Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Metaphysics

Metaphysics (1.4.6-1.4.10)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0086.tlg025.perseus-eng2:1.4.6-1.4.10
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1.4.6', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Section 4 Subsection 6'}, 'end': {'reference': '1.4.10', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Section 4 Subsection 10'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '1'}, {'reference': '1.4'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

At any rate Love often differentiates and Strife combines: because whenever the universe is differentiated into its elements by Strife, fire and each of the other elements are agglomerated into a unity; and whenever they are all combined together again by Love, the particles of each element are necessarily again differentiated.

Empedocles, then, differed from his predecessors in that he first introduced the division of this cause, making the source of motion not one but two contrary forces.

Further, he was the first to maintain that the so-called material elements are fournot that he uses them as four, but as two only,

985b
1
treating fire on the one hand by itself, and the elements opposed to itearth, air and wateron the other, as a single nature.[*] This can be seen from a study of his writings.[*]

Such, then, as I say, is his account of the nature and number of the first principles.

Leucippus,[*] however, and his disciple Democritus[*] hold that the elements are the Full and the Voidcalling the one what is and the other what is not. Of these they identify the full or solid with what is, and the void or rare with what is not (hence they hold that what is not is no less real than what is,[*] because Void is as real as Body); and they say that these are the material causes of things.

And just as those who make the underlying substance a unity generate all other things by means of its modifications, assuming rarity and density as first principles of these modifications, so these thinkers hold that the differences[*] are the causes of everything else.

