Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Against Eratosthenes

Against Eratosthenes (36-40)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0540.tlg012.perseus-eng2:36-40
Refs {'start': {'reference': '36', 'human_reference': 'None 36'}, 'end': {'reference': '40', 'human_reference': 'None 40'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

And how monstrous it would be, when you have punished with death the commanders who won the victory at sea[*]they said that a storm prevented them from picking up the men in the water, but you felt that you must make them give satisfaction to the I valor of the deadif these men, who as ordinary persons used their utmost endeavors towards your defeat in the sea-fights,[*] and then, once established in power, admit that of their own free will they put to death many of the citizens without a trial,—if these men, I say, and their children are not to be visited by you with the extreme penalty of the law!

Now I, gentlemen, might almost claim that the accusations you have heard are sufficient: for I consider that an accuser ought to go no further than to show that the defendant has committed acts that merit death; since this is the extreme penalty that we have power to inflict upon him. So I doubt if there is any need to prolong ones accusation of such men as these; for not even if they underwent two deaths for each one of their deeds could they pay the penalty in full measure.

And note that he cannot even resort to the expedient, so habitual among our citizens, of saying nothing to answer the counts of the accusation, but making other statements about themselves which at times deceive you; they represent to you that they are good soldiers, or have taken many vessels of the enemy while in command of war-ships, or have won over cities from hostility to friendship.

Why, only tell him to point out where they killed as many of our enemies as they have of our citizens, or where they took as many ships as they themselves surrendered, or what city they enlisted to compare with yours which they enslaved.

Nay, indeed, did they despoil the enemy of as many arms as they stripped from you? Did they capture fortifications to compare with those of their own country which they razed to the ground? They are the men who pulled down the forts around Attica, and made it evident to you that even in dismantling the Peiraeus they were not obeying the injunctions of the Lacedaemonians, but were thinking to make their own authority the more secure.

