Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Against Alcibiades 1

Against Alcibiades 1 (1-5)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0540.tlg014.perseus-eng2:1-5
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1', 'human_reference': 'None 1'}, 'end': {'reference': '5', 'human_reference': 'None 5'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

I do not believe, gentlemen of the jury, that you desire to hear any excuse for the action of those who have resolved to accuse Alcibiades: for from the outset he has shown himself so unworthy of the citizenship that it is the duty of anyone, even in the absence of a personal wrong suffered at his hands, to regard him none the less as an enemy because of the general tenor of his life.

His offences are not slight or entitled to indulgence, nor do they offer a hope of his reform in the future: they have been committed in such a manner, and have carried villainy to such lengths, that even his enemies feel ashamed for some of the things on which he prides himself. Yet I, gentlemen, since our fathers were previously at feud, and since my long-standing sense of his rascally character has now been increased by maltreatment at his hands, will try with your aid to make him pay the penalty for all that he has done.

Narr

The main indictment has been sufficiently delivered by Archestratides; for he has exhibited the laws and produced witnesses to everything. But on certain points that he has omitted I will give you particular information.

Proof

Now it is reasonable, gentlemen of the jury, that men who are now trying such a case for the first time since we settled the peace[*] should act not merely as jurors, but in fact as law-makers. For you know well that your decision upon these cases will determine the attitude of the city towards them for all time. And it is the duty, in my opinion, alike of a loyal citizen and of a just juror to put such constructions on the laws as are likely to be of benefit to the city in the future.

For some are bold enough to assert that nobody can be chargeable with desertion or cowardice, since no battle has taken place; that the law merely provides for a court-martial on anyone who, from cowardice, has deserted the ranks and retreated while the rest were fighting. But the provisions of the law apply not only to such a case, but also to that of anyone who fails to appear in the infantry lines. Please read the law.

