Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Against Philon

Against Philon (19-22)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0540.tlg031.perseus-eng2:19-22
Refs {'start': {'reference': '19', 'human_reference': 'None 19'}, 'end': {'reference': '22', 'human_reference': 'None 22'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

yet this man ought not to benefit twice from their disability, and be helped thereby to pass your present scrutiny as he was before to rob them of what they had. Nay, if but a single one of those whom he has wronged appears in court, make much of it, and utterly detest this man, who could bring himself to strip of their resources those on whom other men, out of pity for their straits, freely bestowed something from their own. Pray call the witnesses.

Witnesses

Well now, I do not see how your judgement of him should differ from that of his own people; for the facts are of such a nature that, even if he had committed no other offence, they would alone justify his rejection. The strange things of which his mother accused him while she was alive I will pass over; but on the evidence of the measures that she took at the close of her life you can easily judge how he treated her.

She demurred to committing herself to his care after her death, but as she had confidence in Antiphanes, who was no connection of hers, she gave him three minae of silver for her burial, ignoring this man, who was her own son. Obviously, of course, she was convinced that he would not perform the last duties even on the ground of his relationship.

Now I ask you, if a mother,—who is naturally most willing to tolerate even an injury at the hands of her own children, and who counts little benefits as great gains because she assesses their behavior by affection rather than logic,—believed that this man would seek his profit from her even in death, what should be your feeling about him?

