Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / De Filio (Orat. 29)

De Filio (Orat. 29) (16)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg2022.tlg009.1st1K-grc1:16
Refs {'start': {'reference': '16', 'human_reference': 'Chapter 16'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Ἐκεῖνο δὲ πῶς παραδράμωμεν, οὐδενὸς ἧττον τῶν εἰρημένων ὂν ἀξιάγαστον; Ο πατήρ, φησιν, οὐσίας,
ἐνεργείας ὄνομα; ὡς ἀμφοτέρωθεν ἡμᾶς δήσοντες, εἰ μὲν οὐσίας φήσομεν, συνθησομένους ἑτεροούσιον εἶναι τὸν υἱόν, ἐπειδὴ μία μὲν οὐσία θεοῦ, ταύτην δέ, ὡς οὗτοι, προκατείληφες πατήρ· εἰ δὲ ἐνεργείας, ποίημα σαφῶς ὁμολογή- [*] [*] [*] [*] [*] [*] [*] [*]

98
σοντας, ἁλλ οὐ γέννημα. οὗ γὰρ ἐνεργῶν, ἐκεῖ πάντως καὶ τὸ ἐνεργούμενον. καὶ πῶς τῷ πεποιηκότι ταὐτὸν τὸ πεποιημένον, θαυμάζειν φήσουσι. σφόδρα ἂν ᾐδέσθην ὑμῶν καὶ αὐτὸς τὴν διαίρεσιν, εἰ τῶν δύο τὸ ἕτερον δέξασθαι
ἢν ἀναγκαῖον, ἁλλὰ μὴ τὰ δύο διαφυγόντα τρίτον εἰπεῖν ἀληθέστερον· ὅτι οὔτε οὐσίας ὄνομα πατήρ, σοφώτατοι, οὔτε ἐνεργείας, σχέσεως δὲ καὶ τοῦ πῶς ἔχει πρὸς τὸν υἱὸν πατήρ, υἱὸς πρὸς τὸν πατέρα. ὡς γὰρ παρ ἡμῖν αἱ κλήσεις αὗται τὸ γνήσιον καὶ οἰκεῖον γνωρίζουσιν,
οὕτω κἀκεῖ τὴν τοῦ γεγεννημένου πρὸς τὸ γεγεννηκὸς ὁμοφυίαν σημαίνουσιν. ἔστω δέ, ὑμῶν χάριν, καὶ οὐσία τις πατήρ· συνεισάξει τὸν υἱόν, οὐκ ἀλλοτριώσει, κατὰ τὰς κοινὰς ἐννοίας καὶ τὴν τῶν κλήσεων τούτων δύναμιν. ἔστω καὶ ἐνεργείας,εἰ τοῦτο δοκεῖ· οὐδὲ οὕτως ἡμᾶς αἱρήσετε.
αὐτὸ δὲ τοῦτο ἐνηργηκὼς ἂν εἴη τὸ ὁμοούσιον, εἰ καὶ ἄτοπος ἄλλως τῆς περὶ τοῦτο ἐνεργείας ὑπόληψις. ὁρᾶς ὅπως ὑμῶν, καὶ κακομαχεῖν ἐθελόντων, τὰς στροφὰς διαφεύγομεν; ἐπεὶ δέ σου τὸ ἐν τοῖς λογισμοῖς καὶ ταῖς στροφαῖς ἄμαχον [*] [*] [*] [*] [*] [*] [*] [*] [*]
99
ἔγνωμεν, ἴδωμέν σου καὶ τὴν ἐκ τῶν θείων λογίων ἰσχύν, ἃν ἄρα δέξῃ κἀντεῦθεν πείθειν ἡμᾶς.

