Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The "Art" of Rhetoric

The "Art" of Rhetoric (1.2.2-1.2.6)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0086.tlg038.perseus-eng2:1.2.2-1.2.6
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1.2.2', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Chapter 2 Section 2'}, 'end': {'reference': '1.2.6', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Chapter 2 Section 6'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '1'}, {'reference': '1.2'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

As for proofs, some are artificial, others inartificial. By the latter I understand all those which have not been furnished by ourselves but were already in existence, such as witnesses, tortures, contracts, and the like; by the former, all that can be constructed by system and by our own efforts. Thus we have only to make use of the latter, whereas we must invent the former.

1356a
1
Now the proofs furnished by the speech are of three kinds. The first depends upon the moral character of the speaker, the second upon putting the hearer into a certain frame of mind, the third upon the speech itself, in so far as it proves or seems to prove.

The orator persuades by moral character when his speech is delivered in such a manner as to render him worthy of confidence; for we feel confidence in a greater degree and more readily in persons of worth in regard to everything in general, but where there is no certainty and there is room for doubt, our confidence is absolute. But this confidence must be due to the speech itself, not to any preconceived idea of the speaker's character; for it is not the case, as some writers of rhetorical treatises lay down in their Art, that the worth of the orator in no way contributes to his powers of persuasion; on the contrary, moral character, so to say, constitutes the most effective means of proof.

The orator persuades by means of his hearers, when they are roused to emotion by his speech; for the judgements we deliver are not the same when we are influenced by joy or sorrow, love or hate; and it is to this alone that, as we have said, the present-day writers of treatises endeavor to devote their attention. (We will discuss these matters in detail when we come to speak of the emotions.)

Lastly, persuasion is produced by the speech itself, when we establish the true

20
or apparently true from the means of persuasion applicable to each individual subject.

