Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The Discourses of Epictetus

The Discourses of Epictetus (1.23)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0557.tlg001.perseus-eng4:1.23
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1.23', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Chapter 23'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '1'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
Against Epicurus.

Even Epicurus is sensible that we are by nature sociable beings; but having once placed our good in the mere outward shell, he can say nothing

p.1077
afterwards inconsistent with that; for again, he strenuously maintains that we ought not to admire or accept anything separated from the nature of good, and he is in the right to maintain it. But how, then, arise any affectionate anxieties, unless there be such a thing as natural affection towards our offspring? Then why do you, Epicurus, dissuade a wise man from bringing up children? Why are you afraid that upon their account he may fall into anxieties? Does he fall into any for a mouse, that feeds within his house? What is it to him, if a little mouse bewails itself there? But Epicurus knew that, if once a child is born, it is no longer in our power not to love and be solicitous for it. On the same grounds he says that a wise man will not engage himself in public business, knowing very well what must follow. If men are only so many flies, why should he not engage in it?

And does he, who knows all this, dare to forbid us to bring up children? Not even a sheep, or a wolf, deserts its offspring; and shall man? What would you have, that we should be as silly as sheep? Yet even these do not desert their offspring. Or as savage as wolves? Neither do these desert them. Pray, who would mind you, if he saw his child fallen upon the ground and crying? For my part, I am of opinion that your father and another, even if they could have foreseen that you would have been the author of such doctrines, would not have thrown you away.