Tokens

Ἐκεῖνο 1 w 6
δὲ 1 w 8
πῶς 1 w 11
παραδράμωμεν 1 w 23
οὐδενὸς 1 w 31
ἧττον 1 w 36
τῶν 1 w 39
εἰρημένων 1 w 48
ὂν 1 w 50
ἀξιάγαστον 1 w 60
Ο 1 w 63
πατήρ 1 w 68
φησιν 1 w 74
οὐσίας 1 w 81
1 w 83
ἐνεργείας 1 w 92
ὄνομα 1 w 97
ὡς 1 w 100
ἀμφοτέρωθεν 1 w 111
ἡμᾶς 1 w 115
δήσοντες 1 w 123
εἰ 2 w 127
μὲν 1 w 130
οὐσίας 2 w 136
φήσομεν 1 w 143
συνθησομένους 1 w 157
ἑτεροούσιον 1 w 168
εἶναι 1 w 173
τὸν 1 w 176
υἱόν 1 w 180
ἐπειδὴ 1 w 187
μία 1 w 190
μὲν 2 w 193
οὐσία 3 w 198
θεοῦ 1 w 202
ταύτην 1 w 209
δέ 1 w 211
ὡς 2 w 214
οὗτοι 1 w 219
προκατείληφες 1 w 233
1 w 234
πατήρ 2 w 239
εἰ 3 w 242
δὲ 2 w 244
ἐνεργείας 2 w 253
ποίημα 1 w 260
σαφῶς 1 w 265
ὁμολογή- 1 w 273
2 1 w 274
σύναγε 1 w 280
cdefg 1 w 285
duo 1 w 289
Reg 1 w 292
Or 1 w 295
1 1 w 297
3 1 w 299
πάρα 1 w 303
τὸ 2 w 305
πη 1 w 307
παρατροπὴν 1 w 318
om 1 w 321
και 1 w 324
b 1 w 326
παρατροπῇ 1 w 336
Reg 2 w 340
a 1 w 342
3 2 w 344
παρὰ 1 w 349
τὸ 3 w 351
πῆ 1 w 353
κ 4 w 354
ἁπλῶς 1 w 360
The 1 w 365
fallacy 1 w 372
lies 1 w 376
in 1 w 378
arguing 1 w 385
from 1 w 389
the 1 w 392
conditioned 1 w 403
to 1 w 405
the 2 w 408
absolute 1 w 416
lit 1 w 421
is 1 w 425
on 3 w 427
account 1 w 434
of 1 w 436
that 1 w 440
which 1 w 445
is 2 w 447
so 2 w 449
for 1 w 452
special 1 w 459
reasons 1 w 466
and 1 w 469
that 2 w 473
which 2 w 478
is 3 w 480
so 4 w 482
absolutely 1 w 492
4 1 w 496
τοῖς 1 w 501
περὶ 1 w 505
ταῦτα 1 w 510
to 2 w 514
use 1 w 517
the 3 w 520
technical 1 w 529
language 1 w 537
of 2 w 539
logicians 1 w 548
lit 2 w 553
as 2 w 557
it 4 w 559
is 4 w 561
customary 1 w 570
to 4 w 572
speak 1 w 577
technically 1 w 588
for 2 w 591
those 1 w 596
who 1 w 599
concern 1 w 606
themselves 1 w 616
with 1 w 620
these 1 w 625
5 1 w 629
ἡμῶν 1 w 634
γὰρ 1 w 637
κτλ 1 w 640
For 1 w 646
when 1 w 650
we 1 w 652
allow 1 w 657
that 3 w 661
it 6 w 663
is 5 w 665
in 3 w 667
the 6 w 670
nature 1 w 676
of 3 w 678
a 24 w 679
cause 1 w 684
to 5 w 686
be 1 w 688
greater 1 w 695
than 1 w 699
the 7 w 702
thing 1 w 707
caused 1 w 713
they 1 w 718
infer 1 w 723
that 4 w 727
it 7 w 729
is 6 w 731
greater 2 w 738
by 1 w 740
nature 2 w 746
which 3 w 752
is 7 w 754
like 1 w 758
arguing 2 w 765
that 5 w 769
because 1 w 776
we 2 w 778
say 1 w 781
Such 1 w 787
and 2 w 790
