Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The Discourses of Epictetus

The Discourses of Epictetus (1.5)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0557.tlg001.perseus-eng4:1.5
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1.5', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Chapter 5'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '1'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
Concerning the academics.[*]

It is said that there are those who will oppose very evident truths, and yet it is not easy to find a reason which may persuade such an one to alter his opinion. This may arise neither from his own strength nor from the weakness of his teacher; but when a man becomes obstinate in error, reason cannot always reach him.

Now there are two sorts of obstinacy: the one, of the intellect; the other, of the will. A man may obstinately set himself not to assent to evident truths, nor to quit the defence of contradictions. We all dread a bodily paralysis, and would make use of every contrivance to avoid it; but none of us is troubled about a paralysis of the soul. And yet, indeed, even with regard to the soul, when a person is so affected as not to apprehend or understand anything, we think him in a sad condition; but where the emotions

p.1021
of shame and modesty are under an absolute paralysis, we go so far as even to call this strength of mind!

Are you certain that you are awake? am not, replies such a person, for neither am I certain when in dreaming I appear to myself to be awake. Is there no difference, then, between these appearances? None. Shall I argue with this man any longer? For what steel or what caustic can I apply, to make him sensible of his paralysis? If he is sensible of it, and pretends not to be so, he is even worse than dead. He sees not his inconsistency, or, seeing it, holds to the wrong. He moves not, makes no progress; he rather falls back. His sense of shame is gone; his reasoning faculty is not gone, but brutalized. Shall I call this strength of mind? By no means,—unless we allow it to be such in the vilest debauchees publicly to speak and act out their worse impulses.

