 w 2018
should 2 w 2025
also 3 w 2029
cause 12 w 2034
the 31 w 2037
delay 2 w 2042
that 11 w 2046
exists 1 w 2052
in 34 w 2054
coming 1 w 2060
to 22 w 2062
a 169 w 2063
decision 2 w 2071
If 1 w 2074
any 3 w 2077
one 5 w 2080
when 3 w 2085
he 41 w 2087
has 3 w 2090
given 2 w 2095
security 1 w 2103
when 4 w 2109
he 43 w 2111
has 4 w 2114
bound 1 w 2119
himself 2 w 2126
by 6 w 2128
one 6 w 2131
word 1 w 2135
does 1 w 2140
not 5 w 2143
do 4 w 2145
what 2 w 2149
he 44 w 2151
has 5 w 2154
rendered 1 w 2162
himself 3 w 2169
liable 1 w 2175
to 23 w 2177
do 5 w 2179
then 3 w 2184
he 46 w 2186
is 29 w 2188
condemned 1 w 2197
by 7 w 2199
the 33 w 2202
natural 1 w 2209
course 1 w 2215
of 17 w 2217
justice 1 w 2224
without 1 w 2231
any 4 w 2234
appeal 1 w 2240
to 24 w 2242
the 34 w 2245
severity 2 w 2253
of 18 w 2255
the 35 w 2258
judge 4 w 2263
If 2 w 2266
a 181 w 2267
man 3 w 2270
as 14 w 2273
a 184 w 2274
guardian 1 w 2282
or 22 w 2285
as 15 w 2287
a 188 w 2288
partner 1 w 2295
or 23 w 2298
as 16 w 2300
a 191 w 2301
person 2 w 2307
in 36 w 2309
a 192 w 2310
place 1 w 2315
of 19 w 2317
trust 1 w 2322
or 24 w 2325
as 17 w 2327
any 5 w 2330
one 7 w 2333
s 161 w 2335
agent 1 w 2340
has 6 w 2344
cheated 1 w 2351
any 6 w 2354
one 8 w 2357
the 36 w 2361
greater 1 w 2368
his 4 w 2371
offence 1 w 2378
is 31 w 2380
the 37 w 2384
slower 1 w 2390
is 32 w 2392
his 5 w 2395
punishment 1 w 2405
Yes 1 w 2410
for 5 w 2414
the 38 w 2417
sentence 1 w 2425
is 35 w 2427
a 201 w 2428
sentence 2 w 2436
of 21 w 2438
infamy 1 w 2444
Yes 2 w 2450
if 4 w 2453
it 22 w 2455
arises 1 w 2461
from 2 w 2465
an 37 w 2467
infamous 1 w 2475
action 1 w 2481
See 1 w 2486
then 4 w 2491
how 1 w 2495
iniquitously 1 w 2507
it 24 w 2509
happens 1 w 2516
that 12 w 2521
because 7 w 2528
an 38 w 2530
action 2 w 2536
is 37 w 2538
infamous 2 w 2546
therefore 1 w 2556
a 213 w 2557
discreditable 1 w 2570
reputation 1 w 2580
should 3 w 2586
attach 1 w 2592
to 26 w 2594
it 26 w 2596
but 4 w 2600
that 13 w 2604
a 219 w 2605
scandalous 1 w 2615
action 3 w 2621
is 39 w 2623
not 6 w 2626
to 27 w 2628
be 21 w 2630
punished 3 w 2638
because 8 w 2646
if 5 w 2649
it 27 w 2651
were 4 w 2655
it 28 w 2658
would 3 w 2663
involve 2 w 2670
a 224 w 2671
loss 1 w 2675
of 22 w 2677
reputation 2 w 2687
It 1 w 2690
is 41 w 2692
just 2 w 2696
as 19 w 2698
if 6 w 2700
any 7 w 2703
judex 1 w 2708
or 27 w 2710
recuperator 1 w 2721
were 5 w 2725