such 1 w 794
a 37 w 795
man 1 w 798
is 8 w 800
dead 1 w 804
therefore 1 w 815
man 2 w 818
in 7 w 821
the 10 w 824
abstract 1 w 832
is 9 w 835
The 2 w 839
emphasis 1 w 847
of 4 w 850
course 1 w 856
is 11 w 859
on 6 w 861
3 w 862
δεῖνα 1 w 867
and 3 w 871
it 8 w 873
seems 1 w 878
simplest 1 w 886
to 6 w 888
take 1 w 892
ἄνθρ 1 w 896
along 1 w 902
with 2 w 906
it 10 w 908
as 4 w 910
subject 1 w 917
understanding 1 w 931
νεκρός 1 w 937
alone 1 w 942
to 7 w 944
be 3 w 946
predicate 1 w 955
an 10 w 958
arrangement 1 w 969
of 5 w 971
words 1 w 976
like 2 w 980
4 w 981
μέγας 1 w 986
τέθνηκε 1 w 993
Βασίλειος 1 w 1002
But 1 w 1006
the 11 w 1009
sense 1 w 1014
is 12 w 1016
the 12 w 1019
Same 1 w 1023
either 1 w 1029
way 1 w 1032
In 1 w 1035
the 14 w 1038
apodosis 1 w 1046
τὸν 2 w 1050
ἄνθρ 2 w 1054
is 14 w 1057
subject 2 w 1064
the 15 w 1068
predicate 2 w 1077
being 1 w 1082
supplied 1 w 1090
from 2 w 1094
the 16 w 1097
previous 1 w 1105
clause 1 w 1111
sc 1 w 1114
νεκρὸν 1 w 1121
εἶναι 2 w 1126
The 3 w 1130
commentators 1 w 1142
from 3 w 1146
Elias 1 w 1151
onwards 1 w 1158
have 1 w 1162
totally 1 w 1169
failed 1 w 1175
to 10 w 1177
catch 1 w 1182
the 17 w 1185
argument 1 w 1193
or 7 w 1196
even 1 w 1200
to 11 w 1202
understand 2 w 1212
the 18 w 1215
grammar 1 w 1222
of 6 w 1224
the 19 w 1227
passage 1 w 1234
If 1 w 1237
Gr 1 w 1239
had 1 w 1243
intended 1 w 1251
to 12 w 1253
say 2 w 1256
anything 1 w 1264
so 6 w 1266
pointless 1 w 1275
as 7 w 1277
Petavius 1 w 1285
de 6 w 1288
Trin 1 w 1292
II 1 w 1295
v 6 w 1296
12 1 w 1298
makes 1 w 1304
out 1 w 1307
viz 1 w 1311
that 6 w 1316
because 2 w 1323
5 w 1324
δεῖνα 2 w 1329
is 15 w 1331
a 80 w 1332
dead 2 w 1336
man 3 w 1339
therefore 2 w 1349
he 25 w 1351
is 16 w 1353
a 83 w 1354
man 4 w 1357
he 26 w 1360
must 1 w 1364
have 2 w 1368
said 1 w 1372
τὸ 5 w 1374
ἄνθρωπον 1 w 1382
not 1 w 1386
τόν 1 w 1389
So 1 w 1392
far 1 w 1395
Elias 2 w 1400
whom 1 w 1405
Petavius 2 w 1413
quotes 1 w 1419
knew 1 w 1424
better 1 w 1430
16 1 w 1433
Well 1 w 1439
they 2 w 1444
say 3 w 1447
the 22 w 1452
word 2 w 1456
Father 1 w 1462
must 2 w 1466
denote 1 w 1472
either 2 w 1478
nature 3 w 1484
or 10 w 1486
operation 1 w 1495
which 4 w 1501
is 17 w 1503
it 13 w 1505
to 13 w 1507