Tokens

yet 1 w 3
this 1 w 7
man 1 w 10
ought 1 w 15
not 1 w 18
to 1 w 20
benefit 1 w 27
twice 1 w 32
from 1 w 36
their 1 w 41
disability 1 w 51
and 1 w 55
be 2 w 57
helped 1 w 63
thereby 1 w 70
to 2 w 72
pass 1 w 76
your 1 w 80
present 1 w 87
scrutiny 1 w 95
as 2 w 97
he 4 w 99
was 1 w 102
before 1 w 108
to 3 w 110
rob 1 w 113
them 1 w 117
of 1 w 119
what 1 w 123
they 1 w 127
had 1 w 130
Nay 1 w 134
if 1 w 137
but 1 w 140
a 10 w 141
single 1 w 147
one 1 w 150
of 2 w 152
those 1 w 157
whom 1 w 161
he 7 w 163
has 1 w 166
wronged 1 w 173
appears 1 w 180
in 3 w 182
court 1 w 187
make 1 w 192
much 1 w 196
of 3 w 198
it 3 w 200
and 2 w 204
utterly 1 w 211
detest 1 w 217
this 2 w 221
man 2 w 224
who 2 w 228
could 1 w 233
bring 1 w 238
himself 1 w 245
to 4 w 247
strip 1 w 252
of 4 w 254
their 2 w 259
resources 1 w 268
those 2 w 273
on 3 w 275
whom 2 w 279
other 1 w 284
men 1 w 287
out 1 w 291
of 5 w 293
pity 1 w 297
for 2 w 300
their 3 w 305
straits 1 w 312
freely 1 w 319
bestowed 1 w 327
something 1 w 336
from 2 w 340
their 4 w 345
own 1 w 348
Pray 1 w 353
call 1 w 357
the 9 w 360
witnesses 1 w 369
Witnesses 1 w 379
Well 1 w 383
now 1 w 386
I 1 w 388
do 1 w 390
not 2 w 393
see 1 w 396
how 1 w 399
your 2 w 403
judgement 1 w 412
of 6 w 414
him 2 w 417
should 1 w 423
differ 1 w 429
from 3 w 433
that 1 w 437
of 7 w 439
his 3 w 442
own 2 w 445
people 1 w 451
for 3 w 455
the 10 w 458
facts 1 w 463
are 1 w 466
of 8 w 468
such 1 w 472
a 23 w 473
nature 1 w 479
that 2 w 483
even 1 w 488
if 3 w 490
he 14 w 492
had 2 w 495
committed 1 w 504
no 4 w 506
other 2 w 511
offence 1 w 518
they 2 w 523
would 1 w 528
alone 1 w 533
justify 1 w 540
his 4 w 543
rejection 1 w 552
The 1 w 556
strange 1 w 563
things 1 w 569
of 10 w 571
which 1 w 576
his 5 w 579
mother 1 w 585
accused 1 w 592
him 3 w 595
while 1 w 600
she 1 w 603
was 2 w 606
alive 1 w 611
I 2 w 612
will 1 w 616
pass 2 w 620
over 1 w 624
but 2 w 628
on 6 w 630
the 14 w 633
evidence 1 w 641
of 11 w 643
the 15 w 646
measures 1 w 654
that 3 w 658
she 2 w 661
took 1 w 665
at 6 w 667
the 16 w 670
close 1 w 675
of 12 w 677
her 5 w 680
life 1 w 684
you 3 w 687
can 1 w 690
easily 1 w 696
judge 2 w 701
how 2 w 704
he 25 w 706
treated 1 w 713
her 6 w 716
She 1 w 720
demurred 1 w 728
to 7 w 730
committing 1 w 740
herself 1 w 747
to 8 w 749
his 6 w 752
care 1 w 756
after 1 w 761
her 8 w 764
death 1 w 769
but 3 w 773
as 9 w 775
she 3 w 778
had 3 w 781
confidence 1 w 791
in 8 w 793
Antiphanes 1 w 803
who 4 w 807
was 3 w 810
no 5 w 812
connection 1 w 822
of 13 w 824
hers 2 w 828
she 4 w 832
gave 1 w 836
him 4 w 839
three 1 w 844
minae 1 w 849
of 14 w 851
silver 1 w 857
for 4 w 860
her 10 w 863
burial 1 w 869
ignoring 1 w 878
this 3 w 882
man 3 w 885
who 5 w 889
was 4 w 892
her 11 w 895
own 3 w 898
son 1 w 901
Obviously 1 w 911
of 15 w 914
course 1 w 920
she 5 w 924
was 5 w 927
convinced 1 w 936
that 4 w 940
he 36 w 942
would 2 w 947
not 3 w 950
perform 1 w 957
the 17 w 960
last 1 w 964
duties 1 w 970
even 2 w 974
on 12 w 976
the 18 w 979
ground 1 w 985
of 16 w 987
his 8 w 990
relationship 1 w 1002
Now 1 w 1006
I 3 w 1007
ask 1 w 1010
you 4 w 1013
if 6 w 1016
a 56 w 1017
mother 2 w 1023
who 6 w 1028
is 10 w 1030
naturally 1 w 1039
most 1 w 1043
willing 1 w 1050
to 9 w 1052
tolerate 1 w 1060
even 3 w 1064
an 9 w 1066
injury 1 w 1072
at 13 w 1074
the 20 w 1077
hands 1 w 1082
of 17 w 1084
her 13 w 1087
own 4 w 1090
children 1 w 1098
and 4 w 1102
who 7 w 1105
counts 1 w 1111
little 1 w 1117
benefits 1 w 1125
as 15 w 1127
great 1 w 1132
gains 1 w 1137
because 1 w 1144
she 6 w 1147
assesses 1 w 1155
their 5 w 1160
behavior 1 w 1168
by 2 w 1170
affection 1 w 1179
rather 1 w 1185
than 1 w 1189
logic 1 w 1194
believed 1 w 1204
that 5 w 1208
this 4 w 1212
man 4 w 1215
would 3 w 1220
seek 1 w 1224
his 10 w 1227
profit 1 w 1233
from 4 w 1237
her 15 w 1240
even 4 w 1244
in 15 w 1246
death 2 w 1251
what 2 w 1256
should 2 w 1262
be 9 w 1264
your 3 w 1268
feeling 1 w 1275
about 1 w 1280
him 5 w 1283