Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The Discourses of Epictetus

The Discourses of Epictetus (1.20)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0557.tlg001.perseus-eng4:1.20
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1.20', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Chapter 20'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '1'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
In what manner reason contemplates itself.

Every art, and every faculty, contemplates certain things as its principal objects. Whenever, therefore, it is of the same nature with the objects of its contemplation, it necessarily contemplates itself too; but where it is of a different nature, it cannot contemplate itself. The art of shoemaking, for instance, is exercised upon leather, but is itself entirely distinct from the materials it works upon; therefore it does not contemplate itself. Again, grammar is exercised on articulate speech. Is the art of grammar itself, then, articulate speech? By no means. Therefore, it cannot contemplate itself. To what purpose, then, is reason appointed by nature? To a proper use of the phenomena of existence. And what is reason? The art of systematizing these phenomena. Thus, by its nature, it becomes contemplative of itself too.

p.1071

Again, what subjects of contemplation belong to prudence? Good and evil, and that which is indifferent. What, then, is prudence itself? Good. What imprudence? Evil.

You see, then, that it necessarily contemplates both itself and its contrary. Therefore, the first and greatest work of a philosopher is to try to distinguish the phenomena of existence, and to admit none untried. Even in money, where our interest seems to be concerned, you see what an art we have invented, and how many ways an assayer uses to try its value,—by the sight, the touch, the smell, and, lastly, the hearing. He throws the piece down, and attends to the jingle; and is not contented with its jingling only once, but, by frequent attention to it, trains his ear for sound. So, when we think it of consequence whether we are deceived or not, we use the utmost attention to discern those things which may deceive us. But, yawning and slumbering over our poor neglected reason, we are imposed upon by every appearance, nor know the mischief done. Would you know, then, how very languidly you are affected by good and evil, and how vehemently by things indifferent, consider how you feel with regard to bodily blindness, and how with regard to being deceived; and you will find that you are far from being moved, as you ought, in relation to good and evil.

But trained powers and much labor and learning are here needed.

p.1072

What then? Do you expect the greatest of arts to be acquired by slight endeavors? And yet the principal doctrine of the philosophers is in itself short. If you have a mind to know it, read Zeno, and you will see. It is not a long story to say, Our end is to serve the gods, and The essence of good consists in the proper use of the phenomena of existence. If you say, what then is God; what are phenomena; what is particular, what universal nature,—here the long story comes in. And so, if Epicurus should come and say that good lies in the body, here, too, it will be a long story; and it will be necessary to hear what is the principal, and substantial, and essential part in us. It is unlikely that the good of a snail should be placed in the shell; and is it likely that the good of a man should? You yourself, Epicurus, have in you something superior to this. What is that in you which deliberates, which examines, which recognizes the body as the principal part? Why light your lamp, and labor for us, and write so many books? That we may not be ignorant of the truth? But what are we? What are we to you? Thus the doctrine becomes a long story.

