Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Against Philon

Against Philon (27-30)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0540.tlg031.perseus-eng2:27-30
Refs {'start': {'reference': '27', 'human_reference': 'None 27'}, 'end': {'reference': '30', 'human_reference': 'None 30'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

He argues, so I am told, that, if it was a crime to absent himself at that crisis, we should have had a law expressly dealing with it, as in the case of all other crimes. He does not expect you to perceive that the gravity of the crime was the reason why no law was proposed to deal with it. For what orator would ever have conceived, or lawgiver have anticipated, that any of the citizens would be guilty of so grave an offence?

So, I suppose, if one should desert ones post when the city itself was not in danger, but was rather endangering another people,[*] a law would have been made condemning that as a grievous crime; but if one deserted the city itself when the city itself was in danger, we should have had no law against this! Certainly we should, if there had been a thought that any of the citizens would ever commit such a crime.

Not a man but would have reason to rebuke you, gentlemen, if, after honoring in a manner worthy of the city our resident aliens for having supported the democracy beyond the requirements of their duty, you are not going to inflict on this man, for having betrayed the city in violation of his duty, if not some heavier punishment of another kind, at least the dishonor which you hold over him today.

Recall to your minds what reason you can have for honoring those who have proved themselves good servants of the State and for dishonoring those who serve her ill. In either case the distinction has been made not so much for the sake of those who have come into the world, as of those who are yet to come, in order that they may strive to become worthy by studious effort, and in no single direction may attempt to be base.

