Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Arrian's Discourses of Epictetus

Arrian's Discourses of Epictetus (3.17)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0557.tlg001.perseus-eng3:3.17
Refs {'start': {'reference': '3.17', 'human_reference': 'Book 3 Chapter 17'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '3'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
On Providence.

WHEN you make any charge against Providence, consider, and you will learn that the thing has happened according to reason.—Yes, but the unjust man has the advantage.— In what?—In money.—Yes, for he is superior to you in this, that he flatters, is free from shame, and is watchful. What is the wonder? But see if he has the advantage over you in being faithful, in being modest: for you will not find it to be so; but wherein you are superior, there you will find that you have the advantage. And I once said to a man who was vexed because Philostorgus was fortunate: Would you choose to lie with Sura?[*]

239
May it never happen, he replied, that this day should come? Why then are you vexed, if he receives something in return for that which he sells; or how can you consider him happy who acquires those things by such means as you abominate; or what wrong does Providence, if he gives the better things to the better men? Is it not better to be modest than to be rich?—He admitted thisWhy are you vexed then, man, when you possess the better thing? Remember then always and have in readiness the truth, that this is a law of nature, that the superior has an advantage over the inferior in that in which he is superior; and you will never be vexed.

But my wife treats me badly.—Well, if any man asks you what this is, say, my wife treats me badlyIs there then nothing more? Nothing.—My father gives me nothing–[What is this? my father gives me nothingIs there nothing else then?—Nothing][*]: but to say that this is an evil is something which must be added to it externally, and falsely added. For this reason we must not get rid of poverty, but of the opinion about poverty, and then we shall be happy.

