Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The "Art" of Rhetoric

The "Art" of Rhetoric (1.2.12-1.2.16)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0086.tlg038.perseus-eng2:1.2.12-1.2.16
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1.2.12', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Chapter 2 Section 12'}, 'end': {'reference': '1.2.16', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Chapter 2 Section 16'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '1'}, {'reference': '1.2'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

1357a
1
The function of Rhetoric, then, is to deal with things about which we deliberate, but for which we have no systematic rules; and in the presence of such hearers as are unable to take a general view of many stages, or to follow a lengthy chain of argument. But we only deliberate about things which seem to admit of issuing in two ways; as for those things which cannot in the past, present, or future be otherwise, no one deliberates about them, if he supposes that they are such; for nothing would be gained by it.

Now, it is possible to draw conclusions and inferences partly from what has been previously demonstrated syllogistically, partly from what has not, which however needs demonstration, because it is not probable.[*] The first of these methods is necessarily difficult to follow owing to its length, for the judge is supposed to be a simple person; the second will obtain little credence, because it does not depend upon what is either admitted or probable. The necessary result then is that the enthymeme and the example are concerned with things which may, generally speaking, be other than they are, the example being a kind of induction and the enthymeme a kind of syllogism, and deduced from few premises, often from fewer than the regular[*] syllogism; for if any one of these is well known, there is no need to mention it, for the hearer can add it himself. For instance, to prove that Dorieus[*] was the victor in a contest at which the prize was a crown,

20
it is enough to say that he won a victory at the Olympic games; there is no need to add that the prize at the Olympic games is a crown, for everybody knows it.

But since few of the propositions of the rhetorical syllogism are necessary, for most of the things which we judge and examine can be other than they are, human actions, which are the subject of our deliberation and examination, being all of such a character and, generally speaking, none of them necessary; since, further, facts which only generally happen or are merely possible can only be demonstrated by other facts of the same kind, and necessary facts by necessary propositions (and that this is so is clear from the Analytics[*]), it is evident that the materials from which enthymemes are derived will be sometimes necessary, but for the most part only generally true; and these materials being probabilities and signs, it follows that these two elements must correspond to these two kinds of propositions, each to each.[*]

For that which is probable is that which generally happens, not however unreservedly, as some define it, but that which is concerned with things that may be other than they are, being so related to that in regard to which it is probable

1357b
1
as the universal to the particular.

As to signs, some are related as the particular to the universal, others as the universal to the particular. Necessary signs are called tekmeria; those which are not necessary have no distinguishing name.