be 7 w 1509
Neither 1 w 1518
is 18 w 1521
the 26 w 1524
answer 1 w 1530
it 15 w 1533
denotes 1 w 1540
a 95 w 1541
relation 1 w 1549
and 6 w 1553
α 33 w 1554
relation 2 w 1562
which 5 w 1567
implies 1 w 1574
community 1 w 1583
of 7 w 1585
nature 4 w 1591
between 1 w 1598
the 27 w 1601
Father 2 w 1607
and 7 w 1610
the 29 w 1613
Son 1 w 1616
10 1 w 1619
ἀξιάγαστον 2 w 1630
astonishing 1 w 1643
from 4 w 1649
ἄγαμαι 1 w 1655
to 15 w 1658
wonder 1 w 1664
ib 1 w 1667
οὐσίας 3 w 1674
2 w 1676
ἐνεργ 3 w 1681
ὄν 2 w 1684
is 20 w 1689
it 17 w 1691
a 103 w 1692
name 1 w 1696
denoting 1 w 1704
essence 1 w 1711
or 11 w 1714
operation 2 w 1723
12 2 w 1727
ἑτεροούσιον 2 w 1739
A 1 w 1741
word 3 w 1745
modelled 1 w 1753
on 17 w 1755
the 30 w 1758
false 1 w 1763
analogy 1 w 1770
of 8 w 1772
ὁμοούσιος 1 w 1781
It 1 w 1784
should 1 w 1790
be 9 w 1792
ἐτερούσιος 1 w 1802
σοντας 1 w 1809
ἁλλ 1 w 1813
οὐ 6 w 1816
γέννημα 1 w 1823
οὗ 2 w 1826
γὰρ 2 w 1829
7 w 1830
ἐνεργῶν 1 w 1837
ἐκεῖ 1 w 1842
πάντως 1 w 1848
καὶ 1 w 1851
τὸ 6 w 1853
ἐνεργούμενον 1 w 1865
καὶ 2 w 1869
πῶς 2 w 1872
τῷ 1 w 1874
πεποιηκότι 1 w 1884
ταὐτὸν 1 w 1890
τὸ 8 w 1892
πεποιημένον 1 w 1903
θαυμάζειν 1 w 1913
φήσουσι 1 w 1920
σφόδρα 1 w 1927
ἂν 1 w 1929
ᾐδέσθην 1 w 1936
ὑμῶν 1 w 1940
καὶ 3 w 1943
αὐτὸς 1 w 1948
τὴν 1 w 1951
διαίρεσιν 1 w 1960
εἰ 4 w 1963
τῶν 2 w 1966
δύο 1 w 1969
τὸ 10 w 1971
ἕτερον 1 w 1977
δέξασθαι 1 w 1985
ἢν 1 w 1987
ἀναγκαῖον 1 w 1996
ἁλλὰ 1 w 2001
μὴ 1 w 2003
τὰ 1 w 2005
δύο 2 w 2008
διαφυγόντα 1 w 2018
τρίτον 1 w 2024
εἰπεῖν 1 w 2030
ἀληθέστερον 1 w 2041
ὅτι 1 w 2045
οὔτε 1 w 2049
οὐσίας 4 w 2055
ὄνομα 2 w 2060
8 w 2061
πατήρ 3 w 2066
1 w 2068
σοφώτατοι 1 w 2077
οὔτε 2 w 2082
ἐνεργείας 3 w 2091
σχέσεως 1 w 2099
δὲ 3 w 2101
καὶ 4 w 2104
τοῦ 1 w 2107
πῶς 3 w 2110
ἔχει 1 w 2114
πρὸς 1 w 2118
τὸν 4 w 2121
υἱὸν 1 w 2125
9 w 2126
πατήρ 4 w 2131
4 w 2133
10 w 2134
υἱὸς 1 w 2138
πρὸς 2 w 2142
τὸν 5 w 2145
πατέρα 1 w 2151
ὡς 3 w 2154
γὰρ 3 w 2157
παρ 5 w 2160
ἡμῖν 1 w 2165
αἱ 1 w 2167
κλήσεις 1 w 2174
αὗται 1 w 2179
τὸ 13 w 2181
γνήσιον 1 w 2188
καὶ 5 w 2191
οἰκεῖον 1 w 2198
γνωρίζουσιν 1 w 2209
οὕτω 1 w 2214
κἀκεῖ 1 w 2219
τὴν 2 w 2222
τοῦ 2 w 2225
γεγεννημένου 1 w 2237
πρὸς 3 w 2241
τὸ 14 w 2243
γεγεννηκὸς 1 w 2253
ὁμοφυίαν 1 w 2261
