Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Against Theomnestus 2

Against Theomnestus 2 (1-5)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0540.tlg011.perseus-eng2:1-5
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1', 'human_reference': 'None 1'}, 'end': {'reference': '5', 'human_reference': 'None 5'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

That he asserted that I had killed my father is in the knowledge of many of you, and they are my witnesses. But that I have not done it is evident; for I am thirty-two years old, and this is the twentieth year since your return to the city.

You see, then, that I was twelve years old when my father was put to death by the Thirty, so that I did not even know what an oligarchy was, nor was I capable of defending my father. Nor, again, was his property a motive for my having designs upon him; for my elder brother got everything, and left us destitute.

Perhaps he will say that it is not among the forbidden things to say a man has killed his father, since the law does not prohibit this, but disallows the word murderer. But I think our dispute ought not to be over mere terms, but over the intention shown in acts, and that everyone knows that all who have killed others are murderers of those same persons, and those who are murderers of another have killed that man.

For it would be too great a task for the lawgiver to write all the terms that have the same meaning: he preferred to mention one which should indicate all. I presume it cannot be that, if anyone who calls you a father-beater or a mother-beater is liable to a penalty, at the same time a person who says that you strike your male or female parent is to escape punishment.

So, if someone calls a man a shield-caster, he is to be immune, since the law imposes a penalty for saying that a man has thrown away his shield, but not for saying he has cast it. Similarly, if you were one of the Eleven, you would not accept a prisoner arrested for stripping a man of his cloak or his shirt, unless he were given the name of clothes-stealer.