Tokens

The 1 w 3
function 1 w 11
of 1 w 13
Rhetoric 1 w 21
then 1 w 26
is 1 w 29
to 2 w 31
deal 1 w 35
with 1 w 39
things 1 w 45
about 1 w 50
which 1 w 55
we 1 w 57
deliberate 1 w 67
but 1 w 71
for 1 w 74
which 2 w 79
we 2 w 81
have 1 w 85
no 1 w 87
systematic 1 w 97
rules 1 w 102
and 1 w 106
in 2 w 108
the 2 w 111
presence 1 w 119
of 2 w 121
such 1 w 125
hearers 1 w 132
as 1 w 134
are 2 w 137
unable 1 w 143
to 3 w 145
take 1 w 149
a 12 w 150
general 1 w 157
view 1 w 161
of 3 w 163
many 1 w 167
stages 1 w 173
or 3 w 176
to 4 w 178
follow 1 w 184
a 16 w 185
lengthy 1 w 192
chain 1 w 197
of 4 w 199
argument 1 w 207
But 1 w 211
we 3 w 213
only 1 w 217
deliberate 2 w 227
about 2 w 232
things 2 w 238
which 3 w 243
seem 1 w 247
to 5 w 249
admit 1 w 254
of 5 w 256
issuing 1 w 263
in 6 w 265
two 1 w 268
ways 1 w 272
as 2 w 275
for 2 w 278
those 1 w 283
things 3 w 289
which 4 w 294
cannot 1 w 300
in 8 w 302
the 3 w 305
past 1 w 309
present 1 w 317
or 5 w 320
future 1 w 326
be 3 w 328
otherwise 1 w 337
no 3 w 340
one 1 w 343
deliberates 1 w 354
about 3 w 359
them 1 w 363
if 1 w 366
he 9 w 368
supposes 1 w 376
that 1 w 380
they 1 w 384
are 3 w 387
such 2 w 391
for 3 w 395
nothing 1 w 402
would 1 w 407
be 5 w 409
gained 1 w 415
by 1 w 417
it 3 w 419
Now 1 w 423
it 4 w 426
is 4 w 428
possible 1 w 436
to 6 w 438
draw 1 w 442
conclusions 1 w 453
and 2 w 456
inferences 1 w 466
partly 1 w 472
from 1 w 476
what 1 w 480
has 1 w 483
been 1 w 487
previously 1 w 497
demonstrated 1 w 509
syllogistically 1 w 524
partly 2 w 531
from 2 w 535
what 2 w 539
has 2 w 542
not 3 w 545
which 5 w 551
however 1 w 558
needs 1 w 563
demonstration 1 w 576
because 1 w 584
it 5 w 586
is 6 w 588
not 4 w 591
probable 1 w 599
Certain 1 w 607
propositions 1 w 619
which 6 w 625
seem 2 w 629
paradoxical 1 w 640
and 3 w 643
improbable 1 w 653
to 7 w 655
a 50 w 656
popular 1 w 663
audience 1 w 671
must 1 w 676
be 8 w 678
proved 1 w 684
before 1 w 690
it 7 w 692
is 7 w 694
able 4 w 698
to 8 w 700
understand 1 w 710
them 2 w 714
The 2 w 718
first 1 w 723
of 6 w 725
these 1 w 730
methods 1 w 737
is 8 w 739
necessarily 1 w 750
difficult 1 w 759
to 9 w 761
follow 2 w 767
owing 1 w 772
to 10 w 774
its 1 w 777
length 2 w 783
for 5 w 787
the 9 w 790
judge 1 w 795
is 9 w 797
supposed 1 w 805
to 11 w 807
be 10 w 809
a 56 w 810
simple 1 w 816
person 1 w 822
the 10 w 826
second 1 w 832
will 1 w 836
obtain 1 w 842
little 1 w 848
credence 1 w 856
because 2 w 864
it 10 w 866
does 1 w 870
not 5 w 873
depend 1 w 879
upon 1 w 883
what 3 w 887
is 10 w 889
either 1 w 895
admitted 1 w 903
or 9 w 905
probable 3 w 913
The 3 w 917
necessary 1 w 926
result 1 w 932
then 2 w 936
is 11 w 938
that 2 w 942
the 13 w 945
enthymeme 1 w 954
and 5 w 957
the 14 w 960
example 1 w 967
are 4 w 970
concerned 1 w 979
with 2 w 983
things 4 w 989
which 7 w 994
may 1 w 997
generally 1 w 1007
speaking 1 w 1015
be 12 w 1018
other 2 w 1023
than 1 w 1027
they 2 w 1031
are 5 w 1034
the 17 w 1038
example 2 w 1045
being 1 w 1050
a 73 w 1051
kind 1 w 1055
of 7 w 1057
induction 1 w 1066
and 6 w 1069
the 18 w 1072
enthymeme 2 w 1081
a 75 w 1082
