Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Defense Against a Charge of Subverting the Democracy

Defense Against a Charge of Subverting the Democracy (21-25)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0540.tlg025.perseus-eng2:21-25
Refs {'start': {'reference': '21', 'human_reference': 'None 21'}, 'end': {'reference': '25', 'human_reference': 'None 25'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

And you should reflect, gentlemen, on the events that have occurred under the Thirty, in order that the errors of your enemies may lead you to take better counsel on your own affairs. For as often as you heard that the people in the city were all of one mind, you had but slight hopes of your return, judging that our concord was the worst of signs for your exile:

but as soon as you had tidings that the Three Thousand were divided by faction, that the rest of the citizens had been publicly banned from the city, that the Thirty were not all of one mind, and that those who had fears for you outnumbered those who were making war on you, you immediately began to look forward to your return and the punishment of your enemies. For it was your prayer to the gods that those men should do the things that you saw them doing, since you believed that the villainy of the Thirty would be far more useful for your salvation than the resources of the exiles for your return.

You ought therefore, gentlemen, to take the events of the past as your example in resolving on the future course of things, and to account those men the best democrats who, desiring your concord, abide by their oaths and covenants, because they hold this to be the most effective safeguard of the city and the severest punishment of her enemies. For nothing could be more vexatious to them than to learn that we are taking part in the government and to perceive at the same time that the citizens are behaving as though they had never had any fault to find with each other.

And you should know, gentlemen, that the exiles desire to see the greatest possible number of their fellow citizens not merely slandered but disfranchised; since they hope that the men who are wronged by you will be their allies, and they would gladly have the venal informers standing high in your esteem and influential in the city. For they judge the villainy of those creatures to be their own safeguard.

You will do well to remember also the events that followed the rule of the Four Hundred[*]; for you will fully realize that the measures advised by these men have never brought you any advantage, while those that I recommend have always profited both parties in the State. You know that Epigenes, Demophanes and Cleisthenes, while reaping their personal gains from the citys misfortunes, have inflicted the heaviest losses on the public weal.

