Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Metaphysics

Metaphysics (1.4.11-1.5.3)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0086.tlg025.perseus-eng2:1.4.11-1.5.3
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1.4.11', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Section 4 Subsection 11'}, 'end': {'reference': '1.5.3', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Section 5 Subsection 3'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '1'}, {'reference': '1.4'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

These differences, they say, are three: shape, arrangement, and position; because they hold that what is differs only in contour, inter-contact, and inclination .[*](Of these contour means shape, inter-contact arrangement, and inclination position.) Thus, e.g., A differs from N in shape, AN from NA in arrangement, and Z from N[*] in position.

As for motion, whence and how it arises in things,

20
they casually ignored this point, very much as the other thinkers did. Such, then, as I say, seems to be the extent of the inquiries which the earlier thinkers made into these two kinds of cause.

At the same time, however, and even earlier the so-called[*] Pythagoreans applied themselves to mathematics, and were the first to develop this science[*]; and through studying it they came to believe that its principles are the principles of everything.

And since numbers are by nature first among these principles, and they fancied that they could detect in numbers, to a greater extent than in fire and earth and water, many analogues[*] of what is and comes into beingsuch and such a property of number being justice ,[*] and such and such soul or mind , another opportunity , and similarly, more or less, with all the restand since they saw further that the properties and ratios of the musical scales are based on numbers,[*] and since it seemed clear that all other things have their whole nature modelled upon numbers, and that numbers are the ultimate things in the whole physical universe,

986a
1
they assumed the elements of numbers to be the elements of everything, and the whole universe to be a proportion[*] or number. Whatever analogues to the processes and parts of the heavens and to the whole order of the universe they could exhibit in numbers and proportions, these they collected and correlated;

and if there was any deficiency anywhere, they made haste to supply it, in order to make their system a connected whole. For example, since the decad is considered to be a complete thing and to comprise the whole essential nature of the numerical system, they assert that the bodies which revolve in the heavens are ten; and there being only nine[*] that are visible, they make the antichthon[*] the tenth.