Tokens

He 1 w 2
argues 1 w 8
so 1 w 11
I 1 w 12
am 1 w 14
told 1 w 18
that 1 w 23
if 1 w 26
it 1 w 28
was 1 w 31
a 5 w 32
crime 1 w 37
to 2 w 39
absent 1 w 45
himself 1 w 52
at 2 w 54
that 2 w 58
crisis 1 w 64
we 1 w 67
should 1 w 73
have 1 w 77
had 1 w 80
a 11 w 81
law 1 w 84
expressly 1 w 93
dealing 1 w 100
with 1 w 104
it 3 w 106
as 2 w 109
in 2 w 111
the 1 w 114
case 1 w 118
of 1 w 120
all 1 w 123
other 1 w 128
crimes 1 w 134
He 2 w 137
does 1 w 141
not 1 w 144
expect 1 w 150
you 1 w 153
to 3 w 155
perceive 1 w 163
that 3 w 167
the 3 w 170
gravity 1 w 177
of 2 w 179
the 4 w 182
crime 3 w 187
was 2 w 190
the 5 w 193
reason 1 w 199
why 1 w 202
no 2 w 204
law 2 w 207
was 3 w 210
proposed 1 w 218
to 4 w 220
deal 2 w 224
with 2 w 228
it 6 w 230
For 1 w 234
what 1 w 238
orator 1 w 244
would 1 w 249
ever 1 w 253
have 2 w 257
conceived 1 w 266
or 4 w 269
lawgiver 1 w 277
have 3 w 281
anticipated 1 w 292
that 4 w 297
any 1 w 300
of 3 w 302
the 6 w 305
citizens 1 w 313
would 2 w 318
be 1 w 320
guilty 1 w 326
of 4 w 328
so 3 w 330
grave 1 w 335
an 3 w 337
offence 1 w 344
So 1 w 347
I 2 w 349
suppose 1 w 356
if 2 w 359
one 1 w 362
should 2 w 368
desert 1 w 374
one 2 w 377
s 25 w 379
post 1 w 383
when 1 w 387
the 7 w 390
city 1 w 394
itself 1 w 400
was 4 w 403
not 2 w 406
in 3 w 408
danger 1 w 414
but 1 w 418
was 5 w 421
rather 1 w 427
endangering 1 w 438
another 1 w 445
people 1 w 451
i 29 w 453
e 58 w 455
we 2 w 459
are 1 w 462
to 6 w 464
suppose 2 w 471
forsooth 1 w 480
that 5 w 485
desertion 1 w 494
is 3 w 496
a 43 w 497
crime 4 w 502
only 1 w 506
when 2 w 510
the 10 w 513
city 2 w 517
is 4 w 519
so 5 w 521
far 1 w 524
from 1 w 528
being 1 w 533
in 6 w 535
danger 3 w 541
as 9 w 543
to 7 w 545
be 3 w 547
at 11 w 549
war 1 w 552
with 3 w 556
another 2 w 563
city 3 w 567
a 50 w 569
law 4 w 572
would 3 w 577
have 4 w 581
been 1 w 585
made 1 w 589
condemning 1 w 599
that 6 w 603
as 10 w 605
a 56 w 606
grievous 1 w 614
crime 5 w 619
but 2 w 623
if 3 w 625
one 3 w 628
deserted 1 w 636
the 12 w 639
city 4 w 643
itself 2 w 649
when 3 w 653
the 13 w 656
city 5 w 660
itself 3 w 666
was 6 w 669
in 8 w 671
danger 4 w 677
we 3 w 680
should 3 w 686
have 5 w 690
had 2 w 693
no 6 w 695
law 5 w 698
against 1 w 705
this 1 w 709
Certainly 1 w 719
we 4 w 721
should 4 w 727
if 4 w 730
there 1 w 735
had 3 w 738
been 2 w 742
a 66 w 743
thought 1 w 750
that 7 w 754
any 2 w 757
of 6 w 759
the 15 w 762
citizens 2 w 770
would 4 w 775
ever 2 w 779
commit 1 w 785
such 1 w 789
a 69 w 790
crime 6 w 795
Not 1 w 799
a 70 w 800
man 1 w 803
but 3 w 806
would 5 w 811
have 6 w 815
reason 2 w 821
to 8 w 823
rebuke 1 w 829
you 2 w 832
gentlemen 1 w 842
if 5 w 845
after 1 w 851
honoring 1 w 859
in 12 w 861
a 75 w 862
manner 1 w 868
worthy 1 w 874
of 7 w 876
the 16 w 879
city 6 w 883
our 1 w 886
resident 1 w 894
aliens 1 w 900
for 2 w 903
having 1 w 909
supported 1 w 918
the 17 w 921
democracy 1 w 930
beyond 1 w 936
the 18 w 939
requirements 1 w 951
of 8 w 953
their 1 w 958
duty 1 w 962
you 3 w 966
are 2 w 969
not 5 w 972
going 1 w 977
to 9 w 979
inflict 1 w 986
on 12 w 988
this 2 w 992
man 3 w 995
for 3 w 999
having 2 w 1005
betrayed 1 w 1013
the 20 w 1016
city 7 w 1020
in 17 w 1022
violation 1 w 1031
of 9 w 1033
his 3 w 1036
duty 2 w 1040
if 6 w 1043
not 6 w 1046
some 1 w 1050
heavier 1 w 1057
punishment 1 w 1067
of 10 w 1069
another 3 w 1076
kind 1 w 1080
at 15 w 1083
least 1 w 1088
the 22 w 1091
dishonor 1 w 1099
which 1 w 1104
you 4 w 1107
hold 1 w 1111
over 1 w 1115
him 2 w 1118
today 1 w 1123
Recall 1 w 1130
to 11 w 1132
your 1 w 1136
minds 1 w 1141
what 2 w 1145
reason 3 w 1151
you 6 w 1154
can 1 w 1157
have 7 w 1161
for 4 w 1164
honoring 2 w 1172
those 1 w 1177
who 1 w 1180
have 8 w 1184
proved 1 w 1190
themselves 1 w 1200
good 1 w 1204
servants 1 w 1212
of 11 w 1214
the 24 w 1217
State 1 w 1222
and 1 w 1225
for 5 w 1228
dishonoring 1 w 1239
those 2 w 1244
who 2 w 1247
serve 1 w 1252
her 7 w 1255
ill 1 w 1258
In 1 w 1261
either 1 w 1267
case 2 w 1271
the 26 w 1274
distinction 1 w 1285
has 1 w 1288
been 3 w 1292
made 2 w 1296
not 8 w 1299
so 9 w 1301
much 1 w 1305
for 6 w 1308
the 27 w 1311
sake 1 w 1315
of 12 w 1317
those 3 w 1322
who 3 w 1325
have 9 w 1329
come 1 w 1333
into 1 w 1337
the 28 w 1340
world 1 w 1345
as 17 w 1348
of 13 w 1350
those 4 w 1355
who 4 w 1358
are 3 w 1361
yet 1 w 1364
to 13 w 1366
come 2 w 1370
in 24 w 1373
order 1 w 1378
that 8 w 1382
they 1 w 1386
may 1 w 1389
strive 1 w 1395
to 14 w 1397
become 1 w 1403
worthy 2 w 1409
by 1 w 1411
studious 1 w 1419
effort 1 w 1425
and 2 w 1429
in 25 w 1431
no 15 w 1433
single 1 w 1439
direction 1 w 1448
may 2 w 1451
attempt 1 w 1458
to 15 w 1460
be 10 w 1462
base 1 w 1466