Tokens

On 1 w 2
Providence 1 w 12
WHEN 1 w 17
you 1 w 20
make 1 w 24
any 1 w 27
charge 1 w 33
against 1 w 40
Providence 2 w 50
consider 1 w 59
and 1 w 63
you 2 w 66
will 1 w 70
learn 1 w 75
that 1 w 79
the 1 w 82
thing 1 w 87
has 1 w 90
happened 1 w 98
according 1 w 107
to 1 w 109
reason 1 w 115
Yes 1 w 120
but 1 w 124
the 2 w 127
unjust 1 w 133
man 1 w 136
has 2 w 139
the 3 w 142
advantage 1 w 151
In 1 w 155
what 1 w 159
In 2 w 163
money 1 w 168
Yes 2 w 173
for 1 w 177
he 4 w 179
is 1 w 181
superior 1 w 189
to 2 w 191
you 3 w 194
in 4 w 196
this 1 w 200
that 2 w 205
he 5 w 207
flatters 1 w 215
is 3 w 218
free 1 w 222
from 1 w 226
shame 1 w 231
and 2 w 235
is 4 w 237
watchful 1 w 245
What 1 w 250
is 5 w 252
the 4 w 255
wonder 1 w 261
But 1 w 265
see 1 w 268
if 1 w 270
he 7 w 272
has 3 w 275
the 5 w 278
advantage 2 w 287
over 1 w 291
you 4 w 294
in 5 w 296
being 1 w 301
faithful 1 w 309
in 7 w 312
being 2 w 317
modest 1 w 323
for 2 w 327
you 5 w 330
will 2 w 334
not 1 w 337
find 1 w 341
it 2 w 343
to 3 w 345
be 3 w 347
so 2 w 349
but 2 w 353
wherein 1 w 360
you 6 w 363
are 1 w 366
superior 2 w 374
there 1 w 380
you 7 w 383
will 3 w 387
find 2 w 391
that 3 w 395
you 8 w 398
have 1 w 402
the 7 w 405
advantage 3 w 414
And 1 w 418
I 3 w 419
once 1 w 423
said 1 w 427
to 4 w 429
a 37 w 430
man 2 w 433
who 1 w 436
was 1 w 439
vexed 1 w 444
because 1 w 451
Philostorgus 1 w 463
was 2 w 466
fortunate 1 w 475
Would 1 w 481
you 9 w 484
choose 1 w 490
to 6 w 492
lie 1 w 495
with 1 w 499
Sura 1 w 503
Upton 1 w 509
suggests 1 w 517
that 4 w 521
Sura 2 w 525
may 1 w 528
be 5 w 530
Palfurius 1 w 539
Juvenal 1 w 547
iv 1 w 550
53 1 w 553
or 8 w 557
Palfurius 2 w 566
Sura 3 w 570
Suetonius 1 w 580
Domitian 1 w 589
c 11 w 591
13 1 w 594
May 1 w 600
it 5 w 602
never 1 w 607
happen 2 w 613
he 12 w 616
replied 1 w 623
that 5 w 628
this 2 w 632
day 1 w 635
should 1 w 641
come 1 w 645
Why 1 w 649
then 1 w 653
are 2 w 656
you 10 w 659
vexed 2 w 664
if 2 w 667
he 14 w 669
receives 1 w 677
something 1 w 686
in 13 w 688
return 1 w 694
for 4 w 697
that 6 w 701
which 1 w 706
he 15 w 708
sells 1 w 713
or 10 w 716
how 1 w 719
can 1 w 722
you 11 w 725
consider 2 w 733
him 1 w 736
happy 1 w 741
who 2 w 744
acquires 1 w 752
those 1 w 757
things 1 w 763
by 1 w 765
such 1 w 769
means 1 w 774
as 7 w 776
you 12 w 779
abominate 1 w 788
or 11 w 791
what 2 w 795
wrong 1 w 800
does 1 w 804
Providence 3 w 814
if 3 w 817
he 16 w 819
gives 1 w 824
the 9 w 827
better 1 w 833
things 2 w 839
to 9 w 841
the 10 w 844
better 2 w 850
men 1 w 853
Is 1 w 856
it 6 w 858
not 2 w 861
better 3 w 867
to 10 w 869
be 9 w 871
modest 2 w 877
than 1 w 881
to 11 w 883
be 10 w 885
rich 1 w 889
He 1 w 893
admitted 1 w 901
this 3 w 905
Why 2 w 909
are 3 w 912
you 13 w 915
vexed 3 w 920
then 2 w 924
man 3 w 928
when 1 w 933
you 14 w 936
possess 1 w 943
the 12 w 946
better 4 w 952
thing 5 w 957
Remember 1 w 966
then 3 w 970
always 1 w 976
and 3 w 979
have 2 w 983
in 18 w 985
readiness 1 w 994
the 14 w 997
truth 1 w 1002
that 7 w 1007
this 4 w 1011
is 9 w 1013
a 76 w 1014
law 1 w 1017
of 1 w 1019
nature 1 w 1025
that 8 w 1030
the 15 w 1033
superior 3 w 1041
has 4 w 1044
an 15 w 1046
advantage 4 w 1055
over 2 w 1059
the 16 w 1062
inferior 1 w 1070
in 21 w 1072
that 9 w 1076
in 22 w 1078
which 2 w 1083
he 26 w 1085
is 10 w 1087
superior 4 w 1095
and 4 w 1099
you 15 w 1102
will 4 w 1106
never 2 w 1111
be 13 w 1113
vexed 4 w 1118
But 2 w 1122
my 1 w 1124
wife 1 w 1128
treats 1 w 1134
me 7 w 1136
badly 1 w 1141
Well 1 w 1147
if 5 w 1150
any 2 w 1153
man 4 w 1156
asks 1 w 1160
you 16 w 1163
what 3 w 1167
this 5 w 1171
is 12 w 1173
say 1 w 1177
my 2 w 1180
wife 2 w 1184
treats 2 w 1190
me 8 w 1192
badly 2 w 1197
Is 2 w 1200
there 2 w 1205
then 4 w 1209
nothing 1 w 1216
more 1 w 1220
Nothing 1 w 1228
My 1 w 1232
father 1 w 1238
gives 2 w 1243
me 9 w 1245
nothing 2 w 1252
What 2 w 1258
is 13 w 1260
this 6 w 1264
my 3 w 1267
father 2 w 1273
gives 3 w 1278
me 10 w 1280
nothing 3 w 1287
Is 3 w 1290
there 3 w 1295
nothing 4 w 1302
else 1 w 1306
then 5 w 1310
Nothing 2 w 1319
See 1 w 1323
Schweig 1 w 1330
s 81 w 1333
note 1 w 1337
but 3 w 1342
to 12 w 1344
say 2 w 1347
that 10 w 1351
this 7 w 1355
is 16 w 1357
an 20 w 1359
evil 1 w 1363
is 17 w 1365
something 2 w 1374
which 3 w 1379
must 1 w 1383
be 14 w 1385
added 1 w 1390
to 13 w 1392
it 8 w 1394
externally 1 w 1404
and 5 w 1408
falsely 1 w 1415
added 2 w 1420
For 1 w 1424
this 8 w 1428
reason 2 w 1434
we 2 w 1436
must 2 w 1440
not 8 w 1443
get 1 w 1446
rid 1 w 1449
of 2 w 1451
poverty 1 w 1458
but 4 w 1462
of 3 w 1464
the 23 w 1467
opinion 1 w 1474
about 1 w 1479
poverty 2 w 1486
and 6 w 1490
then 6 w 1494
we 3 w 1496
shall 1 w 1501
be 15 w 1503
happy 2 w 1508