That 1 w 4
he 1 w 6
asserted 1 w 14
that 1 w 18
I 1 w 19
had 1 w 22
killed 1 w 28
my 1 w 30
father 1 w 36
is 1 w 38
in 1 w 40
the 2 w 43
knowledge 1 w 52
of 1 w 54
many 1 w 58
of 2 w 60
you 1 w 63
and 1 w 67
they 1 w 71
are 1 w 74
my 2 w 76
witnesses 1 w 85
But 1 w 89
that 2 w 93
I 2 w 94
have 1 w 98
not 1 w 101
done 1 w 105
it 2 w 107
is 2 w 109
evident 1 w 116
for 1 w 120
I 3 w 121
am 1 w 123
thirty-two 1 w 133
years 1 w 138
old 1 w 141
and 2 w 145
this 1 w 149
is 4 w 151
the 4 w 154
twentieth 1 w 163
year 2 w 167
since 1 w 172
your 1 w 176
return 1 w 182
to 1 w 184
the 5 w 187
city 1 w 191
You 1 w 195
see 1 w 198
then 1 w 203
that 3 w 208
I 4 w 209
was 1 w 212
twelve 1 w 218
years 2 w 223
old 2 w 226
when 1 w 230
my 3 w 232
father 2 w 238
was 2 w 241
put 1 w 244
to 2 w 246
death 1 w 251
by 1 w 253
the 8 w 256
Thirty 1 w 262
so 1 w 265
that 4 w 269
I 5 w 270
did 1 w 273
not 2 w 276
even 1 w 280
know 2 w 284
what 1 w 288
an 4 w 290
oligarchy 1 w 299
was 3 w 302
nor 1 w 306
was 4 w 309
I 6 w 310
capable 1 w 317
of 3 w 319
defending 1 w 328
my 4 w 330
father 3 w 336
Nor 1 w 340
again 1 w 346
was 5 w 350
his 2 w 353
property 1 w 361
a 33 w 362
motive 1 w 368
for 2 w 371
my 5 w 373
having 1 w 379
designs 1 w 386
upon 1 w 390
him 1 w 393
for 3 w 397
my 6 w 399
elder 1 w 404
brother 1 w 411
got 1 w 414
everything 1 w 424
and 3 w 428
left 1 w 432
us 1 w 434
destitute 1 w 443
Perhaps 1 w 451
he 13 w 453
will 1 w 457
say 1 w 460
that 5 w 464
it 5 w 466
is 6 w 468
not 3 w 471
among 1 w 476
the 11 w 479
forbidden 1 w 488
things 1 w 494
to 3 w 496
say 2 w 499
a 41 w 500
man 2 w 503
has 1 w 506
killed 2 w 512
his 3 w 515
father 4 w 521
since 2 w 527
the 13 w 530
law 1 w 533
does 1 w 537
not 4 w 540
prohibit 1 w 548
this 2 w 552
but 1 w 556
disallows 1 w 565
the 14 w 568
word 1 w 572
murderer 1 w 580
But 2 w 584
I 7 w 585
think 1 w 590
our 2 w 593
dispute 1 w 600
ought 1 w 605
not 5 w 608
to 4 w 610
be 1 w 612
over 1 w 616
mere 1 w 620
terms 1 w 625
but 2 w 629
over 2 w 633
the 15 w 636
intention 1 w 645
shown 1 w 650
in 11 w 652
acts 1 w 656
and 4 w 660
that 6 w 664
everyone 1 w 672
knows 1 w 677
that 7 w 681
all 2 w 684
who 1 w 687
have 2 w 691
killed 3 w 697
others 1 w 703
are 2 w 706
murderers 1 w 715
of 4 w 717
those 1 w 722
same 1 w 726
persons 1 w 733
and 5 w 737
those 2 w 742
who 2 w 745
are 3 w 748
murderers 2 w 757
of 5 w 759
another 1 w 766
have 3 w 770
killed 4 w 776
that 8 w 780
man 3 w 783
For 1 w 787
it 7 w 789
would 1 w 794
be 2 w 796
too 1 w 799
great 1 w 804
a 62 w 805
task 1 w 809
for 5 w 812
the 18 w 815
lawgiver 1 w 823
to 6 w 825
write 1 w 830
all 3 w 833
the 19 w 836
terms 2 w 841
that 9 w 845
have 4 w 849
the 20 w 852
same 2 w 856
meaning 1 w 863
he 24 w 866
preferred 1 w 875
to 7 w 877
mention 1 w 884
one 3 w 887
which 1 w 892
should 1 w 898
indicate 1 w 906
all 4 w 909
I 8 w 911
presume 1 w 918
it 9 w 920
cannot 1 w 926
be 3 w 928
that 10 w 932
if 1 w 935
anyone 1 w 941
who 3 w 944
calls 1 w 949
you 3 w 952
a 76 w 953
father-beater 1 w 966
or 10 w 968
a 79 w 969
mother-beater 1 w 982
is 11 w 984
liable 1 w 990
to 8 w 992
a 82 w 993
penalty 1 w 1000
at 23 w 1003
the 23 w 1006
same 3 w 1010
time 1 w 1014
a 86 w 1015
person 2 w 1021
who 4 w 1024
says 1 w 1028
that 11 w 1032
you 4 w 1035
strike 1 w 1041
your 2 w 1045
male 1 w 1049
or 11 w 1051
female 1 w 1057
parent 1 w 1063
is 12 w 1065
to 9 w 1067
escape 1 w 1073
punishment 1 w 1083
So 1 w 1086
if 2 w 1089
someone 1 w 1096
calls 2 w 1101
a 94 w 1102
man 4 w 1105
a 96 w 1106
shield-caster 1 w 1119
he 28 w 1122
is 14 w 1124
to 10 w 1126
be 6 w 1128
immune 1 w 1134
since 3 w 1140
the 24 w 1143
law 3 w 1146
imposes 1 w 1153
a 99 w 1154
penalty 2 w 1161
for 6 w 1164
saying 1 w 1170
that 12 w 1174
a 103 w 1175
man 5 w 1178
has 2 w 1181
thrown 1 w 1187
away 1 w 1191
his 5 w 1194
shield 2 w 1200
but 3 w 1204
not 8 w 1207
for 7 w 1210
saying 2 w 1216
he 30 w 1218
has 3 w 1221
cast 2 w 1225
it 10 w 1227
Similarly 1 w 1237
if 3 w 1240
you 6 w 1243
were 1 w 1247
one 6 w 1250
of 6 w 1252
the 25 w 1255
Eleven 1 w 1261
you 7 w 1265
would 2 w 1270
not 9 w 1273
accept 1 w 1279
a 113 w 1280
prisoner 1 w 1288
arrested 1 w 1296
for 8 w 1299
stripping 1 w 1308
a 115 w 1309
man 6 w 1312
of 7 w 1314
his 6 w 1317
cloak 1 w 1322
or 15 w 1324
his 7 w 1327
shirt 1 w 1332
unless 1 w 1339
he 32 w 1341
were 2 w 1345
given 1 w 1350
the 26 w 1353
name 1 w 1357
of 8 w 1359
clothes-stealer 1 w 1374