I 1 w 1
do 1 w 3
not 1 w 6
believe 1 w 13
gentlemen 1 w 23
of 1 w 25
the 1 w 28
jury 1 w 32
that 1 w 37
you 1 w 40
desire 1 w 46
to 1 w 48
hear 1 w 52
any 1 w 55
excuse 1 w 61
for 1 w 64
the 2 w 67
action 1 w 73
of 2 w 75
those 1 w 80
who 1 w 83
have 1 w 87
resolved 1 w 95
to 2 w 97
accuse 1 w 103
Alcibiades 1 w 113
for 2 w 117
from 1 w 121
the 3 w 124
outset 1 w 130
he 5 w 132
has 1 w 135
shown 1 w 140
himself 1 w 147
so 2 w 149
unworthy 1 w 157
of 3 w 159
the 4 w 162
citizenship 1 w 173
that 2 w 177
it 2 w 179
is 1 w 181
the 5 w 184
duty 1 w 188
of 4 w 190
anyone 1 w 196
even 1 w 201
in 1 w 203
the 6 w 206
absence 1 w 213
of 5 w 215
a 12 w 216
personal 1 w 224
wrong 1 w 229
suffered 1 w 237
at 3 w 239
his 1 w 242
hands 1 w 247
to 3 w 250
regard 1 w 256
him 2 w 259
none 1 w 263
the 7 w 266
less 1 w 270
as 2 w 272
an 4 w 274
enemy 1 w 279
because 1 w 286
of 6 w 288
the 8 w 291
general 1 w 298
tenor 1 w 303
of 7 w 305
his 2 w 308
life 1 w 312
His 1 w 316
offences 1 w 324
are 1 w 327
not 2 w 330
slight 1 w 336
or 5 w 338
entitled 1 w 346
to 4 w 348
indulgence 1 w 358
nor 2 w 362
do 2 w 364
they 1 w 368
offer 1 w 373
a 22 w 374
hope 1 w 378
of 10 w 380
his 3 w 383
reform 1 w 389
in 3 w 391
the 10 w 394
future 1 w 400
they 2 w 405
have 2 w 409
been 1 w 413
committed 1 w 422
in 4 w 424
such 1 w 428
a 24 w 429
manner 1 w 435
and 2 w 439
have 3 w 443
carried 1 w 450
villainy 1 w 458
to 5 w 460
such 2 w 464
lengths 1 w 471
that 3 w 476
even 2 w 480
his 4 w 483
enemies 1 w 490
feel 1 w 494
ashamed 1 w 501
for 4 w 504
some 1 w 508
of 11 w 510
the 12 w 513
things 1 w 519
on 6 w 521
which 1 w 526
he 15 w 528
prides 1 w 534
himself 2 w 541
Yet 1 w 545
I 2 w 546
gentlemen 2 w 556
since 1 w 562
our 1 w 565
fathers 1 w 572
were 1 w 576
previously 1 w 586
at 6 w 588
feud 1 w 592
and 3 w 596
since 2 w 601
my 2 w 603
long-standing 1 w 616
sense 1 w 621
of 12 w 623
his 5 w 626
rascally 1 w 634
character 1 w 643
has 2 w 646
now 1 w 649
been 2 w 653
increased 1 w 662
by 1 w 664
maltreatment 1 w 676
at 8 w 678
his 6 w 681
hands 2 w 686
will 1 w 691
try 1 w 694
with 1 w 698
your 1 w 702
aid 1 w 705
to 6 w 707
make 1 w 711
him 4 w 714
pay 1 w 717
the 14 w 720
penalty 1 w 727
for 5 w 730
all 2 w 733
that 4 w 737
he 18 w 739
has 3 w 742
done 1 w 746
The 1 w 750
main 1 w 754
indictment 1 w 764
has 4 w 767
been 3 w 771
sufficiently 1 w 783
delivered 1 w 792
by 2 w 794
Archestratides 1 w 808
for 6 w 812
he 21 w 814
has 5 w 817
exhibited 1 w 826
the 15 w 829
laws 1 w 833
and 6 w 836
produced 1 w 844
witnesses 1 w 853
to 7 w 855
everything 1 w 865
But 1 w 869
on 9 w 871
certain 1 w 878
points 1 w 884
that 5 w 888
he 23 w 890
has 6 w 893
omitted 1 w 900
I 3 w 901
will 2 w 905
give 1 w 909
you 3 w 912
particular 1 w 922
information 1 w 933
Now 1 w 937
it 9 w 939
is 9 w 941
reasonable 1 w 951
gentlemen 3 w 961
of 13 w 963
the 16 w 966
jury 2 w 970
that 6 w 975
men 6 w 978
who 2 w 981
are 2 w 984
now 2 w 987
trying 1 w 993
such 3 w 997
a 70 w 998
case 1 w 1002
for 8 w 1005
the 17 w 1008
first 1 w 1013
time 1 w 1017
since 3 w 1022
we 2 w 1024
settled 1 w 1031
the 18 w 1034
peace 1 w 1039
i 70 w 1040
e 150 w 1042
the 19 w 1047
peace 2 w 1052
of 14 w 1054
404 1 w 1057
B 2 w 1058
C 1 w 1060
which 2 w 1066
ended 1 w 1071
the 20 w 1074
Peloponnesian 1 w 1087
War 1 w 1090
should 1 w 1097
act 3 w 1100
not 3 w 1103
merely 1 w 1109
as 13 w 1111
jurors 1 w 1117
but 1 w 1121
in 19 w 1123
fact 1 w 1127
as 14 w 1129
law-makers 1 w 1139
For 1 w 1143
you 4 w 1146
know 1 w 1150
well 1 w 1154
that 7 w 1158
your 2 w 1162
decision 1 w 1170
upon 1 w 1174
these 1 w 1179
cases 1 w 1184
will 3 w 1188
determine 1 w 1197
the 22 w 1200
attitude 1 w 1208
of 15 w 1210
the 23 w 1213
city 1 w 1217
towards 1 w 1224
them 1 w 1228
for 9 w 1231
all 3 w 1234
time 2 w 1238
And 1 w 1242
it 12 w 1244
is 11 w 1246
the 25 w 1249
duty 2 w 1253
in 21 w 1256
my 3 w 1258
opinion 1 w 1265
alike 1 w 1271
of 16 w 1273
a 88 w 1274
loyal 1 w 1279
citizen 2 w 1286
and 7 w 1289
of 17 w 1291
a 91 w 1292
just 1 w 1296
juror 2 w 1301
to 9 w 1303
put 1 w 1306
such 4 w 1310
constructions 1 w 1323
on 18 w 1325
the 26 w 1328
laws 2 w 1332
as 16 w 1334
are 3 w 1337
likely 1 w 1343
to 10 w 1345
be 6 w 1347
of 18 w 1349
benefit 1 w 1356
to 11 w 1358
the 27 w 1361
city 2 w 1365
in 23 w 1367
the 28 w 1370
future 2 w 1376
For 2 w 1380
some 2 w 1384
are 4 w 1387
bold 1 w 1391
enough 1 w 1397
to 12 w 1399
assert 1 w 1405
that 8 w 1409
nobody 1 w 1415
can 1 w 1418
be 8 w 1420
chargeable 1 w 1430
with 2 w 1434
desertion 1 w 1443
or 18 w 1445
cowardice 1 w 1454
since 4 w 1460
no 12 w 1462
battle 1 w 1468
has 7 w 1471
taken 1 w 1476
place 1 w 1481
that 9 w 1486
the 29 w 1489
law 4 w 1492
merely 2 w 1498
provides 1 w 1506
for 10 w 1509
a 108 w 1510
court-martial 1 w 1523
on 20 w 1525
anyone 2 w 1531
who 3 w 1534
from 2 w 1539
cowardice 2 w 1548
has 8 w 1552
deserted 1 w 1560
the 30 w 1563
ranks 1 w 1568
and 8 w 1571
retreated 1 w 1580
while 1 w 1585
the 31 w 1588
rest 1 w 1592
were 2 w 1596
fighting 1 w 1604
But 2 w 1608
the 32 w 1611
provisions 1 w 1621
of 19 w 1623
the 33 w 1626
law 5 w 1629
apply 1 w 1634
not 4 w 1637
only 1 w 1641
to 13 w 1643
such 5 w 1647
a 119 w 1648
case 3 w 1652
but 2 w 1656
also 1 w 1660
to 14 w 1662
that 10 w 1666
of 20 w 1668
anyone 3 w 1674
who 4 w 1677
fails 1 w 1682
to 15 w 1684
appear 1 w 1690
in 26 w 1692
the 34 w 1695
infantry 1 w 1703
lines 1 w 1708
Please 1 w 1715
read 1 w 1719
the 35 w 1722
law 6 w 1725