Tokens

And 1 w 3
you 1 w 6
should 1 w 12
reflect 1 w 19
gentlemen 1 w 29
on 1 w 32
the 1 w 35
events 1 w 41
that 1 w 45
have 1 w 49
occurred 1 w 57
under 1 w 62
the 2 w 65
Thirty 1 w 71
in 1 w 74
order 1 w 79
that 2 w 83
the 3 w 86
errors 1 w 92
of 1 w 94
your 1 w 98
enemies 1 w 105
may 1 w 108
lead 1 w 112
you 3 w 115
to 1 w 117
take 1 w 121
better 1 w 127
counsel 1 w 134
on 2 w 136
your 2 w 140
own 1 w 143
affairs 1 w 150
For 1 w 154
as 1 w 156
often 1 w 161
as 2 w 163
you 5 w 166
heard 1 w 171
that 3 w 175
the 4 w 178
people 1 w 184
in 2 w 186
the 5 w 189
city 1 w 193
were 1 w 197
all 1 w 200
of 3 w 202
one 1 w 205
mind 1 w 209
you 6 w 213
had 1 w 216
but 1 w 219
slight 1 w 225
hopes 1 w 230
of 4 w 232
your 3 w 236
return 1 w 242
judging 1 w 250
that 4 w 254
our 4 w 257
concord 1 w 264
was 1 w 267
the 6 w 270
worst 1 w 275
of 5 w 277
signs 1 w 282
for 1 w 285
your 4 w 289
exile 1 w 294
but 2 w 298
as 4 w 300
soon 1 w 304
as 5 w 306
you 9 w 309
had 2 w 312
tidings 1 w 319
that 5 w 323
the 7 w 326
Three 1 w 331
Thousand 1 w 339
were 2 w 343
divided 1 w 350
by 1 w 352
faction 1 w 359
that 6 w 364
the 8 w 367
rest 1 w 371
of 6 w 373
the 9 w 376
citizens 1 w 384
had 3 w 387
been 1 w 391
publicly 1 w 399
banned 1 w 405
from 1 w 409
the 10 w 412
city 2 w 416
that 7 w 421
the 11 w 424
Thirty 2 w 430
were 3 w 434
not 1 w 437
all 2 w 440
of 7 w 442
one 2 w 445
mind 2 w 449
and 2 w 453
that 8 w 457
those 1 w 462
who 1 w 465
had 4 w 468
fears 1 w 473
for 2 w 476
you 10 w 479
outnumbered 1 w 490
those 2 w 495
who 2 w 498
were 4 w 502
making 1 w 508
war 1 w 511
on 8 w 513
you 11 w 516
you 12 w 520
immediately 1 w 531
began 1 w 536
to 2 w 538
look 1 w 542
forward 1 w 549
to 3 w 551
your 5 w 555
return 2 w 561
and 3 w 564
the 12 w 567
punishment 1 w 577
of 8 w 579
your 6 w 583
enemies 2 w 590
For 2 w 594
it 4 w 596
was 2 w 599
your 7 w 603
prayer 1 w 609
to 4 w 611
the 13 w 614
gods 1 w 618
that 9 w 622
those 3 w 627
men 3 w 630
should 2 w 636
do 1 w 638
the 14 w 641
things 1 w 647
that 10 w 651
you 16 w 654
saw 1 w 657
them 1 w 661
doing 1 w 666
since 1 w 672
you 17 w 675
believed 1 w 683
that 11 w 687
the 16 w 690
villainy 1 w 698
of 9 w 700
the 17 w 703
Thirty 3 w 709
would 1 w 714
be 6 w 716
far 1 w 719
more 1 w 723
useful 1 w 729
for 4 w 732
your 8 w 736
salvation 1 w 745
than 1 w 749
the 18 w 752
resources 1 w 761
of 10 w 763
the 19 w 766
exiles 1 w 772
for 5 w 775
your 9 w 779
return 3 w 785
You 1 w 789
ought 1 w 794
therefore 1 w 803
gentlemen 2 w 813
to 5 w 816
take 2 w 820
the 21 w 823
events 2 w 829
of 11 w 831
the 22 w 834
past 1 w 838
as 8 w 840
your 10 w 844
example 1 w 851
in 12 w 853
resolving 1 w 862
on 10 w 864
the 23 w 867
future 1 w 873
course 1 w 879
of 12 w 881
things 2 w 887
and 4 w 891
to 6 w 893
account 1 w 900
those 4 w 905
men 5 w 908
the 24 w 911
best 1 w 915
democrats 1 w 924
who 3 w 927
desiring 1 w 936
your 11 w 940
concord 2 w 947
abide 1 w 953
by 2 w 955
their 1 w 960
oaths 1 w 965
and 5 w 968
covenants 1 w 977
because 1 w 985
they 1 w 989
hold 1 w 993
this 1 w 997
to 7 w 999
be 9 w 1001
the 27 w 1004