to 29 w 2727
say 1 w 2730
to 30 w 2732
me 17 w 2734
Why 1 w 2739
you 7 w 2743
might 1 w 2748
have 10 w 2752
tried 1 w 2757
it 29 w 2759
in 42 w 2761
an 41 w 2763
inferior 1 w 2771
court 1 w 2776
you 8 w 2781
might 2 w 2786
have 11 w 2790
obtained 1 w 2798
your 3 w 2802
rights 3 w 2808
by 8 w 2810
an 42 w 2812
easier 1 w 2818
and 16 w 2821
more 6 w 2825
convenient 1 w 2835
process 1 w 2842
therefore 2 w 2852
either 2 w 2859
change 1 w 2865
your 4 w 2869
form 2 w 2873
of 23 w 2875
action 4 w 2881
or 33 w 2884
else 1 w 2888
do 6 w 2890
not 7 w 2893
press 1 w 2898
me 18 w 2900
to 31 w 2902
give 3 w 2906
my 4 w 2908
decision 3 w 2916
And 3 w 2921
yet 2 w 2924
he 59 w 2926
would 4 w 2931
appear 3 w 2937
more 7 w 2941
timid 1 w 2946
than 2 w 2950
a 242 w 2951
bold 1 w 2955
judge 5 w 2960
ought 2 w 2965
to 32 w 2967
appear 4 w 2973
or 35 w 2976
more 8 w 2980
covetous 1 w 2988
than 3 w 2992
it 31 w 2994
is 43 w 2996
right 5 w 3001
for 9 w 3004
a 246 w 3005
wise 1 w 3009
judge 6 w 3014
to 34 w 3016
be 23 w 3018
if 7 w 3021
he 60 w 3023
were 6 w 3027
either 3 w 3033
to 35 w 3035
prescribe 1 w 3044
to 36 w 3046
me 19 w 3048
how 2 w 3051
I 11 w 3052
should 4 w 3058
follow 1 w 3064
up 2 w 3066
my 5 w 3068
own 1 w 3071
rights 4 w 3077
or 38 w 3080
if 8 w 3082
he 62 w 3084
were 7 w 3088
to 37 w 3090
be 25 w 3092
afraid 1 w 3098
himself 4 w 3105
to 38 w 3107
give 4 w 3111
his 6 w 3114
decision 4 w 3122
in 45 w 3124
a 249 w 3125
matter 4 w 3131
which 9 w 3136
was 2 w 3139
brought 1 w 3146
before 2 w 3152
him 7 w 3155
In 1 w 3158
truth 1 w 3163
if 9 w 3166
the 44 w 3169
praetor 1 w 3176
who 1 w 3180
allows 1 w 3186
the 45 w 3189
trials 1 w 3195
to 40 w 3197
proceed 4 w 3204
never 1 w 3210
prescribes 1 w 3220
to 41 w 3222
a 255 w 3223
claimant 1 w 3231
what 3 w 3235
form 3 w 3239
of 24 w 3241
action 5 w 3247
he 65 w 3249
wishes 1 w 3255
him 8 w 3258
to 42 w 3260
adopt 1 w 3265
consider 1 w 3274
how 3 w 3277
scandalous 2 w 3287
a 263 w 3288
thing 4 w 3293
it 33 w 3295
must 1 w 3299
be 28 w 3301
when 5 w 3306
the 46 w 3309
matter 5 w 3315
is 48 w 3317
so 12 w 3319
far 1 w 3322
settled 1 w 3329
for 12 w 3333
a 266 w 3334
judge 7 w 3339
to 43 w 3341
ask 1 w 3344
what 4 w 3348
might 3 w 3353
have 12 w 3357
been 5 w 3361
done 1 w 3365
or 43 w 3368
what 5 w 3372
can 4 w 3375
be 30 w 3377
done 2 w 3381
now 4 w 3384
and 18 w 3388
not 8 w 3391
what 6 w 3395
has 7 w 3398
been 6 w 3402
done 3 w 3406