Tokens

These 1 w 5
differences 1 w 16
they 1 w 21
say 1 w 24
are 1 w 28
three 1 w 33
shape 1 w 39
arrangement 1 w 51
and 1 w 55
position 1 w 63
because 1 w 71
they 2 w 75
hold 1 w 79
that 1 w 83
what 1 w 87
is 1 w 89
differs 1 w 96
only 1 w 100
in 1 w 102
contour 1 w 109
inter-contact 1 w 123
and 2 w 127
inclination 1 w 138
Cf 1 w 141
R 1 w 143
P 1 w 145
194 1 w 149
Of 1 w 153
these 1 w 158
contour 2 w 165
means 1 w 170
shape 2 w 175
inter-contact 2 w 189
arrangement 2 w 200
and 3 w 204
inclination 2 w 215
position 2 w 223
Thus 1 w 229
e 25 w 231
g 3 w 233
A 1 w 236
differs 2 w 243
from 1 w 247
N 1 w 248
in 8 w 250
shape 3 w 255
AN 1 w 258
from 2 w 262
NA 1 w 264
in 9 w 266
arrangement 3 w 277
and 4 w 281
Z 1 w 282
from 3 w 286
N 4 w 287
These 2 w 292
letters 1 w 299
will 1 w 303
convey 1 w 309
Aristotle 1 w 318
s 19 w 320
point 1 w 325
better 1 w 331
to 4 w 333
the 4 w 336
English 1 w 343
reader 1 w 349
but 1 w 353
see 1 w 356
critical 1 w 364
note 1 w 368
in 11 w 371
position 3 w 379
As 1 w 382
for 1 w 385
motion 1 w 391
whence 1 w 398
and 5 w 401
how 1 w 404
it 5 w 406
arises 1 w 412
in 12 w 414
things 1 w 420
they 3 w 425
casually 1 w 433
ignored 1 w 440
this 1 w 444
point 2 w 449
very 1 w 454
much 1 w 458
as 2 w 460
the 6 w 463
other 1 w 468
thinkers 1 w 476
did 1 w 479
Such 1 w 484
then 1 w 489
as 3 w 492
I 1 w 493
say 2 w 496
seems 1 w 502
to 5 w 504
be 3 w 506
the 9 w 509
extent 1 w 515
of 1 w 517
the 10 w 520
inquiries 1 w 529
which 1 w 534
the 11 w 537
earlier 1 w 544
thinkers 2 w 552
made 1 w 556
into 1 w 560
these 2 w 565
two 1 w 568
kinds 1 w 573
of 2 w 575
cause 2 w 580
At 1 w 583
the 13 w 586
same 1 w 590
time 1 w 594
however 1 w 602
and 6 w 606
even 1 w 610
earlier 2 w 617
the 14 w 620
so-called 1 w 629
Aristotle 2 w 638
seems 2 w 643
to 8 w 645
have 1 w 649
regarded 1 w 657
Pythagoras 1 w 667
as 5 w 669
a 45 w 670
legendary 1 w 679
person 1 w 685
Pythagoreans 1 w 698
applied 1 w 705
themselves 1 w 715
to 9 w 717
mathematics 1 w 728
and 7 w 732
were 1 w 736
the 17 w 739
first 1 w 744
to 10 w 746
develop 1 w 753
this 2 w 757
science 1 w 764
Pythagoras 2 w 774
himself 1 w 781
fl 1 w 784
532 1 w 788
B 1 w 789
C 2 w 791
is 8 w 795
said 1 w 799
by 1 w 801
Aristoxenus 1 w 812
ap 5 w 815
Stobaeus 1 w 824
1 2 w 825
20 1 w 828
1 3 w 830
to 13 w 833
have 2 w 837
been 1 w 841
the 18 w 844
first 2 w 849
to 14 w 851
make 1 w 855
a 60 w 856
theoretical 1 w 867
study 1 w 872
of 3 w 874
arithmetic 1 w 884
and 8 w 889
through 1 w 896
studying 1 w 904
it 7 w 906
they 4 w 910
came 1 w 914
to 15 w 916
believe 1 w 923
that 2 w 927
its 1 w 930
principles 1 w 940
are 2 w 943
the 21 w 946
principles 2 w 956
of 4 w 958
everything 1 w 968
And 1 w 972
since 1 w 977
numbers 1 w 984
are 3 w 987
by 2 w 989
nature 1 w 995
first 3 w 1000
among 1 w 1005
these 3 w 1010
principles 3 w 1020
and 9 w 1024
they 5 w 1028
fancied 1 w 1035
that 3 w 1039
they 6 w 1043
could 1 w 1048
detect 1 w 1054
in 26 w 1056
numbers 2 w 1063
to 16 w 1066
a 73 w 1067
greater 1 w 1074
extent 2 w 1080
than 1 w 1084
in 27 w 1086
fire 1 w 1090
and 10 w 1093
earth 1 w 1098
and 11 w 1101
water 1 w 1106
many 1 w 1111
analogues 1 w 1120
Cf 2 w 1122
Aristot 3 w 1130
Met 1 w 1134
14 1 w 1137
6ff 1 w 1141
of 5 w 1145
what 2 w 1149
is 11 w 1151
and 12 w 1154
comes 1 w 1159
into 2 w 1163
being 1 w 1168
such 1 w 1173
and 13 w 1176
such 2 w 1180
a 86 w 1181
property 1 w 1189
of 6 w 1191
number 3 w 1197
being 2 w 1202
justice 1 w 1209
Apparently 1 w 1220
cf 1 w 1223
infra 1 w 1229
Aristot 4 w 1237
Met 2 w 1241
1 5 w 1243
17 1 w 1246
they 7 w 1251
identified 1 w 1261
these 4 w 1266
not 2 w 1269
only 2 w 1273
with 1 w 1277
properties 1 w 1287
of 7 w 1289
number 4 w 1295
but 2 w 1298
with 2 w 1302
numbers 3 w 1309
themselves 2 w 1319
Thus 2 w 1324
justice 2 w 1331
properly 1 w 1340
squareness 1 w 1350
4 3 w 1352
the 28 w 1356
first 4 w 1361
square 2 w 1367
number 6 w 1373
soul 1 w 1378
or 7 w 1380
mind 1 w 1384
1 7 w 1385