Tokens

And 1 w 3
how 1 w 6
monstrous 1 w 15
it 1 w 17
would 1 w 22
be 1 w 24
when 1 w 29
you 1 w 32
have 1 w 36
punished 1 w 44
with 1 w 48
death 1 w 53
the 1 w 56
commanders 1 w 66
who 1 w 69
won 1 w 72
the 2 w 75
victory 1 w 82
at 2 w 84
sea 1 w 87
At 1 w 89
Arginusae 1 w 98
406 1 w 102
B 1 w 103
C 1 w 105
they 1 w 111
said 1 w 115
that 1 w 119
a 9 w 120
storm 1 w 125
prevented 1 w 134
them 1 w 138
from 1 w 142
picking 1 w 149
up 1 w 151
the 5 w 154
men 1 w 157
in 3 w 159
the 6 w 162
water 1 w 167
but 1 w 171
you 2 w 174
felt 1 w 178
that 2 w 182
you 3 w 185
must 1 w 189
make 1 w 193
them 2 w 197
give 1 w 201
satisfaction 1 w 213
to 3 w 215
the 8 w 218
I 1 w 219
valor 1 w 224
of 1 w 226
the 9 w 229
dead 1 w 233
if 1 w 236
these 1 w 241
men 2 w 244
who 2 w 248
as 1 w 250
ordinary 1 w 258
persons 1 w 265
used 1 w 269
their 1 w 274
utmost 1 w 280
endeavors 1 w 289
towards 1 w 296
your 1 w 300
defeat 1 w 306
in 5 w 308
the 12 w 311
sea-fights 1 w 321
It 1 w 324
was 1 w 327
suspected 1 w 336
that 3 w 340
both 1 w 344
at 9 w 346
Arginusae 2 w 355
and 2 w 358
at 10 w 360
Aegospotami 1 w 371
members 1 w 378
of 2 w 380
the 13 w 383
oligarchic 1 w 393
party 1 w 398
had 1 w 401
been 1 w 405
working 1 w 412
for 1 w 415
the 14 w 418
defeat 2 w 424
of 3 w 426
Athens 1 w 432
by 1 w 434
Sparta 1 w 440
and 3 w 444
then 2 w 448
once 1 w 453
established 1 w 464
in 8 w 466
power 1 w 471
admit 1 w 477
that 4 w 481
of 4 w 483
their 2 w 488
own 1 w 491
free 1 w 495
will 1 w 499
they 2 w 503
put 1 w 506
to 5 w 508
death 2 w 513
many 1 w 517
of 5 w 519
the 19 w 522
citizens 1 w 530
without 1 w 537
a 42 w 538
trial 1 w 543
if 2 w 547
these 2 w 552
men 3 w 555
I 3 w 557
say 1 w 560
and 4 w 564
their 3 w 569
children 1 w 577
are 1 w 580
not 1 w 583
to 6 w 585
be 4 w 587
visited 1 w 594
by 2 w 596
you 5 w 599
with 3 w 603
the 22 w 606
extreme 1 w 613
penalty 1 w 620
of 6 w 622
the 23 w 625
law 1 w 628
Now 1 w 632
I 4 w 633
gentlemen 1 w 643
might 1 w 649
almost 1 w 655
claim 1 w 660
that 5 w 664
the 24 w 667
accusations 1 w 678
you 6 w 681
have 2 w 685
heard 1 w 690
are 2 w 693
sufficient 1 w 703
for 2 w 707
I 5 w 708
consider 1 w 716
that 6 w 720
an 6 w 722
accuser 1 w 729
ought 1 w 734
to 7 w 736
go 2 w 738
no 2 w 740
further 1 w 747
than 1 w 751
to 8 w 753
show 1 w 757
that 7 w 761
the 26 w 764
defendant 1 w 773
has 1 w 776
committed 1 w 785
acts 1 w 789
that 8 w 793
merit 1 w 798
death 3 w 803
since 1 w 809
this 1 w 813
is 6 w 815
the 27 w 818
extreme 2 w 825
penalty 2 w 832
that 9 w 836
we 2 w 838
have 3 w 842
power 2 w 847
to 9 w 849
inflict 1 w 856
upon 1 w 860
him 1 w 863
So 1 w 866
I 6 w 867
doubt 1 w 872
if 3 w 874
there 1 w 879
is 7 w 881
any 2 w 884
need 1 w 888
to 10 w 890
prolong 1 w 897
one 1 w 900
s 48 w 902
accusation 2 w 912
of 7 w 914
such 1 w 918
men 5 w 921
as 4 w 923
these 3 w 928
for 3 w 932
not 2 w 935
even 2 w 939
if 4 w 941
they 3 w 945
underwent 1 w 954
two 1 w 957
deaths 1 w 963
for 4 w 966
each 1 w 970
one 2 w 973
of 8 w 975
their 4 w 980
deeds 1 w 985
could 1 w 990
they 4 w 994
pay 1 w 997
the 33 w 1000
penalty 3 w 1007
in 11 w 1009
full 1 w 1013
measure 1 w 1020
And 2 w 1024
note 1 w 1028
that 10 w 1032
he 38 w 1034
cannot 1 w 1040
even 3 w 1044
resort 1 w 1050
to 11 w 1052
the 34 w 1055
expedient 1 w 1064
so 3 w 1067
habitual 1 w 1075
among 1 w 1080
our 2 w 1083
citizens 2 w 1091
of 9 w 1094
saying 1 w 1100
nothing 1 w 1107
to 12 w 1109
answer 1 w 1115
the 35 w 1118
counts 1 w 1124
of 10 w 1126
the 36 w 1129
accusation 3 w 1139
but 2 w 1143
making 1 w 1149
other 1 w 1154
statements 1 w 1164
about 1 w 1169
themselves 1 w 1179
which 1 w 1184
at 26 w 1186
times 1 w 1191
deceive 1 w 1198
you 7 w 1201
they 5 w 1206
represent 1 w 1215
to 13 w 1217
you 8 w 1220
that 11 w 1224
they 6 w 1228
are 3 w 1231
good 1 w 1235
soldiers 1 w 1243
or 12 w 1246
have 4 w 1250
taken 1 w 1255
many 2 w 1259
vessels 1 w 1266
of 11 w 1268
the 41 w 1271
enemy 1 w 1276
while 1 w 1281
in 15 w 1283
command 2 w 1290
of 12 w 1292
war-ships 1 w 1301
or 13 w 1304
have 5 w 1308
won 2 w 1311
over 1 w 1315
cities 1 w 1321
from 2 w 1325
hostility 1 w 1334
to 14 w 1336
friendship 1 w 1346
Why 1 w 1350
only 1 w 1355
tell 1 w 1359
him 2 w 1362
to 15 w 1364
point 1 w 1369
out 3 w 1372
where 1 w 1377
they 7 w 1381
killed 1 w 1387
as 6 w 1389
many 3 w 1393
of 13 w 1395
our 3 w 1398
enemies 1 w 1405
as 7 w 1407
they 8 w 1411
have 6 w 1415
of 14 w 1417
our 4 w 1420
citizens 3 w 1428
or 14 w 1431
where 2 w 1436
they 9 w 1440
took 1 w 1444
as 8 w 1446
many 4 w 1450
ships 2 w 1455
as 9 w 1457
they 10 w 1461
themselves 2 w 1471
surrendered 1 w 1482
or 15 w 1485
what 1 w 1489
city 1 w 1493
they 11 w 1497
enlisted 1 w 1505
to 17 w 1507
compare 1 w 1514
with 4 w 1518
yours 1 w 1523
which 2 w 1528
they 12 w 1532
enslaved 1 w 1540
Nay 1 w 1544
indeed 1 w 1551
did 1 w 1555
they 13 w 1559
despoil 1 w 1566
the 50 w 1569
enemy 2 w 1574
of 15 w 1576
as 10 w 1578
many 5 w 1582
arms 1 w 1586
as 11 w 1588
they 14 w 1592
stripped 1 w 1600
from 3 w 1604
you 10 w 1607
Did 1 w 1611
they 15 w 1615
capture 1 w 1622
fortifications 1 w 1636
to 18 w 1638
compare 2 w 1645
with 5 w 1649
those 1 w 1654
of 16 w 1656
their 5 w 1661
own 2 w 1664
country 1 w 1671
which 3 w 1676
they 16 w 1680
razed 1 w 1685
to 19 w 1687
the 55 w 1690
ground 1 w 1696
They 1 w 1701
are 6 w 1704
the 56 w 1707
men 7 w 1710
who 3 w 1713
pulled 1 w 1719
down 1 w 1723
the 57 w 1726
forts 1 w 1731
around 1 w 1737
Attica 1 w 1743
and 6 w 1747
made 1 w 1751
it 18 w 1753
evident 1 w 1760
to 20 w 1762
you 11 w 1765
that 12 w 1769
even 4 w 1773
in 18 w 1775
dismantling 1 w 1786
the 58 w 1789
Peiraeus 1 w 1797
they 17 w 1801
were 1 w 1805
not 6 w 1808
obeying 1 w 1815
the 60 w 1818
injunctions 1 w 1829
of 17 w 1831
the 61 w 1834
Lacedaemonians 1 w 1848
but 3 w 1852
were 2 w 1856
thinking 1 w 1864
to 21 w 1866
make 2 w 1870
their 6 w 1875
own 4 w 1878
authority 1 w 1887
the 63 w 1890
more 1 w 1894
secure 1 w 1900