p.1073

Tokens

In 1 w 2
what 1 w 6
manner 1 w 12
reason 1 w 18
contemplates 1 w 30
itself 1 w 36
Every 1 w 42
art 1 w 45
and 1 w 49
every 1 w 54
faculty 1 w 61
contemplates 2 w 74
certain 1 w 81
things 1 w 87
as 2 w 89
its 2 w 92
principal 1 w 101
objects 1 w 108
Whenever 1 w 117
therefore 1 w 127
it 3 w 130
is 1 w 132
of 1 w 134
the 2 w 137
same 1 w 141
nature 1 w 147
with 1 w 151
the 3 w 154
objects 2 w 161
of 2 w 163
its 3 w 166
contemplation 1 w 179
it 6 w 182
necessarily 1 w 193
contemplates 3 w 205
itself 2 w 211
too 1 w 214
but 1 w 218
where 1 w 223
it 8 w 225
is 2 w 227
of 3 w 229
a 17 w 230
different 1 w 239
nature 2 w 245
it 9 w 248
cannot 1 w 254
contemplate 4 w 265
itself 3 w 271
The 1 w 275
art 2 w 278
of 4 w 280
shoemaking 1 w 290
for 2 w 294
instance 1 w 302
is 3 w 305
exercised 1 w 314
upon 1 w 318
leather 1 w 325
but 2 w 329
is 5 w 331
itself 4 w 337
entirely 1 w 345
distinct 1 w 353
from 1 w 357
the 5 w 360
materials 1 w 369
it 12 w 371
works 1 w 376
upon 2 w 380
therefore 2 w 390
it 13 w 392
does 1 w 396
not 2 w 399
contemplate 5 w 410
itself 5 w 416
Again 1 w 422
grammar 1 w 430
is 7 w 432
exercised 2 w 441
on 11 w 443
articulate 1 w 453
speech 1 w 459
Is 1 w 462
the 7 w 465
art 4 w 468
of 5 w 470
grammar 2 w 477
itself 6 w 483
then 1 w 488
articulate 2 w 499
speech 2 w 505
By 1 w 508
no 3 w 510
means 1 w 515
Therefore 1 w 525
it 16 w 528
cannot 2 w 534
contemplate 6 w 545
itself 7 w 551
To 1 w 554
what 2 w 558
purpose 1 w 565
then 2 w 570
is 9 w 573
reason 2 w 579
appointed 1 w 588
by 1 w 590
nature 3 w 596
To 2 w 599
a 45 w 600
proper 1 w 606
use 1 w 609
of 6 w 611
the 10 w 614
phenomena 1 w 623
of 7 w 625
existence 1 w 634
And 1 w 638
what 3 w 642
is 11 w 644
reason 3 w 650
The 3 w 654
art 6 w 657
of 8 w 659
systematizing 1 w 672
these 1 w 677
phenomena 2 w 686
Thus 1 w 691
by 2 w 694
its 10 w 697
nature 4 w 703
it 19 w 706
becomes 1 w 713
contemplative 1 w 726
of 9 w 728
itself 8 w 734
too 2 w 737
Again 2 w 743
what 4 w 748
subjects 1 w 756
of 10 w 758
contemplation 2 w 771
belong 1 w 777
to 3 w 779
prudence 1 w 787
Good 1 w 792
and 2 w 795
evil 1 w 799
and 3 w 803
that 1 w 807
which 1 w 812
is 12 w 814
indifferent 1 w 825
What 1 w 830
then 3 w 835
is 13 w 838
prudence 2 w 846
itself 9 w 852
Good 2 w 857
What 2 w 862
imprudence 1 w 872
Evil 1 w 877
You 1 w 881
see 1 w 884
then 4 w 889
that 2 w 894
it 22 w 896
necessarily 2 w 907
contemplates 4 w 919
both 1 w 923
itself 10 w 929
and 4 w 932
its 14 w 935
contrary 1 w 943
Therefore 2 w 953
the 14 w 957
first 1 w 962
and 5 w 965
greatest 1 w 973
work 2 w 977
of 11 w 979
a 69 w 980
philosopher 1 w 991
is 14 w 993
to 4 w 995
try 1 w 998
to 5 w 1000
distinguish 1 w 1011
the 15 w 1014
phenomena 3 w 1023
of 12 w 1025
existence 2 w 1034
and 6 w 1038
to 6 w 1040
admit 1 w 1045
none 1 w 1049
untried 1 w 1056
Even 1 w 1061
in 13 w 1063
money 1 w 1068
where 2 w 1074
our 1 w 1077
interest 1 w 1085