Tokens

At 1 w 2
any 1 w 5
rate 1 w 9
Love 1 w 13
often 1 w 18
differentiates 1 w 32
and 1 w 35
Strife 1 w 41
combines 1 w 49
because 1 w 57
whenever 1 w 65
the 1 w 68
universe 1 w 76
is 1 w 78
differentiated 1 w 92
into 1 w 96
its 1 w 99
elements 1 w 107
by 1 w 109
Strife 2 w 115
fire 1 w 120
and 2 w 123
each 1 w 127
of 2 w 129
the 2 w 132
other 1 w 137
elements 2 w 145
are 1 w 148
agglomerated 1 w 160
into 2 w 164
a 12 w 165
unity 1 w 170
and 3 w 174
whenever 2 w 182
they 1 w 186
are 2 w 189
all 1 w 192
combined 1 w 200
together 1 w 208
again 1 w 213
by 2 w 215
Love 2 w 219
the 6 w 223
particles 1 w 232
of 3 w 234
each 2 w 238
element 3 w 245
are 3 w 248
necessarily 1 w 259
again 2 w 264
differentiated 2 w 278
Empedocles 1 w 289
then 1 w 294
differed 1 w 303
from 1 w 307
his 1 w 310
predecessors 1 w 322
in 7 w 324
that 1 w 328
he 10 w 330
first 1 w 335
introduced 1 w 345
the 8 w 348
division 1 w 356
of 4 w 358
this 1 w 362
cause 2 w 367
making 1 w 374
the 9 w 377
source 1 w 383
of 5 w 385
motion 1 w 391
not 1 w 394
one 1 w 397
but 1 w 400
two 1 w 403
contrary 1 w 411
forces 1 w 417
Further 1 w 425
he 14 w 428
was 1 w 431
the 11 w 434
first 2 w 439
to 4 w 441
maintain 1 w 449
that 2 w 453
the 12 w 456
so-called 1 w 465
material 1 w 473
elements 3 w 481
are 4 w 484
four 1 w 488
not 2 w 492
that 3 w 496
he 17 w 498
uses 1 w 502
them 1 w 506
as 2 w 508
four 2 w 512
but 2 w 516
as 3 w 518
two 2 w 521
only 1 w 525
treating 1 w 534
fire 2 w 538
on 6 w 540
the 14 w 543
one 2 w 546
hand 1 w 550
by 3 w 552
itself 1 w 558
and 5 w 562
the 15 w 565
elements 4 w 573
opposed 1 w 580
to 5 w 582
it 4 w 584
earth 1 w 590
air 1 w 594
and 6 w 597
water 1 w 602
on 8 w 605
the 16 w 608
other 2 w 613
as 4 w 616
a 48 w 617
single 1 w 623
nature 1 w 629
Cf 1 w 632
3 1 w 634
14 1 w 637
This 1 w 642
can 1 w 645
be 2 w 647
seen 1 w 651
from 2 w 655
a 51 w 656
study 1 w 661
of 6 w 663
his 4 w 666
writings 1 w 674
e 103 w 676
g 10 w 678
Empedocles 2 w 689
Fr 1 w 692
62 1 w 695
Diels 1 w 701
Such 1 w 707
then 2 w 712
as 5 w 715
I 1 w 716
say 1 w 719
is 7 w 722
his 5 w 725
account 1 w 732
of 7 w 734
the 19 w 737
nature 2 w 743
and 7 w 746
number 1 w 752
of 8 w 754
the 20 w 757
first 3 w 762
principles 1 w 772
Leucippus 1 w 782
Of 1 w 785
Miletus 1 w 792
fl 1 w 795
circa 1 w 801
440 1 w 804
B 1 w 808
C 2 w 810
See 1 w 814
Burnet 1 w 820
E 3 w 822
G 1 w 824
P 1 w 826
171 1 w 830
ff 5 w 832
however 1 w 840
and 8 w 844
his 6 w 847
disciple 1 w 855
Democritus 1 w 865
Of 2 w 867
Abdera 1 w 873
fl 2 w 876
circa 2 w 882
420 1 w 885
B 3 w 886
C 3 w 888
E 4 w 890
G 2 w 892
P 2 w 894
loc 1 w 897
cit 1 w 901
hold 1 w 906
that 4 w 910
the 21 w 913
elements 5 w 921
are 5 w 924
the 22 w 927
Full 1 w 931
and 9 w 934
the 23 w 937
Void 1 w 941
calling 1 w 949
the 24 w 952
one 3 w 955
what 1 w 959
is 11 w 961
and 10 w 964
the 25 w 967
other 3 w 972
what 2 w 976
is 12 w 978
not 3 w 981
Of 3 w 984
these 1 w 989
they 2 w 993
identify 1 w 1001
the 29 w 1004
full 1 w 1008
or 3 w 1010
solid 1 w 1015
with 1 w 1019
what 3 w 1023
is 13 w 1025
and 11 w 1029
the 30 w 1032
void 1 w 1036
or 4 w 1038
rare 1 w 1042
with 2 w 1046
what 4 w 1050
is 14 w 1052
not 4 w 1055
hence 1 w 1061
they 3 w 1065
hold 2 w 1069
that 5 w 1073
what 5 w 1077
is 15 w 1079
not 5 w 1082
is 16 w 1084
no 6 w 1086
less 1 w 1090
real 1 w 1094
than 1 w 1098
what 6 w 1102
is 17 w 1104
For 1 w 1108
the 32 w 1111
probable 1 w 1119
connection 1 w 1129
between 1 w 1136
the 33 w 1139
Atomists 1 w 1147
and 12 w 1150
the 34 w 1153
Eleatics 1 w 1161
see 2 w 1164
E 6 w 1165
G 3 w 1167
P 3 w 1169
173 1 w 1173
175 1 w 1177
and 13 w 1181
cf 1 w 1183
De 2 w 1186
Gen 1 w 1189
et 5 w 1192
Corr 1 w 1196
324b 1 w 1201
35-325a 1 w 1208
32 3 w 1210
because 2 w 1218
Void 2 w 1222
is 19 w 1224
as 6 w 1226
real 2 w 1230
as 7 w 1232
Body 1 w 1236
and 14 w 1241
they 4 w 1245
say 2 w 1248
that 6 w 1252
these 2 w 1257
are 7 w 1260
the 37 w 1263
material 2 w 1271
causes 1 w 1277
of 9 w 1279
things 1 w 1285
And 1 w 1289
just 1 w 1293
as 8 w 1295
those 1 w 1300
who 1 w 1303
make 1 w 1307
the 38 w 1310
underlying 1 w 1320
substance 1 w 1329
a 96 w 1330
unity 2 w 1335
generate 1 w 1343
all 4 w 1346
other 4 w 1351
things 2 w 1357
by 4 w 1359
means 1 w 1364
of 10 w 1366
its 3 w 1369
modifications 1 w 1382
assuming 1 w 1391
rarity 1 w 1397
and 15 w 1400
density 1 w 1407
as 10 w 1409
first 4 w 1414
principles 2 w 1424
of 11 w 1426
these 3 w 1431
modifications 2 w 1444
so 5 w 1447
these 4 w 1452
thinkers 1 w 1460
hold 3 w 1464
that 7 w 1468
the 42 w 1471
differences 1 w 1482
i 102 w 1483
e 191 w 1485
of 12 w 1489
the 43 w 1492
atoms 1 w 1497
are 8 w 1501
the 44 w 1504
causes 2 w 1510
of 13 w 1512
everything 1 w 1522
else 1 w 1526