kind 2 w 1086
of 8 w 1088
syllogism 1 w 1097
and 7 w 1101
deduced 1 w 1108
from 3 w 1112
few 1 w 1115
premises 1 w 1123
often 1 w 1129
from 4 w 1133
fewer 1 w 1138
than 2 w 1142
the 19 w 1145
regular 1 w 1152
πρῶτος 1 w 1158
the 20 w 1162
primary 1 w 1169
typical 1 w 1177
syllogism 2 w 1186
of 10 w 1188
the 21 w 1191
first 2 w 1196
figure 1 w 1202
syllogism 3 w 1212
for 6 w 1216
if 3 w 1218
any 2 w 1221
one 2 w 1224
of 11 w 1226
these 2 w 1231
is 16 w 1233
well 1 w 1237
known 1 w 1242
there 1 w 1248
is 17 w 1250
no 9 w 1252
need 2 w 1256
to 12 w 1258
mention 1 w 1265
it 14 w 1267
for 7 w 1271
the 24 w 1274
hearer 2 w 1280
can 2 w 1283
add 1 w 1286
it 15 w 1288
himself 1 w 1295
For 1 w 1299
instance 1 w 1307
to 13 w 1310
prove 2 w 1315
that 3 w 1319
Dorieus 1 w 1326
Son 1 w 1329
of 12 w 1331
Diagoras 1 w 1339
of 13 w 1341
Rhodes 1 w 1347
and 8 w 1351
like 1 w 1355
his 1 w 1358
father 1 w 1364
celebrated 1 w 1374
for 8 w 1377
his 2 w 1380
victories 1 w 1389
in 22 w 1391
the 26 w 1394
Greek 1 w 1399
athletic 1 w 1407
contests 1 w 1415
He 1 w 1418
played 1 w 1424
a 94 w 1425
considerable 1 w 1437
part 3 w 1441
in 23 w 1443
political 1 w 1452
and 9 w 1455
naval 1 w 1460
affairs 1 w 1467
in 24 w 1469
support 1 w 1476
of 14 w 1478
the 27 w 1481
Spartans 1 w 1489
412 1 w 1493
407 1 w 1497
B 2 w 1498
C 2 w 1500
whom 1 w 1506
he 35 w 1508
afterwards 1 w 1518
offended 1 w 1526
and 10 w 1530
by 2 w 1532
whom 2 w 1536
he 36 w 1538
is 20 w 1540
said 1 w 1544
to 15 w 1546
have 2 w 1550
been 2 w 1554
put 1 w 1557
to 16 w 1559
death 1 w 1564
was 1 w 1568
the 28 w 1571
victor 2 w 1577
in 25 w 1579
a 112 w 1580
contest 2 w 1587
at 17 w 1589
which 8 w 1594
the 29 w 1597
prize 1 w 1602
was 2 w 1605
a 115 w 1606
crown 1 w 1611
it 17 w 1614
is 21 w 1616
enough 1 w 1622
to 18 w 1624
say 1 w 1627
that 4 w 1631
he 39 w 1633
won 1 w 1636
a 118 w 1637
victory 1 w 1644
at 19 w 1646
the 30 w 1649
Olympic 1 w 1656
games 1 w 1661
there 2 w 1667
is 22 w 1669
no 11 w 1671
need 3 w 1675
to 20 w 1677
add 2 w 1680
that 5 w 1684
the 32 w 1687
prize 2 w 1692
at 21 w 1694
the 33 w 1697
Olympic 2 w 1704
games 2 w 1709
is 23 w 1711
a 125 w 1712
crown 2 w 1717
for 9 w 1721
everybody 1 w 1730
knows 1 w 1735
it 18 w 1737
But 2 w 1741
since 1 w 1746
few 3 w 1749
of 16 w 1751
the 34 w 1754
propositions 2 w 1766
of 17 w 1768
the 35 w 1771
rhetorical 1 w 1781
syllogism 4 w 1790
are 7 w 1793
necessary 2 w 1802
for 10 w 1806
most 1 w 1810
of 18 w 1812
the 36 w 1815
things 5 w 1821
which 9 w 1826
we 7 w 1828
judge 2 w 1833
and 11 w 1836
examine 1 w 1843
can 3 w 1846
be 15 w 1848
other 3 w 1853
than 3 w 1857
they 3 w 1861
are 8 w 1864
human 1 w 1870
actions 1 w 1877
which 10 w 1883
are 9 w 1886
the 39 w 1889
subject 1 w 1896
of 19 w 1898
our 1 w 1901
deliberation 1 w 1913
and 12 w 1916
examination 1 w 1927
being 2 w 1933
all 3 w 1936
of 20 w 1938
such 3 w 1942
a 142 w 1943
character 1 w 1952
and 13 w 1955
generally 2 w 1965
speaking 2 w 1973
none 1 w 1978
of 21 w 1980
them 3 w 1984
necessary 3 w 1993
since 2 w 1999
further 1 w 2007
facts 1 w 2013
which 11 w 2018
only 2 w 2022
generally 3 w 2031