σημαίνουσιν 1 w 2272
ἔστω 1 w 2277
δέ 4 w 2279
ὑμῶν 2 w 2284
χάριν 1 w 2289
καὶ 6 w 2293
οὐσία 6 w 2298
τις 1 w 2301
12 w 2302
πατήρ 5 w 2307
συνεισάξει 1 w 2318
τὸν 6 w 2321
υἱόν 2 w 2325
οὐκ 1 w 2329
ἀλλοτριώσει 1 w 2340
κατὰ 1 w 2345
τὰς 1 w 2348
κοινὰς 1 w 2354
ἐννοίας 1 w 2361
καὶ 7 w 2364
τὴν 3 w 2367
τῶν 3 w 2370
κλήσεων 1 w 2377
τούτων 1 w 2383
δύναμιν 1 w 2390
ἔστω 2 w 2395
καὶ 8 w 2398
ἐνεργείας 4 w 2407
εἰ 6 w 2410
τοῦτο 1 w 2415
δοκεῖ 1 w 2420
οὐδὲ 1 w 2425
οὕτως 1 w 2430
ἡμᾶς 2 w 2434
αἱρήσετε 1 w 2442
αὐτὸ 3 w 2447
δὲ 5 w 2449
τοῦτο 2 w 2454
ἐνηργηκὼς 1 w 2463
ἂν 2 w 2465
εἴη 1 w 2468
τὸ 17 w 2470
ὁμοούσιον 1 w 2479
εἰ 7 w 2482
καὶ 9 w 2485
ἄτοπος 1 w 2491
ἄλλως 1 w 2496
5 w 2497
τῆς 1 w 2500
περὶ 2 w 2504
τοῦτο 3 w 2509
ἐνεργείας 5 w 2518
ὑπόληψις 1 w 2526
ὁρᾶς 1 w 2531
ὅπως 1 w 2535
ὑμῶν 3 w 2539
καὶ 10 w 2543
κακομαχεῖν 1 w 2553
ἐθελόντων 1 w 2562
τὰς 2 w 2566
στροφὰς 1 w 2573
διαφεύγομεν 1 w 2584
ἐπεὶ 1 w 2589
δέ 5 w 2591
σου 2 w 2594
τὸ 18 w 2596
ἐν 11 w 2598
τοῖς 2 w 2602
λογισμοῖς 1 w 2611
καὶ 11 w 2614
ταῖς 1 w 2618
στροφαῖς 1 w 2626
ἄμαχον 1 w 2632
16 2 w 2634
5 2 w 2636
διαφυγόντα 2 w 2646
φυγόντα 3 w 2654
b 18 w 2655
11 1 w 2657
οὐσία 7 w 2662
οὐσίας 5 w 2669
e 154 w 2670
Reg 3 w 2674
Cypr 1 w 2679
14 1 w 2682
αἱρήσετε 2 w 2690
σητεb 1 w 2696
σεται 1 w 2703
d 40 w 2704
15 1 w 2706
δε 4 w 2709
γὰρ 4 w 2713
Reg 4 w 2717
Cypr 2 w 2722
aliiq 1 w 2728
Reg 5 w 2732
et 5 w 2735
Colb 1 w 2739
16 3 w 2743
ἄλλως 2 w 2748
πὼς 1 w 2752
df 1 w 2754
πέρι 1 w 2758
πρὸς 4 w 2763
b 21 w 2764
17 1 w 2766
om 10 w 2768
καὶ 12 w 2771
bc 1 w 2773
1 13 w 2774
οὗ 3 w 2777
γὰρ 5 w 2780
15 w 2781
ἐνεργῶν 2 w 2788
lit 3 w 2792
where 1 w 2799
there 3 w 2804
is 21 w 2806
one 3 w 2809
performing 1 w 2819
an 20 w 2821
operation 3 w 2830
there 4 w 2836
is 22 w 2838
also 1 w 2842
the 33 w 2845
result 1 w 2851
of 9 w 2853
the 34 w 2856
operation 4 w 2865
It 2 w 2869
is 23 w 2871
not 5 w 2874
very 1 w 2878
obvious 1 w 2885
why 1 w 2888
γέννησις 1 w 2896
should 2 w 2902
not 6 w 2905
be 10 w 2907
included 1 w 2915
under 3 w 2920
the 35 w 2923
head 1 w 2927
of 10 w 2929
ἐνέργεια 1 w 2937
and 8 w 2941
Gr 2 w 2943
does 1 w 2948
not 7 w 2951
much 1 w 2955
object 1 w 2961
to 16 w 2963
it 19 w 2965
But 2 w 2969
evidently 1 w 2978