Concerning 1 w 10
the 1 w 13
academics 1 w 22
The 1 w 26
New 1 w 29
Academy 1 w 36
denied 1 w 42
the 2 w 45
existence 1 w 54
of 1 w 56
any 1 w 59
universal 1 w 68
truths 1 w 74
H 1 w 77
It 1 w 80
is 2 w 82
said 1 w 86
that 1 w 90
there 1 w 95
are 1 w 98
those 1 w 103
who 1 w 106
will 1 w 110
oppose 1 w 116
very 1 w 120
evident 1 w 127
truths 2 w 133
and 1 w 137
yet 1 w 140
it 1 w 142
is 3 w 144
not 1 w 147
easy 1 w 151
to 1 w 153
find 1 w 157
a 11 w 158
reason 1 w 164
which 1 w 169
may 1 w 172
persuade 1 w 180
such 1 w 184
an 3 w 186
one 1 w 189
to 2 w 191
alter 1 w 196
his 1 w 199
opinion 1 w 206
This 1 w 211
may 2 w 214
arise 1 w 219
neither 1 w 226
from 1 w 230
his 3 w 233
own 1 w 236
strength 1 w 244
nor 1 w 247
from 2 w 251
the 5 w 254
weakness 1 w 262
of 2 w 264
his 4 w 267
teacher 1 w 274
but 1 w 278
when 1 w 282
a 21 w 283
man 1 w 286
becomes 1 w 293
obstinate 1 w 302
in 5 w 304
error 1 w 309
reason 2 w 316
cannot 1 w 322
always 1 w 328
reach 1 w 333
him 1 w 336
Now 1 w 340
there 2 w 345
are 2 w 348
two 1 w 351
sorts 1 w 356
of 3 w 358
obstinacy 1 w 367
the 7 w 371
one 2 w 374
of 4 w 377
the 8 w 380
intellect 1 w 389
the 9 w 393
other 1 w 398
of 5 w 401
the 11 w 404
will 2 w 408
A 2 w 410
man 2 w 413
may 3 w 416
obstinately 1 w 427
set 1 w 430
himself 1 w 437
not 3 w 440
to 3 w 442
assent 1 w 448
to 4 w 450
evident 2 w 457
truths 3 w 463
nor 2 w 467
to 5 w 469
quit 1 w 473
the 12 w 476
defence 1 w 483
of 6 w 485
contradictions 1 w 499
We 1 w 502
all 1 w 505
dread 1 w 510
a 38 w 511
bodily 1 w 517
paralysis 1 w 526
and 2 w 530
would 1 w 535
make 1 w 539
use 1 w 542
of 7 w 544
every 1 w 549
contrivance 1 w 560
to 6 w 562
avoid 1 w 567
it 4 w 569
but 2 w 573
none 1 w 577
of 8 w 579
us 2 w 581
is 10 w 583
troubled 1 w 591
about 1 w 596
a 46 w 597
paralysis 2 w 606
of 9 w 608
the 13 w 611
soul 1 w 615
And 1 w 619
yet 2 w 622
indeed 1 w 629
even 1 w 634
with 1 w 638
regard 1 w 644
to 7 w 646
the 14 w 649
soul 2 w 653
when 2 w 658
a 50 w 659
person 1 w 665
is 12 w 667
so 7 w 669
affected 1 w 677
as 5 w 679
not 4 w 682
to 8 w 684
apprehend 1 w 693
or 5 w 695
understand 1 w 705
anything 1 w 713
we 2 w 716
think 1 w 721
him 3 w 724
in 12 w 726
a 56 w 727
sad 1 w 730
condition 1 w 739
but 3 w 743
where 1 w 748
the 15 w 751
emotions 1 w 759
of 10 w 761
shame 1 w 766
and 4 w 769
modesty 1 w 776
are 3 w 779
under 2 w 784
an 12 w 786
absolute 1 w 794
paralysis 3 w 803
we 3 w 806
go 1 w 808
so 9 w 810
far 1 w 813
as 6 w 815
even 2 w 819
to 9 w 821
call 1 w 825
this 1 w 829
strength 2 w 837
of 11 w 839
mind 1 w 843
Are 1 w 847
you 1 w 850
certain 1 w 857
that 2 w 861
you 2 w 864
are 4 w 867
awake 1 w 872
am 2 w 875
not 5 w 878
replies 1 w 886
such 2 w 890
a 74 w 891
person 2 w 897
for 1 w 901
neither 2 w 908
am 3 w 910
I 2 w 911
certain 2 w 918
when 3 w 922
in 16 w 924
dreaming 1 w 932
I 3 w 933
appear 1 w 939
to 10 w 941
myself 1 w 947
to 11 w 949
be 2 w 951
awake 2 w 956
Is 1 w 959
there 3 w 964
no 9 w 966
difference 1 w 976
then 1 w 981
between 1 w 989
these 1 w 994
appearances 1 w 1005
None 1 w 1010
Shall 1 w 1016
I 5 w 1017
argue 1 w 1022
with 2 w 1026
this 2 w 1030
man 3 w 1033
any 3 w 1036
longer 1 w 1042
For 1 w 1046
what 1 w 1050
steel 1 w 1055
or 8 w 1057
what 2 w 1061
caustic 1 w 1068
can 2 w 1071
I 6 w 1072
apply 1 w 1077
to 12 w 1080
make 2 w 1084
him 4 w 1087
sensible 1 w 1095
of 12 w 1097
his 7 w 1100
paralysis 4 w 1109
If 1 w 1112
he 27 w 1114
is 18 w 1116
sensible 2 w 1124
of 13 w 1126
it 9 w 1128
and 5 w 1132
pretends 1 w 1140
not 6 w 1143
to 13 w 1145
be 4 w 1147
so 11 w 1149
he 28 w 1152
is 19 w 1154
even 3 w 1158
worse 1 w 1163
than 1 w 1167
dead 1 w 1171
He 1 w 1174
sees 1 w 1178
not 7 w 1181
his 8 w 1184
inconsistency 1 w 1197
or 10 w 1200
seeing 1 w 1207
it 10 w 1209
holds 1 w 1215
to 14 w 1217
the 20 w 1220
wrong 1 w 1225
He 2 w 1228
moves 1 w 1233
not 8 w 1236
makes 1 w 1242
no 13 w 1244
progress 1 w 1252
he 30 w 1255
rather 1 w 1261
falls 1 w 1266
back 1 w 1270
His 1 w 1274
sense 1 w 1279
of 14 w 1281
shame 2 w 1286
is 23 w 1288
gone 1 w 1292
his 9 w 1296
reasoning 1 w 1305
faculty 1 w 1312
is 25 w 1314
not 9 w 1317
gone 2 w 1321
but 4 w 1325
brutalized 1 w 1335
Shall 2 w 1341
I 8 w 1342
call 2 w 1346
this 3 w 1350
strength 3 w 1358
of 15 w 1360
mind 2 w 1364
By 1 w 1367
no 15 w 1369
means 1 w 1374
unless 1 w 1382
we 5 w 1384
allow 1 w 1389
it 11 w 1391
to 15 w 1393
be 5 w 1395
such 3 w 1399
in 22 w 1401
the 22 w 1404
vilest 1 w 1410
debauchees 1 w 1420
publicly 1 w 1428
to 16 w 1430
speak 1 w 1435
and 6 w 1438
act 1 w 1441
out 2 w 1444
their 1 w 1449
worse 2 w 1454
impulses 1 w 1462