seems 1 w 1090
to 7 w 1092
be 3 w 1094
concerned 1 w 1103
you 1 w 1107
see 3 w 1110
what 5 w 1114
an 12 w 1116
art 7 w 1119
we 1 w 1121
have 1 w 1125
invented 1 w 1133
and 7 w 1137
how 1 w 1140
many 1 w 1144
ways 1 w 1148
an 15 w 1150
assayer 1 w 1157
uses 1 w 1161
to 8 w 1163
try 2 w 1166
its 15 w 1169
value 1 w 1174
by 3 w 1178
the 16 w 1181
sight 1 w 1186
the 17 w 1190
touch 1 w 1195
the 18 w 1199
smell 1 w 1204
and 8 w 1208
lastly 1 w 1215
the 19 w 1219
hearing 1 w 1226
He 1 w 1229
throws 1 w 1235
the 20 w 1238
piece 1 w 1243
down 1 w 1247
and 9 w 1251
attends 1 w 1258
to 10 w 1260
the 21 w 1263
jingle 1 w 1269
and 10 w 1273
is 18 w 1275
not 4 w 1278
contented 1 w 1287
with 2 w 1291
its 16 w 1294
jingling 1 w 1302
only 1 w 1306
once 2 w 1310
but 3 w 1314
by 4 w 1317
frequent 1 w 1325
attention 1 w 1334
to 11 w 1336
it 29 w 1338
trains 1 w 1345
his 1 w 1348
ear 2 w 1351
for 6 w 1354
sound 1 w 1359
So 1 w 1362
when 1 w 1367
we 2 w 1369
think 1 w 1374
it 30 w 1376
of 13 w 1378
consequence 1 w 1389
whether 1 w 1396
we 3 w 1398
are 1 w 1401
deceived 1 w 1409
or 9 w 1411
not 5 w 1414
we 4 w 1417
use 3 w 1420
the 23 w 1423
utmost 1 w 1429
attention 2 w 1438
to 12 w 1440
discern 1 w 1447
those 1 w 1452
things 2 w 1458
which 2 w 1463
may 1 w 1466
deceive 2 w 1473
us 5 w 1475
But 1 w 1479
yawning 1 w 1487
and 11 w 1490
slumbering 1 w 1500
over 1 w 1504
our 2 w 1507
poor 1 w 1511
neglected 1 w 1520
reason 4 w 1526
we 5 w 1529
are 2 w 1532
imposed 1 w 1539
upon 3 w 1543
by 5 w 1545
every 2 w 1550
appearance 1 w 1560
nor 1 w 1564
know 1 w 1568
the 24 w 1571
mischief 1 w 1579
done 1 w 1583
Would 1 w 1589
you 2 w 1592
know 2 w 1596
then 5 w 1601
how 2 w 1605
very 4 w 1609
languidly 1 w 1618
you 3 w 1621
are 3 w 1624
affected 1 w 1632
by 6 w 1634
good 1 w 1638
and 12 w 1641
evil 2 w 1645
and 13 w 1649
how 3 w 1652
vehemently 1 w 1662
by 7 w 1664
things 3 w 1670
indifferent 2 w 1681
consider 1 w 1690
how 4 w 1693
you 4 w 1696
feel 1 w 1700
with 3 w 1704
regard 1 w 1710
to 13 w 1712
bodily 1 w 1718
blindness 1 w 1727
and 14 w 1731
how 5 w 1734
with 4 w 1738
regard 2 w 1744
to 14 w 1746
being 1 w 1751
deceived 2 w 1759
and 15 w 1763
you 5 w 1766
will 1 w 1770
find 1 w 1774
that 3 w 1778
you 6 w 1781
are 4 w 1784
far 1 w 1787
from 2 w 1791
being 2 w 1796
moved 1 w 1801
as 8 w 1804
you 7 w 1807
ought 1 w 1812
in 31 w 1815
relation 1 w 1823
to 15 w 1825
good 2 w 1829
and 16 w 1832
evil 3 w 1836
But 2 w 1840
trained 1 w 1847
powers 1 w 1853
and 17 w 1856
much 1 w 1860
labor 1 w 1865
and 18 w 1868
learning 1 w 1876
are 5 w 1879
here 7 w 1883
needed 1 w 1889
What 3 w 1894
then 6 w 1898
Do 1 w 1901
you 8 w 1904
expect 1 w 1910
the 27 w 1913
greatest 2 w 1921
of 14 w 1923
arts 1 w 1927
to 16 w 1929
be 7 w 1931
acquired 1 w 1939
by 8 w 1941
slight 1 w 1947
endeavors 1 w 1956
And 2 w 1960
yet 1 w 1963
the 28 w 1966
principal 2 w 1975
doctrine 1 w 1983
of 15 w 1985