opportunity 1 w 1397
7 2 w 1398
Alexander 1 w 1408
and 15 w 1413
such 3 w 1417
and 16 w 1420
such 4 w 1424
soul 2 w 1428
or 9 w 1430
mind 2 w 1434
another 1 w 1442
opportunity 2 w 1453
and 17 w 1457
similarly 1 w 1466
more 1 w 1471
or 12 w 1473
less 1 w 1477
with 3 w 1482
all 3 w 1485
the 30 w 1488
rest 1 w 1492
and 18 w 1496
since 2 w 1501
they 8 w 1505
saw 1 w 1508
further 1 w 1515
that 4 w 1519
the 33 w 1522
properties 2 w 1532
and 19 w 1535
ratios 1 w 1541
of 8 w 1543
the 34 w 1546
musical 1 w 1553
scales 1 w 1559
are 7 w 1562
based 1 w 1567
on 16 w 1569
numbers 4 w 1576
Pythagoras 3 w 1587
himself 2 w 1594
is 13 w 1596
credited 1 w 1604
with 4 w 1608
having 1 w 1614
discovered 1 w 1624
the 35 w 1627
ratios 2 w 1633
of 9 w 1635
the 36 w 1638
octave 1 w 1644
2 3 w 1646
1 8 w 1648
the 37 w 1653
fifth 1 w 1658
3 2 w 1660
2 4 w 1662
and 20 w 1666
the 38 w 1669
fourth 1 w 1675
4 4 w 1677
3 3 w 1679
Burnet 1 w 1687
E 2 w 1689
G 1 w 1691
P 6 w 1693
51 1 w 1696
and 21 w 1700
since 3 w 1705
it 16 w 1707
seemed 1 w 1713
clear 1 w 1718
that 5 w 1722
all 4 w 1725
other 3 w 1730
things 2 w 1736
have 3 w 1740
their 1 w 1745
whole 1 w 1750
nature 2 w 1756
modelled 1 w 1764
upon 1 w 1768
numbers 5 w 1775
and 22 w 1779
that 6 w 1783
numbers 6 w 1790
are 8 w 1793
the 41 w 1796
ultimate 1 w 1804
things 3 w 1810
in 39 w 1812
the 42 w 1815
whole 2 w 1820
physical 1 w 1828
universe 1 w 1836
they 9 w 1841
assumed 1 w 1848
the 44 w 1851
elements 1 w 1859
of 10 w 1861
numbers 7 w 1868
to 20 w 1870
be 18 w 1872
the 45 w 1875
elements 2 w 1883
of 11 w 1885
everything 2 w 1895
and 23 w 1899
the 46 w 1902
whole 3 w 1907
universe 2 w 1915
to 21 w 1917
be 19 w 1919
a 126 w 1920
proportion 1 w 1930
Or 1 w 1932
harmony 1 w 1939
Cf 3 w 1942
Aristot 5 w 1950
De 1 w 1953
Caelo 1 w 1958
2 5 w 1959
9 2 w 1961
and 24 w 1965
E 3 w 1966
G 2 w 1968
P 7 w 1970
152 1 w 1974
or 15 w 1977
number 11 w 1983
Whatever 1 w 1992
analogues 2 w 2001
to 23 w 2003
the 47 w 2006
processes 1 w 2015
and 25 w 2018
parts 1 w 2023
of 12 w 2025
the 48 w 2028
heavens 1 w 2035
and 26 w 2038
to 24 w 2040
the 49 w 2043
whole 4 w 2048
order 1 w 2053
of 13 w 2055
the 50 w 2058
universe 3 w 2066
they 10 w 2070
could 2 w 2075
exhibit 1 w 2082
in 41 w 2084
numbers 8 w 2091
and 27 w 2094
proportions 1 w 2105
these 5 w 2111
they 11 w 2115
collected 1 w 2124
and 28 w 2127
correlated 1 w 2137
and 29 w 2141
if 6 w 2143
there 1 w 2148
was 1 w 2151
any 2 w 2154
deficiency 1 w 2164
anywhere 1 w 2172
they 12 w 2177
made 2 w 2181
haste 1 w 2186
to 25 w 2188
supply 1 w 2194
it 18 w 2196
in 42 w 2199
order 2 w 2204
to 26 w 2206
make 2 w 2210
their 2 w 2215
system 1 w 2221
a 147 w 2222
connected 1 w 2231
whole 5 w 2236
For 1 w 2240
example 1 w 2247
since 4 w 2253
the 57 w 2256
decad 1 w 2261
is 16 w 2263
considered 1 w 2273
to 27 w 2275
be 22 w 2277
a 150 w 2278
complete 1 w 2286
thing 6 w 2291
and 30 w 2294
to 28 w 2296
comprise 1 w 2304
the 58 w 2307
whole 6 w 2312
essential 1 w 2321
nature 3 w 2327
of 14 w 2329
the 59 w 2332
numerical 1 w 2341
system 2 w 2347
they 13 w 2352
assert 1 w 2358
that 7 w 2362
the 61 w 2365
bodies 1 w 2371
which 2 w 2376
revolve 1 w 2383
in 45 w 2385
the 62 w 2388
heavens 2 w 2395
are 9 w 2398
ten 3 w 2401
and 31 w 2405
there 2 w 2410
being 3 w 2415
only 3 w 2419
nine 1 w 2423
Earth 1 w 2428
sun 1 w 2432
moon 1 w 2437
five 1 w 2442
planets 1 w 2449
and 32 w 2453
the 64 w 2456
sphere 1 w 2462
of 15 w 2464
the 65 w 2467
fixed 1 w 2472
stars 1 w 2477
that 8 w 2482
are 10 w 2485
visible 1 w 2492
they 14 w 2497
make 3 w 2501
the 67 w 2504
antichthon 1 w 2514
i 156 w 2515
e 333 w 2517
counter-earth 1 w 2531
a 169 w 2533
planet 2 w 2539
revolving 1 w 2548
round 1 w 2553
the 68 w 2556
central 1 w 2563
fire 2 w 2567
in 49 w 2569
such 5 w 2573
a 172 w 2574
way 1 w 2577
as 13 w 2579
to 29 w 2581
be 24 w 2583
always 1 w 2589
in 50 w 2591
opposition 1 w 2601
to 30 w 2603
the 69 w 2606
earth 3 w 2611
the 70 w 2615
tenth 1 w 2620