Tokens

As 1 w 2
for 1 w 5
proofs 1 w 11
some 1 w 16
are 1 w 19
artificial 1 w 29
others 1 w 36
inartificial 1 w 48
By 1 w 51
the 2 w 54
latter 1 w 60
I 1 w 61
understand 1 w 71
all 1 w 74
those 1 w 79
which 1 w 84
have 1 w 88
not 1 w 91
been 1 w 95
furnished 1 w 104
by 1 w 106
ourselves 1 w 115
but 1 w 118
were 1 w 122
already 1 w 129
in 2 w 131
existence 1 w 140
such 1 w 145
as 1 w 147
witnesses 1 w 156
tortures 1 w 165
contracts 1 w 175
and 2 w 179
the 3 w 182
like 1 w 186
by 2 w 189
the 4 w 192
former 1 w 198
all 2 w 202
that 1 w 206
can 1 w 209
be 2 w 211
constructed 1 w 222
by 3 w 224
system 1 w 230
and 3 w 233
by 4 w 235
our 2 w 238
own 1 w 241
efforts 1 w 248
Thus 1 w 253
we 2 w 255
have 2 w 259
only 1 w 263
to 2 w 265
make 1 w 269
use 1 w 272
of 2 w 274
the 5 w 277
latter 2 w 283
whereas 1 w 291
we 3 w 293
must 1 w 297
invent 1 w 303
the 6 w 306
former 2 w 312
Now 1 w 316
the 7 w 319
proofs 2 w 325
furnished 2 w 334
by 5 w 336
the 8 w 339
speech 1 w 345
are 2 w 348
of 4 w 350
three 1 w 355
kinds 1 w 360
The 1 w 364
first 1 w 369
depends 1 w 376
upon 1 w 380
the 9 w 383
moral 1 w 388
character 1 w 397
of 5 w 399
the 10 w 402
speaker 1 w 409
the 11 w 413
second 1 w 419
upon 2 w 423
putting 1 w 430
the 12 w 433
hearer 1 w 439
into 1 w 443
a 29 w 444
certain 1 w 451
frame 1 w 456
of 6 w 458
mind 1 w 462
the 13 w 466
third 1 w 471
upon 3 w 475
the 14 w 478
speech 2 w 484
itself 1 w 490
in 9 w 493
so 2 w 495
far 1 w 498
as 3 w 500
it 3 w 502
proves 1 w 508
or 7 w 510
seems 1 w 515
to 4 w 517
prove 2 w 522
The 2 w 526
orator 1 w 532
persuades 1 w 541
by 6 w 543
moral 2 w 548
character 2 w 557
when 1 w 561
his 1 w 564
speech 3 w 570
is 5 w 572
delivered 1 w 581
in 10 w 583
such 2 w 587
a 39 w 588
manner 1 w 594
as 4 w 596
to 6 w 598
render 1 w 604
him 1 w 607
worthy 1 w 613
of 7 w 615
confidence 1 w 625
for 5 w 629
we 4 w 631
feel 1 w 635
confidence 2 w 645
in 11 w 647
a 42 w 648
greater 1 w 655
degree 1 w 661
and 4 w 664
more 1 w 668
readily 1 w 675
in 12 w 677
persons 1 w 684
of 8 w 686
worth 2 w 691
in 13 w 693
regard 1 w 699
to 7 w 701
everything 1 w 711
in 15 w 713
general 1 w 720
but 2 w 724
where 2 w 729
there 1 w 734
is 6 w 736
no 2 w 738
certainty 1 w 747
and 5 w 750
there 2 w 755
is 7 w 757
room 1 w 761
for 6 w 764
doubt 1 w 769
our 3 w 773
confidence 3 w 783
is 8 w 785
absolute 1 w 793
But 1 w 797
this 1 w 801
confidence 4 w 811
must 2 w 815
be 3 w 817
due 1 w 820
to 8 w 822
the 17 w 825
speech 4 w 831
itself 2 w 837
not 2 w 841
to 9 w 843
any 1 w 846
preconceived 1 w 858
idea 1 w 862
of 9 w 864
the 18 w 867
speaker 2 w 874
s 59 w 876
character 3 w 885
for 7 w 889
it 5 w 891
is 10 w 893
not 3 w 896
the 19 w 899
case 1 w 903
as 6 w 906
some 2 w 910
writers 1 w 917
of 10 w 919
rhetorical 1 w 929
treatises 1 w 938
lay 1 w 941
down 1 w 945
in 17 w 947
their 1 w 952
Art 1 w 955
that 2 w 960
the 21 w 963
worth 3 w 968
of 11 w 970
the 22 w 973
orator 2 w 979
in 18 w 981
no 5 w 983
way 1 w 986
contributes 1 w 997
to 12 w 999
his 3 w 1002
powers 1 w 1008
of 12 w 1010
persuasion 1 w 1020
on 16 w 1023
the 23 w 1026
contrary 1 w 1034
moral 3 w 1040
character 4 w 1049
so 6 w 1052
to 13 w 1054
say 1 w 1057
constitutes 1 w 1069
the 24 w 1072
most 1 w 1076
effective 1 w 1085
means 1 w 1090
of 13 w 1092
proof 3 w 1097
The 3 w 1101
orator 3 w 1107
persuades 2 w 1116
by 7 w 1118
means 2 w 1123
of 15 w 1125
his 4 w 1128
hearers 1 w 1135
when 2 w 1140
they 1 w 1144
are 5 w 1147
roused 1 w 1153
to 15 w 1155
emotion 1 w 1162
by 8 w 1164
his 5 w 1167
speech 5 w 1173
for 8 w 1177
the 26 w 1180
judgements 1 w 1190
we 6 w 1192
deliver 2 w 1199
are 6 w 1202
not 4 w 1205
the 27 w 1208
same 1 w 1212
when 3 w 1216
we 7 w 1218
are 7 w 1221
influenced 1 w 1231
by 9 w 1233
joy 1 w 1236
or 25 w 1238
sorrow 1 w 1244
love 1 w 1249
or 27 w 1251
hate 1 w 1255
and 6 w 1259
it 8 w 1261
is 15 w 1263
to 16 w 1265
this 2 w 1269
alone 1 w 1274
that 3 w 1278
as 8 w 1281
we 8 w 1283
have 3 w 1287
said 1 w 1291
the 28 w 1295
present-day 1 w 1306
writers 2 w 1313
of 16 w 1315
treatises 2 w 1324
endeavor 1 w 1332
to 17 w 1334
devote 1 w 1340
their 2 w 1345
attention 1 w 1354
We 1 w 1358
will 1 w 1362
discuss 1 w 1369
these 1 w 1374
matters 1 w 1381
in 20 w 1383
detail 1 w 1389
when 4 w 1393
we 9 w 1395
come 1 w 1399
to 18 w 1401
speak 3 w 1406
of 17 w 1408
the 31 w 1411
emotions 1 w 1419
Lastly 1 w 1427
persuasion 2 w 1438
is 19 w 1440
produced 1 w 1448
by 10 w 1450
the 32 w 1453
speech 6 w 1459
itself 3 w 1465
when 5 w 1470
we 10 w 1472
establish 1 w 1481
the 33 w 1484
true 1 w 1488
or 29 w 1490
apparently 1 w 1500
true 2 w 1504
from 1 w 1508
the 34 w 1511
means 3 w 1516
of 18 w 1518
persuasion 3 w 1528
applicable 1 w 1538
to 19 w 1540
each 1 w 1544
individual 1 w 1554
subject 1 w 1561