p.1078

Tokens

Against 1 w 7
Epicurus 1 w 15
Even 1 w 20
Epicurus 2 w 28
is 1 w 30
sensible 1 w 38
that 1 w 42
we 1 w 44
are 1 w 47
by 1 w 49
nature 1 w 55
sociable 1 w 63
beings 1 w 69
but 1 w 73
having 1 w 79
once 1 w 83
placed 1 w 89
our 1 w 92
good 1 w 96
in 4 w 98
the 1 w 101
mere 1 w 105
outward 1 w 112
shell 1 w 117
he 3 w 120
can 1 w 123
say 1 w 126
nothing 1 w 133
afterwards 1 w 143
inconsistent 1 w 155
with 1 w 159
that 2 w 163
for 1 w 167
again 1 w 172
he 4 w 175
strenuously 1 w 186
maintains 1 w 195
that 3 w 199
we 2 w 201
ought 1 w 206
not 2 w 209
to 1 w 211
admire 1 w 217
or 2 w 219
accept 1 w 225
anything 1 w 233
separated 1 w 242
from 1 w 246
the 2 w 249
nature 2 w 255
of 1 w 257
good 2 w 261
and 1 w 265
he 6 w 267
is 3 w 269
in 11 w 271
the 3 w 274
right 1 w 279
to 2 w 281
maintain 2 w 289
it 2 w 291
But 1 w 295
how 1 w 298
then 1 w 303
arise 1 w 309
any 2 w 312
affectionate 1 w 324
anxieties 1 w 333
unless 1 w 340
there 1 w 345
be 2 w 347
such 1 w 351
a 33 w 352
thing 3 w 357
as 1 w 359
natural 1 w 366
affection 2 w 375
towards 1 w 382
our 2 w 385
offspring 1 w 394
Then 1 w 399
why 1 w 402
do 1 w 404
you 1 w 407
Epicurus 3 w 416
dissuade 1 w 425
a 40 w 426
wise 1 w 430
man 1 w 433
from 2 w 437
bringing 1 w 445
up 1 w 447
children 1 w 455
Why 1 w 459
are 2 w 462
you 2 w 465
afraid 1 w 471
that 4 w 475
upon 1 w 479
their 1 w 484
account 1 w 491
he 12 w 493
may 1 w 496
fall 1 w 500
into 1 w 504
anxieties 2 w 513
Does 1 w 518
he 13 w 520
fall 2 w 524
into 2 w 528
any 3 w 531
for 2 w 534
a 52 w 535
mouse 1 w 540
that 5 w 545
feeds 1 w 550
within 1 w 556
his 1 w 559
house 1 w 564
What 1 w 569
is 8 w 571
it 4 w 573
to 6 w 575
him 1 w 578
if 1 w 581
a 55 w 582
little 1 w 588
mouse 2 w 593
bewails 1 w 600
itself 1 w 606
there 2 w 611
But 2 w 615
Epicurus 4 w 623
knew 1 w 627
that 6 w 631
if 2 w 634
once 2 w 638
a 58 w 639
child 2 w 644
is 9 w 646
born 1 w 650
it 7 w 653
is 10 w 655
no 3 w 657
longer 1 w 663
in 21 w 665
our 3 w 668
power 1 w 673
not 3 w 676
to 7 w 678
love 1 w 682
and 2 w 685
be 4 w 687
solicitous 1 w 697
for 3 w 700
it 9 w 702
On 1 w 705
the 8 w 708
same 1 w 712
grounds 1 w 719
he 16 w 721
says 1 w 725
that 7 w 729
a 63 w 730
wise 2 w 734
man 2 w 737
will 1 w 741
not 4 w 744
engage 1 w 750
himself 1 w 757
in 22 w 759
public 1 w 765
business 1 w 773
knowing 1 w 781
very 1 w 785
well 1 w 789
what 1 w 793
must 1 w 797
follow 1 w 803
If 1 w 806
men 1 w 809
are 3 w 812
only 1 w 816
so 3 w 818
many 1 w 822
flies 1 w 827
why 2 w 831
should 1 w 837
he 17 w 839
not 5 w 842
engage 2 w 848
in 25 w 850
it 10 w 852
And 1 w 856
does 1 w 860
he 18 w 862
who 1 w 866
knows 1 w 871
all 3 w 874
this 1 w 878
dare 1 w 883
to 9 w 885
forbid 1 w 891
us 12 w 893
to 10 w 895
bring 2 w 900
up 3 w 902
children 2 w 910
Not 1 w 914
even 1 w 918
a 72 w 919
sheep 1 w 924
or 7 w 927
a 73 w 928
wolf 1 w 932
deserts 1 w 940
its 2 w 943
offspring 2 w 952
and 3 w 956
shall 1 w 961
man 4 w 964
What 2 w 969
would 1 w 974
you 3 w 977
have 1 w 981
that 8 w 986
we 5 w 988
should 2 w 994
be 5 w 996
as 2 w 998
silly 1 w 1003
as 3 w 1005
sheep 2 w 1010
Yet 1 w 1014
even 2 w 1018
these 1 w 1023
do 3 w 1025
not 6 w 1028
desert 2 w 1034
their 2 w 1039
offspring 3 w 1048
Or 1 w 1051
as 4 w 1053
savage 1 w 1059
as 5 w 1061
wolves 1 w 1067
Neither 1 w 1075
do 4 w 1077
these 2 w 1082
desert 3 w 1088
them 1 w 1092
Pray 1 w 1097
who 2 w 1101
would 2 w 1106
mind 1 w 1110
you 4 w 1113
if 3 w 1116
he 26 w 1118
saw 1 w 1121
his 3 w 1124
child 4 w 1129
fallen 1 w 1135
upon 2 w 1139
the 14 w 1142
ground 2 w 1148
and 4 w 1151
crying 1 w 1157
For 1 w 1161
my 1 w 1163
part 1 w 1167
I 2 w 1169
am 2 w 1171
of 5 w 1173
opinion 1 w 1180
that 9 w 1184
your 1 w 1188
father 1 w 1194
and 5 w 1197
another 1 w 1204
even 3 w 1209
if 4 w 1211
they 1 w 1215
could 1 w 1220
have 2 w 1224
foreseen 1 w 1232
that 10 w 1236
you 6 w 1239
would 3 w 1244
have 3 w 1248
been 1 w 1252
the 18 w 1255
author 1 w 1261
of 6 w 1263
such 2 w 1267
doctrines 1 w 1276
would 4 w 1282
not 8 w 1285
have 4 w 1289
thrown 1 w 1295
you 7 w 1298
away 1 w 1302