Gr 3 w 2980
s 99 w 2983
opponent 1 w 2991
made 1 w 2995
ἐνεργεῖν 1 w 3003
ποιεῖν 1 w 3009
3 3 w 3011
ᾐδέσθην 2 w 3019
iron 1 w 3024
I 7 w 3027
should 3 w 3033
have 3 w 3037
stood 1 w 3042
in 18 w 3044
great 3 w 3049
awe 1 w 3053
7 2 w 3056
σχέσεως 2 w 3064
relation 3 w 3074
explained 1 w 3086
by 2 w 3088
τοῦ 6 w 3091
πῶς 4 w 3094
ὦι 1 w 3096
πρός 1 w 3100
κτλ 2 w 3103
10 2 w 3106
κὰκεῖ 1 w 3111
when 2 w 3115
used 2 w 3119
in 20 w 3121
ref 3 w 3124
to 18 w 3127
the 36 w 3130
Godhead 1 w 3137
12 3 w 3140
συνεισάξει 2 w 3151
will 1 w 3157
at 27 w 3159
the 37 w 3162
same 1 w 3166
moment 1 w 3172
imply 1 w 3177
the 38 w 3180
Son 2 w 3183
15 2 w 3187
αὐτὸδἐ 1 w 3194
τοῦτο 4 w 3199
His 1 w 3204
operation 5 w 3213
will 2 w 3217
still 1 w 3222
have 4 w 3226
produced 1 w 3234
that 7 w 3238
very 2 w 3242
result 2 w 3248
consubstantial 1 w 3262
with 3 w 3266
Himself 1 w 3273
ib 2 w 3277
εἰ 8 w 3280
καἰ 1 w 3283
ἄτοπος 2 w 3289
The 4 w 3293
καὶ 13 w 3296
be 11 w 3298
taken 1 w 3303
closely 1 w 3310
with 4 w 3314
ἄτοπος 3 w 3320
and 9 w 3323
disjoined 1 w 3332
from 5 w 3336
εἰ 9 w 3338
which 6 w 3344
has 2 w 3347
here 6 w 3351
the 39 w 3354
force 1 w 3359
of 11 w 3361
since 1 w 3367
The 5 w 3372
reading 1 w 3379
5 w 3380
adopted 1 w 3388
by 3 w 3390
the 40 w 3393
Benedictines 1 w 3405
makes 2 w 3411
ἄλλως 3 w 3416
superfluous 1 w 3427
The 6 w 3431
notion 1 w 3437
of 12 w 3439
such 2 w 3443
an 24 w 3445
operation 6 w 3454
as 11 w 3456
results 1 w 3463
in 25 w 3465
a 139 w 3466
Son 3 w 3469
would 1 w 3475
be 12 w 3477
absurd 1 w 3483
if 1 w 3485
it 22 w 3487
did 1 w 3490
not 9 w 3493
imply 2 w 3498
a 141 w 3499
real 1 w 3503
i 129 w 3505
e 229 w 3507
a 143 w 3509
consubstantial 2 w 3523
Son 4 w 3527
17 2 w 3530
κακομαχεῖν 2 w 3541
to 19 w 3545
fight 1 w 3550
unscrupulously 1 w 3564
The 7 w 3568
word 4 w 3572
στροφάς 1 w 3579
twists 1 w 3587
shews 1 w 3594
that 8 w 3598
the 41 w 3601
μάχη 1 w 3605
is 27 w 3607
a 147 w 3608
wrestling-match 1 w 3623
not 10 w 3627
a 149 w 3628
battle 1 w 3634
ἔγνωμεν 1 w 3642
ἴδωμέν 1 w 3649
σου 3 w 3652
καὶ 14 w 3655
τὴν 4 w 3658
ἐκ 2 w 3660
τῶν 4 w 3663
θείων 1 w 3668
λογίων 1 w 3674
ἰσχύν 1 w 3679
ἃν 1 w 3682
ἄρα 1 w 3685
δέξῃ 1 w 3689
κἀντεῦθεν 1 w 3698
πείθειν 1 w 3705
ἡμᾶς 3 w 3709