the 29 w 1988
philosophers 1 w 2000
is 22 w 2002
in 36 w 2004
itself 11 w 2010
short 1 w 2015
If 1 w 2018
you 9 w 2021
have 2 w 2025
a 131 w 2026
mind 1 w 2030
to 17 w 2032
know 3 w 2036
it 34 w 2038
read 1 w 2043
Zeno 1 w 2047
and 19 w 2051
you 10 w 2054
will 2 w 2058
see 4 w 2061
It 1 w 2064
is 23 w 2066
not 6 w 2069
a 134 w 2070
long 2 w 2074
story 1 w 2079
to 19 w 2081
say 2 w 2084
Our 1 w 2088
end 3 w 2091
is 24 w 2093
to 20 w 2095
serve 1 w 2100
the 30 w 2103
gods 1 w 2107
and 20 w 2111
The 5 w 2114
essence 1 w 2121
of 16 w 2123
good 3 w 2127
consists 1 w 2135
in 38 w 2137
the 31 w 2140
proper 2 w 2146
use 4 w 2149
of 17 w 2151
the 32 w 2154
phenomena 4 w 2163
of 18 w 2165
existence 3 w 2174
If 2 w 2177
you 11 w 2180
say 3 w 2183
what 6 w 2188
then 7 w 2192
is 27 w 2194
God 1 w 2197
what 7 w 2202
are 6 w 2205
phenomena 5 w 2214
what 8 w 2219
is 28 w 2221
particular 1 w 2231
what 9 w 2236
universal 1 w 2245
nature 5 w 2251
here 8 w 2257
the 34 w 2260
long 3 w 2264
story 2 w 2269
comes 2 w 2274
in 39 w 2276
And 3 w 2280
so 8 w 2282
if 4 w 2285
Epicurus 1 w 2293
should 1 w 2299
come 3 w 2303
and 21 w 2306
say 4 w 2309
that 4 w 2313
good 4 w 2317
lies 1 w 2321
in 40 w 2323
the 35 w 2326
body 1 w 2330
here 9 w 2335
too 3 w 2339
it 35 w 2342
will 3 w 2346
be 8 w 2348
a 152 w 2349
long 4 w 2353
story 3 w 2358
and 22 w 2362
it 36 w 2364
will 4 w 2368
be 9 w 2370
necessary 1 w 2379
to 24 w 2381
hear 2 w 2385
what 10 w 2389
is 29 w 2391
the 36 w 2394
principal 3 w 2403
and 23 w 2407
substantial 1 w 2418
and 24 w 2422
essential 1 w 2431
part 2 w 2435
in 42 w 2437
us 8 w 2439
It 2 w 2442
is 30 w 2444
unlikely 1 w 2452
that 5 w 2456
the 37 w 2459
good 5 w 2463
of 19 w 2465
a 165 w 2466
snail 1 w 2471
should 2 w 2477
be 10 w 2479
placed 1 w 2485
in 43 w 2487
the 38 w 2490
shell 1 w 2495
and 25 w 2499
is 31 w 2501
it 37 w 2503
likely 2 w 2509
that 6 w 2513
the 39 w 2516
good 6 w 2520
of 20 w 2522
a 170 w 2523
man 3 w 2526
should 3 w 2532
You 2 w 2536
yourself 1 w 2544
Epicurus 2 w 2553
have 3 w 2558
in 44 w 2560
you 13 w 2563
something 1 w 2572
superior 1 w 2580
to 25 w 2582
this 1 w 2586
What 4 w 2591
is 33 w 2593
that 7 w 2597
in 46 w 2599
you 14 w 2602
which 3 w 2607
deliberates 1 w 2618
which 4 w 2624
examines 1 w 2632
which 5 w 2638
recognizes 1 w 2648
the 40 w 2651
body 2 w 2655
as 9 w 2657
the 41 w 2660
principal 4 w 2669
part 3 w 2673
Why 1 w 2677
light 2 w 2682
your 2 w 2686
lamp 1 w 2690
and 26 w 2694
labor 2 w 2699
for 7 w 2702
us 10 w 2704
and 27 w 2708
write 1 w 2713
so 10 w 2715
many 2 w 2719
books 1 w 2724
That 1 w 2729
we 7 w 2731
may 2 w 2734
not 7 w 2737
be 12 w 2739
ignorant 1 w 2747
of 21 w 2749
the 42 w 2752
truth 1 w 2757
But 3 w 2761
what 11 w 2765
are 7 w 2768
we 8 w 2770
What 5 w 2775
are 8 w 2778
we 9 w 2780
to 26 w 2782
you 16 w 2785
Thus 2 w 2790
the 43 w 2793
doctrine 2 w 2801
becomes 2 w 2808
a 192 w 2809
long 5 w 2813
story 4 w 2818