happen 1 w 2037
or 23 w 2039
are 10 w 2042
merely 1 w 2048
possible 2 w 2056
can 4 w 2059
only 3 w 2063
be 18 w 2065
demonstrated 2 w 2077
by 3 w 2079
other 4 w 2084
facts 2 w 2089
of 22 w 2091
the 43 w 2094
same 1 w 2098
kind 3 w 2102
and 14 w 2106
necessary 4 w 2115
facts 3 w 2120
by 4 w 2122
necessary 5 w 2131
propositions 3 w 2143
and 15 w 2147
that 6 w 2151
this 1 w 2155
is 26 w 2157
so 2 w 2159
is 27 w 2161
clear 1 w 2166
from 5 w 2170
the 44 w 2173
Analytics 1 w 2182
Aristot 1 w 2189
APr 1 w 2193
1 2 w 2195
8 1 w 2197
13 1 w 2200
it 21 w 2205
is 29 w 2207
evident 1 w 2214
that 7 w 2218
the 45 w 2221
materials 1 w 2230
from 6 w 2234
which 12 w 2239
enthymemes 1 w 2249
are 11 w 2252
derived 1 w 2259
will 2 w 2263
be 19 w 2265
sometimes 1 w 2274
necessary 6 w 2283
but 2 w 2287
for 11 w 2290
the 46 w 2293
most 2 w 2297
part 5 w 2301
only 4 w 2305
generally 4 w 2314
true 1 w 2318
and 16 w 2322
these 3 w 2327
materials 2 w 2336
being 3 w 2341
probabilities 1 w 2354
and 17 w 2357
signs 1 w 2362
it 23 w 2365
follows 1 w 2372
that 8 w 2376
these 4 w 2381
two 2 w 2384
elements 1 w 2392
must 2 w 2396
correspond 1 w 2406
to 23 w 2408
these 5 w 2413
two 3 w 2416
kinds 1 w 2421
of 23 w 2423
propositions 4 w 2435
each 1 w 2440
to 24 w 2442
each 2 w 2446
That 1 w 2451
is 30 w 2453
probabilities 2 w 2467
and 18 w 2470
signs 2 w 2475
correspond 2 w 2485
to 25 w 2487
general 6 w 2494
and 19 w 2497
necessary 7 w 2506
propositions 5 w 2518
This 1 w 2523
is 32 w 2525
not 6 w 2528
strictly 1 w 2536
correct 1 w 2543
only 5 w 2548
the 50 w 2551
τεκμήρια 1 w 2559
correspond 3 w 2569
to 26 w 2571
the 51 w 2574
necessary 8 w 2583
propositions 6 w 2595
the 52 w 2599
other 5 w 2604
signs 3 w 2609
and 20 w 2612
the 54 w 2615
other 6 w 2620
probabilities 3 w 2633
to 27 w 2635
the 56 w 2638
general 7 w 2645
or 29 w 2647
contingent 1 w 2657
propositions 7 w 2669
For 2 w 2673
that 9 w 2677
which 13 w 2682
is 33 w 2684
probable 4 w 2692
is 34 w 2694
that 10 w 2698
which 14 w 2703
generally 5 w 2712
happens 1 w 2719
not 7 w 2723
however 2 w 2730
unreservedly 1 w 2742
as 9 w 2745
some 2 w 2749
define 1 w 2755
it 30 w 2757
but 3 w 2761
that 11 w 2765
which 15 w 2770
is 35 w 2772
concerned 2 w 2781
with 3 w 2785
things 6 w 2791
that 12 w 2795
may 2 w 2798
be 21 w 2800
other 7 w 2805
than 4 w 2809
they 4 w 2813
are 12 w 2816
being 4 w 2822
so 5 w 2824
related 1 w 2831
to 28 w 2833
that 13 w 2837
in 40 w 2839
regard 1 w 2845
to 29 w 2847
which 16 w 2852
it 32 w 2854
is 36 w 2856
probable 5 w 2864
as 10 w 2866
the 59 w 2869
universal 1 w 2878
to 30 w 2880
the 60 w 2883
particular 1 w 2893
As 1 w 2896
to 31 w 2898
signs 4 w 2903
some 3 w 2908
are 13 w 2911
related 2 w 2918
as 11 w 2920
the 61 w 2923
particular 2 w 2933
to 32 w 2935
the 62 w 2938
universal 2 w 2947
others 1 w 2954
as 12 w 2956
the 64 w 2959
universal 3 w 2968
to 33 w 2970
the 65 w 2973
particular 3 w 2983
Necessary 1 w 2993
signs 5 w 2998
are 14 w 3001
called 1 w 3007
tekmeria 1 w 3015
those 2 w 3021
which 17 w 3026
are 15 w 3029
not 8 w 3032
necessary 9 w 3041
have 3 w 3045
no 17 w 3047
distinguishing 1 w 3061
name 1 w 3065