most 1 w 1008
effective 1 w 1017
safeguard 1 w 1026
of 13 w 1028
the 28 w 1031
city 3 w 1035
and 6 w 1038
the 29 w 1041
severest 1 w 1049
punishment 2 w 1059
of 14 w 1061
her 2 w 1064
enemies 3 w 1071
For 3 w 1075
nothing 1 w 1082
could 1 w 1087
be 10 w 1089
more 2 w 1093
vexatious 1 w 1102
to 8 w 1104
them 2 w 1108
than 2 w 1112
to 9 w 1114
learn 1 w 1119
that 12 w 1123
we 5 w 1125
are 1 w 1128
taking 1 w 1134
part 1 w 1138
in 18 w 1140
the 31 w 1143
government 1 w 1153
and 7 w 1156
to 10 w 1158
perceive 1 w 1166
at 18 w 1168
the 32 w 1171
same 1 w 1175
time 1 w 1179
that 13 w 1183
the 33 w 1186
citizens 2 w 1194
are 2 w 1197
behaving 1 w 1205
as 9 w 1207
though 1 w 1213
they 2 w 1217
had 5 w 1220
never 1 w 1225
had 6 w 1228
any 1 w 1231
fault 1 w 1236
to 11 w 1238
find 1 w 1242
with 1 w 1246
each 1 w 1250
other 1 w 1255
And 2 w 1259
you 22 w 1262
should 3 w 1268
know 1 w 1272
gentlemen 3 w 1282
that 14 w 1287
the 36 w 1290
exiles 2 w 1296
desire 1 w 1302
to 12 w 1304
see 1 w 1307
the 37 w 1310
greatest 1 w 1318
possible 1 w 1326
number 2 w 1332
of 15 w 1334
their 2 w 1339
fellow 1 w 1345
citizens 3 w 1353
not 3 w 1356
merely 1 w 1362
slandered 1 w 1371
but 3 w 1374
disfranchised 1 w 1387
since 2 w 1393
they 3 w 1397
hope 2 w 1401
that 15 w 1405
the 40 w 1408
men 9 w 1411
who 4 w 1414
are 3 w 1417
wronged 1 w 1424
by 3 w 1426
you 23 w 1429
will 1 w 1433
be 13 w 1435
their 3 w 1440
allies 1 w 1446
and 9 w 1450
they 4 w 1454
would 2 w 1459
gladly 1 w 1465
have 2 w 1469
the 43 w 1472
venal 1 w 1477
informers 1 w 1486
standing 1 w 1494
high 1 w 1498
in 24 w 1500
your 12 w 1504
esteem 1 w 1510
and 11 w 1513
influential 1 w 1524
in 26 w 1526
the 44 w 1529
city 4 w 1533
For 4 w 1537
they 5 w 1541
judge 1 w 1546
the 46 w 1549
villainy 2 w 1557
of 16 w 1559
those 5 w 1564
creatures 1 w 1573
to 13 w 1575
be 14 w 1577
their 4 w 1582
own 2 w 1585
safeguard 2 w 1594
You 2 w 1598
will 2 w 1602
do 3 w 1604
well 1 w 1608
to 14 w 1610
remember 1 w 1618
also 1 w 1622
the 48 w 1625
events 3 w 1631
that 16 w 1635
followed 1 w 1643
the 49 w 1646
rule 1 w 1650
of 17 w 1652
the 50 w 1655
Four 1 w 1659
Hundred 1 w 1666
June-September 1 w 1680
411 1 w 1684
B 1 w 1685
C 1 w 1687
for 8 w 1692
you 25 w 1695
will 3 w 1699
fully 1 w 1704
realize 1 w 1711
that 17 w 1715
the 51 w 1718
measures 1 w 1726
advised 1 w 1733
by 4 w 1735
these 1 w 1740
men 10 w 1743
have 3 w 1747
never 2 w 1752
brought 1 w 1759
you 26 w 1762
any 2 w 1765
advantage 1 w 1774
while 1 w 1780
those 6 w 1785
that 18 w 1789
I 1 w 1790
recommend 1 w 1799
have 4 w 1803
always 1 w 1809
profited 1 w 1817
both 1 w 1821
parties 1 w 1828
in 28 w 1830
the 53 w 1833
State 1 w 1838
You 3 w 1842
know 2 w 1846
that 19 w 1850
Epigenes 1 w 1858
Demophanes 1 w 1869
and 12 w 1872
Cleisthenes 1 w 1883
while 2 w 1889
reaping 1 w 1896
their 5 w 1901
personal 1 w 1909
gains 1 w 1914
from 2 w 1918
the 56 w 1921
city 5 w 1925
s 97 w 1927
misfortunes 1 w 1938
have 5 w 1943
inflicted 1 w 1952
the 57 w 1955
heaviest 1 w 1963
losses 1 w 1969
on 14 w 1971
the 58 w 1974
public 2 w 1980
weal 1 w 1984